Topic on User talk:Robkelk

Summary by Robkelk

One page was unprotected, and the person who requested the unprotection ended up blocked. Other posts in this thread are the same arguments that have in the past damaged the wiki - let's not go down that road again.

WalrusGuy (talkcontribs)
Robkelk (talkcontribs)

As I have time, but it isn't a high priority.

In the meantime, you can gain confirmed rights (and be able to edit the CM pages) by editing other pages on this wiki.

WalrusGuy (talkcontribs)

Thanks. BTW I saw that Soto from Ice Age is in the Examples that should not be seen here list for Western Animation, the argument being "His actions don't go beyond standard villainy, and is motivated by revenge for family he'd lost to human hunters." I disagree with this. wanting to eat a baby alive is well above standard villainy, and the fact that he's very abusive to his surviving pack members (going so far as to threaten to cannibalize Diego if he fails to deliver said baby), raises the question of whether he genuinely cared for his pack or just saw their deaths as blows to his ego. With that said I feel he should be removed from the non-examples list.

WalrusGuy (talkcontribs)

In the meantime can you just unlock the Dreamworks page?

Robkelk (talkcontribs)

Sure... and done.

WalrusGuy (talkcontribs)

How about the Arkhamverse, Marvel Animation and Marvel Films pages?

DocColress (talkcontribs)

Oh yeah, this was THAT ban evader/vandal...

Soto is a non-example because of the reasons stated. And I'm a bit disheartened that you'd given her what she wanted with the Dreamworks page without stopping to question this person's identity and true intentions.

Robkelk (talkcontribs)

Who hurt you, Doc? Who made you so paranoid?

And a difference of opinion is not vandalism.

DocColress (talkcontribs)

THAT ban evader/vandal whose edits that you feel ought to have been tolerated is who hurt me and made me so paranoid, if you must know.

That person wasn't just adding opinions, they were also deleting opinions that didn't agree with their own. They've always been very self-important regarding what they think makes a CM and what doesn't, and unlike me, they don't have any regard to the actual criteria for qualifying an example - they're just pure "my way or the highway" all the time.

GethN7 (talkcontribs)

Rob, I can confirm Doc is right, they are a ban evader.

Robkelk (talkcontribs)

Did somebody forget to block the IP address when the user was banned here? I know that's an extra step, but it's only one additional checkbox on the Block User page - folks need to remember to do that when blocking users on All The Tropes.

GethN7 (talkcontribs)

I do that by default. Most of these morons abuse proxies and VPNs anyway.