Digging Yourself Deeper



""Ah! You can read... I mean, you are reading. Sorry. It's nice to see people reading. Not a lot of people read these days. People prefer to... hear. But all this 'hearing' is just reading for lazy people. Kids today should be prepared to pick up a book, and not just go around the whole time with all these modern... ears. Sometimes I just wanna rip people's ears off and say 'Read a book, for God's sake!'... Well, actually I'd probably say 'Read a book' first and then rip their ears off, otherwise they wouldn't hear me, hehehe... Actually, I probably wouldn't rip their ears off at all, I'm not a violent person. I like ears! Especially women ears, they're my favorite. I don't mean I collect them or anything! I don't have a big bucket of women ears hidden away somewhere. No, No, No, I'm not after your ears really. Not that there's anything wrong with your ears! You know if I was some kind of mad ear person, your ears would be the pride of my... ear bucket.""

- Jeff, Coupling -- "The Girl with Two Breasts"

In a Sitcom, often a character will say something that's just meant to be a friendly little remark, and it will come out wrong, possibly sounding crazy or offensive; they'll try and clarify it (whether they really need to or not), but just make things worse, and dig themselves deeper and deeper into the crazy/offensive pit. Exceptionally deep and/or frequent excavations are commonplace in Cringe Comedies.

May eventually lead to Shutting Up Now.

See also That Came Out Wrong, Freudian Slippery Slope, Did I Just Say That Out Loud?. Compare Verbal Backpedaling.

Contrast Change the Uncomfortable Subject.

Not to be confused with Dug in Deeper where someone pursues something because they're told they're great at it, even though they're not, or Dug Too Deep, which is about physical digging.

Anime & Manga
"Kaorin: (Sigh) Sakaki is so cool...
 * Kaorin has this one in Azumanga Daioh: Supplementary Materials:

Osaka: Kaorin, are you gay?

Kaorin: The correct term is lesbian! Uh, not that I'm a lesbian!! (next strip) It's just, you know, a teenage thing. That's all. Anyway, that's not what I meant when I said she was cool. Just to prove it, I wouldn't mind if she was a guy!

(Beat)

Osaka: Huh?"


 * Happens in an extra episode of Durarara!!, when some poor sod attempts to talk down Shizuo with flattery and compares him to a really popular Bishonen actor, Yuuhei Hanejima. Unfortunately for him, said actor is actually Shizuo's little brother, whom Shizuo is very protective of, and he instinctively interprets the namedrop as an attempt to invade Yuuhei's privacy through him. Of course, since the poor sod doesn't know this, he just thinks Shizuo's suddenly angry because he hates Yuuhei—so he rescinds his previous statement and calls Yuuhei an asshole. The only thing surprising about what happens next is that the poor sod actually survived.
 * Early in AIR, Yukito's explanation about why he was hugging Kano is like this, and leads to Hijiri getting angry and charging him with scalpels. Luckily, Misuzu's intervention means that Hijiri's reaction is Played for Laughs.
 * In The World God Only Knows, Keima has an accidental pervert moment with Haqua with a predictable result despite him not even really caring. A bit later, he reassures her by saying he has no memory of her naked body anyway. This might help normally, only Haqua is already bothered by the way he never shows attraction to anyone or anything outside of his games. Cue getting hit again.
 * A dramatic example occurs in Happy Yarou Wedding, when a drunken makeout session is suddenly halted by Yuuhi and Todou fears he's made him uncomfortable and lies that he mistook him for his dead wife. Since Yuuhi had stopped because he was shocked to realize he was in love with Todou, this crushes him and he decides to never return. Todou then persistently texts him with messages like "I have no interest in men" and "sorry for making you feel bad" in attempt to get him to come back, but of course this just makes Yuuhi even more upset.
 * In FLCL, Mamimi confronts Naota and accuses him of having a crush on Haruko, to which Naota replies, "How can you like someone who's insane?" The problem is that Mamimi is a pyromaniac arsonist, and Naota knows this.

Comicbooks
"Chad: Awwwwh, c'mon Patty! When I said girl gamers were lame I wasn't referring to you! You're just like one of the guys. Patty: Like one of the guys? Your character suddenly hears a rustling in the underbrush. Roll for initiative. Tank: Careful, Chad. You're digging that hole deeper and deeper."
 * A stunningly awkward moment for Nurse Annie in issue #421 of Uncanny X-Men, doubling as a bit of a Freudian Slippery Slope.
 * Chad from 'Patty's Perps' in Knights of the Dinner Table is a master of this.

"Beetle: My armor should be able to track the watchamatrix's energy sig, but the tracking's all kaflooey. Probability-alteration factor, maybe?...I'm sorry! I'm not making excuses. I swear! I know you hate excuses! I'm trying, I promise! I just- Batman: Jaime... Relax. Beetle: ...Ohmygodyou'renotreallyBatman... OhgodIsaidthatoutloud...
 * The third Blue Beetle stumbles into this when he teams up with Batman in The Brave and the Bold (revived series issue #3).

Batman: Jaime...

Beetle: What? Don't kill me."

"Seven: That hole you're digging is getting deeper."
 * Rocky (from the Swedish furry comic, not the boxer) once gets into this when meeting his current girlfriend's father (I think it was...). He wants to compliment him on his house, but makes a Freudian Slip and substitutes "dick" for "house", and then it gets worse. The girlfriend's father shuts him up with the wonderful comeback: "Kid, if you've put your foot in your mouth, at least have the sense to stand still!"
 * Used as a visual metaphor in the furry comic ISO, when Cody has to swiftly make up lies about his supposed girlfriend to keep his parents from finding out about Doug, as well as the fact he's on the outs with Todd and has a roommate he can't stand.
 * The tie-in comic for Star Trek Elite Force involves Beissman responding enthusiastically to the assignment of watching Seven's back. She handles it in her usual manner.

Film
"Richard: Hi Maggie. Not eating? Maggie: Why are you all so obsessed with what I eat? I am not too skinny. Richard: No, no, no, no. I don't mean... Just that you'll need your energy for the team games. I mean, you're perfect just the way you are. And when I say perfect, I obviously don't mean that in a sexual way. I mean perfect in a neutral way. As if I were another woman saying that you were perfect, you know? Just one woman to another. Not that I'm implying anything like that. Or that there's anything wrong with that... sort of thing. Or... anything. Steve: 'Keep digging, we can still see you."
 * Done in Severence with a great jab at the end:

"Woman: Everyone in the building has been so nice to me. Jim: Well, that's because you've got big jugs! I mean, your boobs are huge. I mean, I want to squeeze them. I mean..."
 * Jim Carrey's character in Liar Liar, cursed so that he Can Not Tell a Lie, boards an elevator with a well-endowed woman. The first words out of his mouth are about her breasts. As he tries to cover himself, more and more lines about her rack spill out... Gilligan Cut to him leaving the elevator, having gotten well-slapped.


 * Done rather drolly in The Great New Wonderful. Pastry chef Emme, along with her assistants, is presenting a line of birthday cakes to a wealthy Park Avenue girl. The girl expresses interest in one cake, commenting on how beautiful it is. One of Emme's assistants, Justin, then chimes in with "And it's easy on the hips." Another assistant hastily bails him out by explaining that the cake is a low-density one that doesn't require a lot of processed sugar to hold it up. When he's done, Justin says "That just basically means it's less fattening."
 * Happens to Cady repeatedly in Mean Girls. She refers to the phenomenon as 'word vomit'.

Literature
""Hi, Jack, it's me. Jas. Jasmine. I'm sorry I missed you on IM yesterday but I got arrested for murder. I mean, I didn't do it, but I accidentally told the police I did, so it was confusing. Now we're going for dinner at The House That Kills, but that is only a nickname because a lot of people have died there, but it's completely safe. Anyway, I hope you're having a very nice morning and not melting in anyone's mouth or hands - Sorry, I meant molting. On anyone. Ha ha. Because molting is bad. Unless you're a wee creature of the forest, but - um, never mind, I've got to go, bye.""
 * In the chick-lit/mystery novels Bad Kitty and Kitty Kitty, the main character Jasmine Callihan has this problem a lot. She blames it all on the monkeys that live in her head. For instance, when she is trying to leave a message on her boyfriend's cell phone, while she is convinced he is cheating on her, Hilarity Ensues:

"Melchior: Judging from past experience and what little I've heard, I'm thinking you're following the pattern where you start out in a lot of trouble, and then through a series of brilliantly chosen words, make it infinitely worse."
 * A scene in Robert Asprin's Myth-ing Persons has Guido doing this to himself with his employer Skeeve; he only belatedly informs Skeeve that they're being followed, and then tries to defend himself by saying that the follower is so obvious that any idiot could tell they were there. Fellow employee Massha cheerfully invokes this trope.
 * In the Gaunts Ghosts novel Blood Pact, Gaunt tricks  into going for his medical by making the latter condemn the person who hadn't gone for medicals until he realises that he's talking about himself.
 * Ravirn: Ravirn has a tendency towards this, which Melchior lampshades in WebMage:


 * In the Belgariad/Malloreon by David Eddings, several characters fall for this, usually cut short by another character suggesting "Why don't you just stop talking now." or "What a fascinating observation, why don't we pursue that line of thought." or similar.

Live-Action TV
"Jeff: You have the eyes of ten women. ...I don't mean, like, in a jar. I wasn't accusing you."
 * Was made into something of an art by Coupling, in which attempted conversation-starters, usually by the hapless Jeff, devolved into such subjects as amputation, and collecting human ears in a bucket. In fact, this page used to be called "Bucket Of Ears".

"Steve: Well erm, you've got four breasts... Jill: I'm sorry? Steve: No, no hang on. Jill: This blouse isn't particularly flattering actually... Steve: No, no. Jill: If nothing else. Steve: I'm not saying you've got four at the moment, just when you're... Jill: What? Steve: Excited. Jill: You think I develop extra breasts when I'm excited? Steve: Not so much develop as, you know... acquire. Jill: What in the name of God are you talking about? Steve: Sorry, sorry I've been totally sidetracked by the irrelevance of your breasts. Not that you have irrelevant breasts! You've only got two, that's for sure. Unless you were some sort of cow. No! No, an attractive cow! Or a prize winning cow! But you're not a cow. You're a person. But I'm sure that you'd be a prize winning person if they had a sort of cattle market for women! A women market! Which, thinking about it would be a bad thing in many ways."
 * A non-Jeff example is when Steve talks to Jane's psychiatrist Jill. She thinks that he's nervous because sometimes what she does makes people nervous in a social context. Believing her to be Jane's girlfriend, he tells her that "you girls" have got "the best of both worlds." When pushed to explain what he's talking about, he uses a metaphor Jeff brought up earlier in the episode:

"Y'know, Buffy, Spring Fling just isn't any dance. It's a time for students to choose, um... a mate and then we can... observe their... mating rituals and tag them before they migrate just kill me."
 * Steve gets a lot of these, usually digging a lot faster than Jeff. During his run-in with his celebrity crush Mariella Frostrup, she apologises for spilling her drink on his pants. He replies "Don't worry about it, I was about to go to the toilet anyway. Not that I was intending to wet my trousers, obviously. Although I am pleased to meet you." At this point he has a hilarious "What the hell I am I saying?" look on his face.
 * Oliver carries on the tradition well on several occasions, such as his conversation with Jane about the large number of toilet rolls he's buying.
 * Seen in the Friends episode "The One Where Ross Can't Flirt," in which Ross's attempts to flirt with a pizza delivery girl degenerate into a lecture on the smell of gas and an intended compliment which makes Ross sound like a pedophile.
 * There was another one where he ended up talking about sewage.
 * And Chandler brought up another occassion, when Ross talked about the Irish Potato Famine.
 * Chandler also did this once, while attempting to suck up to Monica's parents.
 * In an episode of Scrubs, Elliot meets a guy named Sean, but her attempts to strike a conversation up with him end with them talking about poo. "At one point I tried changing the subject to art. But we went from art to artists, to alcohol, to coffee...and that just led right back to poo!"
 * When she first tried talking to Jake, her boyfriend for twenty minutes in season 4, the only thing she could think of was to compliment him on what a perfectly square head he has.
 * There was that one very early episode with Elliot and Carla feuding over Elliot tattling on Carla for not doing something. When Elliot apologizes and then doubles back to elaborate on her reasoning, the scene shifts to a visual gag of her standing in a grave literally "digging herself deeper"; as Carla and the other nurses look on in like the Mafia.
 * Digging Yourself Deeper is pretty much the basis of every episode of Curb Your Enthusiasm where Larry David makes an innocuous statement which is taken badly, or misheard, and the ensuing consequences lead to hilarious further exchanges and climax.
 * Any sitcom involving Ricky Gervais.
 * One House episode had Cameron trying to explain to a TV crew that when she said it was exciting being around him, she didn't mean it that way. It failed in a spectacular way. Because, you know, she kinda actually felt that way in the first place.
 * Xander (of Buffy the Vampire Slayer fame) was very prone to this.

"Buffy: See? I told you, Old Reliable. Willow: Oh, thanks. Buffy: What? Willow: Old Reliable? Yeah, great, there's a sexy nickname. Buffy: Well, I-I didn't mean it as... Willow: No, it's fine. I'm Old Reliable. Xander: She just means, you know, the geyser. You're like a geyser of fun that goes off at intervals. Willow: That's Old Faithful. Xander: Isn't that the dog that that guy had to shoot...? Willow: That's Old Yeller! Buffy: Xander, I beg you not to help me."
 * The kicker is that he's not even talking to Buffy, just practicing with Willow.
 * Which rather neatly demonstrates the wisdom of doing so, yes?
 * Buffy and Xander also get another good one in "Doppelgangland":

"The Doctor: What are you doing that for? Mickey(holding down a button): Because you told me to. The Doctor: When was that? Mickey: About half an hour ago. The Doctor: Um... you can let go now. Mickey: Well, how long has it been since I could've stopped? The Doctor: Ten minutes? Twenty? Twenty-nine?"
 * In Doctor Who, the Doctor does this quite a lot, especially in his fourth and tenth versions. However, this is quite often a highly calculated move on his part, as a way of distracting the person he is talking to.
 * Though not always:

"The Doctor: Lovely to meet you, Mrs Jones. Heard a lot about you. Francine: Have you? What have you heard then? The Doctor: Oh, you know; that you're Martha's mother, and...um...no, actually, that's - that's about it. We haven't had much time to chat, you know, we've been...busy. Francine: "Busy"? Doing what, exactly? The Doctor: Oh, you know...stuff..."
 * or:

"The Doctor: Agatha Christie! I was just talking about you the other day. I said, "I bet she's brilliant." I'm the Doctor; this is Donna. Oh, I love your stuff. What a mind! You fool me every time. Well, almost every time. Well, once or twice. Well, once, but it was a good once!"
 * Also well done in the episode The Unicorn & The Wasp:

"The Doctor: But the last time, with Martha, like I said, it got complicated. and it was all my fault. I mean... (sighs) I just want a mate. Donna: You just want TO MATE??! The Doctor: I just want A mate! Donna: You're not mating with me, sunshine! The Doctor: A mate, I want, a! Mate!"
 * And when the Doctor was inviting Donna to travel with him, but wanted to clear up the fact that he wasn't looking for a relationship:

"Doctor: Rory! What a relief! I'd thought I'd burst out of the wrong cake. Again. That reminds me, there's a girl sitting outside in a bikini, could someone let her inside and give her a jumper? Lucy? Lovely girl. Diabetic. Now then, Rory. We need to talk about your fiancé. She tried to kiss me. Tell you what though, you're a lucky man, she's a great kisser. (pause as everyone stares at him in amazement) Doctor (uncomfortably): Funny how you can say something in your head and it sounds fine..."
 * Used yet again when the Doctor goes to talk to Amy's fiancé...and opts to show up by jumping out of a stripper's cake (at his bachelor party):

"Niles:Yes, and even if by some small chance that were to happen, Daphne, I could always use you. ...I, I would know of a position you could take. ...Services that you could perform. ...I would know of an opening. ...This is on me.]"
 * Thank God You're Here tries to actively induce this in contestants. The master of it is Frank Woodley, who can go somewhere horribly, horribly wrong with whatever they throw at him.
 * Jayne Cobb from Firefly manages to turn an observation that dead people make him restless into defensively insisting that he isn't a necrophiliac. He was just giving examples of things he does when he's restless. Nothing corpse-specific in there.
 * Jayne's good at this, but Simon is the undisputed master. Especially if Kaylee's in the room.
 * Heck, the fact that Simon does this is pretty much the reason he and Kaylee don't get together . They'll be flirting and getting close and just as it looks like they'll kiss, he says something that she thinks is offensive and she storms off.
 * Done in Frasier by Niles when talking to Daphne about her possible dismissal.

""Aw, I bet if you hadn't stopped him he would have gone on like that forever!""
 * Speaking of Frasier, this is the formula for a lot of episodes; a conflict arises, and each attempt at a resolution digs the characters deeper. Some (if most) episodes even end without any resolution at all and show the characters wallowing in self pity in their inability to come to a resolution.
 * Stargate Atlantis has Mckay pulling one off in the episode Trio. When Samanta Carter finally stops him, Keller has a nice little comment:

"Woolsey: You’ve approached my private spot!
 * This exchange from 5.15 'Remnants', as Richard Woolsey sees that a women he's been flirting with found his balcony hang-out spot:

Woman: ...What?

Woolsey: I mean you’ve entered my little personal area.

[Beat]

Woolsey: ...This is where I come... to be alone with my thoughts."

"But she's my Stefania! ...I mean, she's my ex-Stefania. ...I mean, you're my Stefania now... baby."
 * Robert did this at least once on Everybody Loves Raymond. Amy invites Stefania over to a singles party because she thought Peter might like her, but Robert is not happy with her arrival.

"Roy: I'm sorry, it's just that you look exactly like my mother. Not - not that my mother's ugly or anything, she's a very sexy woman. Not that I want to have sex with her, because I know how you psychiatrists think, and my mother would never stand for anything like that. I can see her now... "what you are you doing, Roy? What are you doing?!""
 * Probably the most blatant example is the entire premise of "Faux Pas", where Ray makes a joke about his son's new best friend's dad, tells it to the man himself, and keeps trying to apologize, only making it worse. His family coming in doesn't help, either.
 * In an episode of The IT Crowd, Moss dates a woman that looks exactly like Roy's mother. She's also a psychiatrist, which leads to an... interesting conversation:

"Tony: Do you sleep with a gun under your pillow every night? Kate: That depends. Tony: On what? Kate: On who I'm sleeping with... (she turns around and runs into Gibbs) Oh uhh, I didn't mean that the way it sounded. Tony just asked me what I would do if a man came into my bedroom and I said it depends. I mean it doesn't depend on the man... Tony could you help me out here please?
 * In Cheers, Diane begins by yelling at a prospective employer, "I will not sleep with you!". It actually manages to go downhill from there.
 * When Norm finds his dream job as a beer taste tester and is only an interview with the president away from getting it, Rebecca advises him not to do something stupid like mention his pants. Of course, the first thing he does is say "Nice pants!", not so bad in itself, but he retracts himself immediately, then retracts the retraction and digs his way down to a song and dance number about him not being such a grumpy puss. Camera cut back to the bar and Norm mourning his lost opportunity.
 * Half the fun in The Thick of It and by extension, In the Loop.
 * On Get Smart, a married Max is on a mission dating a KAOS femme fatale; a very pregnant and emotional 99 isn't taking it well. She sniffs "You've stopped loving me just because I've grown fat and unattractive!" He soothingly replies "That's ridiculous - just because you've grown fat and unattractive doesn't mean I don't love you anymore!"
 * Brilliantly done in an episode The Office (American flavor) wherein a) Michael manages to accidentally imply to a superior that the office runs better when he is absent, b) tries to cover that up by saying that it runs much better when he is around after earlier stating that he is frequently away during work hours and c) trying to cover that up by then implying that he his presence or absence has absolutely no meaningful effect on business at all.
 * A minor one from the NCISepisode "UnSEALed":

Tony: She sleeps with a gun boss.

Gibbs: That true?

Kate: Sorta... sometimes... yes.

Gibbs: Good girl!"

"Tony: That's not a short list! (Death Glare from Gibbs) ...of people that - that you've angered just because you have rock-solid principles, and so it's easy for people to misunderstand that, and misconstrue, because, you know, people don't -- Director: Why don't you quit while you're behind, DiNozzo? Tony: I'm trying!"
 * Another from NCIS, after the Director has suggested that Gibbs has "really pissed somebody off":

"I got you a diet soda, 'cause I figured you're probably watching your figure. ...Not that you need to watch your figure, you have a great body! ...Not that I was looking at your body!"
 * Josh of Drake and Josh, on a date with a model:

"Guy: You're a racist! (stalks off) Hawthorne: (ashamed) Yeah..."
 * Gwen did this often, sometimes once an episode during season one of Merlin.
 * In the Hawtho R Ne episode "Final Curtain", the titular nurse keeps doing this with a doctor (or nurse, it wasn't really specified). She tries to get him to talk Arabic to a patient's husband, but (1) the husband is speaking Dari (as we find out from the Army vet nurse Sullivan) and is thus Afghani, & (2) the guy in the turban is Sikh, not any kind of Muslim (and from Chicago).

"McCoy: Say to yourself: "the child is mine. The child is mine. It is mine". Eleen: Yes. It's yours. McCoy: No... no, you've got it all wrong. Eleen: Yes... McCoy... it's yours. McCoy: No. Say to yourself "the child is mine. It is mine. It is--" (Beat) Uh-oh."
 * She manages to keep digging later, by thanking him with a namaste gesture, which is not generally used that way when you're not Hindu.
 * In an episode of Star Trek TOS McCoy is trying to convince a woman (Eleen) to want the child she is going to give birth to:

"Basil: Well then, I'll leave you to it. I mean, to go to bed! To *sleep*! To sleep, perchance to dream."
 * Fawlty Towers - a psychiatrist guest is talking about vacations, and asks Basil, who hadn't heard most of what he'd said, "How often do you and your wife manage it?" Basil thinks he's talking about sex ("that's what it's all about to them!") and gets all indignant and defensive. When he hears from his wife what the psychiatrist was in fact asking about, he rushes out with a plastered-on grin and starts babbling about how he thought he was talking about walks, not sex! NO, vacations! and coming off much worse than he started.
 * Basil digs himself even deeper that night, while bidding the psychiatrist and his wife good night

"Ryan: "Hi. How are you? We don't know what you're watching, so we're not gonna tell you when we're gonna return you to it." Colin: "Oh, w-- We're watching animal porn!" [Beat] *double Face Palm* Ryan: *snickering* Colin: "Mary Had A Little Lamb, we'll be right back in just a second. But you..." (Drew frantically buzzes) Ryan: *laughing out loud*"
 * Whose Line Is It Anyway, Greatest Hits, "Songs of the Motorcycle."

"Karofsky: Who told you that? Santana: No one had to tell me. First of all, I saw you checking out Sam's ass the other day. You really need to be more careful with your leering. Karofsky: I didn't. I was just... seeing what jeans he was wearing. Santana: ...Like that is any less gay."
 * Glee: Santana tells Karofsky that she has figured out that he is gay.

"Jason: Hoyt, I had sex with Jessica. Hoyt: (obviously hurt) How?
 * True Blood gave us this priceless exchange between best friends Jason and Hoyt:

Jason: Well, first we did it missionary, then doggystyle, then...

Hoyt: (clocks him square in the face) I MEANT HOW COULD YOU?!"


 * On The Muppet Show, Miss Piggy tells Danny Kaye how thrilled she is to meet him. Danny says that they've actually met before, which she might not remember because it was a long, long time ago. Then he realizes women don't like to be reminded of their ages, and says it was back when she was thin. The punchline comes during their subsequent musical number: "I'm sorry I said I knew you when you were thin. I never knew you when you were thin."
 * Frequently, this is what people do on Survivor when the jury really doesn't like them and is just picking between the lesser of two-three evils.

Music
"My first crush on an Irish girl... I was ten years old, and her name was Elaine. Little red-haired girl; Well, she looked like you, But if you were ten, Which you're clearly not. Not that you look old, but you get my-- I'll just stop now."
 * The Jason Robert Brown song, "I Could Be In Love With Someone Like You" starts out like this, although the singer recovers admirably by the end of the song:

New Media
"Rosti, can I ask you something as a close friend?  you could ask me something as a complete stranger, but go ahead Do you reckon Emma would go out with me if I asked her?  errr....  ask her yourself? no fucking way until I get a second opinion  dude she's in the channel no she isn't  yeah she is mate, look up  she got op'd yesterday fuck PLAN B spam the channel with text so it goes  hi off her scrollback  ahaha FUCK  I'm going to go install Windows 7 right now  so I'll be offline for a bit  if he gets the balls to come back in here in the meantime tell him the answer is yes  rofl  that was some hardcore nerd courtship ritual right there  Oh man, I wish I could fuck up asking a girl out that badly and still succeed"
 * Overheard semi-example: The first quote here.
 * A bit of transcript from bash.org nicely illustrates this
 * massacre has quit (PLAN C!!!)
 * Audia has quit (QUIT)

Radio

 * Alan Partridge often backtracked with "Not literally; that would be hideous."

Theater
"Cyrano: Oh!. . .death itself is hardly terrible,. ..
 * Cyrano De Bergerac: Act IV, Scene IV gives us this gem: After De Guiche informs the cadets the Last Stand, Cyrano offers Christian the goodbye letter he has prepared for Roxane, whom Cyrano has implied he does not love. Christian sees a spot in the letter and asks Cyrano why he has wept a tear on the letter:

—But, ne'er to see her more! That is death's sting!

—For... I shall never...

(Christian looks at him): We shall...

(Quickly): I mean, you...

Christian (snatching the letter from him): Give me that letter!"

Videogames
"John: When you find yourself in a hole, the first thing to do is stop digging."
 * Shortly after you meet Liara in Mass Effect, she tells you she finds you fascinating because of your encounter with the Prothean beacon on Eden Prime. You can tease her about how clinical her interest sounds ("Sounds like you want to dissect me in a lab"), prompting her flustered response, "I only meant that you would be an interesting specimen for an in-depth study. No, that's even worse!"
 * Tali gets similarly flustered in the sequel.
 * Knights of the Old Republic's Bastila has one or two Freudian slips that result in similar conversations with a male player. One of those conversation paths contains one of the funniest lines of the whole game: when Bastila is trying to clarify what she meant by 'feelings for' the player, a possible response is "You're cute when you're embarassed."
 * Defied in Red Dead Redemption. When talking to his wife about Bonnie, who saved his life, John Marston stops digging and starts giving her compliments.

"Merrill: "... and I'm rambling again, aren't I?""
 * Bioware must love these, because Merrill does this all the time in Dragon Age II, and she knows it.


 * In Portal 2 Wheatley tells Chell that he hates having to look after all the 'smelly humans' and then blusters about it.
 * James Tobin has this happen to him in the game In the 1st Degree. He changes his story of what happened between him and Zack more than once. He admits to shooting himself in the leg because he was afraid no one would believe him when he said that Zack was shot in self-defense. If you play the game right, you get to watch as the prosecutor Granger pins Tobin on the leg-shooting thing. Granger asks if Tobin's first thought was to protect himself as his own business partner was lying there at his feet bleeding to death. Tobin responds by saying no, and that he tried to give Zack CPR. Granger says "You tried giving CPR to a man who was bleeding from the throat?" Tobin then gives a "Yes! I mean...No!" Yep, Tobin is so experiencing this trope.

Webcomics
"Alex: You tell us everything, and I mean everything. Well, not everything, actually. Just the stuff about you and your friends and things. None of that birds and bees stuff. We already know all that, and besides, it's kind of icky."
 * Alex does this once in Angel Moxie.

"Mort: Y'know, It's probably because you're so attractive. I noticed that about you when we first met. Antimony: Oh? Mort: Oh! I uh... I don't mean you're attractive... I mean, like a magnet... or a medium... Haha... Yeah. Ah! B... But I don't mean you aren't... I mean you look really... I... Uh... Oh geez...
 * Mort from Gunnerkrigg Court falls into this when speculating on why Antimony can see The Guides:


 * turns into a tombstone with a picture of a foot going into a mouth*"

"Tagon: I'm not stopping until this hole goes straight through."
 * An essential part of Hannelore the whole cast from Questionable Content
 * Piro of Megatokyo tends to do this a lot. Some times are worse than others.
 * Jeremy from Dead Winter, here.
 * This Darths and Droids, in which Jim gets mixed up between talking in character and out of character, as well as whether Padme is telling Anakin she loves him, or whether he's telling Annie that he loves her.
 * Inherent to Schlock Mercenary. Usually with Tagon, who has done this not only with a compliment to Breya, but his defence in a trial as well.

"Mitzi: Uh... you stopped rowing."
 * Mitzi, realizing that Rocky's been saying that she might've offed her husband tried to reassure Wick that's not the case, but ends up making a lot of joking remarks about offing Rocky.

"Jhalm: Honored Digger... Almost, I could believe I had misjudged you. Except that this very morning, I received a report from one of the Veiled, that you were seen to be consorting with a hyena creature, not half a mile from this spot. The very same creature that attacked me a few days ago. Digger: (stunned expression) Statue of Ganesh: Is this true, Burrower? Digger: Well-- Yes, but-- It wasn't like that! Jhalm: Do you deny that it was the same creature, then? Digger: No-- Jhalm: Do you deny that it attacked me? Digger: No, but-- Jhalm: Do you deny that you were speaking on friendly terms with it? Digger: No! But that's a recent development! We weren't friends before she attacked you! Digger: (Face Palm) Hang on, that didn't come out right at all...
 * Used as a visual metaphor in Flying Suit Reiko, when one character awkwardly confesses his FA/Feederism fetish to his girlfriend. His thought balloons have him digging a hole deeper and deeper. When she finally tells him it's okay and she likes it too, his visual metaphor is raised out of the pit by an oil geyser.
 * El Goonish Shive has a character "good" in this - Abraham, who managed to rile Raven more with every phrase as he tried to explain himself. There are no tongue slips - everything he says is completely intentional - he just doesn't realize that he's hitting another one of Raven's Berserk Buttons with every passing sentence.
 * He's absent for now, but Elliot somehow found his Idiot Ball.
 * Tedd at least can catch himself.
 * Digger has a hilariously cringe-inducing example, split across three pages:

Jhalm: An interesting criterion for friendship, Honored Digger."

"Scratch: There should be no reason for you to feel uncomfortable with this interaction. Try to think of me as one of your kindly human uncle figures. Scratch: In fact, if I were in your presence now, I would offer you candy to prove it."
 * In Everyday Heroes, the local Goth girls refer to Summer's friend as "the Blessed Virgin Carrie". Carrie ignores it, but Summer and Uma try to explain why she should be insulted ... and end up invoking this trope.
 * In Homestuck, Doc Scratch, "an immortal entity with a large cue ball for a head, and no biological means of reproduction", explains to Rose that he doesn't like her that way after being Mistaken for Pedophile:


 * Some people, like Larisa in Sandra and Woo, just shouldn’t try to defend themselves...
 * Misfile Rumisiel manages to pull this big time when talking to Dr. Upton about his daughter. The comic provides a nice visual metaphor for what he's doing, pictured on top of this page.
 * Eerie Cuties, after magical shenanigans gave Nina grown up figure for a while and Layla's "fiance" began swooning in her direction too... he tries to be sweet with Layla. "It was a two-for-one sale" cannot help his case.

Western Animation
"Aang: Us...kissing... (looks dreamy) Katara: Heh, us, kissing! What was I thinking? Can you imagine that? Aang (laughs it off): Heh, yeah, I definitely wouldn't want to kiss you. *suddenly realizes what he just said* Katara (offended): Oh. Well, I didn't realize it was such a horrible option. Sorry for suggesting it. Aang: No, no! I mean, if it was a choice between kissing you and dying... Katara: UGH! Aang: What? I'm saying I would rather kiss you than die! That's a compliment! Katara: *storms off* Well, I'm not sure which I would rather do! Aang: What is wrong with me...?"
 * "The Cave of Two Lovers" episode in Avatar: The Last Airbender had a stunningly awkward pit trap for Aang when he tried to diffuse his embarrassment over a possible kiss with Katara.

"Bolin: I'm sorry, no, no! I didn't mean to assume! It's that, I was just figuring... with your Water Tribe getup... that you are... a Water Tribe... gal."
 * Followed by Zuko in the third season revealing that he sent Combustion Man after them when, at the time, all they knew about him was that he was a psycho who wouldn't stop chasing them. This revelation didn't exactly earn Zuko any points with the good guys.
 * In Sequel Series The Legend of Korra's "A Leaf in the Wind", Bolin correctly presumes that Korra is a waterbender due to ethnicity and clothing, but Korra trolls him by saying she's an earthbender (which she is too...). Bolin hastily tries to apologize for Mistaken Nationality.


 * Oh poor Naveen in The Princess and the Frog:

"Bruce: "Working late again?" Roxanne: "Yeah. Fortunately my boyfriend is very understanding. What about yours?" *pause* "Girlfriend, I mean! Of course, girlfriend! I mean, considering your reputation and- NOT that it's bad or anything or even any of my business, because it's not, I was just curious!" *stops suddenly* "How red is my face?"
 * And to think, the poor shmuck's trying to
 * Mama Odie did tell him to dig a little deeper...
 * In the end, she did admit that she thought the fumbling around was cute.
 * Batman: Mystery of the Batwoman had this one from one:

Bruce: (cheerfully) "Crimson.""

"Peter: Oh, my God, Mr. Pewterschimdt, you're having an affair? Ew! Eww! Carter: No, no, this is my sister! Peter: Eww! Carter: No, no, no, I'm impotent! Peter: Eww! Carter: I mean, she looked at me, while I did it to myself! Peter: Ewww! Carter: I mean, she's a man! Peter: Ewww!"
 * Averted by Kevin in Ben 10: Ultimate Alien after he tells Gwen that you need to treat a car like you treat a woman. Gwen asks him to go on, but he wisely drops the idea.
 * In the Bump in the Night episode "A Sneeze In Time," Bumpy points out Squishy's mistake by saying, "What a rush! Why'd you turn the wrong valve? Boy, only a doofus would do that!" In an attempt to undo his indirect insult, he travels back in time. He only makes it worse. He tries this repeatedly until
 * In the Family Guy episode "Welcome Back, Carter", when Peter catches his father-in-law with a woman:

"Daffy: You'll have to pardon my friend. The heat's getting to him. He's not used to this. He's not a hardened criminal like you. I mean, I shouldn't assume that you're a hardened criminal. But in my defense, you do have a Neanderthal-shaped head, which I normally equate with stupidity--uh, not that you're stupid. I just mean that you look stupid. I don't mean that as an insult. I mean, some people think stupid to mean cool, like "That's a stupid car," "You've got a stupid apartment"...I wish I could stop talking. I'm just very nervous right now. I tend to ramble when I'm nervous. You know what the word "ramble" means? You're probably too stupid to know! And here, I mean stupid-stupid, not stupid-cool!"
 * Used in The Looney Tunes Show when Crusher is staring down Daffy:

"Ratchet: No, wait, please listen to me. You can't do this to me. This job is my life. It means everything to me. You don't know what I've done to get here. The lies I've told! The lives I've ruined! Wait... this isn't helping me!"
 * From Robots


 * In The Simpsons episode "Girls Just Want To Have Sums", while Principal Skinner is publicly speaking to a former student of his, he states that she wasn't that good at math because "hey, you are a girl". This gets him in hot water and he tries to explain himself, but his comments only make him sound like more of a misgynist until finally pleading "Just tell me what to say!".
 * In "Bart-Mangled Banner", the Simpsons are accused of being unpatriotic when Bart accidentally moons the American flag (and a little word-twisting) and are put on a talk show to clear themselved, the host asks "Which part of America do you hate the most?". Marge protests, sarcastically replying that if the government is built on questions like that, then she does hate America. Naturally, this gets the family in a bigger mess.
 * In the same episode, Springfield is renamed "Libertyville" to fess up to the nation. At the church, Lisa announces her views of patriotism. Yeah, I think you should have kept your big mouth shut, Lis.
 * In "Double, Double, Boy in Trouble", a rich boy named Simon Woosterfield traded places with Bart. When Lisa figured out Simon wasn't Bart, she slapped him and pointed out the real Bart would have hit her back. Simon then asked if he would defenestrate her, prompting Lisa to mention the trope.

Real Life

 * It is possible to do this to oneself in an argument, especially if you're using straw men in the first place.
 * There's an old story about a German mayor who didn't want people let their dogs run unleashed in the local forest, so he had put up a sign stating: "Anyone who'll let his dog run unleashed in the forest will be shot!" When someone remarked that this could be read as if the owners of the dogs were shot, the mayor had it "improved" to: "Anyone who'll let his dog run unleashed in the forest will be shot, the dog!" ("Dog" being a somewhat outdated insult.)