Topic on User talk:Hsart

The Horrible Monster Island Buddies Remake

2
Robkelk (talkcontribs)

Hello, and welcome to All The Tropes!

I saw your submission for The Horrible Monster Island Buddies Remake in the Moderation queue... and then set it aside for a day, thinking that it would be faster to reject the submission and re-write it than it would to fix all of the problems with the article.

First, at no place in the description does it say what The Horrible Monster Island Buddies Remake actually is. We have no idea whether this is a film, a comic book, a radio show, an opera, a fanfic, or something else entirely.

First-and-a-half, if this is an online work (and the mention of YouTube hints that it might be), the description doesn't have a link to it. Where can people find this work that you like so much that you're willing to start a page for it?

Second, you didn't use a page template - which means that your page would not appear in the list of works that have pages here.

Third, you over-coded almost every internal link. Exactly_What_It_Says_on_the_Tin|Exactly What It Says on the Tin is functionally identical to Exactly What It Says on the Tin - there is absolutely no reason to use the underscores in that or any other page link.

I have approved the submission, and immediately added in the technical elements that would have been present if you had used the page template to begin with - so the page now appears on the list of works that ATT has pages for. Please go back in and at the minimum add a link to the work.

Also, please read All The Tropes:Works Page Guidelines so that you'll know what an All The Tropes page is "supposed to" look like. (Even if you think that the rules should be changed, you need to know what they are first.)

-- robkelk, admin

@Labster @Looney Toons @GethN7 @QuestionableSanity @Derivative @SelfCloak

Hsart (talkcontribs)

Hello, and thanks for the feedback! I will be editing it very soon.