Not So Invincible After All

""I'm Invincible. Ugh. I've got to stop using that line right before I get the snot beaten out of me.""

- Invincible #42

Perhaps your Badass Longcoat has developed a deadly cough over the last few days, or perhaps the Big Bad has enjoyed a few too many of those fancy cigars and develops lung cancer, or maybe the team's muscle tests positive for Huntington's, or maybe the resident Genki Girl's hyperactivity goes a little too far in the middle of traffic, and she ends up splattered on the street. In any case, a character that is portrayed as invincible and indestructible is brought down by disease or something relatively mundane that may have been hinted at all along, but not truly noticed until it's too late.

This usually tragic happening causes a character to prove that they're Not So Invincible After All, a trope that all powerful characters fear, especially because, no matter how strong you are, or how strong you become, you'll always encounter people who want to prove they are stronger.

Many times, this trope is used in high drama where everyone's fighting and killing each other to bring the cast down to earth for long enough to realize that, hey, they may be powerful, but they're still human.

When done poorly, may be regarded as a Dropped a Bridge on Him. Such a moment may occur when a user of The Law of Diminishing Defensive Effort takes a hit from something that can go through his defence. See also Always a Bigger Fish.

Anime and Manga

 * Naruto gives us the example of Kimimaro, an extremely powerful member of the Sound Five, who nearly kills Gaara and Lee, only to succumb to his fatal illness.
 * Later there's
 * Also, now revealed is
 * The Naruto fandom has even developed an expression for Kimimaro's case, Plot Aids, in reference to deaths of powerful characters due to unexplained diseases.
 * This trope is the reason why Makoto Shishio died on Rurouni Kenshin. It isn't because he was burned alive (though this incidentally was the cause), shot in the head, took a tremendously powerful blow to the head, took several more extremely powerful blows to the body, was shot through a wall, and was hit dead on by arguably the most powerful attack in the series but because he "surpassed his limit", which caused him to spontaneously combust due to all of his sweat glands being melted.
 * On the other hand, that "limit" was imposed by the exact same circumstance that made Shishio so seemingly invincible in the first place.
 * Kind of subversion in the person of Hajime Saitō. This nigh-invincible swordsman died from a stomach ulcer... at the age of 72 after outliving most of his enemies.
 * In Fullmetal Alchemist, Izumi Curtis is the Elrics' teacher, a brilliant alchemist and one of the few people they're truly scared of. (Ed and Al often build up the courage to fight a villain with the line "He's not as scary as our teacher!") However, she also suffers from an Incurable Cough of Death, and in The Movie
 * In the Thriller Bark arc of One Piece, Absalom is totally unfazed by a lightning attack from Nami, takes multiple hits from Sanji, and is nearly crushed by Oz. Then, when Nami tries zapping him again, and he falls down unconscious. With a Hand Wave of "Must've tired himself out."
 * It was also recently revealed that.
 * Zig-zagged with Whitebeard versus the Marines, and later, . Very much as unstoppable as was claimed of him,.
 * In two alternate timelines of Dragon Ball Z, Goku dies of a heart disease. In the normal timeline, he takes a medicine brought from one of those futures to treat it.
 * This trope is one of the major plot points in Gunslinger Girl. While the main characters can destroy buildings full of soldiers and survive gunshots with almost no ill effects, none of them will live out of their teens due to damage done in making them killing machines.
 * Their shortened lives are arguably for the best given the things that happen to them. Near the end of the series Elsa finds the one weak point in their bullet resistance and commits suicide by shooting herself in the eye.
 * In Hellsing, Father Alexander Anderson had for the most part seemed to be The Juggernaut, regenerating from even headshots with explosive rounds. Then at the start of their last encounter, Alucard uses his Jackal Hand Cannon to blow off part of Alex's left arm, and Alex finds that he cannot regenerate the damage.
 * Alucard gets one of these when fighting
 * In Fate/stay night Berserker is a proud user of The Law of Diminishing Defensive Effort, tanking seemingly every attack directed at him without injury. This illusion of invincibility lasts until Archer fights him.
 * To elaborate, Archer makes Berserker BLOCK with one of his fairly basic attacks. And goes on to kill Berserker about five times.
 * Durarara!!'s Shizuo Heiwajima is presented as pretty much damn near invincible for most of the series—so when Horoda manages to demonstrate that he's not as immune to bullets as he is to blades, it comes as quite a shock.
 * In Silent Sinner in Blue, a manga supplement to the Touhou series of games, Watatsuki no Yorihime blows through Marisa, Sakuya, Remilia, and even Reimu without breaking a sweat. In Inaba of the Moon and Inaba of the Earth, another manga in the same story arc, she gets knocked out by one of Tewi's pitfall traps.
 * In the Yu-Gi-Oh! anime, this happens all the time. As early as the first season, Seto Kaiba was considered unbeatable at any competition, until Yugi defeated him at Duel Monsters by using Exodia. Consequently, Exodia's reputation as unbeatable would last until the Battle City arc, when Yugi defeated a Rare Hunter who used it. Also in Battle City, Merrick assumed the Egyptian God Cards were invincible, only to be proven wrong on more than one occasion.
 * Kaiba was on the winning side of this Trope a few times, such as during the Virtual Nightmare arc, with Lecter assuming his Satellite Cannon was invincible, until Kaiba proved him wrong. (More a case of lack of foresight on Lecter's end, as Satellite Cannon's edge was that it could not be harmed by any monster lower than Level 8 - Kaiba signature card is the most famous Level 8 monster at the time and his deck is never without three copies.) And of course, during the DOMA arc, the Seal of Orichalcos was considered an unbeatable magical power, even though only two duels shown in the arc ended with the one using it winning.
 * This trend continued in other parts of the franchise. In Yu-Gi-Oh! R'', Tenma believed the Wicked Avatar to be unbeatable, only to be proven wrong in the final battle. In Zexal, V assumed Number 9: Dyson Sphere was indestructible, and it was easy to see why, as the thing was literally the size of a star. Kaito, however, proved it was not.
 * Of course, as far as Yu-Gi-Oh! is concerned, factors regarding a card’s invincibility, or lack thereof depend on both the competence of whoever is using it, and law of averages, seeing as all these cards were either incredibly rare or unique. In the first case, the Exodia using Rare Hunter had a poorly built deck, his multiple pieces of Exodia taking up fifteen slots of his 40-card deck leaving precious little to defend himself with if he couldn't assemble the five different components soon. In regards to the second, well, just how often did V even use Dyson Sphere (which he considered a secret weapon) competitively in a duel? It would have been hard to use a mon that size while concealing its existence, and if he won a duel using it two or three times, calling it unbeatable is technically true, but doesn't make the designation all that special.
 * Of course, as far as Yu-Gi-Oh! is concerned, factors regarding a card’s invincibility, or lack thereof depend on both the competence of whoever is using it, and law of averages, seeing as all these cards were either incredibly rare or unique. In the first case, the Exodia using Rare Hunter had a poorly built deck, his multiple pieces of Exodia taking up fifteen slots of his 40-card deck leaving precious little to defend himself with if he couldn't assemble the five different components soon. In regards to the second, well, just how often did V even use Dyson Sphere (which he considered a secret weapon) competitively in a duel? It would have been hard to use a mon that size while concealing its existence, and if he won a duel using it two or three times, calling it unbeatable is technically true, but doesn't make the designation all that special.

Comic Books

 * In DC's Hellblazer, John Constantine is known for going up against all manner of demons, supernatural entities, and the Devil himself, and cheating death at every turn. One of the finest Story Arcs of the series, "Dangerous Habits", begins with John discovering he's got terminal lung cancer. Over the course of the storyline, he attempts to call in every favor he can think of, only to discover that the few beings he knows who have the power to help him don't like him enough to do so. He eventually weasels out of the situation, in classic John Constantine style, by.
 * Also one of the greatest crowning moments of awesome ever depicted.
 * In the movie he finally manages to redeem himself to void his earlier suicide which had damned his soul. Pissed at not getting Constantine's soul (John flipping him off as he was ascending to Heaven probably didn't help his mood), the Devil cures his cancer at the last moment, so he'll have time to sin again.
 * Marvel Comics's version of Captain Marvel died not from a supervillain battle, but from cancer. (Admittedly, it was cancer caused during a supervillain battle, but.) The Death of Captain Marvel is probably the character's finest moment.
 * DC's The Question was never a "Big Gun," he had no super powers and his foes were street-level criminals and human organizations, but he was still reputably Badass and tough: the first issue of his Dennis O'Neil series (his most well-known series) ended with him defeated in a one-on-one fight by Lady Shiva, then his body was viciously beaten by the gang she was working for, then he was shot in the head with an air-gun and then he was thrown into a frozen river and left for dead. Not only did he survive, pulled out of the water by Shiva, but he was then given martial arts training by Richard Dragon (Regarded as the premier martial artist of the DCU and one of the trainers of Batman, Bronze Tiger and the afore-mentioned Shiva) so he came back even tougher... then, in 52, it is revealed that he has developed terminal lung cancer exacerbated by a lifetime of smoking. It has recently metastasized and now he is wasting away, physically and mentally. There is no mystical cure and no advanced alien treatment, his cancer is untreatable and he dies outside the gates of Nanda Parbat.
 * Captain Britain foe the Fury was killed by . This wouldn't be a good example compared to the rest if it wasn't Fury, the same being who killed all of it's Universe's superheroes, survived the destruction of the said Universe and get toe-to-toe with one of the most powerful Reality Warpers in the history  . And yet,  was enough to teach it the meaning of death and defeat.
 * After countless times of escaping death, after being one of the most evil and powerful of super villains, after clashing and allying himself with the some of the greatest powers of the DC universe, both good and evil, how does the immortal Hank Henshaw finally die? He makes the mistake of transferring into a robot character who already has a soul, and then is soul-killed which Word of God says is permanent.
 * Annnnnd then Hank came back anyways,

Films -- Live-Action

 * Played for laughs in GoldenEye, where Playful Hacker Boris, after being the last survivor of the, jumps up and hollers his Catch Phrase: "Yes! I AM INVINCIBLE!" A split second later, three tanks of liquid nitrogen explode and flash-freeze him to death.
 * In the movie Rocky IV, Draco seems to be taking no damage whatsoever from Rocky's punches. However, at one point, Draco starts bleeding a little bit from the punches. This emboldens Rocky to win the fight.
 * In the movie The Matrix Reloaded, after Neo stopped a hail of bullets, the Merovengian's mooks pick up swords and start fighting him. When Neo stops a sword with his outstretched hand, a drop of blood from his hand hits the floor. The Merovengian then says "See! He's just a man!" Cue Neo taking swords off the wall and defeating the mooks.

Literature

 * The death of the alien invaders in The War of the Worlds is a classic case, although not a very well foreshadowed one.
 * In the Dale Brown book The Tin Man, Patrick McLanahan is warned that the first version of the titular Powered Armor he's using is vulnerable to knives, something that turns out to be a Chekhov's Gun.  gets this in Strike Force after running into a Russian trap.
 * Porthos the giant member of our band in The Three Musketeers and The Man in the Iron Mask so big and strong that he can't even kill himself by hanging (though it does cure his impotence which is why he was doing it) is killed holding up a huge rock in Thirty Years After
 * In Mistborn, everyone regards the Lord Ruler as a terrifying invincible god. Turns out that his power (or rather, a particularly significant part of it) comes from the mystically empowered bracelets he wears on his upper arms which provide him with a limitless supply of youth and vitality- when they get torn off, he immediately begins to revert to his actual age of approximately one milennium. Though he still has his other powers, he can't use them at all effectively while time is rapidly decaying his own body out from under him.

Live-Action TV

 * Buffy the Vampire Slayer was brought low by a bout of flu in "Killed by Death". Handily, this gave her a reason to investigate a series of deaths in the local hospital.
 * Joss Whedon has a habit of giving main characters senseless, non-heroic deaths, from stray bullets to C-list villains who have simply gotten further in their plans than anyone thought. While the characters weren't ever built up as particularly invincible, their main character status would tend to create viewer expectations of their survival, or at least going out in a blaze of glory.
 * One particularly tearjerking example is Cassie, a minor but much-loved Buffy the Vampire Slayer character who had prophesied her own death. Buffy manages to save her from a Cult looking to perform a human sacrifice, when she is almost cut down by a Booby Trap that comes out of nowhere. But this too, Buffy stops. At which point, Cassie drops dead from a heart defect.
 * Also an example of You Can't Fight Fate
 * The Judge cannot be harmed with any weapon. The Judge declares himself invincible. It took an army to stop him before, and even they could only stop him temporarily. That army did not have a missile launcher, which Buffy uses to blow him away.
 * Sarah Connor in Terminator: The Sarah Connor Chronicles suffers from a unique version of this trope, when she learns that in her uninterrupted timeline, after she had fought to keep John alive and saved the world twice, she died from leukemia. She immediately heads to a hospital in an attempt to stop this.
 * Gai Yuuki/Black Condor in Choujin Sentai Jetman. One full year of fighting Vyram, extraterrestrial invaders full of Complete Monster and he survived them all! Cue 3 years later, a random mugger kills him with a mere stab.
 * In Power Rangers Jungle Fury, Grizzaka is in a huge battle with the rangers. The fight has proceeded to a giant Megazord fight and at one point during that massive showdown he taunts the rangers with "It's your turn to learn the same lesson all of my enemies have. There is no one as powerful as Grizzaka, and never will be," which, unfortunately for him, ends up tempting the rangers to form the Jungle Master Stampede Formation and use it to destroy him. Before exploding, he gets a huge surprise and shouts "Impossible... I am invincible... no one is stronger than Grizzaka...!" After that, his Critical Existence Failure is instantaneous.

Mythology

 * Jason, of the famous ancient Greek myth "Jason and the Argonauts," is a notable example. He survived all manner of crazy adventures, battling against impossible odds. He even betrayed his extremely homicidal wife and lived to tell about it. What did him in? A piece of his ship, the Argo, fell on his head and killed him instantly while he was asleep.
 * In one version, he sat under it, told it that it was the only friend he had... and then it fell on his head and killed him.
 * The mighty Hercules, son of Zeus, a man who stole Cerberus from Hades, who choked an indestructible lion to death, who slew the Hydra: killed by a shirt with some poisonous blood on it.
 * Achilles was rendered invulnerable because his mother Thetis dipped him into the River Styx as a child; however as she was holding onto his heel, it was never made invulnerable. Many years later during the Trojan War, Achilles is the greatest hero on the field...until he is killed by a single arrow in the foot.
 * As with any mythology, there are varying versions. Most of them do make some mention of the arrow being poisoned.

Tabletop RPG

 * In the World War II superhero RPG Godlike, The Invulnerable Man is invulnerable to anything, as long as he knows about it. He dies of lung cancer from smoking; he didn't see that coming.

Video Games

 * Meta example: How many times have you died in a video game seconds after your invincibility power-up wore off? Or during its effects, due to Bottomless Pit or similar?
 * Ukyo Tachibana from the Samurai Shodown video game series was set up for this with his tuberculosis, but due to his popularity, SNK has never followed through, except in the obscure and disliked Warrior's Rage.
 * Zato-1 from Guilty Gear is a straight video game example, although he was originally intended to dodge the bullet. The unexpected death of his voice actor forced the designers to call in a Not So Invincible After All moment to explain the voice change, as he was consumed by Eddie, the shadow parasite he used to fight.
 * Metal Gear Solid 3: Snake Eater features a unique gameplay-affecting example. One of the harder bosses in the game is The End, an incredibly skilled sniper who's also an incredibly old man. If you take a long enough break from the game (or, if you're a cheating bastard, advance the PS2's internal clock), he'll have died of old age when you load back up.
 * And in Metal Gear Solid 4: Guns of the Patriots example, Solid Snake, who's survived Outer Heaven, Zanzibar Land, Shadow Moses, the sinking of the Discovery, and the Big Shell Incident is slowly dying of advanced cell degeneration.
 * Metal Gear Solid 2: Sons of Liberty had a much more sudden and shocking example. Throughout the game, Fortune has been invincible, where bullets literally go around her, and explosives that get close to her don't explode (why nobody takes a knife to her is anyone's guess). She and the other characters dismiss this as supernatural, and the player is convinced of this with an eventually subverted Hand Wave. When the characters begin to pull at the threads of the twist ending, Fortune moves to shoot Ocelot with her BFG, and he quick draws his gun and shoots her,.
 * of Persona 3 certainly seems to be headed this way after it's discovered that, but it ends up being subverted when.
 * Beldr the Immortal of Devil Survivor, who has before made a pact with the earth saying that nothing can hurt him. This makes him Nigh Invulnerable to every one of your attacks, unless you use the one thing that didn't make the pact: Not so immortal after all, huh?
 * In Langrisser (Warsong in North America),  permanently dies from a random arrow in a cutscene at the end of a battle, even though in-game you can take up to nine arrows at a time and still be as good as new after three turns of self-healing (or less, if someone casts a heal spell on you as well).
 * Sgt. Johnson in Halo 3, felled by 343 Guilty Spark at the end of the game.
 * One of Francis's quotes in Left 4 Dead reads "Good thing I'm indestructable."
 * Tubba Blubba from Paper Mario. His invincibility is the plot point of the chapter: you know he has a weakness, you just don't know what it is or where to find it.
 * Warcraft3: Many boss characters are not only very powerful, and possess game breaking spells, they also have Divine armor type which almost completely ignores all damage types, making them practically invincible. When the game requires the player to defeat them, a main quest will have them aquire one or more units that do Chaos damage, which completely ignores all armor types including Divine.
 * To be completely precise, Divine Armor only ever gets on the order of 01% of damage dealt from non-Chaos attacks. There have been recorded instances when seemingly-invincible enemies (Chaos!Grom, Cenarius, and Archimonde) were notably damaged. The game, however, gleefully thwarts such an act, railroading the plot regardless.
 * In a Borderlands DLC there is a mission that requires you to defeat a giant crayfish like enemy called Crawmerax the Invincible, and he is by far the hardest boss in the game. Once you defeat him, you can get an achievement called "Vincible"

Web Comics

 * A Running Gag in Captain SNES. Anyone who says the phrase "I am invincible!", regardless of how powerful they are, will end up getting hurt in some way, even if they're only correcting someone else or quoting someone else who said it. In the world of Final Fantasy IV, an explosion threw a number of treasure boxes all over the world; every single one so far has landed on someone foolish enough to say "I am invincible!" And it happens every single time, without fai— gets hit by a treasure chest from the sky

Western Animation

 * In Futurama, That Guy was cryogenically frozen because they were unable to find a cure for his terrible "boneitis". He turns out to be a cold, skilled businessman, and is just about to sell Planet Express to their biggest rivals, Momcorp, when he keels over and dies, Chekhov's Gun-style, of his boneitis. "I was so busy being an Eighties guy," he laments, convulsing with agony, "that I forgot to cure it..."
 * His one regret was that he had boneitis.
 * Also, during an episode set on a planet of robots who believe humans are evil, a horror film ends with the heroes pontificating that a human was immune to their "most powerful electromagnetic fields," but could be killed by a simple pointy stick in the back.
 * Madame Souza of The Triplets of Belleville is a virtual Implacable Man who crosses the Atlantic in a pedal boat and manages to wipe out the French Mafia with no more aid than three other elderly women and an incredibly fat dog. The ending implies that she died of old age sometime after the events of the film proper.
 * In the opening of the first episode of Batman Beyond, Bruce Wayne hangs up the Bat-mantle after a bad heart forces him to pull a gun on someone.
 * In the second Care Bears movie the villain Darkheart falls out of a rowing boat and nearly drowns, needing to be rescued by his own reluctant minion. For reference, this is the same guy who at the beginning of the movie menaced the Care Bears on their boat in the middle of a storm-tossed ocean by taking the form of an enormous serpent, and possesses huge mystical powers. Who'd have guessed he'd be as vulnerable to the old "banana peel on the floor" trick as anyone?
 * Starscream from Transformers Animated. After Megatron tore his spark out of his chest, Screamer immediately discovered that there is a piece of the AllSpark lodged in his forehead. Cue the Starscream Death Montage. In the finale,
 * In-Universe example in Helluva Boss; in the episode "Western Energy", Stolas is nearly killed by the assassin Striker, and is brought to the same hospital where, coincidentally, Blitzo had just taken Loona for her "hellbies" vaccination. Blitzo is shocked that it was even possible for a demon as powerful as Stolas to be so badly injured.

Other

 * There have been seven ships of the Royal Navy named HMS Invincible.
 * HMS Invincible (1747) was originally a French ship named Invincible. Which proved to not be invincible when it was captured by the British and renamed HMS Invincible. HMS Invincible sank in February 1758 when she hit a sandbank in the East Solent.
 * HMS Invincible (1765): She was wrecked off the Norfolk coast in 1801, with the loss of 400 lives.
 * HMS Invincible (1808): Amazingly, survived until scrapped.
 * HMS Invincible (1861): Renamed HMS Black Prince before her launch.
 * HMS Invincible (1869): Foundered in a storm in 1914.
 * HMS Invincible (1907): She blew up and sank after taking a hit from SMS Lützow during World War I, with the loss of 1,026 crew. Only six crew members survived.
 * HMS Invincible (R05) was a light aircraft carrier, the first of three in the Invincible class. She served from 1980 to 2005, including service in the Falklands War. She was scrapped in Turkey in 2011.
 * In the novel The Hunt for Red October, Soviet Captain Ramius sarcastically mentions the name Invincible to his crew when he spots the ship on his periscope, stating it was an arrogant name for a ship. It is very likely he was well aware of the history of the ships with that name.