Gundam/YMMV

Big Name Fan:
- Mark Simmons is undoubtedly the most knowledgeable member of the English-speaking Gundam fandom, and has even done some work for the franchise in helping iron out official translations. He regularly takes part in the fandom, especially in technical discussions, and his website is probably the single greatest source for Gundam info in English, including the official English Gundam site.
- He's even gotten some nods within the franchise: Mark Simmons is the default name for one of the Create-A-Characters in the video game Encounters in Space, Gundam SEED has a minor character (a mobile suit engineer) named Erica Simmons, and G-Saviour's main character, Mark Curran, has a sidekick named Simmons.
Broken Base: The fandom is generally grouped roughly based on which series brought you into the fandom, though this has died way down since Gundam's heyday in the early 2000s. The original split was between UC purists and Wingers, with a smaller faction of Seedlings arising later. Gundam 00 was divisive due to its much more Super Robot-styled Gundams and the First Contact plot of the movie given that Absent Aliens has long been a hallmark of the franchise. The newest series, Gundam AGE, has caused some disagreements over its "kiddie" styling.
Complete Monster: Every shows needs at least one super bastard with no redeeming qualities whatsoever, from Gihren to Desil. The most popular is undoubtedly Yazan, though he's almost equaled by his later Expy, Ali Al Sachez.
Continuity Lock Out: The main reason for the shift from the UC timeline to alternate universes.
Crowning Moment of Awesome: The 30th anniversary short "Gundam Perfect Mission", where the protagonist Gundams from every anime up through Unicorn work together to get the Core Fighter into space, where it forms into the original Gundam, the whole thing ending with a Yeah! Shot.
Deader Than Disco: Gundam Seed's success would spawn a sequel and a manga spinoff series, and even started talks that the CE timeline could become the new UC. However, Destiny didn't work out so well, and a planned movie to wrap up the saga is in Development Hell, making creators and fans give up on the saga and move on to Mobile Suit Gundam 00. Today, if you ask Gundam fans of their opinion of Seed, you will get plenty of contradicting responses, and you certainly won’t find many fans of Destiny.
- Though the new remastered version of Seed that's currently coming out may change that.
Die for Our Ship: Has its own page.
Fanon: The fandom is quite good at creating it, given how many Alternate Continuity versions and contradictory source materials there are.
Foe Yay: The Hero and The Big Bad / The Rival are prone to this.
Hypocritical Fandom:
- Fans who subscribe to the Draco in Leather Pants interpretation of the Principality of Zeon. They tend to paint The Federation as tyrannical and cruel, but tend to be rather silent on the fact that the first thing Zeon did after declaring war was to kill an entire space colony with poison gas, then try to drop it on the Federation's military capital. After it failed, the only things that kept them from trying again were attrition and a treaty, and even then the myriad spinoffs show them as willing to use nukes and biological agents.
  - A similar phenomenon is going on in Gundam AGE. Fans who are rooting for Vagan, formerly known as the UE, tend to call out the Earth Federal Forces as corrupt and genocidal. At the same time, they tend to stay mum on the fact that the "oppressed martians" kill millions of innocent civilians, many of whom lived in colonies that were never protected by the Earth Federal Forces to begin with.
  - This only leads to Double Standards within the fandom's reactions during discussions about Vagan and the Principality of Zeon. Vagan soldiers wiping out unarmed colonies and killing Yurin? OF COURSE! They are Ax Crazy Complete Monsters who have no regard for human lives! The Principality of Zeon using poison gas to wipe out an entire colony so they could use the colony to drop it on the Federation's capital? How dare you side with the Feddies! Yeah, TOTALLY not hypocritical.
- Also, some fans will rage against one continuity for having newtype ripoffs, or Char Clone, overly simplistic messages and what have you, and yet will turn a blind eye to it when such themes are re-used ad-verbatim in the original Universal Century timeline.
- On the other side, some fans will brand whoever complains about alternate continuities with Double Standards. Complaining about Universal Century, however, is totally OK. Mobile Suit Gundam Unicorn is well-received? Ha! Maybe it's only because it's a Universal Century series! Mobile Suit Gundam 00 is well-received? Of course, it's a really good series! Yeah...they're much more open-minded.
Just Here for Godzilla: Why some fans enjoy the franchise despite finding the plots boring and the characters irritating. It's still got giant robots blowing each other up!
Magnificent Bastard: Almost every series, from the first Mobile Suit Gundam (Char) to Gundam 00 (Ribbons Almark before Villain Decay) has featured one of these as an antagonist in addition to a Complete Monster.
Member Berries: The franchise is no stranger to this trope.
- In a meta sense, the Char Clone, when done poorly, is this trope by virtue of trying to ape the original and making it so obvious it comes off like cheap pandering, Generally, the better ones have something distinctive that sets them apart, while the worse versions are obvious ripoffs.
  - In-universe, they've even discussed and deconstructed the trope in relation to this trope why Memberberrying Char is a bad idea with Full Frontal and Zoltan Akkaenen in Mobile Suit Gundam Unicorn and the immediate followup Mobile Suit Gundam Narrative.
- The Mobile Suit Gundam SEED franchise tends to get panned for a lot of nostalgia reliance to the point of being a crutch, especially in the sequel series, where they blatantly pastiche entire plot arcs and even mecha from the UC series, while letting the story itself suffer by not fixing its preexisting flaws.
- The Mobile Suit Gundam AGE series has a lot of nostalgia pandering throughout its run, with the first arc heavily leaning on the original series, the second cribs a lot from Mobile Suit Zeta Gundam, and the final arc mines a lot of Mobile Suit Gundam SEED and Mobile Suit Crossbone Gundam, right down to slavish pastiches of locations, events, characters, and mechs. While some of these elements aren't bad in and of themselves, detractors of the series often note this nostalgia pandering does little to nothing to fix any flaws of the series while simply hoping to coast by on nostalgia baiting instead.
- Mobile Suit Gundam: Iron-Blooded Orphans is panned for doing this trope, trying to mix the moral ambiguity and terrorism angles of Mobile Suit Gundam 00 and the aristocracy and political patchwork of the world setting of Mobile Suit Gundam Wing. Detractors note that in trying to recall the former, they tend to make almost everyone look so morally questionable it devolves into Darkness-Induced Audience Apathy. As for the latter, it generally noted that the aristocratic elements come off as less well done and that Gjallarhorn comes off as a less competent copy of OZ.
Memetic Mutation: Enough to have its own page.
Misaimed Fandom: Yes, the Federation has corrupt leaders. Yes, Zeon has many good, moral, people who serve it. Yes, the Titans are bad. That being said, it's a little scary how many fans will knee-jerk a SIEG ZEON for a regime that murdered, not millions, but BILLIONS of people and continued to wipe out metropolitan centers every few years... FOR FREEDOM.
Most Wonderful Sound: The Newtype flash.
Recycled Script: Quick, which Gundam show am I describing: the main character is a youngster who gets embroiled in the war when it shows up on his doorstep, leading to him Falling Into the Cockpit of a Gundam. He ends up reluctantly becoming an Ace Pilot, gaining both a personal enemy and a love interest among the enemy, the latter of which dies tragically. Eventually the hero participates in the war's Final Battle, helping defeat the enemy before retiring to a less martial life. Give up? It's MSG, Z, ZZ, Unicorn, V, Seed and Destiny to a lesser extent, and arguably X and Turn A as well. Whew!
Rooting for the Empire: For UC, Zeon has far more vocal fans than the Earth Federation. In CE, just mentioning it in reference to the Earth Alliance or ZAFT is likely to cause a Flame War over who was really the bad guy. Ditto, though to a lesser extent, for Mobile Suit Gundam 00. The same debate over whether Vagan or the Earth Federal Forces is worse in Gundam AGE is getting ugly as well.
They Changed It, Now It Sucks / It's the Same, Now It Sucks: The series often gets complaints that the Gundams all look way too similar to each other. Yet when they went with going with a very different design approach in Turn a Gundam by bringing in American Syd Mead, it was met with heavy derision from the community.
True Art Is Angsty: Zeta Gundam, while having one of the bleakest endings in all Gundam, is generally considered to be one of the best of them all. Gundam 0080 is similarly dark, and similarly exalted. On the other hand, Turn a Gundam is also considered to be among the best, and it's arguably the happiest Gundam series. Ditto for Crossbone Gundam another series that avoids the Kill'Em All status Tomino is infamous for. Incidentally, Tomino wrote all three series.
Unfortunate Implications: One criticism of Tomino's UC works is the frequency at which female pilots are killed off and turned into a driving force for the protagonist . It applies to some of the AU series as well.
Wangst: Happens when the protagonist takes True Art Is Angsty too far, which is depressingly frequent for people who just want to watch giant robots fighting.