All The Tropes

Genocide Dilemma: Difference between revisions

Page Discussion

Genocide Dilemma (view source)

Revision as of 14:55, 8 April 2014

138 bytes removed ,  10 years ago
m
Mass update links
VisualWikitext
m (Mass update links)
m (Mass update links)
Line 4:
'''The Doctor''': [[If You Kill Him You Will Be Just Like Him|But if I kill... wipe out a whole intelligent life form, then I become like them. I'd be no better than the Daleks.]] |''[[Doctor Who]]'', "Genesis of the Daleks"}}
 
We all know the drill. It's [[The Federation]] versus [[The Empire]], and the [[Heroes]] stop the Empire's new superweapon just in time for [[The Cavalry]] to defeat the [[Mooks]]. Now good has triumphed, how do you mop up the resistance? If the heroes are lucky, the Empire will be led by a [[Self-Disposing Villain]] or an [[Evil Overlord]] with a [[Zero-Percent Approval Rating]] who can be [[Sealed Evil in Aa Can|imprisoned]] in the [[Tailor-Made Prison]].
 
But what if the driving force behind the forces of evil is not a single [[Big Bad|Evil Overlord]], but a [[Planet of Hats]] whose hat happens to be [[Always Chaotic Evil]]? You can't very well arrest and try every inhabitant. And it will doubtlessly include children, who, if you did try them, would be acquitted because [[Children Are Innocent]]. But as long as enough remain to propagate the species, they will remain a threat.
Line 32:
 
== Film ==
* In the ''[[Alien (Filmfranchise)|Alien]]'' franchise, somebody always seems to want to capture a live xenomorph....
** But only to try to make them into a weapon. Lampshaded in the [[Green Lantern]] Alien crossover, Hal points out that the xenomorphs are just animals, so they move the hive to Lantern Mogo (a living planet) since he can watch them and make sure no one runs into one.
** For understandable reasons, Ripley seems to have no moral reservations on this point:
Line 40:
** The great irony with the Xenomorphs is that they need live hosts in order to spread. One person = one Xenomorph. If people would just leave them alone they wouldn't be a threat.
*** The third film establishes that they can implant other mammals.
* In ''[[Titan AEA.E.]]'', some aliens apparently see [[Humans Are Bastards|humans]] this way. The story ''begins'' with one race making the decision to choose the 'better safe than sorry' route, which is why AE stands for [[After the End|After]] [[Earthshattering Kaboom|Earth]]. Of course, it [[Genocide Backfire|doesn't work out as planned]].
 
 
Line 46:
* [[Keith Laumer]]'s novel ''The Glory Game''. After the warlike alien Hukk are defeated, the Terran Hardliners want to wipe them out to keep them from threatening Earth again.
* ''[[Ender's Game]]'' and its sequels apply this in one way or another to every nonhuman species in the setting. {{spoiler|''None'' of them intended to start hostilities with humanity, and in only one case (when fighting a seemingly sentient virus that wipes out almost every life form it infects) is genocide portrayed as justified. With each species encountered, humanity is more reluctant to kill fellow rational beings, and the final species in ''Children of the Mind'' is dealt with in a completely nonviolent manner.}}
* The Taxxons in ''[[Animorphs (Literature)|Animorphs]]'' are driven by [[Horror Hunger|unceasing hunger]], to the point that if one of them is injured, the others will ''eat its entrails''. They voluntarily joined up with the resident [[Puppeteer Parasite|mind-controlling parasites]] in the (unsuccessful) hopes that this would keep them from killing everything in sight. The issue of whether they need to die {{spoiler|is ultimately sidestepped through a species-wide [[Metamorphosis]]}}.
** A variant: the Hork-Bajir are a peaceful species, but to weaken them as a tool for the Yeerks Alloran decided to genocide them with a Quantum Virus, earning a [[What the Hell, Hero?]] from his own species.
* The ''[[Star Wars]]'' [[New Jedi Order]] series has the Alpha Red virus, which could kill the Yuuzhan Vong and their biotech, but Vergere destroys it because even the Vong have the right to exist, and the good guys would be monsters if they wiped them out. [[Retcon|Or maybe she didn't have complex and noble motives, she was just an]] [[Department of Redundancy Department|evil Sith villain]]. And then they recreate it, but it doesn't go too well.
** Before the Vong, there were the Yevetha, whom Leia wanted to strand on their homeworld and set up an interdiction field for about the next million years. After the Vong, we have the Lost Tribe of the Sith, where Ben even ''says'' [[Would Be Rude to Say Genocide|it's not genocide, it's just destroying the Sith]]. [[Light Is Not Good]] indeed.
* In [[Andre Norton]]'s ''[[Beastmaster (TV)|BeastmasterBeastMaster]]'' cycle, this dilemma is resolved non-genocidally. Humans have defeated a race of Xiks. Xiks are clearly [[Always Chaotic Evil]], but they're [[Joker Immunity|only left reduced to their homeworld and closely watched]]. When Xik spies' actions are revealed to be the cause of a series of disasters, they're hit with civil - legal - action, instead of military.
** {{spoiler|This despite the fact that the Xiks had just destroyed the planet Earth (we were living on other planets too, so it's not as big a deal).}}
* In the last book of [[Anne McCaffrey]]'s ''[[Tower and The Hive]]'' series, humans and Mrdini debate whether it is moral to simply nuke the [[Horde of Alien Locusts|Hivers]] out of existence. Eventually, a [[Deus Ex Machina]] allows them to end the threat without wiping out the entire species.
* In ''[[The Bible (Literature)|The Bible]]'', the Old Testament Hebrews are instructed on various occasions [[Leave No Survivors|to wipe an enemy nation to the last man, woman and child.]] The Israelites sometimes refuse, [[Call It Karma|which comes back to bite them in the ass later.]] It's... a touchy subject.
* L. E. Modesitt Jr. is rather fond of ending his books with this, and the heroes usually end up deciding to [[Shoot the Dog]].
* [[EEE. E. "Doc" Smith]]'s ''[[Skylark Series|Skylark]]'' series ended with ''Skylark DuQuesne'', where Seaton was debating whether he should or even could wipe out the Chlorans. Eventually after much angst he decided to do it, but during the battle he was incapacitated, and DuQuense (who was the main villain through the series, and who had always sworn to kill Seaton if he had the chance) had to take over to finish the job on the Chlorans. He did so without a qualm, and "The man who slew a galaxy looked no different after the deed than he had before".
* Stewart Cowley's ''Terran Trade Authority'' universe features the Laguna Wars - a nasty fight between Earth and mutinous humans who wiped out an alien civilisation centuries before and took over its machines. The adventure is written for children under ten but pulls no punches, especially near the end; when it's discovered that the cargoes the Earth forces were blockading (and which led the Lagunans to mount an ultimately unsuccessful last-ditch attack on Earth) were an antitoxin against a fungal disease in Laguna Nine's atmosphere. The occupation forces arrive to find to their horror that the entire planet has been completely depopulated. It's not total genocide - the industrial centre on Laguna Seven is still intact - but it's bad enough, and all the more horrifying for it being unintentional.
* Subverted in Mike Resnick's book Birthright: The Book of Man. The other 13,042 sentient races in the Galaxy seem to have no moral qualms whatsoever about hunting Humanity to extinction. It's averted only by the fact that Humanity's last survivors - One man and three women - decide to go out with a bang (literally - they commit suicide by blowing up the planet they're on)rather than surrender and be executed. Same result though, I guess.
 
== Live-Action TV ==
* ''[[Babylon Five5]]'':
** The writers [[Writer Cop Out|took the easy way out]] of the Dilgar question by having their sun go nova shortly after the Dilgar War. How convenient. However, the original punishment was that they stranded all the Dilgar on their homeworld without Faster Than Light travel. The RPG tells of a Dilgar colony that avoided their fate, who (justifiably) stay out of galactic politics, but are not known for the horrors of the rest of the species.
** Gets a bit more interesting, however, when it's pointed out the REASON Dilgar went to war was because their sun was going to go supernova.
Line 66:
* ''[[Battlestar Galactica]]'': humans from a Cylon point of view. At the end of the Miniseries, the Cylons agree that they unfortunately can't give up pursuit of the human fleet even though it's left the Colonial solar system behind and just wants to get as far away as possible, because any survivors will inevitably return and seek revenge.
** A more straight example: In the episode "Torn", the Colonial fleet discovers a virus that kills Cylons horribly and doesn't affect humans. Cue big debate about the ethics of intentionally infecting the Cylon Resurrection Ship with it. Despite the inevitability that the Cylons would have found a cure/treatment/ray gun that addressed the disease before being wiped out entirely (given their technological levels), the debate almost immediately leads to a member of the crew taking matters into their own hands to save the Cylons from the minor inconvenience of losing one resurrection ship (read: perceived genocide).
* ''[[Star Trek (Franchise)|Star Trek]]''. Klingons in ''[[Star Trek VI: theThe Undiscovered Country|The Undiscovered Country]]'' were a unique situation. An environmental disaster caused critical damage to their homeworld, which would almost certainly kill billions over the next several decades and probably plunge the Empire into a civil war. All [[The Federation]] had to do was sit back and "Let them die," as Kirk said. Instead the two governments decide to talk peace and mutual disarmament.
* The third season of ''[[Star Trek: Enterprise (TV)|Star Trek Enterprise]]'', with the Xindi being convinced by an alien race that humanity would destroy them in the future, so they tried to avert this by creating a xenocidal weapon. Although the debates tended to center around whether the accusation was true ({{spoiler|it's not}}), and although the inventor of the weapon has his doubts on the morality, averting their own genocide is all the justification the Xindi need to [[Kill All Humans]]. An alternate timeline shows them tracking down human colonies even after Earth has been destroyed. Eventually, the Xindi factions are divided on whether to go through with the plan {{spoiler|and the majority of them join forces with the humans to stop the weapon from being used, including the weapon's inventor who [[Heroic Sacrifice|dies in the process]]}}.
* ''[[Star Trek: theThe Next Generation (TV)|Star Trek the Next Generation]]'': Picard is faced with the option to implant an [[Logic Bomb|impossible problem]] into the Borg's consciousness through a recovered drone. This would cause the entire collective to spiral out of control trying to solve it, and ending them. However, the drone, named Hugh, has developed a sense of identity. Picard ultimately decides to release Hugh back, hoping the spark of individuality will spread through out the Borg.
** Picard's choice pays off for a few hundred of them, but then Data's [[Evil Twin]] Lore takes command of them, as seen in the "Descent" two-parter.
* In ''[[Star Trek: Deep Space Nine (TV)|Star Trek Deep Space Nine]]'', {{spoiler|Section 31, an underground group in Starfleet,}} infects Changelings, leaders of the Dominion, with a virus that kills them - and because of their lifestyle, all Changelings are affected. The Federation discovers the cure, but refuses to hand it to the Dominion {{spoiler|until Odo can convince the Dominion to surrender in exchange for it}}.
** The Dominion itself, when presented with this situation 200 years ago (with the Ecorians), decided to [[Take a Third Option]]: they infected everyone on a planet with a disease that doesn't kill everybody at once, but rather is hereditary, incurable '''and''' can kill the host at any random time. 200 years later, the Ecorians still haven't even ''[[Despair Event Horizon|attempted]]'' to rebuild their society.
* ''[[Stargate SG -1]]'':
** In an alternate history, O'Neill had never met Teal'c, and as a result, Stargate Command attacked his homeworld for this reason.
** Subverted in Season Five, again with O'Neill. Subverted in that he only threatened it, and that he most likely didn't consider the sentient computer virus that had [[Body Snatcher|taken over]] his Second in Command to actually be 'people.'
Line 81:
== Tabletop Games ==
* Task Force Games' ''[[Starfire]]''. The fanatically racist and warlike Rigelian Protectorate was completely wiped out at the end of the Third Interstellar War under the Alliance's "Genocide Decree". The Alliance believed that all Rigelians everywhere had been slain until two planets were found with Rigelian survivors at a low tech level, leading to a quandary about what to do about them.
* ''[[Magic: theThe Gathering]]'''s Phyrexians have this to some extent. While there are a few good ones, and the entire red Phyrexian faction of the last block is the [[Token Good Teammate]] of them (because asking a [[Barbarian Hero|Vulshok]] or a goblin if he wants to take part in the Great Work is likely to [[Badass|result in missing a few parts]]), as long as a drop of Phyrexian oil exists, the Great Work can begin anew.
 
 
Line 91:
** In ''[[Mass Effect 3]]'', at the end of the Rannoch arc, you get a choice between {{spoiler|allowing Legion to upload Reaper code to the geth, rendering them sentient and intelligent (but dooming the quarians in the process), or killing Legion and allowing the quarians to tear the geth apart. Unless you jumped through enough hoops to [[Take a Third Option]]...}}
** In ''[[Mass Effect 3]]'', {{spoiler|the "Destroy the Reapers" ending will also destroy every other artificial intelligence in the galaxy, including the Geth (if they are still alive) and EDI. Even worse, it's also the ''only'' ending that Shepard has a chance of surviving.}}
** In ''[[Mass Effect 2 (Video Game)|Mass Effect 2]]'', during {{spoiler|Legion's}} loyalty mission, you have to choose between destroying {{spoiler|the heretic geth}} once and for all or commiting [[Heel Face Brainwashing]] on them. {{spoiler|Legion}} leaves this decision to Shepard because he can't decide.
* In the ''[[Homeworld (Video Game)|Homeworld]]'' backstory, the player race (Kushans AKA Hiigarans) were an aggressive, expansionistic race that the Taiidans battled and had nearly extinguished. The galactic outcry for mercy was such that they allowed the Kushan to leave and settle on a planet in the galactic rim after swearing to never use/develop [[FTL]] drives. Thousands of years later, the Kushan history is forgotten and their descendants discover the remnants of their original ship. To escape their dying planet, they set about repairing its [[FTL]] drive...
** Also, the Taiidan are treated this way at the end of the first game, and are allowed to live mostly unmolested (save for having their very evil emperor killed).
** In fact, the Hiigarans were so bad that the Bentusi had to interfere in order to stop them from wiping out the Taiidani. The reason the Taiidani kicked out the Hiigarans from the homeworld in the first place was because the Hiigarans have turned the Taiidan homeworld into an unlivable hellhole with orbital bombardment. Furthermore, had the Hiigarans peacefuly given up their hyperdrive core instead of attacking the Bentusi, they still would've had a fleet to defend against the vengeful Taiidani.
* In the sequel to ''[[In FamousInfamous (Videovideo game Gameseries)|In Famous]]'' you spend the game getting enough power to use the RFI to stop The Beast, but it turns out {{spoiler|the RFI kills Conduits and anyone with the Conduit gene instead of just depowering Conduits. And to top it all off, the plague from the first game has grown out of hand and the only way to stop it is to activate the RFI saving humanity, but killing every Conduit, including Cole, or awaken the powers of every Conduit in the world, making them immune to the plague, but killing everyone else in the process. The final choice of the game revolves around choosing between those two choices.}}
* A major plot point in the ''[[War CraftWarcraft]]'' 'verse. After the end of the second war, the leaders of the Alliance were split on what to do with the (at the time [[Always Chaotic Evil]]) surviving Orcs. Stormwind and Lordaeron felt they should be spared, while Stromgarde and Gilneas wanted to execute them. Eventually, the decision to put the Orcs into labour camps in hopes that they could eventually be reeducated into proper members of society was made. This decision led to the latter two nations leaving the Alliance, though Gilneas would eventually rejoin during the fourth war.
** Not just once. The orcs are tricked by [[Eldritch Abomination|Kil'jaeden]] into killing the majority of the Draenei. Several of them are clearly torn, as they know some of the Draenei personally and have a hard time believing them to be the monsters Kil'jaeden claims they are.
* In ''[[Star Control]] 2'' the Ur-Quan have one of these. After being enslaved for thousands of years by malevolent aliens and having to spend decades wired to artificial pain devices to defeat said aliens, they decide that the hat of [[Always Chaotic Evil]] fits ''all'' other species enough to warrant galactic conquest. They split over whether it's better to lock them up or kill them just to be sure.
Line 107:
 
== Webcomics ==
* ''[[The Order of the Stick (Webcomic)|Order of the Stick]]''. After a dragon threatens his family, Vaarsuvius kills the dragon, then briefly revives it so V can cast "Familicide", which kills the dragon's entire, very extended family. Since the entire dragon species only has about 4 family trees, and proliferate very slowly, this may well have doomed the species to extinction. V casting this spell is treated like a major case of [[Jumping Off the Slippery Slope]], regardless of the fact that black dragons are [[Always Chaotic Evil]]. {{spoiler|And now, V has had to wake up to the fact that the concequences were more rather varied and longer-ranged than s/he thought. Much more varied. Welcome to the dilemma in the trope title, V.}}
* Subverted by Eridan in ''[[Homestuck]]''; he hates the terrestrial portion of the Alternian troll population, and claims that he would happily eradicate the lot of them, even commissioning a (land-dwelling) friend of his to build doomsday devices (that unaccountably fail to work). But by the start of the comic, the other trolls have figured that his aquatic-supremacist rantings are all just a cry for attention, and that if Eridan were given a genuine opportunity for genocide, he would pass it up. {{spoiler|Double-subverted when, in the end, Eridan really does flip the hell out, kills several of his fellow trolls, and destroys the Matriorb, the last hope of his species to repopulate.}}
 
Retrieved from "https://allthetropes.org/wiki/Special:MobileDiff/898614"