Bastard Boyfriend: Difference between revisions

m
Copyedit (minor)
(quote cleanup)
m (Copyedit (minor))
 
(9 intermediate revisions by 5 users not shown)
Line 2:
[[File:Black-Bird-V1.jpg|link=Black Bird|frame|They're in love, can't you ''tell?'']]
 
{{quote|''Well, I don't pretend to understand women's little quirks
''Just one thing I know for sure; chicks dig jerks|'''[[Bill Hicks]]''', "Chicks Dig Jerks"}}
|'''[[Bill Hicks]]''', "Chicks Dig Jerks"}}
 
A common [[Anime Character Types|Japanese character type]], the '''Bastard Boyfriend''' (in Japanese, ''kichiku'', literally "brutal" or "demonic") character is an [[Always Male]] [[Love Interest]] whose defining trait is that he is cold, cruel, or abusive to his romantic partner, in a manner intended to be [[Fetish Fuel|kinky and appealing to the audience]]. Western versions exist, but are comparatively rare nowadays due to the inherent [[Unfortunate Implications]], except in fanfiction (which lacks the watchful eyes of [[Moral Guardians]]).
 
'''Bastard Boyfriends''' can be readily distinguished from the more generic [[Jerkass]] or [[Domestic Abuser]] because their abuse is eroticized (if it isn't already [[Victim Falls For Rapist|explicitly sexual]]), and their <s>victim's</s> beloved's conflict and unhappiness will be played for titillation. As such, they are all-but-guaranteed to be [[Mr. Fanservice]], usually a [[Bishounen]], and the consequences of their behavior are almost never [[Domestic Abuse|handled realistically]]. The '''Bastard Boyfriend''' ''almost always'' [[Official Couple|gets his girl (or guy)]], even in cases where they [[Strangled by the Red String|don't seem particularly compatible]], although a few are doomed to merely be [[Romantic False Lead|the rival]].
 
This type is common in [[Boys Love]] (as a standard [[Seme]] type), [[Shoujo]], and, to a lesser extent, [[Josei]] romances, but comparatively rare in works aimed at a male audience, where guys like this are more likely to be the [[Romantic False Lead]] or just [[Stalker with a Crush|a villain]].
 
Their love interest, male or female, is usually [[The Protagonist]], although a minority of stories are from the '''Bastard Boyfriend''''s point of view. They will probably be presented as a [[Love Martyr]] or [[The Woobie]], and is likely to spend quite a bit of the story [[Angst|anguishing over the relationship]], possibly while [[Sparkling Stream of Tears|weeping beautifully]]. This trope has next to no overlap with [[Belligerent Sexual Tension]], since '''Bastard Boyfriends''' never seem to show an interest in anyone with the backbone to defy them.
 
The '''Bastard Boyfriend''' is sort of the Alpha Male equivalent of a Type A [[Tsundere]], but with the violent temper replaced by [[Tall, Dark and Snarky|cutting sarcasm]] and the ''deredere'' side turned down to near-zero. They are, of course, completely immune to [[Can't Act Perverted Toward a Love Interest]], but they're usually [[Even Evil Has Standards|not]] [[Wouldn't Hit a Girl|physically abusive]], since that's [[Fetish Retardant|just not hot]]. There are plenty of exceptions, though.
 
'''Bastard Boyfriends''' come in two major types:
 
'''Unconflicted''' (standard): Poised, confident, and perfectly happy with his own behavior, either because he [[It's All About Me|doesn't care what the other party thinks of him]], genuinely believes that abduction and molestation are [[Stalking Is Love|viable ways of showing his affection]], or [[For the Evulz|just is a plain, sadistic bastard]]. The [[Bespectacled Bastard Boyfriend]] (''Kichiku Megane'') subtrope is built on this type.
Line 23 ⟶ 24:
Both kinds are highly likely to be [[Crazy Jealous Guy|jealous and possessive]]. Expect plots to feature a [[Green-Eyed Epiphany]]—a character realizing their love only via jealousy.
 
The '''Bastard Boyfriend''' is likely to be [[Love Redeems|redeemed]] by [[The Power of Love]] at the end of the book; alternately, he may eventually be revealed to be [[Jerk with a Heart of Gold|nicer underneath]]. A minority may be revealed to have a [[Freudian Excuse]] (such as [[Abusive Parents]] or [[Love Hurts|extremely bad former romances]]). If none of these things happen, his partner may decide that [[Stalking Is Love]] and embrace their status as a [[Love Martyr]]. Along the way, the '''Bastard Boyfriend''' may well be [[Master of the Mixed Message]], if the author needs something to keep his partner strung along.
 
Mature-rated works that have Kichiku characters are likely to involve [[Mind Game Ship|psychological abuse]], [[Victim Falls For Rapist]], and maybe some [[Bound and Gagged|BDSM]]. PG-rated examples tend to be [[Tall, Dark and Snarky|cold, aloof, or sarcastic]]. In either case, fan reaction tends to be polarized: either they're [[Perverse Sexual Lust|hot and sexy]] and their love affair is [[squee]]able, or they're total [[Jerkass]]es and the relationship is [[squick]]tastic.
Line 38 ⟶ 39:
** The author wants you to think he's a [[Jerkass]] and she's a saint for putting up with him: [[Domestic Abuser]] meets [[Love Martyr]]
** The author wants you to think he's ''totally hot'' and the relationship [[Corrupt the Cutie|is deliciously kinky]]: This Trope
{{examples}}
 
{{noreallife|calling real-life people "bastards" [[Rule of Cautious Editing Judgment|is a bad idea.]]}}
== Anime and Manga ==
 
'''[[Shoujo]]/[[Josei]] examples:'''
{{examples}}
== [[Anime]] and [[Manga]] ==
'''=== [[Shoujo]]/[[Josei]] examples:''' ===
* Kyo in ''[[Black Bird]]'' (page image): wants to marry female lead Misao, who he has been in love with [[Puppy Love|since they were children]], and [[Intimate Healing|licks her erotically]] when she gets attacked by his fellow demons (which is often). Doesn't seem to care that she's not completely on board with either of these ideas. Then she falls in love with him...but the saddest thing is, [[Stockholm Syndrome|he's one of the few reliable allies that she has in the whole Tengu vs. humans deal]], so if she ''did'' fully spurn him, other Tengus would jump at the chance to kill/rape/eat her. [[The Chew Toy|Still sucks to be her.]] In the end, of course, he ''is'' willing to do anything (including killing his own brother) to keep her happy and safe at the expense of his own life, and he ''does'' [[Pet the Dog|show genuine kindness]] [[Friend to All Children|to children]].
* Director Domoto in ''[[Butterflies, Flowers]]'' (but only when in dictatorial-boss mode).
Line 54 ⟶ 57:
* Shoei Jinnai of ''[[Desire Climax]]''.
* One of the "Love Egoist" [[omake]]s from the ''[[Ouran High School Host Club]]'' manga involves a [[Stepford Smiler]] high school girl learning that the cute, friendly young male teacher who all her classmates admire is secretly as mean and sarcastic as she was on the inside.
* [[Deconstructed]] with Shoutaro "Shou" Fuwa from ''[[Skip Beat!]]''. He treats his childhood friend, Kyouko Mogami, like crap since she lives at his house after she falls victim to [[Parental Abandonment]], and is completely devoted to him...but the moment he ''openly'' berates and humiliates her is actually the moment she ''[[Woman Scorned|snaps]]'' on him, realizes how much of an asshole he is, and openly swears [[Revenge]].
* ''[[Akuma de Sourou]]'' has [[Handsome Devil|Takeru]], who blackmails [[Shrinking Violet|Kayano]] into becoming his servant, sabotages her relationship with the guy she likes, and generally emotionally bullies her in the beginning. He seems to think it's only teasing, but considering how shy and emotional Kayano is, it comes off much harsher. Despite the progression in their relationship, he remains cold and distant, which makes her almost perpetually nervous.
* Q-Ta Minamitani from ''[[Honey Hunt]]'' is a [[Manipulative Bastard]] towards Yura, is possessive of her, and shows little genuine interest in learning what Yura truly wants.
Line 61 ⟶ 64:
* ''[[Revolutionary Girl Utena]]'': Just about all of the main male cast with the exception of Miki. This is, of course, played for epic [[Deconstruction]].
 
'''=== [[Boys Love]] examples:''' ===
* Ryuichi Asami in the ''[[Finder Series]]'' (along with many other Ayano Yamane [[seme]]s): atarts off with rape and BDSM, then develops a romantic side. And so Takaba falls in love with him.
* Nakajima in ''[[Gakuen Heaven]]'', in the manga volume that follows his route in the [[Visual Novel]] (which includes [[Victim Falls For Rapist]]—in the first volume that doesn't follow him at all, there's {{spoiler|attempted rape}}, and he is tremendously rude to Keita throughout, though he points out that if the central love interest does nothing, he'll take Keita for himself). In the anime, he's toned down to a [[Jerkass]], and his sexual harassment is elbow-licking.
Line 80 ⟶ 83:
* Naruse Fuuta in the yaoi manga ''[[Kawaii Akuma]]'' and its sequel is definitely Unconflicted.
* Averted and possibly parodied in ''[[Kizuna]]'', where [[Seme]] Kei has the [[Tall, Dark and Handsome]] looks and a [[Yakuza]] background that would make him the ''perfect'' Unconflicted type... yet his [[Uke]], Ranmaru, is a violent [[Tsundere]] and can have him ''very'' whipped.
* [[Gender Flip|GenderFlipped]]ped (as in, [[Yuri]]) examplesexample: Himemiya Yukio from ''[[Gokujou Drops]]''. She is definitely a Conflicted type. {{spoiler|She and the main character, Komari, both get better.}} Why is this example here? Because ifIf all the residents of [[Big Fancy House|Haraiso Yakata]] are male, [[Gender Flip|the story will be pretty much your standard Boys Love plot]]. (And yes, [[Victim Falls For Rapist]] is in full effect.)
* Shiki from [[Togainu no Chi]] is the Unconflicted type.
* Sou Mizuhashi from ''[[After School Nightmare]]''.
Line 88 ⟶ 91:
* Gilbert of ''[[Kaze to Ki no Uta]]'' can be like this to Serge. He's definitely a [[Jerkass Woobie|conflicted version]].
 
'''=== Non-[[Shoujo]] or [[Boys Love]] Examples:''' ===
 
* Parodied in ''[[Majin Tantei Nougami Neuro]]'', where Neuro is constantly cruel to Yako for no good reason, and this is supposed to hint towards romantic relations between the two characters, as well as being played for laughs.
'''Non-[[Shoujo]] or [[Boys Love]] Examples:'''
* ''[[Death Note|]]'': Light Yagami]] definitely qualifies; the only reason he enters any sort of relationship with Misa is because she has her own Death Note and is wildly, cultishly in love with him. He really doesn't seem to give a crap about her other than that, and, in fact, is as willing to cruelly use her as a pawn as he is any stranger on the street. The only time he (pretends to) show any affection for her is when she's angry at him, or he wants her to do something. If Misa hadn't started with the infatuation, there's ''no way'' he would have treated her as anything more than a good lieutenant.
 
* Parodied in [[Majin Tantei Nougami Neuro]], where Neuro is constantly cruel to Yako for no good reason, and this is supposed to hint towards romantic relations between the two characters, as well as being played for laughs.
* [[Death Note|Light Yagami]] definitely qualifies; the only reason he enters any sort of relationship with Misa is because she has her own Death Note and is wildly, cultishly in love with him. He really doesn't seem to give a crap about her other than that, and, in fact, is as willing to cruelly use her as a pawn as he is any stranger on the street. The only time he (pretends to) show any affection for her is when she's angry at him, or he wants her to do something. If Misa hadn't started with the infatuation, there's ''no way'' he would have treated her as anything more than a good lieutenant.
** His treatment of his ''other'' girlfriend/lieutenant, Kiyomi Takada. It's more or less canon that they ''have'' had sex at least once, he manipulates her almost as much as he uses Misa as well, and ''unlike'' in Misa's case, {{spoiler|he callously disposes of her by using a piece of the Death Note to force Takada to burn herself to death as a part of his plan. Right after the girl had not only killed Mello for him, but was naked and frightened and trapped inside a truck, actually ''begging him to help her'' since she genuinely believes in him. [[Base Breaker|It doesn't matter if you liked her or not]], that '''was''' a [[Moral Event Horizon|horrifyingly cruel move]] from Light.}}
* Izaya from ''[[Durarara!!]]'' is an interesting take on the concept: he's not anyone's Bastard Boyfriend—he's ''everyone'''s bastard boyfriend. Specifically, he insists that he's madly in love with ''humanity'' despite (nay, ''because of'') [[Humans Are Bastardsthe Real Monsters|all of its flaws]], and demonstrates this "love" by [[Manipulative Bastard|trolling, manipulating, and generally dicking around with just about every person he meets]] [[Troll|to get the reactions from humanity he loves so much]]. He even gets possessive and jealous when he encounters something that might upset the balance of this relationship (like, say, a [[Yandere]] [[Evil Weapon|sword]] that ''also'' insists she's in love with all of humanity).
* Kouta from the one-shot manga ''Vitamin'' is like this. He says he loves his girlfriend Sawako and will stick by her, but he forces her into having sex and lies about being with her. Sawako eventually breaks up with him though.
 
== [[Fan WorkWorks]] ==
 
== Fan Work ==
 
* [[Yaoi Fangirl|Some]] [[Most Fanfic Writers Are Girls|fans]] love to turn Canon Characters into this trope, notably:
* Sasuke Uchiha from ''[[Naruto]]'', whether it's Yaoi, or Hetero. Can't be too hard to find.
* Seto Kaiba from ''[[Yu-Gi-Oh!]]'': [http://m31ru-ch4n.deviantart.com/art/TPNM-Cover-141912936 example].
** Also, try and find a [[Sharing a Body|Yami Bakura/Ryo Bakura]] fanfic that ''doesn't'' have Yami Bakura mentally or even physically abuse his poor suffering host (and giving him his own body just to make the latter possible). Go on. We'll wait.
*** ChallangeChallenge accepted. [http://sesshomaruswoman.deviantart.com/art/The-Possessed-Fanfic-Preview-245002178?q=gallery%3Asesshomaruswoman%2F9923519&qo=2 Behold,] a [[Portmanteau Couple Name|Tendershipping]] fic in which Ryo Bakura abuses his Yami!
* [[Draco in Leather Pants|Draco Malfoy]] in ''[[Harry Potter (novel)|Harry Potter]]'' fanfic.
** Sirius Black seems to get this interpretation as well in some fics, particularly the [[Ho Yay|Sirius/Remus]] ones.
* [[Anti-Hero|Edmund Pevensie]], from ''[[Chronicles of Narnia]]'', is portrayed as this in some fics, especially the [[Brother-Sister Incest|Edmund/Lucy]] ones. Well, it's not that hard to see him that way since he practically [[Kids Are Cruel|torments and mocks the poor girl]] for pretty much the entire first book. So it's almost [[canon]]... without the [[Slash Fic|slash]] part, of course.]]
** Although the second book prominently shows that he learned from his mistakes and is Lucy's strongest supporter when she keeps talking about seeing Aslan, the movie version still likes to portray him as [[The Dark Side|dark]] to an extent, due to his [[Deadpan Snarker|snarkiness]] and witty character. They even switched his and Capian's lines from the book, because, while Caspian was supposed to be tempted by evil in the third movie, they gave this role to Edmund and made him look like a jerk again when he fell into temptation for the second time, even though it was for a short period of time. That's why many fans still see him as the [[Anti-Hero|bad one]]. And the Bastard Boyfriend title is easily used when it comes to Edmund Pevensie.
* Craig Tucker from ''[[South Park]]'' is portrayed as this in most fics, particularly the [[Ho Yay|Craig/Tweek]] ones, since he is...let's say, [[Anti-Hero|not quite]] [[Deadpan Snarker|a pleasant]] [[The Stoic|character]]. In most stories, he either acts like a jerkass towards everyone, a bully, a sociopath or he just does anything to obtain what he wants, using methods [[Memetic Molester|like rape or molestation]].
Line 142 ⟶ 141:
* Ulquiorra Schiffer in ''[[Bleach]]'' is transformed into this in [[Fanon]], particularly in some Ulquiorra/Orihime fics. This is usually featured along with [[Die for Our Ship]], most likely towards Orihime for not expressing romantic feelings towards him in canon. [[Flame War|And let's just leave it at that.]]
 
== [[Literature]] ==
 
* The sheik from ''[[The Sheik]]'': causing an entire generation of girls to swoon at the thought of being kidnapped and raped by a hot Arabian prince. (That [[Fetish Fuel]] was the intention is made transparent by the book's final pages, in which, {{spoiler|in a fit of conscience, he decides to send her away so he won't hurt her anymore, and the heroine threatens to kill herself}}. The fact that [[The Film of the Book]] starred [[Mr. Fanservice|Rudolph Valentino]] helped.
== Literature ==
* It has been [[Alternative Character Interpretation|HEAVILY''heavily'' argued]] that ''[[Twilight (novel)|Twilight]]''{{'}}s Edward Cullen is an unintentional Conflicted type example of this trope. Jacob also [[Derailing Love Interests|gets warped]] into this in the third book. To add irony, it took Jacob becoming a Bastard Boyfriend for Bella to realize she has feelings for him.
* The sheik from ''[[The Sheik]]'': causing an entire generation of girls to swoon at the thought of being kidnapped and raped by a hot Arabian prince. (That [[Fetish Fuel]] was the intention is made transparent by the book's final pages, in which, {{spoiler|in a fit of conscience, he decides to send her away so he won't hurt her anymore, and the heroine threatens to kill herself}}. The fact that [[The Film of the Book]] starred [[Mr. Fanservice|Rudolph Valentino]] helped.
* It has been [[Alternative Character Interpretation|HEAVILY argued]] that ''[[Twilight (novel)|Twilight]]'''s Edward Cullen is an unintentional Conflicted type example of this trope. Jacob also [[Derailing Love Interests|gets warped]] into this in the third book. To add irony, it took Jacob becoming a Bastard Boyfriend for Bella to realize she has feelings for him.
* The ''[[Wicked Lovely]]'' series has Irial, who is incredibly emotionally abusive to Leslie, but is still hot. One reviewer describes their connection as 'Destructive yet seductive'.
** Don't forget his relationship with Niall in the past, after the whole ultimatum.
Line 155 ⟶ 153:
* Nagasawa to Hatsumi in ''[[Norwegian Wood]]''. She puts up with him throughout most of the book despite his casual cheating and bad treatment of her.
* The knight Erlend exhibits this behavior to the teenage girl Kristin in the trilogy ''Kristin Lavransdatter'', set in the Middle Ages. Played straight in the first book, where Kristin falls in love with Erlend, breaks her engagement with her [[Nice Guy]] fiance, and defies the will of her father to be with him, all despite his shady past and his none-too-kind treatment of her. Deconstructed in the two later books, set after Erlend and Kristin's marriage, where she has to live with the painful consequences of her decision, all in a highly patriarchial world that offers little support for women.
* ''[[The Phantom of the Opera]]'': in the original book by Gaston Leroux, Erik (the titular phantom) could be a [[Deconstruction]], if not an [[Unbuilt Trope]]: Erik is [[The Grotesque]] [[Psychopathic Manchild]] who terrorizes Christine [[And Now You Must Marry Me|into marrying him]]. In the book, the author wants you to think Erik's a [[Jerkass]] and Christine is a saint for putting up with him ([[Domestic Abuser]] meets [[Love Martyr]]), but the [[Misaimed Fandom]] (and [[Lost in Imitation|all the adaptations]]) wants you to think Erik's totally hot and the relationship is [[Corrupt the Cutie|deliciously kinky]].
 
== [[Music]] ==
 
== Music ==
* The lyrics of the song "El duelo" by Chilean group ''La Ley'' seems to be written from the POV of a Bastard Boyfriend.
* "Why Don't You Get A Job?" by [[The Offspring]] gender flips this trope first, and plays it straight in the second half of the song.
* ''[[The Rolling Stones|"Under My Thumb]]''" by [[The Rolling Stones]] comes off as a celebration of this, highlighted in its use in ''[[Scott Pilgrim Versus the World|Scott Pilgrim vs. The World]]''.
 
== [[Video Games]] ==
 
== Video Games ==
* Eldoth to Skie in ''[[Baldur's Gate]]''. He's a blatantly sleazy, chauvinistic [[Jerkass]] who embodies the selfish nature of his [[Neutral Evil]] alignment. The only reason he elopes with Skie is so that he can blackmail her father by claiming he kidnapped her. He is only able to get away with this because Skie is just that naive and foolish and thinks he is romantic.
* Damien has at least significant shades of the conflicted version in ''[[Magical Diary: Horse Hall]]'', considering that he jerks you around for most of the year, culminating in breaking your heart {{spoiler|and trying to kill you by way of stealing your soul}}. The ''only'' way to get any of his endings - not even just the good one - is to tell him that you love him no matter what and then forgive him for what he did when he shows up again. Your roomies, however, ''will'' call you out on being a [[Love Martyr]] if they find out that you've taken him back, though. {{spoiler|And by using Spirit Echoes and Empathy, you can find out that he has genuinely fallen in love with you and really does want to reform. But if you haven't been working on White magic, you might be left wondering how long it will be before he turns on you again.}}
* Lahmu from ''[[Shin Megami Tensei|Shin Megami Tensei V]]'' acts like one of these to Sahori. While he leads Sahori to believe that he loves her, in reality he doesn’t see her as her own person, and aside from possessing her body in order to gain greater power, he wishes to corrupt Sahori into more or less being a demon like himself.
 
== [[Visual Novels]] ==
* The love/hate routes of the otome game ''[[Under the Moon]]'' plays off this trope. The love interests begin the game on the fence about how to treat the heroine. The player's choices push them in one of two directions: towards "pure love" routes or "love/hate" routes. "Pure love" is [[Exactly What It Says on the Tin]]. In "love/hate", on the other hand, the guys give in to [[Romanticized Abuse|"romantic" abuse]] inclinations that generally include rape.
* Nakajima in ''[[Gakuen Heaven]]'', in his route.
 
== [[Web OriginalComics]] ==
* Although the story's only two chapters in, and there seems to be more to be revealed where he's concerned, [[Meaningful Name|Cain]] of the ''Starfighter'' webcomicweb comic plays this one straight from the get-go. His idea of an icebreaker with his new navigator/roomie Abel is to bite Abel's lip so hard that he leaves a permanent scar, announce that Abel is now his bitch, and alternately threaten and sexually harrass him (sometimes both at once). Give Abel his due, though, despite his occasional emotional moments, he's a lot more assertive about not taking Cain's shit than most of the [[Love Martyr]]s listed here.
** "The one with the scar... Don't look at him, don't touch him... ... And don't fucking talk to him!" [[Exactly What It Says on the Tin|Self Explanatory]].
 
== Webcomics [[Web Original]] ==
* Although the story's only two chapters in, and there seems to be more to be revealed where he's concerned, [[Meaningful Name|Cain]] of the ''Starfighter'' webcomic plays this one straight from the get-go. His idea of an icebreaker with his new navigator/roomie Abel is to bite Abel's lip so hard that he leaves a permanent scar, announce that Abel is now his bitch, and alternately threaten and sexually harrass him (sometimes both at once). Give Abel his due, though, despite his occasional emotional moments, he's a lot more assertive about not taking Cain's shit than most of the [[Love Martyr]]s listed here.
** "The one with the scar.. Don't look at him, don't touch him.. .. And don't fucking talk to him!" [[Exactly What It Says on the Tin|Self Explanatory]].
 
 
== Web Original ==
* [[Ask That Guy With The Glasses]]'s sexual sadism towards [[Depraved Bisexual|everyone]] he meets is very often played for [[Fan Service]].
 
Line 192 ⟶ 187:
[[Category:Boys Love Tropes]]
[[Category:Turn-On Tropes]]
[[Category:Bastard Boyfriend]]
[[Category:No Real Life Examples, Please]]
[[Category:Abuse Tropes]]
[[Category:The Jerk Index]]
[[Category:Alliterative Trope Titles]]
[[Category:Bastard Boyfriend{{PAGENAME}}]]