Rhetorical Question Blunder



"Captain America (comics): Big man in a suit of armor. Take that away, what are you? Iron Man: A genius billionaire playboy philanthropist?"

- The Avengers

Ah, rhetorical questions. Is there anything they can't do? ...Wait, don't answer that.

A Rhetorical Question Blunder is what happens when a character asks a question that they didn't need an answer to... and then gets an answer anyway. That answer will almost always be contrary to the point they were trying to make. Occasionally this can lead down a slippery slope as the asker tries to salvage the original intention.

Could easily lead to a Rhetorical Request Blunder. Particularly common when dealing with someone who Does Not Understand Sarcasm. Related to Analogy Backfire.

Despite the common use of the phrase when the asker sees this coming, this has nothing to do with Don't Answer That, which is a trope about Perp Sweating.

See About Rhetorical Questions for why rhetorical questions don't work well on a wiki.

Anime
"Yamamoto: You fools, what do you think of the Captain's cloak? Kuchiki Byakuya: Cheap. Zaraki Kenpachi: Nuisance. Kyoraku Shunsui: Fashionable? Yamamoto: Shut up, you morons."
 * In Bleach:
 * 3 Captains of the Gotei 13 "lost" their cloak during a fight, and have been called up by the Captain Commander Yamamoto to explain.

Comics
"Namor: When were you going to tell me about this? Iron Man: It just happened yesterday. Namor: I thought we agreed to keep each other informed of major superhuman developments. Iron Man: Does anyone know how to say "It just happened yesterday" in Atlantean? Reed Richards: Fortanu Vasyama. Everyone in the room stares at Richards. Reed Richards: Sorry. I thought he was actually asking."
 * Don Rosa played with the trope in "A Little Something Special". After Magica De Spell, Flintheart Glomgold, the Beagle Boys and Blackheart Beagle teamed up in a plan to steal Scrooge McDuck's fortune and failed, Magica and the Beagles went to South Africa and robbed Flintheart, who asked what he did to deserve that but quickly added a "Don't Answer That" command.
 * From New Avengers:

Film -- Animated
"Governor Ratcliffe: Wiggins, why do you think those insolent heathens attacked us? Wiggins: Because we invaded their land and cut down their trees and dug up their earth? Governor Ratcliffe: It's the gold! They have it and they don't want us to take it from them. Well, I'll just have to take it by force then, won't I?"
 * Pocahontas has one between Governor Ratcliffe and Wiggins. For bonus points, Ratcliffe ends his monologue with another rhetorical question.

"Scuttle: Have I ever been wrong? (Pause) I mean when it's important!"
 * In Alice in Wonderland, when Alice shrinks back to normal size after calling the Queen out, the Queen rhetorically asks what she was saying and the Cheshire Cat answers. But unlike many other examples, it's likely he knew it was a rhetorical question and he did it for a laugh.
 * In Disney's The Little Mermaid:

"Hopper: Are you saying that I'm stupid? Princess Atta: (bursts out laughing) Yes!"
 * From the Hilarious Outtakes at the end of A Bugs Life:

Film -- Live Action
""All right, but apart from the sanitation, medicine, education, wine, public order, irrigation, roads, the fresh water system and public health, what have the Romans ever done for us?" "Brought peace?" "Oh, peace! SHUT UP!""
 * Life of Brian has an extended example: when Reg asks "What have the Romans ever done for us?" the other revolutionaries begin offering examples, eventually leading to:

"Evil: That's a good question. Why have I let the Supreme Being keep me here in the Fortress of Ultimate Darkness? Robert: Because you - (he explodes) Evil: Shut up, I'm speaking rhetorically."
 * Time Bandits has the embodiment of Evil thinking aloud:

"Mal: Do you want to run this ship!? Jayne: Yes. Mal: ...Well you can't."
 * Serenity has one such example, where in the midst of an argument between the crew, Mal barks a question at Jayne, who promptly answers, much to throw Mal off of his speechifying track.

"Holly: I have a request. Hans Gruber: What idiot put you in charge? Holly: You did. When you murdered my boss. Now everybody's looking to me."
 * Die Hard:

"Bubba: Forrest...why'd this happen? Forrest: You got shot."
 * Hans, being who he is, proceeds to act like a perfect gentleman.
 * Errol from Snatch has this problem, with his boss Brick Top just wanting him to be Dumb Muscle. "It was a rhetorical question, Errol. What have I told you about thinking?"
 * A rather tragic example from Forrest Gump, when Bubba is dying in Gump's arms.

"Steve: Big man in a suit of armor. Take that away, what are you? Tony: Genius billionaire playboy philanthropist."
 * In The Avengers.

"Vitti: Know what I'm gonna do to you if you if you don't answer me? Crony: You gonna slug me with that pipe? Vitti: That was a rhetorical question, moron!!"
 * In Analyze This, mobster Paul Vitti is interrogating a crony while threatening him with a pipe:

Literature
"Cut-Me-Own-Throat Dibbler: Trust me. Have I ever lied to you? Bezam Planter: Well, one night last month you sold me a sausage in a bun and you said - Throat: I was speaking rhetorically. Bezam: Oh. Well. I dunno about rhetorically."
 * In The Talisman by Stephen King, the Big Bad considers the Bible verse "For what shall it profit a man, if he shall gain the whole world, and lose his own soul?" He concludes, "It profits him the world."
 * Several Discworld examples:
 * Moving Pictures has:


 * Moving Pictures also has the same The Merchant of Venice gag as Neverwhere (below), with the troll who asked the question still insisting "Ah, but I would if I had blood. I'd bleed all over the place."
 * In Going Postal, Mr. Groat informs Moist von Lipwig that he has to take "The Postman's Walk" if he wants to be accepted as the new Postmaster by the Order of the Post. Moist decides to go through with what he thinks is just a harmless initiation ritual, asking "What's the worst that could happen?" After a bit of thought, Mr. Groat responds "The worst that could happen is you lose all your fingers on one hand, are crippled for life, and break half the bones in your body. Oh, and then they don't let you join."
 * In Thud, Fred Colon comments on the trouble in Koom Valley with the immortal question "War, Nobby, huh. What is it good for?" This being Discworld, where rhetorical questions never caught on, Nobby answers the question with things like "Freeing slaves?" and "Protecting yourself from a totalitarian aggressor?"
 * The undefined-but-clearly-supernatural nature of Messrs Croup and Vandemar in Neverwhere is shown when Vandemar sticks a knife through the back of his own hand, doesn't bleed, and shows no pain. Shortly afterward, Mr Croup makes a comment about "Oh, Mr Vandemar, if you cut us, do we not bleed?" Vandemar's response is a carefully considered "No."
 * In A Civil Campaign by Lois McMaster Bujold, Richars Vorrutyer gives a speech with a lengthy list of insulting rhetorical questions. Then someone answers him.

Live Action TV
"Blackadder: I mean, look at this. What is it? Baldrick: I'm surprised you've forgotten, my lord. Blackadder: I haven't forgotten. It's a rhetorical question. Baldrick: No, it's a potato."
 * On 3rd Rock from the Sun, Dick Solomon responds to the question "You think you're the smartest person in the world, don't you?" with "For the thousandth time, yes!"
 * In Blackadder II, Blackadder shows Baldrick a potato and One Dialogue, Two Conversations ensues:

"Professor Crawley: Let me ask you a question. What does an accomplished entomologist with a doctorate and twenty years of experience do when the university cuts all his funding? Raj: Ask uncomfortable rhetorical questions to people?"
 * This happens in The Big Bang Theory when Raj, Howard, and Sheldon go look up an entomologist to settle a bet:

"Penny: And what kind of doctor removes feet from asses? Sheldon: Depending on the depth, that would be either a proctologist or a general surgeon....Oh."
 * Sheldon often answers rhetorical questions.

"Artie: For crying out loud. Who designed this thing? Leena: Thomas Edison. Nicola Tesla. And M. C. Escher."
 * In Warehouse 13, Artie is looking at the Warehouse's electrical schematic and muttering to himself.

"James: Isn't that adorable? When was the last time you saw a diaper poking out from a Dolce and Gabbana suit? Marshall: Tuesday, At work... some of the senior partners are really getting up there."
 * One Mark Wary sketch on The Wedge features his manager asking "How could Mark possibly have impregnated three women at the same time?" Mark, sitting next to him, unhelpfully answers "Daylight Savings."
 * In How I Met Your Mother, Barney's brother shows the gang pictures of his son.

"Barney (to the girl he's about to climb in bed with) Who's your daddy? Girl: (flirtatiously) I don't know... who's your daddy? Barney: (bursts into tears) I don't know!"
 * Also Barney once, when he was angsting about finding his father.

"Mr. Whitmore: How many of us have lost countless productive hours plagued by unwanted sexual thoughts and feelings? Xander raises his hand. Mr. Whitmore: That was a rhetorical question, Mr. Harris, not a poll."
 * Buffy the Vampire Slayer has:

"Xander: (to Willow) Excuse me? Who made you the boss of the group? Anya: You did. Tara: You said Willow should be boss. Anya: And then you said "let's vote," and it was unanimous... Tara: ...and then you made her this little plaque, that said "Boss of Us," you put little sparkles on it... Xander: Valid points all."
 * And in "Bargaining, Part I":

"Buffy: How hard you gonna hit when you're blowin' in the wind? (Vampire kicks Buffy into a tombstone just as she dusts him) Buffy: (groaning in pain) That was rhetorical."
 * In "Seeing Red" Buffy is up against a vampire who's putting up a good fight.

"Spike: What the bleeding hell is wrong with you bloody women? What the hell does it take? Why do you bitches torture me? Buffy: Which question do you want me to answer first?"
 * Played with in "Crush".

"Angel: Do you know how hard it is to think with a rebar through your torso? Cordelia: Actually, I do. Benefits of a Sunnydale education."
 * Angel gets in on it too, when Cordelia is chastising him for letting a demon get away:

"Grace: I'm doing the right thing, right? Will: Well-- Grace: What?! Will: Nothing. No, I just--I'm just saying--as a friend, I want you to know that if you were thinking of calling it off, don't worry about the people out there. Don't worry about all those gifts. You do what your heart tells you is right. Grace: ...Are you freaking kidding me with this?! Will: "If," I said "if!" Grace: The question was rhetorical. That means you're supposed to say "yes." Will: That's not what "rhetorical" means. Grace: Are we talking about what "rhetorical" means or about how you're freaking me out right now?! Will: Am I supposed to answer that or is that rhetorical too?"
 * On Will and Grace, when Grace is getting ready for her rushed wedding to Leo, she and Will have this exchange:

"Kirk: Trying to get yourself killed. Do you know how much Starfleet has invested in you? Spock: One hundred twenty two thousand two hundred - Kirk cuts him off Kirk: Never mind. But thanks."
 * In Star Trek: The Original Series, Spock sometimes answers rhetorical questions. For example, this exchange from "The Apple," after Spock has risked his life to save Kirk:

"Dean: "Dude, could you be more gay? ...Don't answer that.""
 * Supernatural did one of these in the episode "Bedtime Stories".

"Geoffrey: Which would you prefer: an empty house with a great play, or a full house with a piece of garbage? Richard: GARBAGE! GARBAGE! I want GARBAGE!"
 * Community—in "Competitive Wine-Tasting" Professor Sheffield, who teaches a class critically analysing Who's The Boss?, opens his first class with the question: "Who was the Boss?" He intends it as a rhetorical question—unfortunately, as Abed ends up conclusively and empirically demonstrating, this particular question has a quite clear and definite answer.
 * So the professor moves on to "What was happening?" (a course critically analyzing What's Happening)
 * Slings and Arrows has this dialogue exchange (from "Steeped In Blood"), which perfectly typifies the difference in philosophy between Geoffrey and Richard.

"Charles: Will they stop at nothing?! Carol I don't know, do you think they will? Charles: I meant that rhetorically. Carol What does rhetorically mean? Charles: It means I didn't expect an answer."
 * From Monty Python's Flying Circus, the Science Fiction Sketch:

"Debra: I've sat through god knows how many briefings; why am I so fucking nervous? Dexter: Because everyone'll be looking to see if you know what you're doing? Debra: Do me a favor: when you get back to your desk, look up the word "rhetorical"."
 * From Dexter:

"Whitaker: (sarcastically) And how many people do you think you can pluck off the streets before people start noticing? Molly: (completely serious) Approximately 300."
 * Done in Threshold. Awesomely


 * When Samantha Carter is introduced in the pilot of Stargate SG-1, the men in the briefing room are somewhat annoyed that "another scientist" (and a female one, no less) is being foisted on them for the recon mission to Abydos. Maj. Kawalsky condescendingly asks her if she has ever pulled out of a simulated bombing run in an F-16 at eight-plus g's. Carter's response is a Blunt Yes, and Kawalsky has to stop and process that before saying that traveling through the stargate feels worse.

Music
"Do you like my band? ...Don't answer that."
 * Bowling for Soup's song "No Hablo Ingles", in a verse containing a series of questions:

"Are you out of love with me? Are you longing to be free? Do I drive you up a tree? (Yeah! Oh, yeah!) Do I drive you up the wall? Do you dread every phone call? Can you not stand me at all? (Yeah! Oh, yeah!)"
 * The Magnetic Fields' "Yeah! Oh, Yeah!"

Newspaper Comics

 * Garfield says this to a mirror in the January 15, 1985 strip when he asks it who the cutest cat of all is and Nermal walked up soon after.

Theater

 * In the musical of Wicked, Glinda the Good Witch enters in the first song to cheers and halloos. She, smiling, replies "It's good to see me, isn't it?" They all respond, "Yes!" She (still smiling) answers, "You needn't respond; that was rhetorical."

Video Games
"Tan Soldier: Colonel Grimm and the Sarge have escaped our forces and captured a blue intelligence officer and...to make matters worse, Sarge found one of our portals. General Plastro: WHAT? Tan Soldier: Colonel Grimm and Sarge have escaped - General Plastro: I HEARD YOU! IT WAS A RHETORICAL 'WHAT'! (punches the soldier out of the building) Does anyone else have any good news they'd like to share? Tan Soldiers: No sir! Nope! Not me! Nothin'!"
 * In Ghost Trick, Bailey the prison guard blunders over his own rhetorical question when he replies to a co-worker implying he's stupid with "What's that supposed to mean?", then explains apropos of nothing that it was just an expression of indignation.
 * Done hilariously in Army Men: Sarge's Heroes

"Wrex: So tell me, who would win in a fight between you and Shepard? Tali: Do krogan always size up one another for a fight? Even friends and allies? Wrex: Yes."
 * In the first Mass Effect 1 game, Urdnot Wrex has a penchant for these, particularly in his elevator conversations with Tali.

"Wrex: Hey, Tali. Your people created the geth, ever talk about it? Tali: Do the krogan talk about starting a stupid war that got your species sterilized? Wrex: All the time."

Web Comics
"Beatriz Juruna: What does it profit a man to gain the world and lose his soul? Vergil Haas: ...Well, he profits by one entire world, for starters."
 * From A Miracle of Science:

"Percy: Is there anything in the world more miserable than a wet cat? Pooch: Ummmm... A frozen penguin? ... A shaved porcupine? Constipated skunk? ... A toothless beaver!"
 * El Goonish Shive: Do you have a distinctive impression that Abraham didn't care to hear the answer to this question?
 * Sinfest: Here:

"Nogg: Does failing so many times mean I should give up, or that it's more noble that I keep getting up to get knocked down again? ... That's rhetorical. Krep: Do you hear me replying?"
 * Implied here -- "You been living in a cave or something?" is not answered "Yes", but the readers know it's true.
 * Bob and George: Anyone want to know why I named him Mega Man X?
 * Girl Genius, with Agatha and Krosp, when she didn't know who and what he is yet.
 * The Grandmother's errant flyboy here. And again on the next page. Any rhetorical question with a possible answer including the words "massive firepower" should be retroactively reclassified as Tempting Fate.
 * The Last Days of Foxhound: "Do I look like a masochist? Don't answer that."
 * Spacetrawler, on this page.

"Schlock: That's not how I remember it, Commander. Kevyn: Who's telling this story, Sergeant? Schlock: Oooh! I know this one! "A mind-control test-subject who hasn't yet had his head re-examined!""
 * Schlock Mercenary


 * Unshelved demonstrates an easy way to use it.
 * Sluggy Freelance had a moment when Lodoze walked right into this one.

Western Animation
"Mr. Butlertron: What would the real Joan of Arc have done? Joan: She would have listened to her heart. And then she would've gotten burned at the stake. [nervous laugh] But what are the odds of that happening again? Mr. Butlertron: 38%."
 * From Clone High:

"Bart: This isn't bad! Homer: "Isn't bad"? Tell me one thing mankind has ever done that's any better? Lisa: The Renaissance? Homer: This is better!"
 * The Simpsons did it several times.
 * In "Homer To The Max":

"Lisa: What is the sound of one hand clapping? Bart: Piece of cake. [claps with one hand] Lisa: No, Bart, it's a 3000-year-old riddle with no answer. It's supposed to clear your mind of conscious thought. Bart: No answer? Lisa, listen up! [claps with one hand]"
 * And again in "Dead Putting Society":

"Mona Simpson [sings]: How many roads must a man walk down / Before you can call him a man? Homer: Seven. Lisa: No, dad, it's a rhetorical question. Homer: OK, eight. Lisa: Dad, do you even know what "rhetorical" means? Homer: Do I know what "rhetorical" means?"
 * And also heavily lampshaded it in "Mother Simpson":

"Patrick: When did the fun go away, Spongebob? Spongebob: Right after you went over that cliff."
 * In the Flowers for Algernon Syndrome episode of SpongeBob SquarePants, this leads to a Eureka Moment when Patrick figures out why he's suddenly become super-intelligent.

"Chris: And what's a baby carriage without a baby? Owen: Oooh! A SHOPPING CART! Chris: It was a rhetorical question!"
 * Used in Total Drama World Tour, when Chris was trying to tell the contestants that one of them would have to ride in the baby carriage as part of their challenge.

"Bender: If that stuff wasn't real, how can I be sure anything is real? Is it not possible, nay, probable, that my entire life is just a figment of my or someone else's imagination? Technician: No. Get out."
 * Futurama really likes doing this with "is it not" questions:
 * "Obsoletely Fabulous'' has:

"Farnsworth: I know this anomaly is terrifying, but, as scientists, is it not our sworn duty to seek out knowledge, even at the cost of our very lives? Stephen Hawking's head: No."
 * The Beast With A Billion Backs has a similar example:

"Zapp Brannigan: We have failed to uphold Brannigan's Law. However, I made it with a hot alien babe. And, in the end, is that not what man has dreamt of since first he looked up at the stars? [Beat] Kif, I'm asking you a question!"
 * "Love's Labours Lost In Space" has this inversion:

"Stormy: You and I may have to repopulate the human species, Debby! Debby: That's disgusting! Stormy: (flirtingly) Is it? ...[beat]… (seriously) Well is it? Debby: YES!"
 * Similar to the Futurama example, the episode Predator of Sealab 2021 has this inverted example:

"Eddy: Do I look like twenty bucks or what? Edd: "Or what?" is a good question...
 * The bit is echoed later in the same episode with Captain Murphy and Dr. Quinn.
 * Has happened to Eddy a couple times on Ed, Edd n Eddy.

Eddy: I was born to fleece, Double D! Do you know who I think I am? Edd: Unfortunately, yes.

Eddy: What could be more important than Master Eddy? Ed: COOKIE DOUGH!! Yum-yum-yum-yum-yum-yum-yum-yum!"

"Nightmare Moon: Am I not royal enough for you? Don't you know who I am? Pinkie Pie: Ooh, ooh, more guessing games! Um, Hokey Smokes? How 'bout... Queen Meanie? No, Black Snooty! Black Snooty! [cue Applejack trying to shut Pinkie up by stuffing a cupcake in her mouth]"
 * Maybe he's learning his lesson; in Ed, Edd, 'n' Eddy's Big Picture Show, Eddy, having gotten stranded in the middle of the desert with his friends, says to Double D, "Have I ever steered you wrong? Don't answer that."
 * From the first episode of My Little Pony Friendship Is Magic:

"Rainbow Dash: Hey! What are you waiting for, an invitation? Pinkie Pie: Ooh, I think I have one in my bag!"
 * Pinkie does it again in "Dragonshy":

"Rarity: Sweetie Belle, what am I going to do with you?! Sweetie Belle: Oh, we could paint together! We could ride bikes, play chess, sing a song, catch frogs, pillow fight... Rarity: That's not what I meant!"
 * Sweetie Belle gets in on the act in "Sisterhooves Social":

"Boris: What did I ever do to deserve this? Natasha: Well... Boris: Don't answer that."
 * In one episode of Rocky and Bullwinkle, Boris says something to the effect of "Do I look like the kind of guy who'd lie to you? Don't answer that."
 * Also

"Fred: Have I ever given you a bum steer? Barney: Well I... Fred [covering Barney's mouth]: Don't answer that!"
 * The Flintstones:

"[during the Christmas Episode] Ron: What? I'm supposed to let you take over the world? Drakken: In the spirit of the season, yes!"
 * Daffy Duck while flattering a cop in the Looney Tunes short "Hollywood Daffy": "What's Errol Flynn got that you ain't got? [to audience] Don't answer that!"
 * Kim Possible:

"Old Lady: Would you care for a free lollipop? Chowder: Would I?! Old Lady: Would you? Chowder: Would I?! Old Lady: Would you?"
 * From the Chowder episode "Schnitzel Makes a Deposit":

"Jimmy: Would you have a good date with a sandwich? Beezy: *begins drooling* Jimmy: Don't answer that."
 * Jimmy Two-Shoes:

"Lydia: What's the sound of one hand clapping? (Chicken is about to write but is stumped) Beetlejuice: And if a log falls on a lumberjack in the forest and no one's around, does he make a sound? (Chicken now getting frustrated) Lydia: (winks to B.J.) Now here's the clincher. Which came first, the chicken or the egg? (Chicken loses it and explodes)"
 * Phineas and Ferb: "You wanna live forever?" "Was that an option?"
 * In the Beetlejuice episode "Poultrygeist," Beetlejuice is tormented by a sentient roast chicken from his refrigerator that has an answer for every question which it writes on a note pad. Lydia has the solution—ask it questions that have no answer.

"Lila: Johnny, how many times have your father and I told you not to bring back the dead?! Johnny: Um, never? Hugh: Well, we shouldn't have to!"
 * An episode of Johnny Test where Johnny uses a device to reanimate the corpses of Porkbelly's founding fathers has this exchange: