Deadly Premonition/YMMV

""This game is so bad, it's not just become good. It's pretty close to perfect.""
 * Accidental Aesop: Smoking literally shaves hours off of York's life every time he lights up. About one full minute of smoking in game can shave off an ENTIRE DAY.
 * And the Fandom Rejoiced: An updated port coming to the US and Europe for the Play Station 3 has been announced.
 * It's also been announced that there are more Deadly Premonition projects.
 * Awesome Music:
 * The Woods and the Goddess
 * Life is Beautiful aka the Whistle Theme
 * Carol's lounge music, Miss Stiletto Heels Slightly ironic, given that
 * The opening theme, Greenvale (with vocals). Particularly haunting and quite lovely.
 * Pillow Stain, from the "Rainy Woods" trailer, played nowhere else in the game itself except in the sound test.
 * Complacent Gaming Syndrome: People prefer to use the machine guns on Shadows despite them getting more and more effective and bullet resistant. It also doesn't help that a side quest that can easily be completed early in the game gives you one that has infinite bullets. It's probably due to the fact that successive headshots practically stun-lock Shadows until they're dead.
 * Complete Monster: . Not only was he responsible for 50 years ago, he also . But, to top it all off he.
 * Critical Research Failure: Stock monkey sound effects are used for squirrels in at least one cutscene.
 * Crosses the Line Twice: When York talks about the cases he's been on previously, he mentions horrifying cases (such as one involving a man using skulls for everyday practices and a man who raped 800 people), but his skewed priorities when it comes down to the horribleness of the crime and the reactions of Emily, Thomas, and George make it very, very funny.
 * Cult Classic: It's got a relatively small fanbase, but those who like it call it either gaming's definition of So Bad, It's Good, or a rough, uncut diamond in a sea of polished, cut coal.
 * Ear Worm: Don't be surprised if you catch yourself whistling along with the Whistle Theme.
 * Ensemble Darkhorse: Thomas seems to be a rather popular character, even.
 * Don't forget The Raincoat Killer.
 * Punk York. Although never seen in-game, York's mention that he used to dress like a punk rocker captivated fans' imaginations. He shows up with regularity in fan art, and a punk costume for York was commonly speculated/asked for leading up to the Director's Cut.
 * Epileptic Trees: Are the Shadows citizens who were caught in the rain and ? Are they ? Are they merely figments of York's imagination, and if so, how do they cause him real pain? Or perhaps they're ?
 * Word of God suggests it's the second one.
 * Fashion Victim Villain:
 * Freud Was Right: .... has mommy issues....
 * Game Breaker: Legendary Guitar Grecotch, which, while slow, usually take out shadows in just one or two hits, and, due to the fact it's a quest item, will not break.
 * Arguably even better is the wrench, which is almost as strong as Grecotch, also indestructible, and much faster.
 * Weapons aside, the Weather Doll. When activated, your health will automatically regenerate, rendering all the first-aid kits you've been hoarding completely useless. There's a reason this is one of the hardest items to obtain, unlocked after completing Emily's sidequests which can only be done when it's raining, and at a specific time frame.
 * Goddamned Wall Crawlers: The wall crawler enemies which are unfortunately common during the second part of the game and take far too long to kill trying to kill normally. They would be Demonic Spiders, except that they don't really pose a threat. They're just really tedious to fight without using an unintuitive alternate method. If you have unlocked the Wesley Special, they become a LOT easier.
 * Another option is you could use Legendary Guitar Grecotch and a shotgun, which can kill them in 13 seconds.
 * Good Bad Bugs: As supergreatfriend's Let's Play can attest, at times, the characters animations while you're talking to them sort of break, resulting in gems like Emily, who is supposed to be drinking Alcohol, pouring it in her ear.
 * Memetic Mutation:
 * The game's gotten quite a bit of this. Isn't that right, Zach?
 * "F K"... In the coffee!
 * The Whistle Song will never leave your head.
 * ...So says Mr. Stewart.
 * York being extremely late for every important meeting.
 * Most Annoying Sound:
 * "Must you drive so safely?! My pot is getting cold!!"
 * "You swine!" "Dodge this!" "Take that!"
 * Narm Charm: The whole damn game is either one or the other. From the scares to the fuzzy feelings, it is everywhere.
 * The ending may escape this, as the story simply becomes so deranged and tragic that not even the game's own narm can spoil it.
 * Nightmare Retardant:
 * The shadows are more goofy than scary with their funky limbo moves and slow garbled speech. At least, until one of them gets a hold of you and tries to shove its arm down your throat.
 * 's monster forms are pretty silly in design. One of them ends up looking like a Super Saiyan.
 * It honestly says something when
 * Scrappy Mechanic/That One Level:
 * The first level does NOT do a very good job of easing you into the game. In addition to introducing the weakest part of the game first, the combat, the combination of fussy controls, very few melee weapons, the weak starter pistol, a poorly placed patch of Respawning Enemies and the instant kill quick time event at the very end turn a lot of people away before the game even really starts.
 * Okay, whose idea was it to make this the first and only Wide Open Sandbox game where your car can run out of gasoline?
 * The segment in which you have to fish for evidence can be agonizing if you haven't gotten used to the fishing mechanic before hand.
 * So Bad It's Good: Some claim that Deadly Premonition IS this trope in game form.
 * Okay, whose idea was it to make this the first and only Wide Open Sandbox game where your car can run out of gasoline?
 * The segment in which you have to fish for evidence can be agonizing if you haven't gotten used to the fishing mechanic before hand.
 * So Bad It's Good: Some claim that Deadly Premonition IS this trope in game form.


 * Or, as one Destructoid user put it, "LADIES AND GENTLEMEN. WE HAVE FOUND GAMING'S Citizen Kane.".
 * Special Effect Failure: Okay, most of what we see in the game is actually not half bad, especially for a budget title, and a lot of the interior areas have quite good attention to detail. The outdoors (specifically, the woods) are another story entirely, with oft too repeated textures and sub-Dreamcast level tree textures floating in the air. Of course, for some, that's part of the charm.
 * Spiritual Licensee: A lot of people on the internet have compared it to Twin Peaks, even more so before the game came out, before the game was changed in response.
 * Squick: It is a horror game. Even so, York's description of a past case he's involved himself in a particular scene was more grating than what actually happens. It's somehow borderline worse.
 * Uncanny Valley: Humans seem to fall into this category sometimes, particularly when their mouths are open, as it is traditional.
 * Tear Jerker: A good deal of the ending sequence.
 * York and Zach.
 * The Woobie: Many, many people in Greenvale seem to fit this, such as Olivia, who thinks her husband is cheating on her, and Lysander, who reveals that.