Trope Workshop:Boy Meets T-Girl

Everything About Fiction You Never Wanted to Know.
Jump to navigation Jump to search

This is a Trope Workshop page, still under consideration for creation.
Help out by editing the current page, or leave a comment on the Talk page.
Trope Workshop Guidelines

A subtrope and variant of one of the most basic and oldest plots, which originally went: Boy Meets Girl, boy loses girl, boy finds girl again. But with a twist.

One of the pair is the inevitably shy and innocent boy next door - a straight stock character. The other is inexplicably gorgeous, intelligent, sympathetic, single and seemingly perfect in every way... but for one minor detail, which serves as a source of dramatic tension at her expense for most of the story. She was assigned male at birth; her backstory involves a long and difficult transition, of which the boy who's just been smitten by her has no inkling or idea. Effectively, she's left wondering how he will react once he learns of her past - and he will be caught completely off-guard, to the point that that he risks losing the girl if he reacts the wrong way or (if she's "outed" by someone else) fails to defend her honour.

The Reveal is usually played in one of two ways. If this is being written as porn or erotica, she's transformed into a futanari-like fetish object, the best of both worlds sexually, as Fan Service.[1] If this is being written as the sort of teen fiction which turns up in public libraries, she becomes An Aesop - a lesson to bullying teens not to judge others on the basis of their sexuality.

Another variant involves a fellow falling for a transgender woman in some context where he knows (or at least suspects) what's going on, but where his family, friends or colleagues don't know (and react negatively or even violently when they learn the truth).

Despite the trope title, Boy Meets T-Girl could just as easily have been played the other way around... as there are just as many transsexual persons transitioning female-to-male as male-to-female. It just seems to be played as straight boy/trans woman because a transgender woman is a more readily sexualised character (see Attractive Bent Gender and Everybody Wants the Hermaphrodite) but, at the same time, more free to express emotion if the main character allows anyone to hurt her in some way - as Men Don't Cry but trans women (as they are women) do.

Not to be confused with Something's Different About You Now, where the lad already knew the lady before transition.

See Transsexualism and Transgender. See also the older-than-dirt parent trope, Boy Meets Girl.

Examples of Boy Meets T-Girl include:

Film[edit | hide]

  • The Crying Game has a man unwittingly fall in love with a transwoman as just one more twist in an already-complex plot.
  • Soldier's Girl has a soldier fall in love with a transgender showgirl. He's fine with her status, two of his fellow soldiers are not.
  • XXY (2007 film) has a boy fall in love with an intersexual main character, who is living as a teen girl but hiding that she medically has some characteristics of both genders (as XX is the usual genetic code for a lady and XY for a gentleman, XXY is unusual and rare).

Literature[edit | hide]

  • Almost Perfect by Brian Katcher. Written by a schoolteacher whose own daughter is the age of the trans girl in the story, it's basically an Aesop aimed at a teen-fiction audience.
  • If I was your girl, by Meredith Russo. This is more of the same, but tends to stretch a bit further to try to get a happy ending as the author is a transgender woman.

Live-Action TV[edit | hide]

  • Transparent (Amazon video series): Josh (Jay Duplass) and his crush on Shea (Trace Lysette) in season three.

Oral Tradition, Myths and Legends[edit | hide]

Other Media[edit | hide]

Real Life[edit | hide]

  1. As is usual for anything that is an example of Fan Service, Your Mileage May Vary. Nobody likes everything that's billed as Fan Service, but everything that's Fan Service is liked by somebody.