Shoo Out the New Guy: Difference between revisions
Content deleted Content added
m categories and general cleanup |
m Mass update links |
||
Line 1:
{{trope}}
[[File:the_poochie_chainsawsuit_2451.png|link=Chainsawsuit
{{quote|''"[[But Now I Must Go|I have to go now]]. My planet needs me."''|'''Poochie''', ''[[The Simpsons]]'' [[hottip:Note:Poochie [[Bus Crash|died on the way to his home planet.]]}}
A character is introduced into a show with a lot of fanfare, and almost at once moves up to main character status (if not necessarily the credits). He/she will often form a close relationship with the existing main characters, and may even have a prior history with a main character, even if this has [[Remember the New Guy?|never been mentioned before]]. Sometimes the character is a result of [[Executive Meddling]].
For some reason, the character doesn't gel. Maybe [[The Scrappy|the audience takes against him/her]], maybe the actor [[Large Ham|over-]] or [[Dull Surprise|underperforms]], maybe the writers realize they have no idea what to do with him/her. Whatever it is, the character will end up [[Put
Different from [[Chuck Cunningham Syndrome]] in that the character's disappearance will be explained, even if in a fairly flimsy manner.
The easiest way to tell if it's this trope is if the character is written out in a clumsy manner -- if their [[Put
Compare with [[Aborted Arc]] and [[Chuck Cunningham Syndrome]]. Contrast with [[The Artifact]].
Line 16:
== Anime and Manga ==
* In the Orange Islands saga of the ''[[Pokémon (
== Comic Books ==
* ''[[Justice Society of America]]'' had Magog, who joined the cast when Alex Ross was allowed to collaborate with Geoff Johns on his own "Kingdom Come" sequel. Magog made a huge splash, was subject to a MASSIVE multi-part storyline and ultimately given both his own comic book AND his own spin-off JSA team book! But fans didn't take to him and not only was his comic canceled, but he was killed off in the pages of "Justice League: Generation Lost".
* Maggott and Marrow in ''[[X
* Likewise, the sister book ''[[New Mutants]]'' had Rusty Collins and Skids, who were added to the book as part of a group of kids called the X-Terminators. While initially important, they were [[Trapped
** Rusty was later killed in a crossover event. Skids, however, is alive and well and working as a S.H.I.E.L.D. agent!
* Jeph Loeb's run on ''[[The Ultimates]]'' managed to have no less than three of these: Black Panther, Ka-zar, and Shanna. All were introduced and removed in the same arc, without even doing anything significant to the plot, due to backlash from before the story was even published.
* Thunderfox fron [[Femforce]] was introduced with much fanfare, but only appeared in eight issues before disappearing. The explanation occured five issues after her last appearance, telling us that her 'book' was cancelled.
* In [[Red Hood and
== Film ==
* Jar Jar Binks is an infamous failed attempt at [[Kid Appeal Character|pandering to kids]] in ''[[Star Wars]]: [[The Phantom Menace]]''. Thankfully, [[George Lucas]] took the hint and severely reduced his screentime in the following prequels. Nowadays, he usually only shows up as [[Take That Scrappy|the butt of cheap jokes]]; and even ''[[Star Wars:
== Literature ==
* The [[Star Wars Expanded Universe]] gave us Callista, a [[Mary Sue]] girlfriend for Luke who was quickly written out. She later came back, assimilated by Abeloth.
* ''[[Twilight (
== Live Action TV ==
* ''[[
* Several characters in ''[[The OC]]'' suffered this, but Lindsay Gardner was an especially glaring example, as she was introduced as a love interest for Ryan and turned out to be a blood relative of three other main characters. She didn't even return for {{spoiler|Caleb's funeral}}, despite discovering {{spoiler|he was her real father}}.
* Likewise in ''[[
** In fact, ''[[
* ''[[Thats Life]]'' (the American dramedy, not the British consumer protection show) featured a variation with one of the original cast as being shooed out: Candy Cooper, one of the protagonist's best friends, was written out half-way through the first season.
* Megan Donner of ''[[CSI: Miami]]'' had the same fate.
Line 50:
* In ''[[Scrubs]]'', Julie Miller was [[Chuck Cunningham Syndrome|Brother Chucked]] after the writers realized that she was a Dr. Cox [[Distaff Counterpart]], but with the key difference of not having any redeeming qualities, and his ex-wife Jordan already having that position, therefore making her a completely superfluous character.
* The Applewhite family from season 2 of ''[[Desperate Housewives]]'', and Kayla Scavo from season 4.
** A better example would have to be Ana from season six. For some time, there was quite some buzz over her entrance, only for her to be reviled by many fans on message boards. She eventually got [[Put
* ''[[The Muppet Show]]'' had Fleet Scribbler, tabloid journalist. One show, a few mentions later, and he vanished. The critics loved him. The writers hated him.
* ''[[Just Shoot Me]]'' had Vicki Costa, a brash hairdresser whom Jack brought in to help make the magazine hipper. Everyone else's story lines were sidetracked to revolve around her -- Jack immediately respects her, Elliot immediately falls for her, Nina feels threatened by her, Finch thinks she's really hot, and Maya is obsessed with getting Vikki to open up to her. All the while, Vikki's too cool to really participate in the plot and usually has to be pursued by the other characters. It's been suggested by somewhat dubious sources that forcing her character into the cast was an aggressive attempt by executives to give Rena Sofer a star vehicle. Ratings plummeted after her introduction, she barely lasted half a season, and they didn't even air her farewell episode.
* Nikki and Paulo from ''[[Lost]]'' were suddenly introduced in the third season as regular characters. The idea was to shine a light on what was happening with some of the other survivors who were not main characters. The characters were written to be somewhat unsympathetic at first to give them an arc, much like many of the other main characters. However, [[The Scrappy|fans didn't like the new characters]], nor the artificiality of their sudden inclusion. Luckily, the writers had sensed the incoming backlash and "scrapped" the idea, chosing to give them a gruesome death in a single [[Character Focus|character-centric]] episode. Happy now, Losties?
* West in ''[[Heroes (TV series)|Heroes]]''. His much-trumpeted relationship with Claire ended in the final episode of Series 2, leaving a way for him to be left out in the future because he was [[The Scrappy|poorly received by fans]]. The show's creator has stated in an interview that one of the mistakes he made with this series was writing the romance badly.
** West did, however, appear in the graphic novels that run concurrent to the television show, as {{spoiler|one of the freedom fighters working with Rebel}}. He's not nearly as annoying when he's not around Claire, but he did not reappear on the show.
*** Or maybe it was because it was a comic. The role may have been miscast.
Line 61:
** Monica Dawson was written out the same time West was and was equally hated.
** DL could count seeing as he wasn't introduced until episode 5. He was killed offscreen in possibly the lamest way possible. (Niki developing a THIRD personality WHICH IS NEVER SEEN AGAIN)
* Tori on ''[[Saved
** This is a zig-zag. The final season had its episode count doubled very shortly before shooting, and Thiessen (and Elizabeth Berkeley) refused to sign a new contract for the extra episodes.
* After the death of James Beck (Private Walker), ''[[Dad's Army
* Lauren Graham played efficiency expert Andrea for a few episodes of ''[[News Radio]]''. With [[Writer Revolt|that writing staff]], the character was probably doomed to begin with. One story has it that Andrea was introduced as a potential replacement for Khandi Alexander's Catherine Duke. After a few episodes, Graham got cold feet about joining the cast when another well-liked actress was being pushed out. Sadly, Catherine was written out anyway.
* The Ferrera family on ''[[Eastenders]]'' was introduced to compensate for the lack of South Asian characters on the show. They were introduced with a great deal of hype, but became immensely unpopular despite at least one storyline that threatened to elevate them to [[Spotlight-Stealing Squad]] status. Viewers complained that these characters were deathly boring and the writers [[Did Not Do the Research]] into the Ferreras' ethnic background. Finally, one actor had to leave the show because of problems with his permit to work in the UK, and the rest of the family was then written out due to their unpopularity.
* Sadie from ''[[
** Doc in season 2. It seems that the only reason he {{spoiler|died from [[Soap Opera Disease]]}} was simply because the writers didn't want to deal with him anymore.
* Cousin Pam on ''[[The Cosby Show]]''.
** Cousin Pam deserves special mention because she managed to bring in her rather shrill friend Charmaine and Charmaine's even more annoying boyfriend Lance, both of who embodied the very [[Uncle Tomfoolery]] that [[The Cosby Show]] was meant to subvert.
* [[Supergirl|Kara]] of ''[[Smallville]]'' is a "writers didn't know what to do with her" version. She was an interesting side character for about five episodes, then bigger and better ways are found of keeping her out of things. She spends a great deal of time wandering with amnesia, returns fully for an episode or two before it's revealed that {{spoiler|Brainiac is impersonating her and has her trapped in the Phantom Zone. When Brainiac is defeated, she is not freed}} and the show goes on without her as normal. She finally does come back for one episode before deciding at the end, "Hey, I'll just fly into space in a random direction and hope I run into some other Kryptonians." She was never seen or mentioned again to date.
** However, {{spoiler|they did bring her back in season 10, though this might be a case of a season-long [[Back for
** Also from ''[[Smallville]]'': Lex Luthor's long lost half-brother Lucas from season two. He appeared in one episode (which was almost ''painfuly'' bad) and was immediately [[Put
** Lana Lang's real father was revealed to be Henry Small in Season 2. They managed to get along with each other, and Henry appeared ([[Trapped
* The second season of ''[[
** He was seen putting a For Sale sign up in the season 2 finale. He didn't much care to be around witches and warlocks. Being turned into an 80 year old man (albeit temporarly) can do that to a guy.
* ''[[Community]]'' mocks this mercilessly with Jack Black's appearance as "Buddy", a student who has allegedly been in the gang's Spanish 101 class this entire time. The entire main cast are either weirded out by his sudden, unexplained appearance in their lives or convinced he's a murderous psycho. {{spoiler|The episode ends with Owen Wilson suddenly appearing and offering Buddy a spot in the "[[Informed Ability|cool]]" clique.}}
* ''[[Doctor Who]]'' had one early in its long run. In the fourth and final part of ''The Myth Makers'' (set during the Trojan War), a Trojan handmaiden named Katarina snuck on board the TARDIS and became the First Doctor's latest companion. She was promptly killed off in the following adventure, the 12 part epic, ''The Daleks' Master Plan''...in part four. According to the actress who played Katerina, her death scene was ''the very first scene she was filmed in''. This means that the writers created the character, tried her out, decided she wasn't working, and [[Dropped a Bridge
** Kamelion, a shape-changing robot who joined the Fifth Doctor and his companions on board the TARDIS. Kamelion was an actual [[Real Life]] robot...built by a guy who promptly died without telling anybody how to operate the blasted thing. Technically, Kamelion was a companion for nearly a full year. In practice, he only showed up in 2 adventures, the one where he came onboard the TARDIS and the one where the writers said, "Enough's enough," and [[Dropped a Bridge
* Josie Sutton on ''[[
* ''[[Married...
* Marcus from ''[[The Suite Life On Deck]]'', a former hip-hop star who came to the ship to try and live a (fairly) normal life, was introduced to the series with a decent amount of fanfare, quickly receiving a [[Promotion to Opening Titles]] and becoming a [[Regular Character]] soon after. He left the show a season later to become one half of a ''[[Pair of Kings]]''
* Lana Sheilds on ''[[
* ''[[Degrassi the Next Generation]]'' introduced multiple short-lived New Guys between Seasons 7 and 8. Thankfully as it's a school characters vanishing from the center stage is easily handwaved away.
** Season 7 gave us Damian who started off as Manny's love interest, quickly became Emma's love interest, then quickly became Liberty's love interest. And at the end of the season he's gone because he graduated... and all three girls want nothing to do with him.
** Kelly, Leia, and Blue in season 8. Kelly was the cool stoner roommate for Manny, Emma, and Liberty. Quickly put in a love triangle with Manny and Emma, then became Emma's new romance. He's never seen again after he breaks up with Emma in Season 9. Leia and Blue were never fleshed out, Leia's a pathological liar trying to fit in and Blue is a tall dreamy artist who can net himself any girl he wants. When Blue and Holly J don't work out, Blue slowly fades into the background. Leia appears for two episodes in Season 10, but after that she's dropped from the credits.
* ''[[Star Trek: Deep Space Nine
* An odd example from ''[[Merlin (TV series)|Merlin]]'': in the first episode of season two a new knight called "Sir Geraint" in the credits was introduced, who seemed to function as Arthur's second-in-command and was given several promotional shots. He was never seen after the first episode, possibly because the ''second'' episode introduced... [[Ensemble Darkhorse|Sir Leon!]]
* ''[[Whos the Boss]]'': During the fall of 1990, a [[Cousin Oliver|cute kid]] named Billy (Jonathan Halyalkar) briefly joins the Miceli-Bower household, purportedly as a comic foil to Tony Danza's male lead character; the idea was that Billy's parents had died several months earlier in a car accident, and that Tony (both he and Billy were from the same Bronx neighborhood) would be the perfect person to raise him. Although a promising actor, Halyalkar had problems meshing with the cast (according to Katherine Helmond in a series retrospective that aired on E!), plus he came off as annoying to audiences. By the end of the season, Billy had gone to live with a new foster family, and he was retconned out of existance.
* ''[[Buffy the Vampire Slayer]]'' had Riley Finn, introduced in season 4 to be Buffy's new love interest after ''[[Angel]]'' got his own series. He was never really accepted by the fans, and got written out again in season 5.
* ''[[Law and Order Special Victims Unit|Law & Order SVU]]'' added Kim Greylek in Season 10 to replace the disbarred Casey Novak. Her cold demeanor didn't win over fans so after 15 episodes she was quickly booted and replaced with the returning Alex Cabot.
* ''[[Dallas]]'' had an interesting case with Jack Ewing, played by Dack Rambo. He was brought in near the end of season 7 to replace the departing Patrick Duffy. He had a major roll in the [[All Just a Dream]] season 8. When Duffy returned for season 9, the character was no longer needed and [[Put
Line 105:
* In the [[WWE]], Kevin [[Fan Nickname|"Big Poochie"]] Nash (though nicknamed more for his [[Spotlight-Stealing Squad]] nature). Came in with lots of history (he was, after all, Diesel back in the early '90s, but [[Fleeting Demographic Rule|wrestling fans aren't supposed to remember that]]) and an infamous [[Real Life]] friendship with [[Shawn Michaels]], [[Triple H]], Scott Hall, and X-Pac (his teammates in the nWo). His presence seemed to leave a bad taste in a lot of fans' mouths, and after his [[Game-Breaking Injury|second quad tear]], he left for another several years. Why Hall and X-Pac didn't get a [[Shoo Out the New Guy]] treatment is anyone's guess.
** Nash's nickname of "Big Poochie" actually [[Older Than They Think|dates back to]] late-90s WCW, where he was [[Running the Asylum|Head Booker]] and essentially forcing ''Nitro'' to revolve around himself, with increasingly absurd segments that seemed to be aired purely for the amusement of Nash himself.
* This is actually fairly common in wrestling. Whenever a wrestler debuts and is immediately hated by the fans, promotions will usually either retool him with a different gimmick, or [[Put
** A more recent example was Kizarny. The gimmick was that he was apparently a carnival/circus performer so he always spoke in Carny. Carny is a form of [[Pig Latin]] commonly used by carnival folks ([[Captain Obvious|duh]]) and wrestlers, where you put "iz" before the first (or maybe all) vowels of a word. This, of course, made nearly everything the guy said unintelligible and the character was dropped before he could even debut save for one match against MVP.
** In 80's [[WWE|WWF]] a lot of vignettes were filmed hyping a wrestler named Outback Jack. This was basically Vince's attempt to cash in on the success of [[Crocodile Dundee]]. After months and months of hype, fans were treated to some of the worst "wrestling" ever performed in public. Jack was shown the door in short order.
Line 114:
== [[Video Games]] ==
* As much as [[Unpleasable Fanbase|fans complain]] about [[Loads and Loads of Characters|all the additional]] ''[[Sonic the Hedgehog]]'' characters the newer games have added, Sonic Team seemed to learn their lesson with [[The Scrappy|Silver]]; after his debut in ''[[Sonic the Hedgehog 2006 (
** His return in ''[[
Line 124:
== Webcomics ==
* Parodied in [http://www.missmab.com/Comics/Vol_188.php this] ''[[Dan and
* The second ''[[
== Western Animation ==
* Poochie from ''[[The Simpsons]]'', who is an in-universe example. [[Executive Meddling|Meddling executives]] create the [[Totally Radical]] character (voiced by Homer) in a clumsy attempt to pander to kids. In his first episode of ''[[The Itchy and Scratchy Show]]'', Poochie sidetracks the plot to introduce himself by rapping about all of the reasons kids should just love him. The audience overwhelmingly hates Poochie and the focus being put on him. In the very next episode, the president crudely alters the cartoon himself to [[Bus Crash|kill Poochie "on the way back to his home planet."]] Krusty then promises the audience that [[Deader Than Dead|he will never be brought back]], to great celebration. The same episode got all meta and dropped a cool guy named Roy into the Simpson family's house, with no explanation. At the end, he moved into [[
** The sad thing is, Fox was at first actually '''serious''' about the idea of having a new 'hip' character in the Simpsons' household. Of course the writers were against it; and thus they created this parody instead.
** Poochie does make a brief cameo without any lines in another Itchy and Scratchy episode.
|