View source for Non-Entity General

{{trope}}
{{Video Game Examples Need Sorting}}
{{quote|''[[Command & Conquer|Welcome back, Commander]].''}}

A specific case of [[Featureless Protagonist]] that applies to [[Strategy Game]]s. Often it is unclear whether the [[Player Character]] is even a player character at all, as even if he has a specific role, he might have absolutely no development at all. He may be referred to only by a rank or title, or even never referred to at all if the game gives mission objectives in third person.

He isn't present in any combat location. Even if the game covers the entire world or galaxy, there is nowhere the enemy could attack to kill him. As long as any friendly units are alive, the player is assumed to be among them.

Additionally, even in low-tech settings, troops have [[Easy Communication|absolutely no hurdles in receiving or understanding your orders]] and will often [[Command and Conquer Economy|not do anything at all]] without them.

All in all, its almost as if the player was a [[Hive Mind]] made up of his troops rather than their commander.

Near-omnipresent in [[4X]] games, where the "ruler" usually have only name, or at most name and portrait.

Contrast [[Hero Must Survive]].

{{examples}}
* ''[[Warcraft]]'' I and II used these, though it was subverted in the backstory of ''Warcraft II'', where we find out that the Orc commander of the first game, who is given the name Orgrim Doomhammer, became the warchief and is the boss of that game's orc commander. The human commander was likely Lothar.
** According to Blizzard, the player in ''Warcraft II'' is none other than [[Memetic Badass]] Varok Saurfang (going by his role as Orgrim's second-in-command), though in the novelization Orgrim's second-in-command is named Tharbek (never seen before or since).
** Unlike [[StarCraft]], which adds snippets of backstory to the players' roles, the retconned identities of the Warcraft ones are the subject of fan speculation.
** ''Warcraft III'' on the other hand never refers to the player commander in-story, and canonically the hero units led their armies on their own.
* Most games in the ''[[Command & Conquer]]'' series use this; however, in ''Tiberian Sun'', you are implied to be either Michael MacNeal or Anton Slavik.
** In the first game, you were supposed to be a "telegeneral", looking over the battlefield and ordering your forces from a computer screen - [[Painting the Fourth Wall|just like playing a real-time strategy game]]. All the [[cutscene]]s, where GDI command, Nod, or Kane hacking GDI videolinks were video communication shown on your screen. Later games moved away from this, and the Commander was actually in the scene.
*** This is actually explicitly shown in ''Renegade'', [[Oddball in the Series|the FPS]]. At one point we see a screen displaying a base as seen in-game with a commando, whereupon you cut to being said commando and the screen goes to full 3D as you actually get onto the battlefield. Throughout the game, you get orders to kill a certain unit or blow up a building, just as you (a player) might do by right-clicking in the RTS.
** ''Tiberian Sun'''s expansion goes back to the non-entity roots: In the GDI campaign, MacNeal is disposed of by way of his aircraft crashing, while in the Nod campaign the player gets his order from Slavik.
** The third game's expansion pack avoids it by giving the player a name and making him  {{spoiler|a Nod AI called LEGION, based off CABAL.}}. of course, [[Robotic Reveal|you don't realize this for a while.]]
*** And since CABAL was [[People Jars|biologically augmented]], it is entirely possible that  {{spoiler|the Non-Entity General is a part of LEGION's hypothetical bioaugmentation.}}
** The FMVs from ''[[Command & Conquer|Red Alert]]'' are seen from the point of view of a specific character, who was infrequently addressed by the others. You are simply referred to as "Commander" (or your current rank, as you get promoted several times in the Soviet campaign) and not given any characterization beyond that and sometimes being referred as male.
** In ''Red Alert 2'', however, the Soviet Commander makes a brief appearance in person when he {{spoiler|confronts General Vladimir in the White House.}}
** When playing Yuri's faction in the ''Red Alert 2'' expansion, Yuri usually reacts to commands given to him, as issued by himself. He even refers to the player as his "exquisite mind". You are, essentially, Yuri's [[Ghost in the Machine]].
** While you never get a name, you, as each different commander, are addressed personally by your aides in all three of the campaigns of ''Generals''; you are also personally [[Power Levels|given promotions to higher rankings]].
** ''[[Command & Conquer: Red Alert 3]]'' [[lampshade]]s it: at the end of the Soviet campaign, your co-commander suggests that they'll rename {{spoiler|New York City}} in your honour: "Commandergrad", suggesting that your non-entity-Commander is actually ''named'' [[His Name Really Is "Barkeep"|Commander".]]
** In general, the Red Alert commanders have an unusual amount of interactions and developments for a character that never appears on screen or gets a name—the Soviet Commander in the first Red Alert nearly gets ''executed'', and may or may not have gotten a promotion to Chairman in the Soviet ending, the Allied Commander in Yuri's Revenge hooks up with [[Mission Control]] for the victory ball...
* ''[[StarCraft]]'''s canon is very confusing in this aspect:
** The Terran commanders from both the vanilla and expansion set campaigns are never shown or referred to outside their playable appearances.
*** As far as canon is concerned this works quite well for the Brood war commander, though not so well for the actual character. As a UED naval captain it is fair to assume they were  {{spoiler|killed in the destruction of the UED fleet}}. The fate of the previous Terran commander is more troublesome, particularly in the starcraft 2 where one is forced to wonder where Raynor's former commanding officer has got to and why they aren't in charge. For those who care about those sort of details however one could theorise that they are {{spoiler|fighting the zerg invasion}} in the fringe worlds and arming colonists. This would tie in neatly with Raynor managing to build an army from very little.
*** It would have made a lot of sense for it to be [[Remember the New Guy?|Matt Horner]], but that's [[Jossed]] by his backstory.
*** Raynor only breifly touched upon what happened to the Colonial Magistrate (the Terran commander from the first game). They apparently parted ways with each other after the events of Brood War and Raynor has not seen him since. Incidently this establishes the only definite canononical fact about any of the generals, the terran commander from the first game was male.
** The Protoss executor from the vanilla campaign is made into an NPC named Artanis in the expansion set, whose executor on the other hand appears as an NPC (Selendis) in ''[[StarCraft II]]''.
** The Zerg cerebrate from the vanilla missions is never shown or referred to. The expansion pack's campaign tries to [[Hand Wave]] why Kerrigan would have a cerebrate working under her, but the background info for the sequel makes it quite clear she never ''did'' have one.
*** The Zerg Cerebrates have also been explained in Retcon. The Starcraft Cerebrate was among those killed by Zeratul during the defense of Aiur, while Kerrigan's Brood War Cerebrate eventually died without the Overmind to sustain it as it was one that was wrestled away from the Overmind's control while the UED held the Overmind captive and was still dependent on it to live.
** ''[[StarCraft II]]'' takes the ''Warcraft III'' route: the player is never referred to and instead simply commands Jim Raynor through his story.
* Inverted in ''[[Fire Emblem]] 7'' (just ''Fire Emblem'' in the US) for the Game Boy Advance. You did in fact have a character represented, a novice tactician who commanded the units and was actually spoken to often. However, your sprite was just a person in a robe, with nothing visible, and you never said anything. You could set your gender, which slightly altered some text (Primarily with [[Chivalrous Pervert]] Sain and [[Does Not Like Men]] Florina) but didn't change the sprite, which was of indeterminate gender. Second playthoughs even give the option of getting rid of this entirely.
* Similarly, in the other Intelligent Systems series that released its first US installment at around the same time, ''[[Advance Wars]]'' cast the player as an advisor that the COs would speak to on occasion. The advisor didn't appear on screen, however. Interestingly, all the factions treat Orange Star's hiring of you as an advisor as some sort of impressive tactical advantage... which makes it weird the whole thing gets dropped from the series in the next installment. (The COs themselves seems to be the "[[Player Character]]" instead.)
** Honestly when is having an ally that [[Save Scumming|can turn back the flow of time in case a battle goes bad]] NOT a major advantage?
** According to Olaf, advisors are sort of like the tactical equivalent of training wheels.
* The ''[[Civilization]]'' games have famous historical figures as leaders that are all inexplicably alive from 6000BC to 2050AD and retain supreme power no matter what revolutions happen within their governments. If Rome overthrows its monarchy in favor of a republic, Julius Caesar is still the all-powerful head of state.
** Supposedly the developers said that you're actually always playing as the latest in the leader's dynasty. So by 2050AD, you're actually Lincoln's great great great great... You get the idea, [[Voodoo Shark|despite "hereditary rule" being in the game as an optional tech thousands of years after the start]].
** Averted in ''[[Sid Meier's Alpha Centauri]]'', Every faction is controlled by single leader for some 600 years, who even have some biography, and all of whom seem to be philosophers or thinkers of a kind (you hear snippets of their works after discovering new technologies, building Secret Projects, etc.). The leader was given life prolongation treatment, and it is even possible to give such a treatment to all your people later in the game.
* An interesting case comes up in ''[[Ultima]] 3''. Later games assure us that the Avatar (main hero) was indeed in that band of 4 characters who defeated Exodus. (Supposedly he was known as "The Stranger.") Yet what class and even species of those 4 is entirely variable and there is no characterization. It's possible to have all 4 characters be species that are not from Earth, or depicted in any other Ultima game.
** ''Ultima 7'' mentions the Avatar's body is materialized from scratch each time he travels to another dimension, with his earth body (the player) being the only constant one. This serves as a catch-all justification for all variations of the Avatar's appearance or stats or virginity between games, as he is reincarnated on each visit. The Avatar is literally the player's [[Avatar]], on top of being a [[Digital Avatar]] and the [[Crystal Dragon Jesus|Avatar of Virtues]].
* Literally the case in the old PC game ''[[Dungeon Master (video game)|Dungeon Master]]'' (not the trope) where "you" are in fact an invisible spirit guiding a group of warriors whom you've resurrected; they do all the grunt work.
* The Keepers in ''[[Dungeon Keeper]]'' are named, though the player's keeper is not, however they all fit the archetype perfectly, as they are non-physical entities.
** Although they do have a physical component, the dungeon keeper's heart, and if it is destroyed they die. And of course, their ability to control their warriors is much more limited than in most RTS, unless they use the ''Possession'' spell to take a first person perspective.
* ''[[Supreme Commander]]'' touches this a fair bit, but does have the commanders as specific characters. When shown outside their ACU, they are shown wearing face-obscuring helmets, although the UEF & Cybran commander is a male, while the Aeon one is clearly female.
** The commanders do receive a degree of implied character development during the campaign-the Cybran commander in particular, during the ending credits of the game, has a great deal of backstory revealed. {{spoiler|He's a clone of Dr. Brackman, the creator of the simbionts and leader of the Cybran Nation.}}
* Aside from offering each race a different Player title (the Tarth "Ubergeneral," the Human "Commander," the Chch't "Hive Imperius," etc.), the ''Deadlock'' turn-based strategy games follow this.
* Averted in the ''[[Stronghold]]'' series, where the [[Hello, Insert Name Here|player can choose a name]] and whether to be male or female. The player has an avatar in-game in the form of a warlord who hangs around the starting area. If the warlord dies, it's game over. In the spin-off ''Stronghold Crusader'', the player can also choose between a Caucasian or Arabic warlord.
** ''Stronghold 2'' will actually greet you in your name if you have a common name that it recognizes. ("Greetings, Sir David!") The game also had a few easter eggs related to this, for instance you could set your name as [[Star Wars|Darth Vader]] and the game will greet you as such.
* ''[[Hostile Waters]]'' refers to you only as Captain, the only living person aboard the ''Antaeus''. As for how were you preserved for the twenty years it spent on the seabed, the ship took one of those little brain chips that you put into vehicles and literally built you a body.
* While you manage a space station in ''[[Startopia]]'', the station's AI, VAL, refers to you as "Administrator" and makes comments that suggest you're a contemporary human (i.e., [[Painting the Fourth Wall|you]]). This may explain why there aren't any humans aboard, but not how you came to be there.
* In ''[[Perimeter]]'', you're a computer AI commander refered to as 'Legate'. After your group splits into three factions, each with mutually exclusive goals, you still command all three, taking turns. Presumably, they just duplicated you.
* ''[[World in Conflict]]'' gives the player a name and rank on both sides (Lt. Parker and Lt.Romanov, respectively) for other officers to address him with, but little else.
** At least in the original ''World in Conflict'', your player character actually has screen presence, despite the fact you never get a clear view of his head you can tell Parker is a white male, and at the end you learn  {{spoiler|the narrator was your character all along looking back at his career.}} Soviet Assault though seems to abandon this for the generic commander role.
* ''[[Panzer General]] II'' addresses the general in the briefing room as an actual person, who is offered smokes, drinks from the samovar, etc. They even talk of rewards for good performances in battle. Additionally, if you check your performance screen (i.e., how many awards you've won), you have a picture of you followed by a randomly generated name.
* ''[[Star Wars]]: Empire at War'' and its expansion both use this, though it is kind of implied that the commander is the Droid Adviser each faction has.
** This goes back to Star Wars: Rebellion as well.
** The fact that the Imperial officer in the tutorial, at least, clearly threatens the player with demotion.
* Speaking of Star Wars, this trope is successfully averted in ''Star Wars: Force Commander'', in which the titular Force Commander, Brenn Tantor, is the player character. As a result, in certain missions, you command yourself - in one instance, your in-game avatar responds to commands as if talking to himself. Plot-irrelevant "skirmish" maps include Brenn as the generic driver of the TR-MB vehicle.
* Taken to a logical conclusion in ''[[Battalion Wars]]'': The Commander you play not only doesn't have a name, but seems to lack a ''body'' as well, instead leaping from one unit on the battlefield to the next. The characters who give you orders seem to acknowledge this, given that they will often [[He Knows About Timed Hits|order you to take control of specific units]] during a mission.
* In ''[[Dwarf Fortress]]'', the player seems to be some sort of omniscient spirit, able to set priorities that all the dwarves instantly recognize. And unlike the dwarves, the player needs no in-game food.
** A common theory is that the player is in fact Armok, the god of blood the gamer refers to in its full title. Given the very creatively brutal ideas the community comes up with, this isn't hard to believe.
* Obscurity of ''[[Sacrifice]]'' would be the only explanation of why it's [[Averted Trope|notable aversion]] (you actually exist on the battlefield itself) wasn't listed on this page before.
* The ''[[Age of Empires (video game)||Age of Empires I]]'' [[All There in the Manual|manual]] describes the player as a sort of guardian spirit to a tribe.
** In [[Age of Empires II]], with the exception of the Saladin and William Wallace campaign, you ''personally'' are just some peasant/monk/young soldier who happened to strike up a conversation with someone who knows a lot about the stories, as seen in the cutscenes. It's the [[Narrator All Along|narrators you have to wonder about]].
*** Most narrators actually do identify themselves and explain why they know what they do. The Mongol narrator mentions he was chosen to record his people’s journey from the moment they decided to leave Mongolia. In Joan d’Arc’s story, it is one of the first soldiers to join her. In Saladin’s, it’s a crusader soldier who was taken prisoner yet allowed a lot of freedom.
*** The expansion, ''The Conquerors'', is a bit better: the El Cid campaign is narrated by his wife at his funeral in Valencia, and El Cid himself appears in every battle, more or less; in the Attila campaign, Attilla is, again, a character on the battlefield; and in the Montezuma campaign, it's implied that you are either Montezuma or his warrior-priest Cuauhtémoc (who narrates). The fourth campaign is a collection of individual historical battles, most but not all of which feature the person you're playing as a character.
* While the original ''[[Dawn of War]]'' was rather... ambiguous as to whether the player character existed or not (just who ''was'' Gabriel talking to in the first mission?), in the ''Dark Crusade'' and ''Soulstorm'' expansions, when selecting an army to play as in the campaign, the player is pretty much told that they are the leader-hero of the faction they control. This is done even more explicitly in ''Dawn of War II'', with the opening [[Cutscene]] referring literally talking to the player and telling them that they are the nameable Force Commander in the game.
* In ''[[Evil Genius]]'' it would be easy to assume the player's role is that of the disembodied [[Austin Powers|Frau Farbissina]]-[[The Baroness|soundalike]] who (very loudly) relays the orders you give, but the tutorial makes clear you are neither her, the Genius or the henchman. [[The Man Behind the Man|Naturally]].
* In ''[[Seven Kingdoms]] 2: The Frythan Wars'' (And possibly the first one) the player does not get any real story. However, the [[Anyone You Know|name entered when creating the profile]] is used as the name of the player's King (All High for non-human factions) unit in game, giving the impression that the player is actually there leading the kingdom. However, getting killed just puts one of your generals in charge.
* Averted (or played with) in ''[[Achron]]''. The game makes a strong distinction between chronal and [[Ripple-Effect-Proof Memory|achronal]] entities. You are the general precisely ''because'' of your achronal nature; which makes a lot of sense since battles in the game are won or lost on the basis of who can out-time-travel his/her opponents.
* While ''[[Heroes of Might and Magic]]'' gave players a choice of four lords to serve as their avatar, its sequel II simply stars some faceless, nameless commander loyal to either of the Ironfists. This same character serves the same role in the Erathia campaigns for Heroes III, alongside a few corresponding blank slates to represent the neutrals, the Nighons, the Deyjans and the Contested Lands. All further Heroes games have since done away with this, instead focusing on individuals and third-person narrative.
* ''[[Sword of the Stars]]'' uses this.
* ''[[Baten Kaitos]]'' makes use of this in an interesting way; you, the player, are an otherworldly soul who shares the heart of the main character. Through this, you get to give input on in-game situations ,although you can make no changes to how the plot plays out. It makes it easier to break the fourth wall when you're just talking to your second soul, instead of asking yourself 'Do I want to jump into the pit of darkness yet?'.
* In ''[[Total War]]'' games, even leaders refer to you as "sir", when they are people like kings or daimyos who technically wouldn't answer to ''anyone''. On the battlefield however there is a general, though he can get his loaf sliced.
* ''[[Valkyria Chronicles]]'', post the first game, is a strange example of this. The squad does have a commander ([[Valkyria Chronicles II|Avan]] or [[Valkyria Chronicles III|Kurt]]) and possibly sub-commanders, but even if all the commanders get Hospitalized from battle, the squad will go on fighting. (This is not true in ''[[VC 1]]'', where it's a game over if Welkin is down). Furthermore, characters will affirm ("Let's fight!", "I'm doing my best!", etc) if given orders in battle, even if the commander (or for that matter, other squad members) is nowhere near them. Subtle [[Survival Mantra]]?
* Generally averted in the campaign of ''[[Rise of Legends]]'', where it's made very clear that "you" are Giacomo, the game's protagonist who always starts missions in the field as a hero unit. It's murkier when Giacomo is destroyed and can be re-summoned, [[Fridge Logic|unless you assume it was only his walker that was destroyed and has to be rebuilt]]. Played straight in skirmish.
* ''Star Reach'' allows to choose between entity and non-entity (traditional RTS) commander modes, the latter is even called "Phantom".

{{reflist}}
[[Category:{{PAGENAME}}]]
[[Category:Strategy Game Tropes]]
[[Category:Video Game Characters]]