Trickster Mentor

"Speedy: You wanted him to steal that junk, Lou? That's a lot of baloney. Narrator: With Guru Lou, Pizza Cats, you never know what's bologna and what's filet mignon."

- Samurai Pizza Cats

This is a Trickster whose actions, while seemingly pointless, selfish, antagonistic, or just plain random, contain a valuable lesson. If you're the hero in a series with a Trickster Mentor, life will probably be twice as hard -- and twice as rewarding.

In more fantastic settings, this will often be a more benign Great Gazoo, who educates their proteges by subjecting them to various transformations, body-swaps, literal wishes, and faked tests of character. Trickster Mentors love it when someone who first meets them doesn't realize who they are. They get to assess the "true character" of someone, then beat their sense of superiority out of them with it after the revelation. Or, rarely, give them a small break if they reveal honesty and good intentions.

Essentially, a blend of order and chaos in the finest Zen tradition. Some accompany their teachings with profound Koans, but they are just as likely to throw in a few Ice Cream Koans to keep their disciples on their toes.

Anime and Manga

 * Mephisto from Blue Exorcist, who wants to make Rin strong enough to defeat Satan and (supposedly) bring peace to both humans and demons. He does this by repeatedly putting Rin in difficult, life-threatening situations--even sending the demon prince Amaimon to try and kill him.
 * Kisuke Urahara acts like this when training Ichigo in Bleach. His methods of training tend to mean death if failed. If Ichigo doesn't dodge an attack, he dies. If he doesn't look inside himself for his powers, he dies. If he fails to knock Urahara's hat off, he dies. Seriously.
 * Urahara also has a tendency to screw with people just for the hell of it. When beginning training, he gives Ichigo a helmet and claims that Ichigo needs to yell "TAKE THIS! THE POWER OF JUSTICE! JUSTICE ARMOR! JUSTICE HACHIMAKI! ATTACK!" When Ichigo does so almost instantly, Urahara mutters, "Wow! I can't believe he actually said that!"
 * Possibly justified in that while Urahara certainly enjoys being a dick to Ichigo, in the first example he genuinely thought that if Ichigo died, he wouldn't be able to make it into Soul Society in the first place.
 * Izumi Curtis' idea of training is abandoning the Elrics on an island for a month and unleashing a monster (although it is later revealed that the "monster" was a shop assistant) on their tails. All for them to find the meaning of the philosophy behind alchemy.
 * Izumi is an odd case since she learned this method from her mentor,
 * Oddly enough, is also this to the Elrics, especially Ed.  genuinely pleased when Ed finally figures it out.
 * Jiraiya from Naruto adopts the "thrown in at the deep end" method of training. Literally. Unsatisfied with the hero's progress at accessing his power, he throws him off a waterfall.
 * Franz Stresemann to Chiaki in Nodame Cantabile.
 * Sometimes, the blacksmith Totosai towards Inuyasha. Though other times Inuyasha just misunderstands what the blacksmith asks of him as training.
 * It has been argued that Genma Saotome and Happosai from Ranma ½ are this sort of mentor - putting Ranma through humiliation and hell for the express purpose of teaching him to be a superior martial artist. Genma steals Ranma's food? Defense training. Happosai tries to make Ranma wear lingerie? Teaching spiritual detachment. Or it could be that they're both dicks, which is the general view of the other characters.
 * Cologne has some of this as well, but her Training From Hell is always well-intentioned, and her students are very quick to catch on that both the training and the objective are equally useful. Then again, she sometimes pokes fun at the youngsters for the hell of it. Or because her cafe is overstocked with rancid noodles and can't think of any other way to get rid of them.
 * Jack Rakan of Mahou Sensei Negima is like this. His training techniques include things like "Make a really ugly face and do 100 punches!" and "Punch me as hard as you can!". Yet, Negi still manages to  under his guidance.
 * It should also be noted that Rakan trains himself like this, too. After demonstrating said, he reveals he had never actually tried it before, instead just being sure it'd work, and that he.
 * Initial D has Bunta Fujiwara, who secretly trains his son Takumi's road racing skill through years of tofu delivery runs on Mount Akina. And these aren't just any tofu delivery runs; Takumi is also given a cup of water to put in his car's cup holder, and must complete his run without spilling a drop of water. And then in Initial D Second Stage,
 * One Piece: Some might say Luffy's grandfather is one as well considering his training techniques to make Luffy a great marine, however, since his reasoning was make clear and it backfired big time it could just be Training From Hell.
 * The masters of Ryouzanpakou do this to Kenichi all the time. Their favorite technique is to focus training on one main task that is completely impossible, so that Kenichi will be so focused on that failure that he doesn't notice any of the progress he's made.
 * This is the preferred method of Hayato Furinji (a.k.a. The Elder). Akisame also often uses it. Other masters not so often, especially not Apachai who teaches very directly.
 * Takamura, towards Ippo in Hajime no Ippo.
 * Possibly,  towards   in X 1999
 * Cross Marian of D.Gray-man, with a healthy dose of Comedic Sociopathy. His poor protege qualifies for an honorable mention under Abusive Parents thanks to Cross's Jerkassitude. Unfortunately, it's played for laughs.
 * One very twisted example is the relationshp between Askeladd and Thorfinn in Vinland Saga. Askeladd sees himself is this towards Thorfinn, but Thorfinn hates Askeladd with a burning passion, and would sooner die then admit he had any such relationship with the man.
 * Hattori in Bakuman｡, long after he's no longer actually Ashirogi Muto's editor.
 * Clow Reed in Cardcaptor Sakura. He has no issues leading Sakura and his own creations to believe that a danger is very real, only to reveal after they overcome it that there never was any risk.
 * In Nagasarete Airantou, main protagonist Ikuto has a Stealth Mentor (literally, even; Ikuto had no idea who he was, at first) in the West Leader, one of the Four Leaders that govern the island, and arguably the strongest of said four. When the West Leader finally reveals his identity to Ikuto, he quickly swerves into this type.
 * Xerxes Break in Pandora Hearts.
 * In Durarara a very, very generous interpretation of Izaya's character places him as one of these. His favorite hobby is messing with people's heads, manipulating them into going through emotionally devastating circumstances, seemingly For the Lulz. However, the ordeals Izaya puts people through often force them to confront some ugly truths about themselves, as Izaya is happy to point out. They may not be happier, but Izaya's victims are often wiser for having been used by him.

Comic Books
"Fone Bone: The dragon's doing this! He wants you to think he doesn't exist! The Red Dragon: (Pokes his head out of a well) Actually, I just want her to think you're nuts."
 * In many ways, the Silver Age Superman was one of these, particularly to his pal Jimmy Olsen and his girlfriend, Lois Lane (as well as his various other girlfriends). There are countless stories where Superman puts his loved ones through various sorts of Hell in order to teach them lame moral lessons. For Jimmy, the lessons often boiled down to "don't drink things you're not supposed to;" for Lois, they usually were "stop trying to find out my secret identity/trick me into marrying you." For the readers, the lesson was "Superman is a dick."
 * The Super-Teacher From Krypton was a robot built by Jor-El to teach his son. Of course, then the planet blew up... but by a fluke, the robot survived (a lot of Kryptonian stuff survived in the Silver Age) and eventually found Kal-El as a teenager on Earth. The robot took it upon itself to guide him in the wise use of his powers. The robot appeared twice, once in the Silver Age and then once in the Bronze Age. In both cases, it acted like an incredibly high-handed and manipulative Jerkass, and while Clark had to admit he had learned valuable lessons from it, he was very glad when the wretched thing took off back into outer space. So maybe this is where Supes picked up these same qualities when "mentoring" people as an adult.
 * The Red Dragon from Bone is a pretty low-key example; but it's especially noticable in the early parts of the comic, where he in between his lazing around and Big Damn Heroes moments will occasionally do some pretty weird things, either to teach the protagonists a lesson or just mess around with them.

Film

 * Mr. Miyagi from The Karate Kid, as a particularly iconic example.
 * Nanny McPhee in the movie of the same name.
 * Yoda.
 * Willy Wonka in Charlie and the Chocolate Factory is a variation. Gene Wilder, who played him in 1971, beautifully summarizes this trope with the story of agreeing to do the film on one condition: he wanted to make his entrance with a cane, limping, then suddenly somersaulting, "Because from that point on, no one will know if I'm telling the truth or lying." The director agreed to it, and the rest is history.
 * In The Grifters, Roy Dillon (John Cusack) finds a Con Man and asks to be taught how to be a grifter. The man agrees and gives him some advice. At the end of their conversation the man asks Dillon for $10. After Dillon gives it to him, the man says "Come around tomorrow, I'll take you again."
 * "The Old Man", of The Golden Child, played by none other than Victor Wong, who would later go on to play Egg Chen in Big Trouble in Little China. His first appearance to Eddie Murphy's Chandler Jarrell has him pretending to be a Tibetan street vendor selling junk jewelry, and scamming Jarrell out of money as a Secret Test of Character.
 * Played for Laughs in Dodgeball, where the team's mentor, Patches O'Houlihan, goes so far as to throw wrenches at the players, declaring that "if you can dodge a wrench, you can dodge a ball".
 * "If you can dodge traffic, you can dodge a ball!"
 * Buddy in Anger Management.
 * Lionel Logue in The King's Speech.

Literature
"Ista: "What training? You never explained anything." Bastard: "Instructing you, sweet Ista, would be like teaching a falcon to walk up to its prey. It might with great effort be done, but one would end with a very footsore and cranky bird, and a tedious wait for dinner. With a wingspan like yours, it's ever so much easier to shake you from my wrist and see you fly." Ista: "Plummet." Bastard: "No. Not You. Granted, you tumble and complain halfway to the abyss, but eventually you do spread your wings and soar.""
 * Mary Poppins, of the book and movie of the same name.
 * "Mr. Wednesday" in American Gods.
 * Hagbard Celine in The Illuminatus Trilogy.
 * Likewise, the Dealy Lama (no misspelling). Both more or less good guys who make extreme effort to appear unreliable or even dangerous and evil to their wards. When you manage to connect the dots, you'll realize that the Dealy Lama took this Beyond the Impossible:
 * Terry Pratchett's Discworld novel Thief of Time includes Lu-Tze, a deliberate pastiche of Mr. Miyagi style trickster mentors. In true Zen form the humble sweeper Lu-Tze never quite lets on whether he's a profoundly enlightened wiseman with reality-defying martial arts powers or just a wiseass who gets by on audacity and luck alone. Right up until the end, when it is revealed
 * In the Strugatsky Brothers' later Noonverse novels, Rudolf Sikorski, the Government Conspiracy Knight Templar, works somewhat like that with the protagonist Maxim Kammerer. He keeps shooting the dog and does a classic Breaking Speech when Maxim first meets him. It all seems to do Maxim some good service in the end, though.
 * It is impossible to describe the Quintarian deity known as the Bastard from Bujold's Chalion books, Paladin of Souls in particular, as anything but this.


 * Hasan ibn Sabbah in Vladimir Bartol's Alamut, with the twist that he usually has the followers who realize that he is a trickster covertly killed. When one of them survives and comes back for revenge, he declares him as his own son in every sense but biological, and blesses his search for enlightenment. And it works!
 * Fizban in the Dragonlance Chronicles trilogy.
 * Vergere from the New Jedi Order. Later works established her as being also an Evil Mentor.
 * K. Pinkerton Silverfish, the author of the titular self-help book in Stephen Manes' children's novella Be a Perfect Person in Just Three Days. The protagonist Milo does all sorts of ridiculous things at Dr. Silverfish's instruction, like wearing a stalk of broccoli around his neck, going without food for a whole day, and finally staying up all night doing nothing but laying in bed and drinking weak tea. When Milo screws up by nodding off during the last task, the book reassures him by explaining the moral of the story: nobody's perfect, and people who obsess over trying to be perfect just make themselves look silly.
 * An Elegy for the Still-living: Robin Goodfellow, when he isn't just messing with Francis for the fun of it.
 * In The Once and Future King the wizard Merlyn teaches Arthur/The Wart through a series of trials by transforming him into various animals to prepare him for life once he becomes the High King.

Live Action TV
"Claude: "Do! Something! Unexpected!""
 * Q, from the various Star Trek series, plays tricks that seem borderline evil at times, but ultimately contain an important lesson . . . unless he's just messing with you.
 * 3 big ones, he engineers a contact between the Enterprise and the Borg, giving the Federation knowledge about them and time to prepare a year before they will arrive anyways. Another time, Q gives Picard a chance for a Do-Over when he was young and brash with the promise it won't affect others, leading Picard to discover that untidy past was necessary for him to be himself, and finally, Q sets up Picard to create the Paradox that would prevent life evolving on Earth; but at the same time gives him the tools to escape.
 * The Continuum itself managed a double-header. In making Q mortal for his constant jerk-ass behavior, they taught him a bit of humility, but also got to see how humanity would treat someone who had put them through so much aggravation while he was helpless.
 * Sabrina's Quiz Master on Sabrina the Teenage Witch.
 * The Trickster from Supernatural. Half the time he's teaching a lesson, and the other half he's just killing for fun. Oh, and  Arguably, he is always teaching someone a lesson, these just usually go over the recipient's head. Often because said head is rolling away.
 * Claude from Heroes, whose training methods include gleefully whacking his pupil over the head with a stick and throwing him off the roof of a skyscraper.


 * Mr. Roarke from Fantasy Island. He'll give you the means to fulfill your biggest dream, but it doesn't mean he'll grant said dream to you in exactly the way you want it to be. You'll have to learn your lesson through it, and sometimes your life and sanity will depend on it...
 * Garak was a Trickster Mentor to Bashir in Star Trek: Deep Space Nine.
 * Satan himself plays a Trickster Mentor to Zeke in Brimstone and Sam in Reaper.
 * In their essay "The Sound of One House Clapping" (appearing in the volume House and Philosophy), Jeffrey C. Russ and Jeremy Barris argue that House is a trickster mentor in the classic Zen tradition. The closing arc of Season 3 has Foreman wrestling with the prospect that he's an Evil Mentor. This comes back in Season 6
 * R.J. in Power Rangers Jungle Fury fulfills this role. He often will have the rangers do seemingly stupid things in the name of teaching them valuable lessons.
 * Also Dimitria from Power Rangers Turbo, who spends much of her time speaking in riddles for the team to solve.
 * Max Malini in The Cape

Mythology
"Once a renown philosopher and moralist was traveling through the land and stopped in Nasrudin's village. He asked Nasrudin to recommend a place to eat, and, being hungry for intelligent company as well, invited Nasrudin to accompany him. At the restaurant, they asked the waiter what the special of the day was, and were told, "Fish -- fresh fish!" They ordered two.
 * Older Than Print: Some versions of Merlin and Morgan le Fay from the Arthurian mythos.
 * Trickster figures in myth and folklore tend to vary by region -- particularly with the Native American tricksters. Raven was typically the more wise, trickster mentor. Crow tended to be more mercurial, even malicious. Coyote inhabited pretty much the entire spectrum between trickster creator, noble trickster, mean-spirited prankster, and avatar of chaos; depending on the particular region and people. African and European tricksters varied similarly by people and region. Anansi generally deviated between being brilliant but so lazy that he never got anything done and brilliant but so conceited that he stumbled over his own convoluted tricks. Loki is clever but doesn't seem to have any particular lessons in mind with his tricks.
 * Nasrudin (also called Nasruddin, Nasredin, and Nasreddin, or if you're an Arab, Juha, Jawha, Guha, and--deep breath--Goha) was the king of this. A famous Sufi Muslim form of this, he varies from eminently wise to incredibly stupid to a mixture of the two depending on the story. Besides being a general Trickster, he has a strong Trickster Mentor aspect. For example:
 * He was brought to hear the Emir (i.e. prince) recite a poem he had written. After all the other people in attendance had given their (very flattering) reviews, Goha (I'm an Arab) said: "With respect, my lord, your poem was terrible." The Emir immediately ordered him to be jailed for thirty days. Shortly after Goha was released, the Emir had another poem recital. When the Emir asked Goha his opinion, Goha immediately stood up and started for the door. "Where are you going?" asked the Emir. "To the jail, my lord," responded Goha.
 * That story is Older Than Feudalism.
 * Another example, this one taken from an affiliate of The Other Wiki:

When the waiter brought the fish on a great platter, however, one was noticeably larger than the other. Nasrudin, seeing this, immediately slid the larger fish onto his own plate. The philosopher, shocked, proceeded to berate Nasrudin at length for violating the precepts of every religion and moral system ever thought of.

At the end of this, Nasrudin asked, "What would you have done?"

The philosopher said, "I, as a conscientious human, would have taken the smaller fish."

Nasrudin replied, "Here you go, then", and slid the smaller fish onto the philosopher's plate."


 * There are entire schools of Zen Buddhism and Sufi Islam dedicated to this.
 * Certain schools of Hinduism regard the Buddha as a Trickster Mentor of Hinduism: they believe that he was the ninth incarnation of Vishnu, sent to teach falsehood so that Hindus would know the danger of being sucked into reasonable-seeming but wrong religious arguments.

Theater

 * El Gallo in The Fantasticks is this, though the protagonists never quite recognize him as such.

Video Games

 * Jade Empire furnishes a few examples. Master Li is characterized this way early on, with several characters remarking on his idiosyncratic behavior. The Forest Shadow is a more complete example: she's a powerful fox spirit (see the citation on Coyote above), a class of beings assigned by the Celestial Bureaucracy to confront humans with Secret Tests of Character--even when she needs your help, this is how she approaches you.
 * Ovan picked up this habit in .hack GU, giving him the Fan Nickname of Trollvan.
 * In Westwood Studio's 1997 game based on the film Blade Runner, Graf acts as one to the protagonist Ray McCoy.

Web Comics
"Dron: For future reference, half of what I teach you in this class will be true. The other half will be a lie. Your final grade depends on how good you are at telling the difference. Aylia: Yep. That's consistent. Dron: Of course, I wouldn't lie to you today... or would I?"
 * In Thog Infinitron, Shaman Magog acts both as Thog's mentor and trickster, often leading Thog into situations that will allow Thog to grow as a human being, but sometimes seemingly just for his own entertainment.
 * Netta from DDG veers between trickster or cynical mentor depending on her mood
 * In Ascension, Telious gives Aramis a sword and no training, and makes him face "zombie fight surprise" many times after it's very very clear Aramis has no sword talent or training. Then he sends Aramis (after having him fatally backstabbed by an assassin) against another zombie, but with no sword just a little golden whistle. Aramis technically fails the test by not even attempting to use magic for which he has no training, but passes it by attempting to kill Telious before he bleeds to death - and still keeping up the belief that despite Telious being a sick bastard he keeps hope because despair is a form of sloth his church warns against.
 * Tell me of a religion where keeping hope is a central tenet and respect for the church itself is expendable, I'd consider joining if there aren't any surprise zombie fights!
 * Not to mention Aramis is sent to scout ominous ancient evils that may or may not exist by himself, and not told the person he's supposed to meet is part demon yet a nice person! The total lack of instructions or even hints in dealing with evil makes this church's moral standards very peculiar indeed...
 * Coyote in Gunnerkrigg Court has become this to Antimony Carver.
 * Dron the Dragon, full stop.


 * In Sinfest, Buddha, in the best Zen tradition, offers a flower in response to a request for enlightenment.

Web Original

 * In Whateley Universe, Chou is 'blessed' with the Monkey King as a mentor. In "Summoning Sweeties", the Monkey King explains his/her actions all but quoting this trope.

Western Animation
"Manic: Do you ever give a straight answer? Oracle: What do you think?"
 * Rafiki the baboon from The Lion King. Behaves like this only during Simba's revelation that he cannot keeping moping over his past, and returns to his homeland to correct the Circle of Life (he actually whacks Simba over the head with his staff, without warning). However, he may act like this more often, outside of the story.
 * He definitely acts like this in the Timon and Pumbaa series
 * The Dungeon Master from the cartoon Western Animation//DungeonsAndDragons.
 * Puck (of Shakespeare fame) in Gargoyles
 * King Bumi for the duration of "The King of Omashu" on Avatar: The Last Airbender.
 * Iroh arguably also fits the mold, though his ward turns out to be so thickheaded that eventually he just ends up spelling out his teachings when the subtleties fail.
 * The Oracle of Delphius from Sonic Underground fills this trope. He comes complete with koan-slinging and a lampshade.


 * Princess Celestia from My Little Pony: Friendship Is Magic. She so often sets up the episode's whole source of conflict, runs away when anything dangerous happens, or chooses not to be a Deus Ex Machina even when she could easily solve everything on her own that fans have dubbed her "Princess Trollestia"
 * She knows full well about the prophecy predicting that her sister which she imprisoned is about to escape and wreak havok, and rather than explain things, or even do anything herself, she just tells the protagonist to "stop reading those dusty old books" and make friends, and is absent for the rest of the episode. Incidentally this is exactly what needs to be done, and as she notes later, she never explicitly said that the prophecies were wrong.
 * She knows that Twilight has six friends, but gives her only two tickets to the Gala, forcing her to agonize over who to give the extra ticket to. Though there is some controversy over whether she might have honestly expected Twilight to just go with Spike.
 * She sits back and watches as Rarity plummets to her doom, letting Rainbow Dash have a Big Damn Heroes moment. The fact that Rarity was put in this situation due to the heat of the sun, and the fact that Celestia controls the sun leads some to suspect that she caused the whole incident to begin with.
 * She invites the main characters to a snooty boring rich-people party in the hopes that they'll cause a disaster and liven up the event.
 * In spite of being over 1,000 years old, she acts as though she's never heard of Parasprites when she finally visits the ruined town at the end of the episode.
 * She might be honest here. She certainly looks completely surprised at Pinkie Pie's stunt. Parasprites are from the Everfree Forest, a place that she might not be knowledgeable with.
 * She might very well not. After all she lived there before her sister's Face Heel Turn.
 * She intentionally tricks overzealous waiters into filling her teacup to overflowing.
 * She takes her old, dying pet bird to a party, then runs away and leaves it there with Fluttershy, resident animal lover,

Real Life

 * Ken Kesey.
 * Aleister Crowley.