Special:Badtitle/NS90:Talk:Pokémon Diamond and Pearl/YMMV/The Great Big Cyrus Effort Post (2)/reply

I'm not going to argue for Cyrus, but I'm genuinely curious: why does him getting redeemed in two unrelated mangas with separate continuities count against him? I fail to see how they're relevant since they're in their own universe with characters interpreted in wildly different ways (Surge Sabrina and Koga being Team Rocket flunkies, the Kanto Elite Four being a bunch of terrorists, Pryce being a master criminal twisted by loneliness and grief). It's like the equivalent of disqualifying the likes of, say, Light Yagami or Kristoph Gavin because they're given a full-on Draco in Leather Pants treatment by some horny fangirls in fanfiction or something.