39,327
edits
m (Mass update links) |
m (Mass update links) |
||
Line 20:
== [[Anime]] and [[Manga]] ==
* [[
* [[Anime News Network]] has a number of reviewers who hate all things [[Moe]] with a burning passion and think it's killing the industry.
** ANN's review of the [[Saiyuki]] anime was apparently done by a guy who hated it for not being [[Shonen]].
Line 29:
== [[Fanfic]] ==
* [[The Nostalgia Critic
== [[Film]] ==
* Critic Peter Bradshaw panned [[Peter Jackson]]'s film trilogy of ''[[The Lord of the Rings (
* Critic Armond White repeatedly trashes of the films of [[Noah Baumbach]], often with personal overtones. In this case the driving force of the [[Bias Steamroller]] seems to be personal: White had previously feuded with film critic Georgia Brown, who was Baumbach's mother. In addition, he has panned every [[Pixar]] movie to come out during his time as a reviewer, often spending half the review complaining about the company itself rather than the film. On the other side of the trope, there seems to be a very short list of directors that Armond will like no matter what: [[Steven Spielberg]], [[Mike Leigh]], [[Wes Anderson]], [[Edgar Wright]], and [[The Coen Brothers]].
** His love for all things Anderson becomes especially interesting when you realize that two of his films that White praised (''[[The Life Aquatic With Steve Zissou]]'' and ''[[The Fantastic Mr. Fox]]'') were co-written by Baumbach.
* [http://filmatheist.com/ The Film Atheist] reviewer gives ''[[
* [[
** He also drives one right over ''[[Doug]]''. This is a totally character reason however, as people confusing him with the main is one of the many reasons why he got so badly bullied at school. Doug the real life person just finds it dull.
** And then there's his problems with [[Matthew Broderick]].
** ''And'' [[Randy Newman]].
* [[
* While [[Love It or Hate It|its certainly up for debate on this matter]], [[Michael Bay]] has been a victim of this many times. While its true that violent explosions, car chases, and [[Ms. Fanservice]]'s are common in his films, he does work to have plot in the films and Character depth at least. However, as far as some people are concerned, if a film has Michael Bay as director, it's nothing but a stupid lowbrow wet dream.
** Similarly, any film staring [[Shia
** And [[Megan Fox]], and [[Live Action Adaptation|films based on a franchise aimed at children]]. Wow, Transformers never had a chance, did it?
Line 52:
== [[Music]] ==
* One of the most notorious examples of a bias steamroller in music criticism is Lester Bangs. A huge fan of free jazz and punk-related rock, if a musician was a virtuoso yet engaged in a genre that was outside of Bangs' tastes (including [[Progressive Rock]], [[
* Christian Clemmensen of Filmtracks towards anything done by a young composer, done in a non-traditional style or done by [[Hans Zimmer]]. He also hates the Oscars and composers like [[Vangelis]] (whom Clemmensen claimed was a one-hit wonder, a major [[Critical Research Failure]] on his part) whom he claims are undeserving Oscar winners.
* Piero Scaruffi's reviews are rather infamous for his seemingly biased (and mostly negative) opinion towards many popular musicians, most notably [[The Beatles]], [[Elvis Presley]], [[Radiohead]] and [[David Bowie]].
* [[Todd in
** In the same video, though, he admits that he does like a few of Chris Brown's songs, and ''wants'' to get past the main reason he hates him (the whole abuse debacle with Rihanna,) but that Chris Brown's [[Small Name, Big Ego|massive ego]] and refusal to truely learn anything from his mistakes won't let him.
** He's also heavily biased against the "White guy with acoustic guitar" genre.
Line 62:
* [[Game FAQs]] reviewers: It's not uncommon to find reviews that merely "This game sucks because it's an [[RPG]]", "This game sucks because it's an [[FPS]]", "This game rules because it's a point and click adventure game", "This game sucks and has shitty graphics", "This game sucks because it's a [[Nintendo]] game", or whatever steamroller that particular poster like to drive.
** Or not to mention, people going in-depth with one bad experience and accentuating that entirely; even if they were blatantly doing something wrong.
* [[Zero Punctuation
** Not to mention his hate for "Modern Shooters", constantly bashing [[Insurmountable Waist-Height Fence|"Chest-high walls"]], regenerating health, macho protagonists and grim & gritty settings.
** Although in general its arguable if he belongs here, since by being biased against EVERYTHING (other than Silent Hill 2, Saints Row and that Spiderman game), it arguably stops being a bias and is more of an [[Unpleasable Critic]] type thing.
** He also goes the other way sometimes; for one thing, he's a rabid [[Valve]] fanboy (to the extent that his rampant cynicism will allow). ''[[Portal (
* Finnish games reviewer and columnist Niko Nirvi once took note of this effect in a column explaining the various ways in which [[Four Point Scale|a review score]] can be affected by outside factors, such as the "Wrong Guy" effect, where the game in question is a sequel to something that the reviewer previously loathed, the Ancestor effect, where the game is made by an established developer, so the score is based entirely on what the reviewer thinks of the developers, or the Genrebonus effect, where the reviewer is a fan of the IP the game is based on ("It's a [[Batman]] game! I love Batman! Have some Bat-points!"). There's also the Critic effect, where the reviewer can't admit to liking anything that isn't independent or artsy, and the exact opposite phenomenon, the Laddie effect.
* GamePro would often disparage an RPG ''because'' it was an RPG or in the case of "politically important" games like ''[[Final Fantasy VIII]]''', heaping a ton of cynicism into their reviews. ("Politically Important" in this case means "The publisher is paying us a lot to advertise in our magazine") This attitude also seeped into their coverage, wherein they would make all sorts of research flaws while making guides and showing other information about games that was blatantly wrong.
** One particularly heinous review for ''Star Trek Voyager: Elite Force'' had the review bashing the related [[Star Trek: Voyager]] television series which had nothing to do with the review, before going on to admit that the game was good despite his bias. One wonders why they didn't have a reviewer who at least had a passing interest in the show review the game based on it.
** Parodied in ''[[Homestuck]]'' by the magazine "Game Bro," whose [http://www.mspaintadventures.com/?s=6&p=001942 review of SBURB], the game at the heart of the plot of the webcomic, was written by someone who didn't even play the game because it isn't a beat-'em-up or skateboarding game.
* ''Game Informer'' tends to flat out trash whatever games are considered "casual" merely on basis of not being "Core" games. This was especially blatant in their review of ''[[Farmville]]'', in which they don't find the game bad on its own merits - they find it bad because it's not like ''[[Mass Effect 2]]''. They've admitted in the past that they have a bias steamroller for whatever they believe their readers' biases are.
** Their review of ''Botkai: The Sun Is In Your Hands'' makes one question whether or not they actually ''played'' the game in question; since the bulk of the review was spent ranting about how the window wouldn't charge their sunlight, how the glare off the Game Boy Advance screen was giving them a headache, and said very little about what the game was actually ''about''. You probably wouldn't even know what ''genre'' of game it is by reading the review.
** Their review of ''[[
** They '''loathe''' the ''[[Mario Party]]'' series. They have never given any of the games in the series a rating higher than 4/10, and whenever they preview a new entry they can barely hide their contempt.
* Noah Antwiler, the maker of ''[[
** On the related note, his friend at [[That Guy With
* [[
* ''[[X
** When ''The Legend of Zelda: Skyward Sword'' won Game of the Year, the hosts said the only reason ''Skyward Sword'' won was because of angry Nintendo fans, and show an air of contempt.
** Occasionally averted in the case of [[RPG|RPGs]]. They seem to like The Elder Scrolls series, having given [[The Elder Scrolls III|Morrowind]], [[The Elder Scrolls IV|Oblivion]], and [[The Elder Scrolls V|Skyrim]] all 5/5 stars.
Line 86:
== [[Western Animation]] ==
* [[
{{reflist}}
|