Superdickery.com/Characters

Characters in the website documenting the trope:

Superman

 * Complete Monster
 * Disproportionate Retribution: And the victims are lucky if he's going after them out of spite. Often he'll just assault innocents.
 * Enfante Terrible: Whenever he's being turned into a baby.
 * Jerkass: They don't call the site Superdickery for nothing.
 * Mind Rape: When physical destruction feels bland for a while, he'll move to slowly torturing Jimmy Olsen mentally.
 * Nice Hat: The Pope Hat. Only appeared on one cover but was frequently mentioned and praised by the writer. Actually appeared in the Superdickery tribute episode of Batman The Brave And The Bold.
 * Not As You Know Them: Compare this Superman with the actual Superman.
 * Omnicidal Maniac: At times.

Jimmy Olsen

 * Butt Monkey: The most often to be on the receiving end of Superman's dickery.
 * The Dog Bites Back: On at least one cover he tries to kill Superman.
 * Superpower Lottery: He gets powers so often it's a drinking game.

Batman

 * Ambiguously Gay
 * Asshole Victim: The times Superman has killed him/exposed his identity.
 * Depending On the Writer: He's either a victim of Superman's dickery, attempting to stop Superman, or sometimes teaming up with him for "double dickery".
 * Mistaken for Pedophile: Batman isn't gay! ...Robin, they don't know.

Lois Lane

 * And Now You Must Marry Me: said by her to Superman, or by someone else to her. Including two months in a row for the latter.
 * Asshole Victim
 * Butt Monkey: Keeps getting killed by Superman.

Supergirl

 * Woman Scorned: As the annotation said, "Note to self: Do not date Supergirl"

Wonder Woman

 * Bound and Gagged
 * Depraved Bisexual
 * Distaff Counterpart: Of Superman. In the sense that they're both dicks.
 * Too Kinky to Torture

Robin

 * Ambiguously Gay
 * Butt Monkey