×××HOLiC/Headscratchers: Difference between revisions

 

== Watanuki's living situation ==

* The above here. The implication this troper got was that EVERYONE who knew anything about or was in any way connected to the {{spoiler|Li-Kinomoto's}}, or at the very least about Watanuki/ {{spoiler|Syaoran Jr.}}, was mindwiped or given a specific amnesia rewrite that believes he "died in the car accident" or whatever. This Troper is also still pissed that ALL this came about, and Watanuki suffers so much basically because {{spoiler|Clow Reed needed a 10 year old girl to watch over his magical card friends which he'd completely irresponsibly created and loosed on the world}}. That's how many lives you've irreversibly screwed up for your own selfish reasons?

** Er, in Clow's defense, Sakura wasn't just 'watching over' them. If he hadn't set it up so Sakura became their new master, {{spoiler|Keroberos, Yue, and all of the Clow Cards would have faded out of existence, effectively dying.}} The question of 'true altruism' aside, I still wouldn't call attempting to {{spoiler|save the lives of 21 different entities (''54'' in the anime, and 22/55 if you count Yukito)}} 'selfish'. Especially given the implications that the TRC group would be even more screwed than they already are otherwise.

** Okay, so Watanuki kind of {{spoiler|''lied to Doumeki about the true reason he's stuck in the shop'', as he was trapped in the other world and the only way he could've gotten out was by ''paying his freedom''.}}

** But now what I don't get is why Watanuki would {{spoiler|lie about why he is staying in the shop}} in the first place. Sure, it's a really long explanation, but what's to be gained from it? Or did I just miss something?

*** Watanuki lied probably because Doumeki would likely pay a price. If it's Watanuki's choice, then he respects it, but if it was forced, as this was the case, he'd search for something to give on return and hurt himself.

*** This fits the narrative really well so far, but my problem is the same as it was when {{spoiler|he was staying to see Yuko again}}. What pissed me off was that Watanuki spent the series learning about how he should let others help carry his burden. Supposedly. He apparently hit his head and forgot the entire eye incident off screen, as this plot/character point keeps getting drop kicked out a window every time I turn around. It isn't even as though he's sparing his friends of hardship, either. They're going through hell, and not being able to do anything only makes it worse for them.