Shana Clone: Difference between revisions

m
clean up
m (clean up)
Line 1:
{{trope}}
[[File:TsundereM10_5194TsundereM10 5194.jpg|frame|<small>Clockwise from top left: [[Toradora!|Taiga]], [[Lotte no Omocha|Lotte]], [[MM!|Mio]], [[Zero no Tsukaima|Louise]], [[Gosick|Victorique]], [[Hidan no Aria|Aria]]. Center: [[Shakugan no Shana|Shana]].</small> ]]
 
{{quote|''Urusai! Urusai! Urusai!!!'' (Shut up! Shut up! Shut up!)|'''[[Catch Phrase|Everyone on this page]]'''}}
 
The [['''Shana Clone]]''' is a character archetype originating in Japanese [[Light Novel|Light Novels]]s, [[Manga]] and their [[Anime]] adaptations, begun by the popularity of the character [[Fountain of Expies|Shana]] from the [[Light Novel]] series ''[[Shakugan no Shana]]''.
 
The Shana Character Archetype includes the following:
* The character is a teenage girl, though sometimes younger, with an often childlike body-type, meaning she is [[Pettanko|flat-chested]] and usually [[Older Than She Looks]] (typically by being quite short in stature), often resulting in [[Mistaken Age]], a [[Napoleon Complex]] and [[A-Cup Angst]].
* The character has long, ''at least'' waist-length [[Rapunzel Hair]], usually unkempt or tied into [[Twin Tails]]. The actual color is less important, but [[Hair of Gold|blond]], [[Rose-Haired Girl|pink]] or [[Fiery Redhead|red]] are the most common.
* The character wears dresses, usually [[Joshikousei]], or long [[Elegant Gothic Lolita]] style dresses (the latter probably inspired by [[Gosick|Victorique]] and [[Rozen Maiden|Shinku]]), and [[Zettai Ryouiki]] at ''Grade A'', often qualifying for ''Grade S'',<ref>In fact, the "Grade S" classification of [[Zettai Ryouiki]] is based on a similar concept to this trope</ref>, though that requires only any [[Twin Tails]], and any kind of Tsundere behavior. Also note that the ''Grade S'' classification was popularized by [[Fate/stay night|Rin Tohsaka, who doesn't fall under this trope]], though if her dress is a long one, it may be difficult to identify the grade and my simply appear to be full tights.
* The character is a heavily Type A [[Tsundere]], infamous for her use of the [[Abuse Is Okay When Its Female On Male|Violent Approach]]. She physically assaults her [[Love Interest]] on a regular basis, sometimes with little to no provocation. To some extent this attitude may stem from a [[Hair-Trigger Temper]] and [[No Social Skills|awkward social skills with boys]], but hers is also often a result of an [[Tiny Tyrannical Girl|inherently dominant, bossy personality]], almost to the point of evoking the attitude of a [[Dominatrix]].
* The character is the female lead of the work, and the main [[Love Interest]] of the male lead, their relationship heavy on the [[Belligerent Sexual Tension]] and [[Cannot Spit It Out]]. Often there is a [[Supporting Harem]] of other girls as rivals.
 
Though perhaps not the actual [[Trope Maker]], Shana certainly [[Trope Codifier|popularized]] this specific combination of characteristics and they are becoming an extremely common archetype, especially in [[Light Novel|Light Novels]]s. This series of characters even had direct [[Shout-Out|shout outs]] to the original, effectively identifying them as [[Expy|Expies]] of Shana, but then came some ''other'', indirectly related characters following the formula, resulting in the formation of a whole new archetype rather than a collection of Expies, in much the same way as the [[Rei Ayanami Expy]] came to be.
 
Adding to the archetype are a number of more 'optional' traits which have come to be associated with these characters, some of which did not originate with Shana herself:
Line 31:
* Before Shana, this archetype was preceded by Kotetsu from [[The Adventures Of Kotetsu]].
* [[Trope Namer|Shana]] is the [[Fiery Redhead]] [[Action Girl]] who made this archetype famous in ''[[Shakugan no Shana]]''. The rousing success of Her performance has since inspired many writers to imitate or outright copy her personality, [[Fountain of Expies|as seen in the following examples]]. Rie Kugimiya point: 1
* Shinku from ''[[Rozen Maiden]]'' could be considered the [[Ur Example]]. She's (even) smaller than the other girls on this list--[[Justified]] by her being, well, [[Captain Obvious|a doll]]--but—but she has [[Pettanko|the same proportions]] and [[Twin Tails|hair]], and while she's not conscious of her body like later examples, she otherwise retains most of the typical personality attributes; she is bossy and abusive to Jun and basically takes over his domestic life (this despite his technically being her master), but deeply cares about him as more than just her medium. It's unclear whether she is romantically interested, but Suiseiseki (who definitely is) recognizes that [[First Girl Wins|she shares the closest bond with him]] out of [[Unwanted Harem|all the dolls]].
* ''[[Hayate the Combat Butler]]'': Nagi Sanzenin shows all the signs except for being slightly friendlier to her [[Love Interest]], making him into her toy with [[Dragged Into Drag|crossdressing cosplay]] and having him be her [[Knight in Shining Armor]]. Rie Kugimiya point: 2
* Aisaka Taiga from ''[[Toradora!]]'', though her story is more of a [[Love Dodecahedron]] [[Dramedy]] than a typical [[Harem Series]]. Rie Kugimiya point: 3
Line 40:
* Mio, from [[Author Existence Failure|the late, lamented]] ''[[MM!]]'', who is only different from most other examples in that she is tied in a [[Balanced Harem]] with her main rival, not a clear lead character.
* Victorique from ''[[Gosick]]'' who more of a reserved version of [[Tsundere]] and is not violent in general but is incredibly bossy and has been known to kick her [[Love Interest]] or smack him if he defies her. She has the long blond hair, tights, body-type and is partial to sweets. She is more directly based off of [[Rozen Maiden|Shinku]], who herself is an [[Ur Example]].
** She's a rare hybrid of both the [[Shana Clone]] and [[Rei Ayanami Expy]].
* Mina from ''[[Dance in the Vampire Bund]]'' has all theses traits, except she's more of a type-B tsundere.
* ''[[Mahou Sensei Negima]]'': Evangeline Athanasia Katherine McDowell -- aMcDowell—a [[Rapunzel Hair|long-haired]] [[Elegant Gothic Lolita]], stuck in a 10 year old body, often wearing [[Zettai Ryouiki]], very strong type A [[Tsundere]]. She compliments Negi twice in 300 chapters, and usually tortures him via [[Training From Hell]]. Any hint of her ''dere'' side is quickly called out by Chachamaru and followed by a fast "I do not!".
** However, ''Negima'' started only half a year after the Shana novels started, so this one may just be a coincidence.
** Also, Anna Yurievna Cocolova, 11 years old [[Twin Tails|twin-tailed]] [[Tsundere]], a [[Playing with Fire|literal]] [[Fiery Redhead]]. While on a [[First-Name Basis]] with Negi, she is still very violent when it comes to things concerning her [[Love Interest]]: her first appearance since chapter 1 (in chapter 170) is to deliver [[Calling Your Attacks|Anya Flame Kick]] to Negi for not coming home.
10,856

edits