Nice Job Breaking It, Herod: Difference between revisions

m
clean up
m (update links)
m (clean up)
Line 6:
The [[Big Bad]] has just learned that a child that can defeat him has or will soon be born. The obvious solution to this problem is to [[Screw Destiny]]. Nip this danger in the bud and kill the Infant Hero before he can become any kind of threat. This is the stage where the problems crop up. Either the [[Big Bad]] has no idea who this child actually ''is'', or other characters also aware of this destiny have taken the initiative to [[Moses in the Bulrushes|hide and protect the child]] before the [[Big Bad]] can actually reach him. Or the would-be killer ''thinks'' they've done the deed, but unbeknownst to them, some force or benevolent person intervenes and child is actually [[Not Quite Dead]]. Whatever the mechanism, the upshot is that [[You Can't Fight Fate]].
 
Often the only thing to do in cases where they can't identify the child is to attempt to track down the newborn hero, baby-by-baby if necessary. The [[Big Bad]] will investigate or, if impatient, simply kill any child in the proper age range to attempt to secure his safety -- thissafety—this may result in a [[Childless Dystopia]] if he's thorough enough. Inevitably, [[Infant Immortality|it never works]], and if [[Children Are Innocent|innocent children]] ''are'' killed, the resultant crossing of the [[Moral Event Horizon]] makes clear just how [[Complete Monster|complete a monster]] the villain is - and of course [[Laser-Guided Karma|karmically]] [[Karmic Death|seals their fate]]. Worse yet, this act often directly ''[[Genocide Backfire|backfires]]'', giving the hunted newborn [[The Unchosen One|a reason beyond mere prophecy]] to go after the [[Big Bad]] after he's grown up enough to take him on; see [[Self-Fulfilling Prophecy]].
 
This being a form of [[Villain Ball]], it almost ''never'' occurs to anyone that a wiser thought might be to try to find and raise the child himself. Though you might occasionally see it among the more [[Genre Savvy]] villains, who take the view that the kid might love him too much to finish him or, in the worst case scenario, will be close at hand if he ''does'' [[Heel Face Turn]]. This often doesn't work either, though, and is irrelevant if the prophecy is that the child ''will'' defeat him.
Line 20:
== Anime and Manga ==
* ''[[One Piece]]'' revealed that the government went on a newborn hunt trying to find the unborn baby of {{spoiler|Gold Roger.}} The baby's [[Mama Bear]] protected her child ''[[Longest Pregnancy Ever|by staying pregnant for twenty months]]'' so the child could not be associated with his father.
* An interesting variant in ''[[Elfen Lied]]'' -- the—the antagonists actively seek out and imprison [[Person of Mass Destruction|diclonii]] as they're born. Their primary approach is to visit hospitals daily and inspect the nurseries, looking for horns. If one is found, they then make every effort to persuade the unlucky parents into giving up the infant, and if that fails, they take it by force [[Paranoia Fuel|with the assistance of hospital security]]. {{spoiler|Then they go on to enslave and torture the children and, down the line, are surprised when they turn out twisted and angry.}}
* ''[[Scrapped Princess]]''. Legends speak of a royal princess who will destroy the world. When she is born, the [[Crystal Dragon Jesus|Church of Mauser]] throws her off a cliff. {{spoiler|The queen arranges for someone to catch her.}}
* The main villain of ''[[Mugen Densetsu Takamagahara Dream Saga|Mugen Densetsu Takamagahara: Dream Saga]]'' actually does think of raising the kid himself. He just picked up all the kids it could have been and killed them when they proved not to be the one.
Line 36:
 
== Fairy Tales ==
* In "[http://www.surlalunefairytales.com/authors/jacobs/english/fishring.html The Fish and the Ring]", "[http://www.surlalunefairytales.com/russian/russianwondertales/vasiliiunlucky.html Vasilii the Unlucky]", "[http://www.surlalunefairytales.com/authors/grimms/29devilgoldhairs.html The Devil With the Three Golden Hairs]", "[http://www.mythfolklore.net/andrewlang/260.htm The King Who Would Be Stronger Than Fate]", and many other fairy tales, a man who discovers finds his child [[Self Fulfilling Prophecies|doomed]] to marry a poor child starts by trying to kill the infant. When he learns that the child has grown up, he tries to kill them with [[Impossible Task|Impossible Tasks]]s, before and after the wedding; in the end, he fails.
* The Queen in "[[Snow White and The Seven Dwarfs (novel)|Snow White]]" may be the most memorable example of this trope. She had little trouble finding the infant Snow White in the first place, but the kindly huntsman who spares Snow White's life and the Queen's ultimate downfall fully adhere to the trope.
 
Line 69:
** Zeus himself was worried about being overthrown by his children. When it was predicted that if his lover Metis bore a son he would be overthrown, Zeus tricked Metis into transforming into a fly and swallowed her. Metis took up residence in Zeus' head, hammering armor for her future child, giving Zeus terrible headaches. Metis' child eventually was born, emerging full-grown and clad in armor [[Body Horror|from Zeus' head]], not a god but the [[No Man of Woman Born|goddess]] Athena.
*** In another version, Zeus was told that the off-spring of Zeus and Metis would be far more powerful than her father. And indeed, Athena ''[[Your Mileage May Vary|was]]'' more powerful than Zeus - but she was also totally loyal to her father and wouldn't dream of overthrowing him.
**** Zeus was perhaps right to fear, but could've been more [[Genre Savvy]] by now, since it runs in the family. Before Cronus, his father Uranus feared an overthrow, and had children capable of doing it sent to Tartarus. Unfortunately, they were all their mother's favorites, and Gaia sent Cronus to take revenge -- Uranusrevenge—Uranus's castration was [[Mama Bear|probably]] [[Woman Scorned|her]] [[Cool and Unusual Punishment|idea]].
** Oedipus' parents tried to kill him as an infant due to the Oracle's prophesy that he would murder his father and bed his mother. Unfortunately for them, he got rescued by royals of a neighboring city-state. And so we have the [[Oedipus Complex]]...
*** Paris was also prophesied to cause the downfall of the kingdom and the death of his father. They pulled the same "we couldn't bear to kill him, let's just leave him to die/be found and brought up by a poor shepherd" that they did with Oedipus. This led to him being handy when Athena, Hera, and Aphrodite needed a judge for a beauty contest. Each goddess tried bribing Paris differently, with Aphrodite promising him the most beautiful woman in the world if he chose her, and the rest is history (or, you know, mythology).
Line 77:
** In a subversion, Zeus manages to avert this fate by learning that a certain goddess's (Thetis) child will become more powerful than his father, and proceeds to very carefully ''not'' sleep with her. He wound up arranging her marriage to a mortal. The son? Achilles.
*** ... which is the Greatest Miracle Ever Performed in Greek Mythology. Slightly marred by the whole golden apple incident at the wedding, though. Eris probably wasn't very popular with the rest of Olympus for a while afterwards.
** Yet another time when Zeus was enough of a [[Magnificent Bastard]] to actually be successful in pulling off this maneuver was the case of Typhon. Gaia had supported Cronus in his uprising against his father Uranus, and then Cronus had proceeded to treat his own sons and daughters just as badly -- sobadly—so that Zeus had had to rebel against Cronus the same way. To Gaia, it seemed as if this was just another turn in the cycle of revenge and patricide, so she decided to give birth to a creature who was supposed to defeat Zeus in just the same way as Zeus had done for Cronus and Cronus had done for Uranus. This was the dragon Typhon, and it appeared to be a brutal creature with no redeeming qualities, much like the giants and cyclopes of Uranus's day. But Zeus was able to win his battle against Typhon, thus allowing himself to break the cycle of one tyrant replacing another -- foranother—for in this case, Typhon would surely have been worse than the god it replaced, not better.
** Typhon wasn't the last time. Gaia later attempted the same trick by giving birth to the Giants, snake legged creatures which could not be defeated by gods. Fortunately, Zeus and the others had enough of a warning to start getting hot and heavy with mortal women. By the time the Giants got born, they managed to breed Heracles, who was powerful enough to turn the tide.
** It is kind of averted at the end of the Trojan War. Astyanax, the infant son of Hector, is thrown from the walls of Troy so that he won't live to avenge his father's death. [[The Extremist Was Right|It worked]]. Of course, there was no prophecy involved, but the Greeks probably figured they couldn't be too careful.
Line 91:
** An interesting little [[Word of God]] statement mentions that this royally pissed off [[Big Bad]] Ishamael badly enough that he messily killed the head of the Black Ajah at the time.
* A large part of the prequels to [[David Eddings]]' ''[[Belgariad]]'' deals with Polgara's task of safeguarding the line of young Rivan kings from Torak's assassins. In the main story, Asharak gets the full treatment, as Garion enacts a [[Death by Irony|very specific form of revenge]] upon him for the deaths of his parents.
** This is touched off by an earlier [[Nice Job Breaking It, Herod]] when Torak sent assassins to eliminate the Rivan royal family. Polgara's charges are the descendants of the one son who inevitably escaped the slaughter.
* "Heroics For Beginners" mentions a villain who succeeded to the throne of a kingdom by slaughtering the rightful ruler, his wife, their children, and so on. The catch was he couldn't get all of the children -- evenchildren—even though he'd been wise enough to schedule an assault on ''every potential heir and his or her family''. Amazingly, the villain was [[Genre Savvy]] enough to '''not''' attempt to [[Nice Job Breaking It, Herod|break it]]; not because he didn't want the successors dead, but because if he did kill everyone in the necessary age groups -- teenagersgroups—teenagers and under -- heunder—he'd cripple the country's economy down the road. Instead, he went [[Properly Paranoid|psychotically paranoid and ended up locking himself in a nigh-inaccessible room.]]
* ''[[The Chronicles of Narnia|The Horse and his Boy]]'': The corrupt official Lord Bar in King Lune's court in Archenland learned of the prophecy that one of the twin newborn princes would someday save Archenland from the greatest danger that would ever threaten it. Even though Bar had no idea what this danger would be, on the off-chance it would be something he would cause, he decided to try to get said prince out of the way just to be on the safe side. Too bad for him Aslan was watching over things...
* Let's not forget [[Macbeth]] (the [[William Shakespeare|Shakespeare]] version): Because the witches have told him that the offspring of Banquo will be kings, [[Macbeth]] decides it's a good idea to have Banquo and son murdered. The murderers kill Banquo, but naturally screw up the ''important'' part of the job. It's a ''variation'' on the trope, because [[Macbeth]] is not killed or overcome by Fleance, but his descendants later fulfilled the prophecy (at least according to the erroneous genealogies of Shakespeare's time).
Line 139:
{{quote|'''Moist''': There's a kid in Iowa grows up to become President. That'd be big.
'''Billy''': I'm not gonna kill a little kid. }}
* The [[Additional Evil Overlord List Cellblock B]] has some advice to [[Big Bad|Big Bads]]s on how to deal with such prophecies.
{{quote|''If I hear about a prophecy or prophecies that state that a child will be born in a certain place with a birthmark or some other sign who will bring about my downfall, I will not immediately send troops to kill the child and its entire family. Instead, I will wait until the child is about five, while keeping it under surveillance, and then have it kidnapped and killed. Once this is done, I will bury the body in a careful location so the body does not get eaten by wild beasts, resurrected by the good guys or wash up on some foreign shore. And for everyone's sake, I will make sure that the child is actually dead, instead if just stabbing it once or suffocating it. Bullets are very helpful, especially fifty-fold.''}}
 
 
== Western Animation ==
* ''[[Avatar: The Last Airbender]]'' -- After—After Avatar Roku died, Sozin knew the next one would be an Airbender, so he had them wiped out... and ''still'' failed to kill the right one.
** To their credit, the Fire Nation realized fairly quickly they missed Aang, and spent a century trying to track him down. (Most of them got much less concerned as the years went by and the Avatar never showed up.)
** Also, there's the Fire Nation's campaign of capturing and exterminating waterbenders of the Southern Water Tribe. (The exact reasons for this are not explained, though [[Wild Mass Guessing|theories]] abound that they were trying to stop another Avatar and/or wipe out resistence.) They missed Katara, who went on to train Aang and play a part in their downfall.
10,856

edits