All The Tropes talk:How We Do Bans Around Here
- (cur prev topic) 15:04, 17 April 2024 . . Robkelk (talk | contribs) commented on "Proposal: Add "edit warring" to the "bannable" list" (We have consensus on this, so I've added it to the "tempban after warning" list. Thanks, everyone.) . . +99
- (cur prev topic) 14:39, 17 April 2024 . . Robkelk (talk | contribs) commented on "Proposal: Add "edit warring" to the "bannable" list" (We're already doing "three strikes" for minor issues. First strike gets a comment, second strike gets an "On Notice" warning, and third s...) . . +160
- (cur prev topic) 21:55, 16 April 2024 . . RivetVermin (talk | contribs) commented on "Proposal: Add "edit warring" to the "bannable" list" (This seems like a common-sense rule. Based on previous experiences with other wikis, I would suggest reinstating deleted content made wit...) . . +422
- (cur prev topic) 15:30, 14 April 2024 . . MilkmanConspiracy (talk | contribs) edited a post on "Proposal: Add "edit warring" to the "bannable" list" . . +140
- (cur prev topic) 15:07, 14 April 2024 . . Robkelk (talk | contribs) commented on "Proposal: Add "edit warring" to the "bannable" list" (No worries on the wall'o'text. I'd much rather see reasoned debate than rubber-stamping of a mod proposal.) . . +106
- (cur prev topic) 14:41, 14 April 2024 . . MilkmanConspiracy (talk | contribs) commented on "Proposal: Add "edit warring" to the "bannable" list" (Sorry for the Wall O’ Text, turned out longer then I thought.) . . +61
- (cur prev topic) 14:38, 14 April 2024 . . MilkmanConspiracy (talk | contribs) commented on "Proposal: Add "edit warring" to the "bannable" list" (A few notes for consideration: There are a few kinds of reverts, with different levels of intent. This isn’t exhaustive, but generally th...) . . +2,895
- (cur prev topic) 05:41, 14 April 2024 . . GentlemensDame883 (talk | contribs) commented on "Proposal: Add "edit warring" to the "bannable" list" (Thanks for the clarification. I'd like to go with Lequinni's three strikes idea, the better to sort out the innocent or confused mistakes...) . . +200
- (cur prev topic) 23:06, 12 April 2024 . . Lequinni (talk | contribs) commented on "Proposal: Add "edit warring" to the "bannable" list" (I vote for ot to be banneable, but in a three strikes level. One time can be a mistake, twice is a Kpop girl group, and thrice is fully o...) . . +232
- (cur prev topic) 21:58, 12 April 2024 . . Jlaw (talk | contribs) commented on "Proposal: Add "edit warring" to the "bannable" list" (Ah okay. Hmmm) . . +13
- (cur prev topic) 20:44, 12 April 2024 . . Robkelk (talk | contribs) commented on "Proposal: Add "edit warring" to the "bannable" list" (Yes, which is what reminded me of the absence. A new troper, still under moderation, added back in the "how to use this template" comment...) . . +244
- (cur prev topic) 19:10, 12 April 2024 . . Jlaw (talk | contribs) commented on "Proposal: Add "edit warring" to the "bannable" list" (Has anything happened recently?) . . +31
- (cur prev topic) 19:01, 12 April 2024 . . Robkelk (talk | contribs) commented on "Proposal: Add "edit warring" to the "bannable" list" (It's on our list of ban reasons in the tool, but it isn't in any of our guidelines or policies yet. So far, the votes are to add, prefera...) . . +209
- (cur prev topic) 17:55, 12 April 2024 . . Looney Toons (talk | contribs) commented on "Proposal: Add "edit warring" to the "bannable" list" (I could've sworn we already had that, but no. Failing that, I thought it must be on another page somewhere, but again, no. Yes, yes, a mi...) . . +290
- (cur prev topic) 17:53, 12 April 2024 . . HLIAA14YOG (talk | contribs) edited a post on "Proposal: Add "edit warring" to the "bannable" list" . . +25
- (cur prev topic) 17:52, 12 April 2024 . . HLIAA14YOG (talk | contribs) commented on "Proposal: Add "edit warring" to the "bannable" list" (I would advise to not do immediately; I think doing any kind of punishment on a hurry is a dangerous idea.) . . +106
- (cur prev topic) 17:33, 12 April 2024 . . HeneryVII (talk | contribs) commented on "Proposal: Add "edit warring" to the "bannable" list" (I vote aye, I've had a lot of trouble with such folks on other wiki sites) . . +73
- (cur prev topic) 15:28, 12 April 2024 . . Robkelk (talk | contribs) commented on "Proposal: Add "edit warring" to the "bannable" list" (Undoing and re-doing of the same edit.) . . +38
- (cur prev topic) 15:21, 12 April 2024 . . GentlemensDame883 (talk | contribs) commented on "Proposal: Add "edit warring" to the "bannable" list" (For the avoidance of doubt, what exactly constitutes "edit warring"?) . . +68
- (cur prev topic) 14:39, 12 April 2024 . . Robkelk (talk | contribs) commented on "Proposal: Add "edit warring" to the "bannable" list" (Especially the type of edit-warring that re-breaks something that a mod fixed, but the garden-variety "is not!" "is too!" "is not!" "is t...) . . +560
- (cur prev topic) 16:49, 16 April 2020 . . GethN7 (talk | contribs) commented on "Proposal: Add "vandalizing a content page" to the list" (That's a good point. If someone blanks a page and replaces it with a message for people to kill themselves, then I think we can reasonabl...) . . +249
- (cur prev topic) 12:42, 16 April 2020 . . TBeholder (talk | contribs) commented on "Proposal: Add "vandalizing a content page" to the list" ("Tempban, then case by case" makes the most sense in general, in that it's not even always intentional. From previous experience we know...) . . +485
- (cur prev topic) 13:36, 15 April 2020 . . GethN7 (talk | contribs) edited a post on "Proposal: Add "vandalizing a content page" to the list" . . 0
- (cur prev topic) 11:52, 15 April 2020 . . Robkelk (talk | contribs) edited a post on "Proposal: Add "vandalizing a content page" to the list" . . +53
- (cur prev topic) 11:45, 15 April 2020 . . Robkelk (talk | contribs) commented on "Proposal: Add "vandalizing a content page" to the list" (It appears we have consensus. Updating the page...) . . +50
- (cur prev topic) 04:22, 15 April 2020 . . GethN7 (talk | contribs) commented on "Proposal: Add "vandalizing a content page" to the list" (Concur wholeheartedly. While the damage is not irrevocable, someone mass deleting content from a page harms out overall mission to presen...) . . +198
- (cur prev topic) 02:12, 15 April 2020 . . HeneryVII (talk | contribs) commented on "Proposal: Add "vandalizing a content page" to the list" (I agree too, Vandalizing a page can get a poster kicked out of any other Wiki I know of, so that should be the case here.) . . +121
- (cur prev topic) 01:58, 15 April 2020 . . Lequinni (talk | contribs) commented on "Proposal: Add "vandalizing a content page" to the list" (I agree with LT. Obvious vandalizing is grounds of permaban almost elsewhere, and adding "vandalizing and blanking wiki pages" to the lis...) . . +346
- (cur prev topic) 01:36, 15 April 2020 . . Looney Toons (talk | contribs) edited a post on "Proposal: Add "vandalizing a content page" to the list" . . +6
- (cur prev topic) 01:29, 15 April 2020 . . Looney Toons (talk | contribs) commented on "Proposal: Add "vandalizing a content page" to the list" (I'm surprised none of us ever noticed it wasn't on the list of offenses, because I know we've had to deal with this before. This is a per...) . . +1,154
- (cur prev topic) 00:53, 15 April 2020 . . Robkelk (talk | contribs) commented on "Proposal: Add "vandalizing a content page" to the list" (Because I just had to give somebody a ban for replacing an entire trope page with a single word, and the only thing I could find on the l...) . . +910
- (cur prev topic) 14:28, 7 February 2020 . . Robkelk (talk | contribs) commented on "I haven't seen anyone else comment on this yet..." (I like the last one - succinct and clear.) . . +41
- (cur prev topic) 14:25, 7 February 2020 . . Looney Toons (talk | contribs) commented on "I haven't seen anyone else comment on this yet..." (Assuming an "All The Tropes:" namespace before them: "Tempban and Permanent Ban Policy" "Bans: Rules and Guidelines for Qualifying and Ap...) . . +220
- (cur prev topic) 22:42, 6 February 2020 . . Robkelk (talk | contribs) commented on "I haven't seen anyone else comment on this yet..." (Okay, the text has been polished. I think this is now almost launchable. The sole flaw that I see: It needs a better name.) . . +127
- (cur prev topic) 22:11, 6 February 2020 . . Looney Toons (talk | contribs) commented on "I haven't seen anyone else comment on this yet..." (Agreed, although we should clean up some of the chattier or uncertain parts first.) . . +82
- (cur prev topic) 21:18, 6 February 2020 . . Robkelk (talk | contribs) commented on "I haven't seen anyone else comment on this yet..." (I think it's safe to turn this into a proper guideline page.) . . +60
- (cur prev topic) 20:40, 5 January 2020 . . SelfCloak (talk | contribs) commented on "I haven't seen anyone else comment on this yet..." (I checked the draft, it all looks good to me.) . . +45
- (cur prev topic) 17:49, 5 January 2020 . . Robkelk (talk | contribs) commented on "I haven't seen anyone else comment on this yet..." (More changes made to the draft. Input is requested from @Labster, @GethN7, @Looney Toons, @QuestionableSanity, @Derivative,@SelfCloak, an...) . . +458
- (cur prev topic) 15:22, 31 December 2019 . . Looney Toons (talk | contribs) commented on "I haven't seen anyone else comment on this yet..." (It occurs to me that we should probably lay out explicitly the bans for spam somewhere, too. Our current procedures are permanent ban for...) . . +404
- (cur prev topic) 02:24, 31 December 2019 . . Robkelk (talk | contribs) commented on "I haven't seen anyone else comment on this yet..." (Thanks, LT. As for the schedule: It seems to me that a one-day or shorter tempban doesn't do much, especially if the offender doesn't try...) . . +359
- (cur prev topic) 01:53, 31 December 2019 . . Looney Toons (talk | contribs) commented on "I haven't seen anyone else comment on this yet..." (Just added a reason for an immediate tempban that we've had in place for years now. As for when we shift from temp to perm, well, we had...) . . +592
- (cur prev topic) 12:47, 30 December 2019 . . Robkelk (talk | contribs) edited a post on "I haven't seen anyone else comment on this yet..." . . +44
- (cur prev topic) 12:47, 30 December 2019 . . Robkelk (talk | contribs) commented on "I haven't seen anyone else comment on this yet..." (Good point. I've split "what is grounds for..." into two subsections: immediate tempban and tempban only after a warning) . . +120
- (cur prev topic) 07:29, 30 December 2019 . . Derivative (talk | contribs) commented on "I haven't seen anyone else comment on this yet..." (Strong language per content pages should maybe considered not an immediate tempban) . . +82
- (cur prev topic) 06:21, 30 December 2019 . . Looney Toons (talk | contribs) commented on "I haven't seen anyone else comment on this yet..." (...so I'll start. Overall this looks good. I've read through it several times over the past few days, and no real changes come to mind. I...) . . +193