Neopets/YMMV


 * Alternative Character Interpretation: Jhudora. Is she evil or is she actually nice inside?
 * And I Must Scream: When a Petpetpet dies in the Habitarium, it turns into a diamond with a face on it (these you collect to gain Experience Points, thus levels and bonus Neopoints). Seeing as this falls under the category of Your Mileage May Vary, that might not qualify (the faces have a "what just happened" expression, then they smile, like, "oh, cool!").
 * And the Fandom Rejoiced: Moltara. Your Mileage May Vary, of course, but not many people were expecting a Steampunk-themed world, of all things!
 * In a volcano, to boot! (Nod to the old Tyrannian Crack?)
 * MR.COCONUT HAS RETURNED.
 * Yooyuball has a mouse option again!
 * Anticlimax Boss: The eponymous villain in The Darkest Faerie is built up as being the toughest opponent in her game. If you decide to save your Nova Motes, she's nothing more than a pushover, and the 3 minute timer doesn't actually help her.
 * The Neggbreaker from the Y14 Negg Festival event. Listed with a difficulty of 100,000 (which, in comparison, is two hundred times Chiazilla's difficulty) with exactly as many hitpoints, uses some of the most powerful weapons in the game... but equipping the Negg Amulet from the same event lets you deal 20,000 damage to it each round and completely block all of its attacks. Even at level 1.
 * Artificial Stupidity: Loads.
 * Master Vex, the host of Cellblock, has apparently "Never lost a game". However, he can be defeated in nine moves, nearly every time.
 * The Altador Cup--specifically, Yooyuball. The only real challenge is figuring out the quickest path to the goal, weaving through the opposing team, then shooting. Once you've got that sorted, it's just a matter of tedious repetition.
 * Partly fixed with the keyboard version. Now the opposing team is even more frustrating.
 * Creator's Pet: Aristotle A. Avinroo, the mascot of the Gamesmaster Challenge, is a symbol of the site's decline and focus on events rather than plots. Plus, his events have cut short the Return of Dr. Sloth (but thankfully only gave The Faerie's Ruin a slight delay).
 * In the pre-Viacom days, Chias were a Creator's Pet species; Adam and Donna LOVED Chias, and they got two holidays ("Chocolate Chia Day" and "Celebrate the Birth of the First Chia") to every other pet's one. Along with their rather poor design and having the much better designed Lupe as their "rival" species, they remain The Scrappy to this day.
 * Designated Hero: Oh my god, Hoban.
 * Dork Age: It went through one from around 2007 (when the NC Mall opened and the site got a revamp) to about 2010. Consensus among the fans is that The Faerie's Ruin broke the site out of its Dork Age.
 * Ear Worm: Two words: Meepit Juice Break.
 * Ice Cream Machine and Hasee Bounce fits too.
 * Ensemble Darkhorse: For a species that was introduced third-to-last in order, the Xweetoks have a fairly high population. To clarify, they're the fifth most popular pet, and the four before them are some of the first and most marketed pets with a five-year headstart over them.
 * The Xweetok also used to sell without any merch or characters to help promote it, but this thinned out gradually. also helped give the species a boost. There's also Lillian Fairwether from the Journey to the Lost Isle plot.
 * And then we have Neopia's first Big Bad, the Affably Evil Dr. Frank Sloth himself.
 * Some of the Faeries count, as well, especially Jhudora, The Darkest Faerie, Illusen, and the Space Faerie.
 * Many Altador Cup players, the big one being Team Darigan's Tandrak Shaye. Another example is Lost Desert's Vonde Cayle, who was originally supposed to be in the shadow of fellow forward Derbi Azar but ended up being the more popular of the two. Lastly, there's Jair Tollet, who has several NT stories dedicated to her thanks to her transfer from Maraqua to Roo Island.
 * Speaking of the Altador Cup, there's the Techo Super Fan, the bug-eyed, fist-shaking fanatic who roots for whatever team you do. He even got his own game!
 * Abigail Avinroo has this status, mainly due to having a much more likeable personality than her Creator's Pet of a big brother, AAA.
 * mr.coconut. When both him and his "GOOD NIGHT!" were removed from the Editorial, tons of users sent letters demanding his return. Site staff responded not by restoring the Running Gag, but making the search for a replacement a Running Gag in itself.
 * The Sharkaw was one of fifty "new pets" unveiled on April Fool's, 2005. It was in a poll to determine which of these would be an actual new Neopet, but the fellow Darkhorse Lamameeah won and became the Gnorbu, which got some major flak for changing too much from the April Fool's design and winning mostly because of a llama meme going around the Neoboards.
 * Evil Is Sexy: Judging by some of the fandom, Lord Kass, Ylana Skyfire, Captain Scarblade, Jazan (before his Heel Face Turn), Kanrik (See Jazan), Eithne, and Xandra get this.
 * Fanon: Occasionally fan work published in the Neopian Times will reach this status, at least within the circle of Neopian Times readers. This is how the pink Uni working at the pound came to be known as Rose, among other examples.
 * Freud Was Right: Zafara chest fur seems to fill out their clothes quite well. And yes, this also applies to males.
 * Every now and then, boards pop up debating whether or not certain items have arguably sexual designs. After several pages, it's rather difficult to get your mind out of the gutter.
 * This user's gallery (you might need to be logged in to see it) has some... questionable items in it.
 * You have to save some Neopets in The Faerie's Ruin plot by pulling them away from purple tendrils which are holding them and draining their life force. The tendrils can "waver strangely," "vibrate gently," "ripple oddly," "undulate slowly" or "pulse threateningly.' Also notice that they are not called "tentacles."
 * Fake Difficulty: Training your neopet for the battledome makes EV training in Pokémon look like a cakewalk. While your neopets do gain experience with each battle, the experience doesn't boost said pets stats at all. To boost your pets stats, you need to take them to the training school which asks for codestones (not that easy to get ahold of depending on which stone they ask for). However many codestones they ask of you will only contribute to the boosting of one stat per training session as well. On top of that, Elemental Rock-Paper-Scissors doesn't come into play at all. So you can't arm you neopet with any fire-based weapons in hopes of improving your chances against, say, the Snowager.
 * Foe Yay: A weird, fan-specific example: the Neopian Writers and the Help Chat had a bit of a Tsundere relationship for awhile. It fizzled out, due to the HC loosening up a bit and the NW learning the merits of personal space. Either that, or both sides just got bored.
 * Genius Bonus: There is an aquatic Petpet called the Ghoti. According to The Other Wiki, "ghoti" is pronounced "fish".
 * Ho Yay: The epilogue of . Jazan is shown with his wife, Nabile, who is his 'second favourite Ixi thief'. Second favourite?
 * Remember who's telling the story (that is, the supposed "first favorite Ixi thief"), though this may only change who the Ho Yay is coming from.
 * Internet Backdraft: The revamps. Let's leave it at that.
 * Jumping the Shark: Many former Neopets users thought Neopets Jumped the Shark with its radical new layout a few years ago.
 * For others, it was the Customization feature.
 * How does that count? Clothing items finally had a use other than being Vendor Trash.
 * Or when they sold the site and started putting ads everywhere.
 * General consensus is that the site Jumped the Shark the day it was purchased by Viacom, though things might be swinging the other way thanks to The Faerie's Ruin not being rushed to an early end for the GMC.
 * Lighter and Softer: Neopets was meant for young adults when it first came around. The early plots all had gobs of black comedy. Everything has since lost that sort of humour when the site was made kid friendly, but the old pages from old plots still float around, waiting to become Nightmare Fuel. Other bits that still float around are details changed in upgraded games. The Game Graveyard lets you play the old versions, where Carnival of Terror still says "cause of death" when you lose. And the game Spell or Starve, from the very old Doctor Sloth plot.
 * On the other hand, The Faerie's Ruin has basically become the darkest thing in the history of the site with its Wham Episode.
 * Maraquans Love Elon Hughlis
 * Memetic Mutation: During a site event/minor plot for Krawk Island in 2011, users on the boards played a game they called "Put Something In McGill's Hand"... where they 'shopped random things into McGill's hand, due to the odd way he was drawn. It spread like wildfire, with most of the boards reaching the maximum number of posts.
 * Nice Job Breaking It, Hero: A sort of meta example: Neopets was launched around the same time as the Children's Online Privacy Protection Act of 1998 (coming into effect in early 2000), meaning that it was one of the first major websites to have to deal with laws concerning the collection of personal information from minors. Specifically, users under 13 had to have their parents fax a signed form indicating that the child had permission to sign up and use certain futures of the site (such as Neo Mail). The prompt and decisive response from the preteen would-be userbase was to simply lie about their age when creating their accounts. Fast forward to circa 2006: Neopets implements a birth date check in their login form. Now, what fake birth date did you enter on a whim some long-passed Wednesday back in 5th grade? ...Yeah, that's what I thought. Cue the anguished cries of thousands of nostalgia-seeking teenagers as they're simultaneously locked out of their childhood. Oops.
 * Nightmare Fuel:
 * The Transparent color. This is what happens. Sure, Invisible was literal... but this is what happens when your pet is stuck in an X-ray.
 * There's actually a lot of this. The entire Haunted Woods probably counts, if you go into detail. There's a tree with a brain and a face there.
 * Some of the Mutant forms can be kind of disturbing, but the Mutant Kau takes the cake, especially compared to a normal Red Kau...
 * Beware, all users with laggy computers, or who dare to wait between levels on certain games (looking at you, Typing Terror). You might be surprised by something.
 * Were you expecting the uncased Robot Poogle to look like this? Yeah, didn't think so.
 * Then, there's this little beauty.
 * The loud sound effect that always plays when you lose Darigan Dodgeball and considering the type of game it is, losing is inevitable.
 * What about the new Transparent color? Though it's only for the Wocky, Elephante and Skeith at the moment, it shows their bones and organs!!
 * The at the end of Lair of the Beast., but still.
 * Scrappy Level: The code breaking in the Return of Sloth plot, and the Tarla plot.
 * From the Faeries' Ruin plot, the Barrier Shield Reinforcement step. The four tasks are already challenging, but because you have to cooperate with three other players (who may or may not be competent) while dealing with the site's horrendous lag, and the fact that it's timed sends it straight into Fake Difficulty territory. Slightly mitigated by the fact that you can form groups with users to do this step, thus ensuring a level of competence.
 * "Stop Having Fun!" Guys: The Altador Cup. If you join a popular team, an unpopular team, or submit less than 100 wins per day, you will be mocked on the forums for it. Guaranteed.
 * But the best prizes are worth millions of NP, so actually trying is somewhat worth it for the poor.
 * They Changed It, Now It Sucks: The site underwent a major revamp in Year 9 (2007). Heck, some users quit the site because of it!
 * More commonly expressed as "Viacom bought it now it sucks."
 * The new Yooyuball... Has not been well received thanks to the controls being unnecessarily simplified. We want our mouse controls back!
 * Ugly Cute: Mutant and Darigan pets. (The ones that aren't Nightmare Fuel anyway.)
 * Viewer Gender Confusion: Several of the players in the Altador Cup. Specifically, Jair and Lilo from Roo Island.
 * Villain Decay: Dr. Sloth
 * Curiously, a lot of this Villain Decay was helped along by the fans of the site. Go figure.
 * The Woobie: Grey Faeries are intentionally like this.
 * As is the Darigan Citadel, once you learn what happened to them at the hands of Meridell.
 * Also, the Discarded Magical Blue Grundo Plushie of Prosperity.

Plots provide examples of:

 * And the Fandom Rejoiced: The fandom response for The Faerie's Ruin, especially when compared to Atlas of the Ancients, has been overwhelming positive especially now there are puzzle-related plot steps AND a war. Plus The Angry Orange Yurble Forefitor returned and the Gamesmaster Challenge didn't cut the story short, and that's all before the Wham Episode hit...
 * Creepy Awesome: Probably the reason has a fanbase. Besides being a Magnificent Bastard, she's also one of the scariest villains to appear in Neopets, even edging out a God of Evil.
 * Complete Monster: Quite a few plot villains stand out, most notably:
 * Razul: An emperor who had a lust for immortality so great, he cast a curse upon his own city--and his own son--to become a fiery demon, and when he returned, he attempted to murder his daughter-in-law.
 * Lord Kass: After Lord Darigan was defeated, Kass ascended to the leadership of the Citadel through blackmail, bribery, intimdation, and propaganda, and then waged war against Meridell to gain power. More than a few fans are reminded of Hitler. Unfortunately, he's a huge victim of Draco in Leather Pants.
 * Alexander Krawley: The mysterious villain of the Tale of Woe, Krawley tricked an entire town into taking a potion that would turn them into monsters, and apparently caused the death and abandonment of The Meepit Oaks Sanitorium, all for kicks.
 * The Bringer of Night: A silent demigod of death who attempted to commit genocide on an entire species due to being Made of Evil.
 * Although the Bringer ended up hijacking the plot, Galem Darkhand counts. After all, he WAS willing to let an entire species die out of Greed.
 * Captain Scarblade: Most pirates in Neopia are pirates who don't do anything. Scarblade averts that; he's as vicious and cruel as Real Life pirates, and attempted to destroy Maraqua simply because it didn't stay destroyed. He, too, is subject to Draco in Leather Pants.
 * The Darkest Faerie: She betrayed her closest friends and caused the near-destruction of an entire kingdom, and upon her return, tried to crash Faerieland into Meridell out of sheer spite.
 * Draco in Leather Pants: A LOT of plot villains get this status, no matter how evil they are.
 * Lord Kass is the first villain to really get this, and does it ever show. Maybe TNT shouldn't have given him a Shirtless Scene?
 * Kanrik got this, too, although he later earned a good reputation.
 * Jhudora and the Darkest Faerie... No, evil Faeries in general get this because they're The Beautiful Elite.
 * From Return of Dr. Sloth, Ylana Skyfire gets this for being pretty Badass and being a Bounty Hunter.
 * Captain Scarblade fell victim, mainly because users love pirates.
 * Like Kanrik, Prince Jazan did a Heel Face Turn and redeemed himself.
 * is the most recent DILP, but it's because raises some valid points about Faeries, no matter how Ax Crazy  was.
 * Hoban to a degree, mostly because he's something of an Asshole Victim (who didn't die).
 * Ensemble Darkhorse: So very many.
 * The Meridell plots gave us Lord Darigan, who was the first morally ambiguous character on the site (although he's far more heroic than that fat oaf Skarl); Jeran, a Knight in Shining Armor AND a Big Badass Wolf; and Lord Kass, the first Complete Monster in site history.
 * Hannah and the Pirate Caves was so popular, the eponymous Usul adventuress appeared in her own plot, which introduced another Darkhorse, Kanrik.
 * From the Curse of Maraqua, we have the Maraquan Aisha sisters, Isca and Caylis, and the villain, Captain Scarblade.
 * The Lost Desert plot gave us Prince, now King Jazan, who was popular enough to return for The Faerie's Ruin, and his friend, the Nightsteed. It also introduced the Angry Orange Yurble Foreman/Chef/Janitor/Librarian. His presence in a plot is viewed as a very good sign.
 * A Tale Of Woe is another interesting case where one of the central characters was already a Darkhorse. Sophie is still one of the most popular characters on the site due to being a very amusing Grumpy Bear. Bruno is another example, due to being Ugly Cute in his mutated form, and Adorkable before AND after.
 * Despite being a mini-plot, the Cyodrake's Gaze gave us Hoban, a grumpy navigator, and Bonju, the temperamental chef.
 * Although it suffered from a big-time Gecko Ending, Journey To The Lost Isle spawned Lillian Fairweather, who actually happens to be a Xweetok! Roxton was also one, and appeared in Atlas of the Ancients.
 * From the Return Of Dr. Sloth, Ylana Skyfire is ridiculously popular due to being a very, VERY Badass Bounty Hunter.
 * Even before The Faerie's Ruin, Hubrid Nox was this for years despite never doing anything. His death helped him get this status.
 * Growing the Beard: It's so nice, it happened twice.
 * The first beard growth was in the Champions Of Meridell plot, due to not only being the first plot that let you choose sides, but being more morally complex. Will you fight for the bright, shiny, pretty land of Meridell, although they only got that way because they stole an artifact from another land... Or will you aid the ominous floating Darigan Citadel, who are fighting to take back what is rightfully theirs from the thieves who stole it from them? This beard growth lasted for years, from 2002 when the plot started, to 2006 when the Tale of Woe plot ended. However, the site shaved the beard and focused more on Aristotle A. Avinroo and other "events" instead of actual plots.
 * The second beard growth involved The Faerie's Ruin, in which the villain brought up similar issues of morality about the faeries, who didn't seem to be doing anything with their power for the Neopians. It also involved a Crowning Moment of Awesome for both  and the entire site when   crashed Faerieland into Neopia. Time will tell how long this beard growth lasts, but it was hilariously accompanied by a literal beard growth on the part of the head coder for the plot!
 * This beard growth may last for quite a while, considering that TNT not only announced on the official Neopets Facebook page that they already have some ideas for the next plot, but are asking the users themselves for suggestions!
 * HSQ: Faerie's Ruin..
 * Magnificent Bastard:.
 * Moral Event Horizon: While most villains often fall in the Harmless Villain territory as it can be seen here. Actually doing something not even the Big Bad Dr. Sloth was able to do.
 * Speaking of Dr. Sloth, he arguably crosses this when he creates a cyborg that proceeds to wipe out almost the entire Neopets staff.
 * Most plot villains jump over the Moral Event Horizon somehow; Galem jumps over it when he's willing to cause an entire species to die out of his own Greed; Scarblade is actually attempting to destroy a land and commit genocide out of Fantastic Racism; Razul cursed his own city--and his own SON--so he could achieve eternal life as a fiery demon; Krawley manipulated EVERYONE into furthering his whims so Neovia got worse; and Kass... Well, anything Kass does, but ESPECIALLY when he seemingly kills Jeran.
 * Nightmare Fuel: The Shadow Wraiths gain their power by using tendrils to consume the life force of Neopets, leaving them shriveled husks. Ow.
 * Seasonal Rot: The overall stories, both short and overarching, were in decline from about 2007 up until 2010, when The Faerie's Ruin brought things back to a 2004-2006 level of awesome.
 * Out of all plots, though, Atlas of the Ancients is the best example of Seasonal Rot; poor art (which is unforgivable when there were earlier plots like A Tale of Woe, which had GORGEOUS art); a really bad, almost non-existant story that was basically a Random Events Plot; and being a gaming event like the Daily Dare in a crappy plot guise. About the only good thing it brought was give us Moltara.
 * Straw Man Has a Point: Surprisingly in The Faerie's Ruin, . even has converted part of the audience to cause (see Draco In Leather Pants).
 * Viewer Gender Confusion: Brynn has been mistaken for a boy by a number of users, despite other characters using female pronouns to refer to her.
 * Win Back the Crowd: The Faerie's Ruin has been a smash hit upon old-school Neopets fans from the pre-Viacom years, and among newer fans.