Black Butler (manga)/Nightmare Fuel


 * In the manga when Ciel and Sebastian are at Baron  mansion and are having dinner. The "circus" show he has a few children put on isn't all that scary... Until   It was a pretty disturbing chapter, but the ones following it had their fair share of horror--Ciel's flashbacks?
 * Drossel Keinz living dolls are literal Nightmare Fuel for people with Dollphobia. But also the fact that he himself is a doll is quite the Fuel itself. But the worst thing for Dollphobic is the puppet of Drossels "Master", which basically caused at least 15 SLEEPLESS NIGHTS for at least every watcher.
 * Black Butler II also has its fair share of horror, but the one scene that tops everything occurs in episode 10. It begins with Hannah talking to Ciel and saying that she has something to show him. Perfectly pleasant, right?
 * Dear God, Black Butler II. How about that bit where
 * Episode 1 where Alois stabs out Hannah's eye with his fingers.