Wall of Text: Difference between revisions

m
Mass update links
m (categories and general cleanup)
m (Mass update links)
Line 29:
** In the same tradition (though more tongue-in-cheek, obviously) Chris Sims of the Invincible super-blog does a feature he calls [http://www.the-isb.com/?cat=201 Warrior Wisdom Fridays] that feature one of Ultimate Warrior's characteristically incoherent Wall Of Text rants, plus a hilarious [[Alt Text]] haiku summary.
* Dave Sim's ''[[Cerebus]]'' went beyond the [[Walls of Text]] and into chronic [[Author Filibuster]] when the comic itself was repeatedly put on hold to make space for multi-page misogynistic rants of plain text. It does get over that phase eventually<ref> the walls of text, not the misogyny</ref>, then later falls back into it.
* A dreadful example: ''[[Tintin (Comic Book)]] in America''. Hergé shocked Europe with this thing. Now almost everyone knows text walls are ''pure evil.''
* [[Don Rosa]]'s earlier works (particularly ''The Pertwillaby Papers'') had tight-packed expository speech bubbles. Not so much in his Disney comics, though; the "Disney remakes" of his stories are a good example of how one can thin the information flow without really affecting the ''net amount'' of information conveyed to the reader.
* The online archive of the surreal Brown University newspaper comic ''Burble'' is fully aware of its large bits of dialogue; despite its high quality compared to most other strips at the time, it was mocked (and later self-mocked) for "too many words".
Line 35:
* ''[[Mallard Fillmore]]'' often doesn't even draw the character's ''body'', instead crowding piles and piles of text around a floating disembodied head.
** ''[[This Modern World]]'' is the same.
* One issue of ''[[Howard the Duck (Comic Bookcomics)|Howard the Duck]]'' was 22 pages of text-with-an-illustration of [[Steve Gerber]] apologizing for not having a fully-formed comic ready for publication that month.
* [[EC Comics]] had a pattern: the dialogue was put on the page before the artwork was. The writer would occasionally write his script directly onto the storyboards as he came up with it. This often meant that around 90% of the panel was pure text, with the art shoehorned into what was left. Some comics would end with a panel that was nothing ''but'' text to explain the story.
** The exception are the stories that Harvey Kurtzman drew, as well as the ones he wrote and storyboarded for other artists.
Line 47:
* The problem has been endemic long enough in the comics industry to make famous one particular work offering a way to patch it: "[http://joeljohnson.com/archives/2006/08/wally_woods_22.html Wally Wood's 22 Panels That Always Work], or Some Interesting Ways to Get Some Variety into Those Boring Panels Where Some Dumb Writer Has a Bunch of Lame Characters Sitting Around and Talking for Page After Page!"
* In a recent interview, celebrated comic scribe [[Larry Hama]], a penciler turned writer, observed that the format of Marvel Comics' books in the 1970s and early 1980s was often guilty of this, bemoaning the overuse of captions. "You'd have a caption covering 3/4 of a panel, [[Narrating the Obvious|describing the content of the panel it was covering!]]"
* German comic ''[[Rudi (Comic Strip)|Rudi]]'' is (in)famous for this and sometimes lampshades it.
* [[Justified Trope|Justified]] in ''[[American Splendor (Comic Book)|American Splendor]]'', as the story is less about the pictures and more about character dialog and Harvey Pekar's inner monologue.
 
 
Line 64:
* Nobel prize Jose Saramago loved to to this, do not try to imitate him, he got a nobel for a reason.
* The literary style of maximalism emphasizes the author writing down ''everything'' that crosses his/her mind in the interest of painting a more "complete" picture of the author's/character's mindset.
* [[JRRJ. TolkienR. (Creator)R. Tolkien|JRR Tolkien]]
 
 
== Live-Action TV ==
* One ''[[Whose Line Is It Anyway?]]'' "Let's Make a Date" game gave Wayne a very complicated role to play (something pretty close to "smooth rap star blindfolded and tied to the bed by his girlfriend gradually realizing the night is going terribly wrong"). When Greg saw the card (about 8"x8"), his reaction was a stunned "There's two paragraphs of text on this!"
** The guessing-game personalities when Whose Line started in Britain were extremely simple ("a pirate," etc.), and gradually became longer and more convoluted over the next 18 seasons.
 
 
== Manga ==
* The ''[[Death Note (Manga)|Death Note]]'' manga can be particularly guilty of this at times. In the later volumes of the manga, the characters spend a ton of time out-thinking each other in a 3-way cat-and-mouse game, and all of the text used for that can be jarring, even though it's essential. To make it worse, it's complex enough that, if you blink and miss a crucial detail, you're totally lost.
* As a self-styled modern day Sherlock Holmes, ''[[Detective Conan]]'' more often than not feature walls (and walls and walls) of text while [[Pull the Thread|pulling the thread]] to reveal who did it. [[Kindaichi Case Files|Kindaichi]] can be just as wordy, but he at least has the courtesy to break up his walls of text.
* ''[[Mahou Sensei Negima]]'' often falls into this, and even plays this one for comedy once, having Yue go off on lengthy [[Expospeak]] tangents only to discover no one was listening.
Line 98:
 
== Video Games ==
* ''[[Marathon (Video Game)Trilogy|Marathon]] 2: Durandal'' features [http://marathon.bungie.org/story/blake.html#22 a terminal in the level Kill Your Television] with no spaces or punctuation deliberately to be cryptic and vague. [http://marathon.bungie.org/story/kytterm.html Fans did decrypt the message], but, in typical old-school Bungie fashion, [[Mind Screw|it still didn't make much sense]].
* If you make a rather wordy post on the ''[[City of Heroes]]'' forum, some people will complain they were killed by your wall of text. Some [[Troll|Trolls]] will engage in wall of text contests to see if they can overload the forum display.
{{quote| Wall of Text crits you for [[Over Nine Thousand|9999]] damage.<br />
Line 110:
* In one stage of ''[[Wangan Midnight Maximum Tune]] 2'', [[Joke Character|Gatchan]] lets off two consecutive blocks of texts so big that ''they obscure your vision''. Taken [[Up to Eleven]] in ''Maximum Tune 3'' and its upgrades, where not only does he have ''four'' blocks of text, he has the gall to say them NEAR THE END OF THE STAGE, making you more likely to lose.
* In the early text-based game [[Colossal Cave]], the description of the volcano.
* In ''[[Fate/stay Stay Nightnight]]'', Kotomine and Rin are prone to expository lectures, Kotomine describing the functions and history of the Grail Wars, Rin less frequently on the mechanics of magic. Many Chekovs Guns have been obscured in the pages of pages of text, and the voice-acted version hardly saved them. This was impatiently Lampshaded by Shirou's internal monologue in the final arc: "Doesn't he ever shut up?"
* It is apparently a popular joke in [[Touhou Project]] doujinshi to have Nitori or someone else go to lengthy descriptions (usually of technology) to the other characters wo more likely than not are not actually listening. One doujin parodied it by having Alice get pushed against a wall by the huge speech bubble.
* When [[Cloudcuckoolander|Rin]] in ''[[Katawa Shoujo]]'' starts rambling, it's shown in the largest and fullest textbox in the game. [[No Punctuation Period|With barely if any punctuation.]]
Line 118:
== Web Comics ==
* [[Web Comics]] usually [[Lampshade Hanging|lampshade]] their frequent large blocks of exposition, often in the narration or titling:
** One solution used in ''[[El Goonish Shive (Webcomic)|El Goonish Shive]]'' was to put a [http://www.egscomics.com/?date=2002-07-08 very faint greyscale picture in the background of the text balloon] as foreshadowing of the second half of the story arc; the exposition itself is also lampshaded in the dialogue as well.
** ''[[Penny Arcade (Webcomic)|Penny Arcade]]'''s "[http://www.penny-arcade.com/comic/2006/04/10 I Hope You Like Text]." This exchange was deemed ''[[Crowning Moment of Awesome|so awesome]]'' that it was put on a ''shirt'' which sells, apparently, very well.
** Similarly lampshaded by an [[Author Guest Spot]] in [http://www.missmab.com/Comics/Vol_922.php this] ''[[Dan and MabsMab's Furry Adventures]]'' strip.
*** ''DMFA'' frequently uses the phrase "Wall of Text" during big exposition parts. Occasionally, you need to wear construction helmets.
*** Fa'Lina recommends this as the preferred way to avoid having your mind read by cubi. Memorize a boring wall of text, such as legal babble.
** ''[[Saturday Morning Breakfast Cereal]]'' notes that [http://www.smbc-comics.com/index.php?db=comics&id=1538#comic "When people think 'funny', they think 'tons of words!'"]
* This is a criticism often levelled at ''[[Ctrl +Alt +Del (Webcomic)|Ctrl Alt Del]]''. In fact, a certain [[Image Board]] came up with something called "CAD Rule" -- the law that if you take the first panel and the last panel of a ''Ctrl+Alt+Del'' strip, remove the text from the last panel, and post it, it will automatically be much funnier, as [http://www.cad-comic.com/cad/20060331 this strip] "shows".
** A similar device is the infamously named ''buckleybox'', a smaller but equally superfluous [[Wall of Text]] used to reiterate something that ''[[Don't Explain the Joke|should already appear in the actual comic]]'' visually, but may not due to odd dialogue placement, poor art not conveying it, or the assumption [[Viewers are Morons]].
* ''[[8-Bit Theater (Webcomic)|Eight Bit Theater]]'' does this a lot, like in [http://www.nuklearpower.com/2003/09/30/episode-336-elves-love-talking/ this] strip. Note the title of the strip itself. And yes, there are more extreme ones.
* ''[[Goodwill Heroes]]'' had an instance where [http://www.goodwill-heroes.net/06-06-2011/bk01-ch02-pg03/ the Librarian] belittled the main cast for raising their voices in a library.
* ''[[Xkcd (Webcomic)|Xkcd]]'' once had a wall of text that [http://xkcd.com/160/ broke the frame of the comic].
* ''[[Dresden Codak]]'' has been accused of this ever since Aaron Diaz [[Cerebus Syndrome|added an actual plot]]. Possibly the strongest case can be found [http://www.dresdencodak.com/cartoons/dc_041.html here].
* ''[[Triangle and Robert (Webcomic)|Triangle and Robert]]'' once had a main character killed by a Wall of Text exposition, [http://tr.froup.com/tr.pl?785 here] and [http://tr.froup.com/tr.pl?786 here].
* ''[[Silent Hill Promise]]'' The comic, like the [[Adventure Game|adventure games]] it apes, supplements the images with plenty of narration.
* ''[[Something Positive (Webcomic)|Something Positive]]'' has a bad case of this; ironically this is more noticable since the comic is drawn to allow ample space from them, and is a good indication to the presence of strawmen. One particularly [[Egregious]] [http://www.somethingpositive.net/sp07232004.shtml example] is lampshaded with the following:
{{quote| '''Warning:''' The following comic contains a lot of words. Those who are frightened or intimidated by reading are encouraged to seek entertainment elsewhere. [[Viewers are Morons|We recommend a shiny ball of foil]].}}
* ''[[Irregular Webcomic (Webcomic)|Irregular Webcomic]]'' made fun of this trope [http://www.irregularwebcomic.net/1159.html here]. Notable that it use the strings of text as a way to make fun of the trope instead of having some sort of [[Lampshade Hanging]] outside the strings of text.
* ''[http://www.viruscomix.com/subnormality.html Subnormality]'' '''is''' walls of text (except when it's [[Text Plosion]]... Or totally wordless). It's right there in the sub-title: "Comix with too many words since 2007."
** This trope is referenced by name at the start of [http://www.viruscomix.com/page494.html this strip].
** [http://www.viruscomix.com/page505.html This] is the most excessive example of Wall of Text ever seen. 19 panels. ''2500 words.''
* ''[[The Order of the Stick (Webcomic)|Order of the Stick]]'' actually played this one staggeringly straight [http://www.giantitp.com/comics/oots0282.html in this comic]. Though it ''did'' throw in [[Lampshade Hanging]]: Vaarsuvius, king (or queen) of overtalking, complains about the brevity -- when you think about it, [[Fridge Brilliance|really quite a valid complaint in a trial]].
** Later on lampshaded again with "[http://www.giantitp.com/comics/oots0558.html comic way too wordy for chief grukgruk sometimes.]"
* ''[[The Adventures of Dr. McNinja (Webcomic)|The Adventures of Dr. McNinja]]'' [http://drmcninja.com/page.php?pageNum=20&issue=5 stuck this] on Frans Rayner when he explains his sinister plan in ''immense'' detail. Lampshaded in the alt text for the page where the author ''congratulates'' the reader for making it all the way through.
* ''[[Errant Story]]'', although it does manage to pull it off quite well with the storytelling style.
* This is a common criticism of ''[[Better Days]]'' ([[Firefly|No relation]]), made only worse when it turns up in the supplementary porn comics.
Line 148:
* ''[[Precocious (Webcomic)|Precocious]]'' [[Played for Laughs|plays this for laughs]]. It happens whenever Suzette goes into a rant (could be about anything from her [[Straw Feminist]] [http://www.precociouscomic.com/archive/comic/2009/03/24 philosophies] to [http://www.precociouscomic.com/archive/comic/2009/03/23 someone forgetting her name and believing it to be snobbery])
** It also uses [[Wall of Blather]].
* One of the many, MANY criticisms of ''[[Sonichu (Webcomic)|Sonichu]]'', as elaborated on [http://www.cogsdev.org/cwcki/Chris_and_writing#Textwalls_and_unreadable_bubble_layouts here.]
* In ''[[Pastel Defender Heliotrope]],'' [[Unicorn Jelly|and possibly every other Jennifer Diane Reitz work,]] everyone communicates via text walls. [[Up to Eleven|Every page, every panel, every word bubble.]] [[Rimshot|There are enough walls of texts in there to keep out Mongol invaders!]]
* [[Captain Obvious]] in ''[[The Way of the Metagamer (Webcomic)|The Way of the Metagamer]]'' combines these with [[Department of Redundancy Department]].
* ''[[Far Out There]]'' had a very bad case of this [http://www.drunkduck.com/Far_Out_There/index.php?p=360961 in its early days.] Thankfully, the author is gradually learning to [http://www.drunkduck.com/Far_Out_There/index.php?p=614943 show, not tell.]
* Though most walls of exposition are stowed away in boxes below the comic rather than panel bubbles, ''[[Homestuck (Webcomic)|Homestuck]]'' has more than its share of walls of text. The ''[[Lower Deck Episode|Hivebent]]'' arc, in particular, [[Word of God|has been described by Andrew Hussie as]] "[http://www.formspring.me/andrewhussie/q/1158778979 a very vividly illustrated e-novel]", rather than a webcomic.
** In Act 6 Act 3, Homestuck [[Reconstructed Trope|actively defends its method of long-winded narration]] by having a new character who hates long stories tell her arc in bullet points and skip straight to the end, depriving the reader of almost all the interesting details. A second character, pissed off at this display of storytelling, decides to [[Call Back|recap the Ancestor Arc]] in the same bullet style, showing that while the initial version of that arc was fairly long-winded, the bullet-point style turns every character into a one-dimensional plot device and turns the narrative into a terribly-paced [[Random Events Plot]].
* Once used in ''[[At Arm's Length (Webcomicwebcomic)|At Arms Length]]'' as as [http://atarmslength.smackjeeves.com/comics/676446/deerwitchproject-28/ weapon against Ally].
* [[Bleedman]], aka Vinson Ngo, is usually guilty of this in his webcomics when it comes to exposition. ''[[Grim Tales Fromfrom Down Below|Grims Tales]]'' and ''[[Sugar Bits]]'' in particular.
 
 
Line 179:
* Every last usage license agreement. Ever. Including the one that is the picture at the time of this writing.
* [[UNIX]] manual pages.
* [http://www.adturds.co.uk/2010/11/tell-me-what-this-baffling-job-description-means.html The incoherent, babbling, jargon-filled mess that is the job description critiqued in this blog article,] and it isn't exactly helped by [[Wanton Cruelty to Thethe Common Comma|some of the worst grammar to ever exist in something that was supposed to attract people to the job]]: [[No Punctuation Period|three full stops in the entire block of text]], random capitalisation and abuse of apostrophes. This borderline [[Word Salad]] was more likely to have put people ''off'' applying than it was to generate recruits.
{{quote| Zola the Gorgon (commenter on blog): "I think someone wrote this ad by running a mission statement generator (e.g. http://www.isms.org.uk/mission... and [[They Just Didn't Care|cutting and pasting all the results into a solid block of text until they met their wordcount]]."}}
* The labels on bottles of [http://www.drbronner.com/dr_bronners_philosophy.php Dr. Bronner's Magic Soap] mix this with a kind of religious/philosophical/advertising version of [[Room Full of Crazy]]. (If the picture on their [http://www.drbronner.com/history_overview.php history page] is really of the late Dr. B, it would certainly [[Mad Scientist|explain a lot]].)