Special:Badtitle/NS90:Forum:Trope Talk/Complete Monster YMMV/reply (7)

I guess the thing is, I don't see how this is a greater judgement call than, say, Tsundere. In fact, I think it's less YMMV than Tsundere, because a character might be "a little bit" tsuntsun, where as Complete Monster has a finish line of which you at least have to be in the close vicinity to qualify. Borderline cases are still cases, as we have a fairly bright-line border.

Almost all tropes imply a judgement call, because of inversions, subversions, perversions, and all of the various metatropes. Disagreement among which examples qualify is not a reason to label it YMMV, because that happens with every trope.