Another Gay Movie

A 2006 parody of gay movies and teen movies. The plot very closely follows American Pie, but with gay characters: the four teenage friends Andy, Nico, Jared and Griff make a pact to lose their anal virginity by the end of the summer. Goes straight for the Squick and, well, isn't for everyone (although it's a lot better than some similarly-titled movies).

Spawned a sequel of dubious quality called Another Gay Sequel: Gays Gone Wild -- which takes its plot from Girls Gone Wild


 * Actor Allusion: Stephanie McVay reprises her role from Edge of Seventeen, and the coming-out scene is almost identical until the comedic twist. Writer and director Todd Stephens also wrote Edge of Seventeen. Not to mention the poster of Edge of Seventeen in the video shop.
 * All Gays Are Promiscuous
 * Ass Shove: Quite a lot, particularly with Andy.
 * Bi the Way: Andy's dad, when they encounter each other in a public bathroom.
 * Butch Lesbian: Muffler.
 * Camp Gay: Nico, massively. His mom tells him "Duh!" when he comes out to her.
 * Cast Full of Gay: Not sure if there's a single straight character in the whole movie.
 * What about the blind chick?
 * Caught with Your Pants Down: The first scene with Andy masturbating with vegetables; a later scene where he is caught having sex with a quiche, with a gerbil up his ass.
 * Coming Out Story: Mostly averted, and subverted when Nico's mom knows already and thinks it's obvious -- showing up in the next scene covered in PFLAG badges, spoofing the mom from Queer as Folk.
 * A Date with Rosie Palms: The first scene involving Andy and a collection of oddly shaped vegetables, clearly a spoof of American Pie.
 * Dawson Casting: About as much as one might expect in order to legally depict teen sexuality, but especially notable is Nico, whose actor was nearly 30 at the time of filming yet still looks age-appropriate for a high-school graduate.
 * Depraved Bisexual: Andy's dad.
 * Drag Queen: Andy's mom.
 * Four Man Band:
 * The Hero -- Andy
 * The Smart Guy -- Griff
 * The Big Guy -- Jared
 * The Chick -- Nico
 * Fun with Acronyms: Spoofing MILF to get GILWAD, something along the lines of "Grandad I'd Like to Wine And Dine Me".
 * Their home town is San Torum (a reference to the word santorum), and the high school sports team is called the San Torum Donkeys.
 * Incest Is Relative: Andy nearly gets it on with his dad in a public bathroom... then in the second movie they have full on raging sex by accident.
 * Latin Lover: Andy's boyfriend in the second movie.
 * Lesbian Jock: Muffler.
 * Love Epiphany:
 * Love Triangle
 * A Man Is Always Eager: Parodied, subverted and inverted, the guys are gay, but they're all eager to have sex, while still being nervous about it. Plus, they all proclaim themselves to be the dominant "tops" of their relationship, including the submissive "bottom". The one who is most eager about having sex is actually.
 * May-December Romance:
 * Quest for Sex
 * Sensual Slavs: Graham Norton's character.
 * Sex Comedy
 * Sex as Rite-Of-Passage
 * Shout-Out: Numerous films are referenced or spoofed, and Nico and his mom own a video store, and he spends most of the day adorning the walls with gay film posters.
 * Invisible to Gaydar: Jared. Andy and Griff veer towards this too.
 * The Other Darrin: Three of the main actors were replaced for the second movie; lampshaded by Nico's mom, lamenting that the actors didn't want people to think they were gay.
 * While this may have a grain of truth to it, some of the reviews for the second movie remarked that the original actors' agents more likely took a look at the script and felt that the actors' careers wouldn't exactly benefit from such an inferior sequel.
 * And the actor playing Nico was also credited as an executive producer in the first film, so he was most likely contractually obliged to resume the role in the sequel and/or may have partially financed the production. Either way, this would force him to be available to perform a reprise of his character in the sequel too, while his co-stars from the original film had no such obligations.
 * The Twink: Nico.
 * Token Lesbian: Muffler.
 * Where Everybody Knows Your Flame: The bar in the first movie.