Superdickery.com/Characters

Characters in the website documenting the trope:

Superman

 * Complete Monster
 * Disproportionate Retribution: And the victims are lucky if he's going after them out of spite. Often he'll just assault innocents.
 * Enfante Terrible: Whenever he's being turned into a baby.
 * Jerkass: They don't call the site Superdickery for nothing.
 * Mind Rape: When physical destruction feels bland for a while, he'll move to slowly torturing Jimmy Olsen mentally.
 * Nice Hat: The Pope Hat. Only appeared on one cover but was frequently mentioned and praised by the writer. Actually appeared in the Superdickery tribute episode of Batman: The Brave and the Bold.
 * Not as You Know Them: Compare this Superman with the actual Superman.
 * Omnicidal Maniac: At times.

Jimmy Olsen

 * Butt Monkey: The most often to be on the receiving end of Superman's dickery.
 * The Dog Bites Back: On at least one cover he tries to kill Superman.
 * Superpower Lottery: He gets powers so often it's a drinking game.

Batman

 * Ambiguously Gay
 * Asshole Victim: The times Superman has killed him/exposed his identity.
 * Depending on the Writer: He's either a victim of Superman's dickery, attempting to stop Superman, or sometimes teaming up with him for "double dickery".
 * Mistaken for Pedophile: Batman isn't gay! ...Robin, they don't know.

Lois Lane

 * And Now You Must Marry Me: said by her to Superman, or by someone else to her. Including two months in a row for the latter.
 * Asshole Victim
 * Butt Monkey: Keeps getting killed by Superman.

Supergirl

 * Woman Scorned: As the annotation said, "Note to self: Do not date Supergirl"

Wonder Woman

 * Bound and Gagged
 * Depraved Bisexual
 * Distaff Counterpart: Of Superman. In the sense that they're both dicks.
 * Too Kinky to Torture

Robin

 * Ambiguously Gay
 * Butt Monkey