Die for Our Ship/Anime and Manga/Axis Powers Hetalia



Axis Powers Hetalia, despite being a show full of Ho Yay-fueled Moe Anthropomorphisms, has a fandom that's largely free of Shipping Wars, probably because almost any pairing can be justified, and multishipping and Ship Mates are very common. But even it isn't completely free from this trope (...okay, the list below is rather long, but that's mainly because of Loads and Loads of Characters, and most examples are still limited to Vocal Minority status). In other words, even the nicest and most civil of fanbases - Hetalia shipping being on the whole wonderfully accommodating - can't eradicate the 'fanatic' in 'fandom.'


 * England gets the worst of this from militant Russia/America fans who twist and warp his Tsundere behavior and possible crush toward America to Jerkass or even Yandere levels to make him into a pathetic Crazy Jealous Hopeless Suitor who can't accept that America doesn't want him or even a creepy pedophile who's been perving on America ever since he was a kid. The worst cases have England as a Domestic Abuser toward America who seems to have forgotten all about his own Super Strength or a Manipulative Bastard who uses poor America's undying love for him to emotionally abuse him. (Russia, if he appears, is of course entirely sane and supportive to America.) Never mind that in canon, England has almost Woobie moments with America, or that America is actually a lot harder on him than the other way around. Or that Russia is clearly Satan.
 * Pedophile!England perving on young America is not a rare phenomenon in stories that feature America with someone else and feel the need to justify the pairing by showing how horrible England/America would be... even though canon has zero evidence that would back this up; in fact, America seems to think back on their days together with nostalgia. Plus, if England has more-than-brotherly feelings for America, they seem to have been kickstarted when America was a teenager at the very least.
 * As for America, there are some fics that play up his stupidity and tactlessness to emphasize just how unsuitable a partner he would be for England. It is canon that America can be a jerk to England at times and is the main source of his heartbreak, but some rabid England/someone-other-than-America shippers would have you believe that America enjoys making England suffer and couldn't possibly ever be nice or flirtatious toward him without having some secret agenda to crush his heart again (while conveniently overlooking that America is canonly friends with England). This mentality crops up the most often in England/Canada fics, where it goes hand-in-hand with some Canada fans' bad habit of putting down America to make Canada look better too.
 * America also comes off badly in some Japan/someone-other-than-him fanworks where he's depicted as being in love with Japan instead of them just being best friends, with his somewhat tactless but genuinely cheerful and friendly attitude toward Japan in canon somehow being translated into him becoming unnervingly possessive and stalkerish toward, if not outright abusing, Japan. About the only justification ever given for this is that America's dropping of two atomic bombs on Japan at the end of WWII must mean that he's actually a Yandere deep down, which completely ignores not only everything we've seen of them together in canon but everything else about their (currently good) real-life relations, so it can't even be passed off as "historical canon".
 * There's also the portrayal of Austria in some Prussia/Hungary fanworks. While they rarely go so far as to make Austria beat the hell out of Hungary (who's still physically stronger than he is, anyway), they still sometimes portray him as a Bespectacled Bastard Boyfriend cold, snobbish and neglectful of Hungary to the point of emotional abuse to not only discredit their canon marriage as a loveless Arranged Marriage (even though they show romantic affection for each other even after their "divorce") but to have Hungary seek out comfort in the "not as well-off but more fun and passionate" Prussia's arms behind Austria's back. More than once it's coupled with Chickification, since Hungary goes from a Tomboy who became more girly without losing her backbone and fighting skills to a weepy and wangsty mess who whines and cries about her "loveless married life" with abusive-asshole!Austria and pines endlessly for badass-romantic-hero!Prussia rescuing her from such torment - without even attempting to do anything for her own sake.
 * For Poland/Hungary fics, you can replace "Gilbert" with "Feliks" and it's the same. Apparently the Polish and Hungarian traditional friendship, their parts in the 1848 revolutions and the Austro-Hungarian Compromise that came in later equal to "Austria is a cold and cruel Complete Monster who rapes Hungary every night and keeps her locked up while pretending they're Happily Married in public, so she whines and cries herself to sleep and needs to be rescued from her torture by a super manly Jerk Stu who only resembles Poland in name!"
 * Romania is starting to get this treatment from some rabid Prussia/Hungary fans, especially because many fans have liked him since his appearance and started shipping him with Hungary, even though Romania and Hungary are said to hate each other with a burning passion—which is easy to see as potential Interplay of Sex and Violence. He's also interpreted pretty badass due to the fact that he's apparently a mischievous yangire with a vampire vibe AND also uses Black Magic, which helped increase his popularity even more. He also looks like a combination between Hungary and Prussia.
 * While some Prussia/Hungary fans see Romania as a "serious obstacle" like they do to Austria, others treat the "rivalry" more as a Running Gag and make Prussia a prospect Butt Monkey whom Hungary is still Tsundere for, rather than a super Stu-fied romance hero who must "recover" his love interest from Romania's "dirty" paws and vampire teeth. And two/three others seem to favor an OT3 in which Hungary gets it on with both Prussia and Romania.
 * Hungary herself, while normally embraced by fans for being a Hot Amazon and Yaoi Fangirl, isn't free of this. Some Germany/Austria fics portray her as a whiny, self-centered Clingy Jealous Girl or a brainless, weak, "girly" female who breaks the Austro-Hungarian compromise solely because Austria pays less attention to her than she wants to. Seems somebody hasn't read the Anschluss, New Year and/or Valentine strips, huh?
 * Don't forget the "feminists" who also apply the "girls are Relationship Sues" trap to her. Double when they also whine about how Hungary is a horrible role model for girls and a slutty Shallow Love Interest because of her Girliness Upgrade and her love of Austria.
 * This troper once found a Belgium/Austria fic. Okay, that's good. But then she found out that it had heavy Hungary bashing. Eeeep, hitting the "back" button.
 * The Ship-to-Ship Combat between Russia/Lithuania and Poland/Lithuania shippers has fallen more than once into this. The most rabid Poland/Lithuania shippers portray Russia as a Complete Monster who beats and rapes Lithuania For the Evulz (Russia is a canon Psychopathic Manchild and Yandere, but many Poland/Lithuania fans ignore his sympathetic backstory and iron out all nuances in his character to make him into the stock evil antagonist, AND they also tend to ignore how Himaruya now plays up more his Adult Child side than the Psychopathic Manchild one in the last strips), and the most vocal Russia/Lithuania fans take Poland's initial selfishness and Dumb Blonde quirks (played for laughs in-series) to Character Exaggeration extremes, denying Poland's own Character Development which was remarked on in the third manga volume.
 * Russia in general has been used as a stock antagonist in many other shipping fics, not so much because the fanwriters hate him but more because he's the closest thing the series has to an "evil" character and they find it all too easy to crank up his "become one with me, da...?" line to a "you WILL become one with me, whether or not you like it, and only your true love can save you from my clutches, DA!" ultimatum. Suffice it to say that while he's no saint in canon, he's still far from the kidnapping, torturing, raping plot device villain these kind of fics make him into.
 * Belarus, as the Yandere stalker of Russia, who not only is the fandom bicycle but also her brother, doesn't get nearly as much hate as you'd expect and many fans actually enjoy her Played for Laughs role as the stalker of the stalker. However, more serious fics that pair Russia up with someone other than Belarus often turn her into a Complete Monster without a drop of sympathy or depth. True, Belarus canonically resents anyone Russia shows interest in and she doesn't get a Freudian Excuse or Hidden Depths regarding her behavior like her brother does, but the worst thing she did in canon was breaking Lithuania's fingers - and that was solely done for humor on a date that Lithuania himself asked Belarus for. Having her go out of her way to tie up and rape Lithuania just to prove the point of him being "unworthy" of Russia's love is probably taking it too far.
 * While it hasn't translated into outright Ron the Death Eater in fanworks yet (if only because most Turkey/Greece works simply leave Japan out entirely), the Vocal Minority of Turkey/Greece shippers can become very wanky toward Japan and the Greece/Japan ship when provoked, especially after the "provocation" of the anime faithfully adapting some of Japan's strips with Greece and Turkey that had been on the Web for years beforehand, with them deriding Japan as a Flat Character who only got the attention of Greece and Turkey because of him being a "gigantic Canon Sue who has half of the cast as his harem" and claiming that Greece loses all personality and historical depth when paired with him over his "far more interesting and historically important" rival Turkey.
 * To elaborate on that final point, some fans think that being with Japan makes Greece a "weak Shallow Love Interest" because he acts calm, gentle and laidback with him whereas being with Turkey makes him a "strong, interesting character" because he acts short-tempered, violent and angry with him. Apparently, Greece being The Philosopher with Japan gives him no additional depth because it's "not physical" or something like that. Can lead to Unfortunate Implications if you think too hard about the "he's a Shallow Love Interest if he acts sweet to his boyfriend instead of fighting with him all the time!" or "he can be interesting only if he's paired up with the one that constantly makes him angry and violent!" implications.
 * Turkey has a case similar to France's (listed just below); he isn't demonized nearly as often by Greece/Japan shippers as you might expect as most of them view him as posing no real threat to their ship, but if they feel the need to have someone stir up some external drama for Greece and Japan, he's the one they're most likely to use. It doesn't help that exaggeration of Turkey's Boisterous Bruiser traits to Jerkass, Manipulative Bastard or Smug Snake levels is a not-uncommon sight even in non-shipping and Turkey-pairing fanworks, which can cause some fans to forget that Turkey is canonly friends with Japan and leans more toward being a Jerk with a Heart of Gold than an irredeemable Jerkass.
 * As for Greece, he's mostly free of this trope. Mostly. There are still some fans who are not pleased about him being paired up with Japan so often (and are not feeling charitable enough to simply make him Just Friends with Japan) and hence try to make him out to be a Jerk In Nice Guy's Clothing who lies about what "really" happened on that night with Japan or a pathetic Crazy Jealous Guy who exists solely to bitch about how Japan's not with him and thus come off as worse than the nation the author wants Japan to be with instead. A few of these fans even claim that Greece hangs out with Japan only because he wants to get into Japan's pants, even though a read-through of all his strips with Japan will show that this is almost certainly not the case. It's pretty mild compared to many other characters' cases on this list, but it still really stands out in Greece's case, considering his sleepy Kindhearted Cat Lover personality in canon.
 * France is mostly free of this in America/England fics, in spite of having a personality that could very easily fall victim to Character Exaggeration of the worst possible kind, with almost all America/England fans simply pairing him up with someone else (usually with Canada), making him a Shipper on Deck for America and England, or going the I Want My Beloved to Be Happy route if he's depicted as being in love with England. However, he's still the character most likely to be used as an obstacle against their relationship; as such, there are some who make either character a Knight in Shining Armor who foils France's Attempted Rape of the James Bondage.
 * A more subtle yet venomous and insidious way to make France look bad in USUK fics (principally Doujinshi) is to take the French Crown's historical role in The American Revolution and flanderize it by characterising France as a borderline Evil Mentor to America who sleeps around in the war camps and seems to have fun by pitting a young and easy to manipulate America against his eternal enemy England under the excuse of "giving America the chance to develop into his own country", but actually just wants to make England suffer and get revenge against him. Way to twist historical canon to fit your ship preferences, people.
 * To be fair, one of the main reasons that the French Crown got involved with the American Revolution was to get revenge on England for the Seven Years War. In canon, France is pretty self-centered and likes to cash in on other people's victories, so him being a "borderline Evil Mentor" isn't that out of character. It can definitely be pushed too far(and often is) but the premise is relatively reasonable.
 * Believe it or not, North Italy gets bashed by rabid fans who'd rather pair up Germany with others, especially Austria or Germany's older brother Prussia. Some shippers of Germany/Prussia are notorious for turning Italy into a Psychopathic Manchild who actively sexually, emotionally, and physically abuses Germany, so that Prussia can come in and rescue his younger brother and offer him a "truly loving" relationship.
 * North Italy's big brother Romano has lately been getting this piled on him too, by those who can't stand his abrasive personality and would prefer Spain be with a more "suitable" (or "historically important") partner like France. It's often forgotten that both Romano and Spain have issues with their personalities and in dealing with each other and that South Italy has shown more than once that he genuinely cares for Spain underneath it all (the major proof comes when when Spain falls sick and Romano goes searching for a cure, willing to deal even with The Mafia to help him). All this hasn't stopped the detractors from derailing South Italy into a Complete Monster of a boyfriend that you wonder how Spain could ever have been cheerful around, or making Spain into the worst case of a Love Martyr who must be saved by France. Unless we talk about him actually raping and torturing North Italy to "keep him in check" and "away from the potato bastard" (re: Germany).
 * In the rare Romano/Belgium ships they occasionally seem to change Spain from a good-natured, happy character who cares about Romano's wellbeing into a perverted caretaker. That being said, they do have an equal chance of making him have an I Want My Beloved to Be Happy moment, which is less of a character derailment that the former.
 * There are a distressing number of stories where America, North Italy and/or Poland's natural ditziness illustrates how they'd be unsuitable partners to another character (often England, Germany or Lithuania, respectively). Yes, America's not the sharpest knife in the drawer, but he's not a moron that needs help counting to ten; Italy may not take everything seriously, but he's not brainless; and Poland is flighty, but he's most certainly not an idiot that makes a chimp look like Einstein in comparison.
 * While still rare (we hope), some rabid Prussia/Canada fans are really horrible not only to France, but to Cuba too. Because not being a Bishonen and mistaking Canada for America apparently makes Cuba a horrible bully whom Prussia must defeat to release poor uke Canada from his abuse, obviously missing how Cuba is very apologetic whenever that happens and how they get along extremely well otherwise.
 * Though extremely rare, Sweden gets this treatment from time to time in Estonia/Finland fics; usually becoming an abusive "husband" keeping Finland from Estonia, or something of a Stalker with a Crush that poor little Finland is too weak to push away.
 * Some fanworks take Denmark's canon Boisterous Bruiser traits and make him an insane Yandere who drove Sweden to run away with Finland after raping and torturing him into almost insanity. Even some works that are ostensively Denmark/Sweden use this; there's a very popular doujin that represents the infamous Stockholm Massacre by first making Denmark severely injure Sweden's eyes with his axe when Sweden merely says something that sounds like he'll leave the Nordic group (which "explains" why Sweden uses glasses), and then torturing and raping him among the ruins of Stockholm right after his defeat.(Though in that doujin has a rather cute reconcilation between them at the end.)
 * All of the female characters in Hetalia have been falsely accused of being Relationship Sues for the guys. While it is true that some shippers in both W-Fen and J-Fen are fond of disregarding the girls's canon personalities in their fanwork (with America/Belarus, America/Vietnam, England/Seychelles, Prussia/Hungary and Japan/Taiwan shippers as the main culprits), that is hardly the girls's own fault as they are not necessarily there just to have the guys stick their cocks inside of any of them. (Also, let's consider how many male characters fall in the same trap but this seems to be tolerated much more by the same fangirls who whine about the girls being Sues...)
 * ...with the exception of Japan who was getting just as bad Relationship Sue accusations from the Vocal Minority of W-fen long before the above cases came to light, with them making his LOATS status in J-fen out to be a horrible Misplaced Nationalism crime worthy of bashing him for alone. Some of them even used this to discredit the England/Japan pairing (many England/Japan fics do suffer from OOCness and Relationship Suedom for Japan, but that doesn't mean that the pairing itself has zero credibility!). And when they found out about the Greece/Japan/Turkey triangle, their accusations got truly ridiculous. All while the majority either ignored them, squeed over the episodes, or went "...What, you're just learning about Japan's relations with Greece now? Boy, you really need to read the webcomic in full."
 * The biggest female victim is Seychelles, the local Nubile Savage and Plucky Girl. She was a minor character with a mere cameo in the comics... then she became an Ascended Extra in Gakuen Hetalia (both the original script and the PSP game), and then the poor girl started getting shit from everyone coming from everywhere. The Het Is Ew camp called her a Relationship Sue, and the USUK and FRUK rabidshippers accused her of standing in between their beaus because she had some degree of Ship Tease with both England and France. (Nevermind that France is after Anything That Moves, that Gakuen Hetalia isn't that centered in romance but more in The Power of Friendship, and that in the PSP game itself )
 * Belgium may not be as big of a target as Seychelles, but she still gets potshots from rabid Spain/Romano fangirls that falsely accuse her of standing in between. An apparently Lost Forever Spamano fanart has Canada threatening to hit her (yes, CANADA) because she won't give up on interferring with them, and we're supposed to cheer for Canada when he says he'll hit her.
 * Even Liechtenstein, who's a Proper Lady in canon, is once in a while treated as being an evil Mary Sue who stole Switzerland from Austria. (Nevermind that she and Austria are very polite and civil to each other in canon). Luckily it's not that common, but there are some Unfortunate Implications in how the hate stopped only in the Hetalia Bloodbath 2011 when she seemed to approve of Swiss and Austria's somewhat improved relationship.
 * Poor Ukraine actually gets this from a certain corner of the fandom who bash her for a barely hinted at Brother-Sister Incest affection for Russia in her character song. A lot of the bashing comes from the fact that she dares to have a large chest and is a Nice Girl and relatively well-liked Team Mom, which makes the Het Is Ew camps treat her as an annoying crybaby Mary Sue who is a terrible female character. Never mind that she canonically has hints of being a Lady of War and is a huge Chew Toy.
 * Wy got pegged with this shortly after her first appearance by Sealand/Latvia and Sealand/Iceland shippers. The fact that she already had Scrappy status from being a Little Miss Snarker certainly didn't help her case any.
 * Not really. The Sealand/others shippers that bad her aren't that numerous, as the major part of the fandom tends to get Wy outta the way peacefully via giving her a Precocious Crush on Seborga instead, since he promised to hit on her when she grows up.
 * Taiwan is generally liked as she's a cheerful Plucky Girl, but she's often falsely accused of being Japan's Relationship Sue and prospect child bride. Thing is, while canon shows that she does look up to Japan and prefers her to China, it's not clear if it's a crush-like affection or simply a case of a young girl who wants her favorite sibling to aknowledge her. A lot of the accusations also seem to take Fanon as canon: it's true that some Japan/Taiwan shippers reduce the very complicated Japanese occupation of the Taiwanese island to a Romance Novel-like Lady and Knight deal, but that is not the fault of Taiwan the character in any way and it doesn't necessarily reflect her canon interaction with Japan.
 * Even Vietnam, who has had barely any screentime at all gets this from people who dislike how some members of the fandom pair her up with America, Russia, France, and/or China and refer to her as a Relationship Sue because of Fanon portrayals. Despite the fact that, in canon, she has not had any reaction with anyone other than Taiwan and Thailand so far, she has gotten some accusations of being a Flat Character who only exists to ruin other pairings. Thankfully, this portion of the fanbase is very small in comparison with hate that the other females have gotten, as it's very easy to ignore her character entirely.