All The Tropes:Everything You Wanted to Know About Changing Trope Names: Difference between revisions

added a section
(added advice about DEFAULTSORT after renaming)
(added a section)
 
(9 intermediate revisions by 3 users not shown)
Line 30:
* If a trope '''has the same title as a work of fiction''', except if that title is a common established term for that trope.
* We no longer name tropes after '''a line of dialogue or a Stock Phrase'''. It risks editors wikilinking the ''phrase'' every time that particular combination of words occurs, whether the underlying ''trope'' actually applies in that context or not.
* '''"Trope" used as a [[Metasyntactic Variable|placeholder word]]''' (e.g. "[[More Tropes Than God|More [Tropes] Than God]]", "[[Gonna Need More Trope|Gonna Need More [Trope] ]]") is now deprecated, as it misuses the word "trope".
* '''Acronym or initialism''' trope names. We generally prefer the title spelled out unless it has profanity (for example: the [[BFG]] trope, or Big [[Bowdlerisation|<s>Fucking</s> Freaking]] Gun). Initialisms tend to be turned into disambiguation pages around here (for example: [[BFG]]).
* If a trope was '''launched prematurely''' from YKTTWthe [[Trope Workshop]] before consensus was reached about a title and a description, it <s>should probably</s> ''will'' get sent right back.
 
=== What to do if you think a rename is called for. ===
Line 40:
=== What happens after you bring it up===
 
First of all: As long as there is no consensus to rename, you should leave the name be. Consensus does not mean a simple majority. While there's no hard-and-fast rule for what constitutes consensus, for renames we generally look for at least a 2:1 ratio in favor -- that is, twice as many people think it should be changed as think it shouldn't. However, an alternative titles crowner does not need any particular ratio: the most popular title with more supports than opposes wins.
 
=== Yay, my change was approved. Who makes it? ===
 
One of the admins will perform the actual rename, as well as any other related changes that are required (such as updating the corresponding category). Users do ''not'' have access to the wiki's Move function, as it has been abused in the past by both vandals and users who felt they knew better than anyone else and refused to listen to consensus.
 
=== Oh, and one more thing... ===
Line 54 ⟶ 58:
*If the page name is like ''The Page Starting with An Article'', add <nowiki>{{DEFAULTSORT:Page Starting with An Article, The}}</nowiki> at the bottom.
*If the page name is like ''"Quote Marks" Start The Name'', add <nowiki>{{DEFAULTSORT:Quote Marks Start The Name}}</nowiki>.
 
Don't forget to add/update DEFAULTSORT on all the page's subpages as well!
 
{{reflist}}