Everybody Hates Hades: Difference between revisions

m
clean up
No edit summary
m (clean up)
Line 1:
{{trope}}
[[File:rsz_hades_hate_2965rsz hades hate 2965.jpg|frame|'''Left''': Hades, from [[Classical Mythology]]. [[Licked by the Dog|Animal Lover.]]<br />'''Right''': Hades, from Disney's ''[[Hercules (Disney film)|Hercules]]''. [[Obviously Evil]].]]
 
{{quote|''"Oh and you think I enjoy this? I'm sick and tired of always being the bad guy! What I do has to be done!"''|'''Death''', ''[[Family Guy]]''}}
Line 22:
A [[Sub-Trope]] of [[Sadly Mythtaken]] and a form of [[Adaptational Villainy]]. Compare with [[Hijacked by Jesus]], when the similarities with Christianity are painfully obvious. Contrast with [[Don't Fear the Reaper]]. See [[Historical Villain Upgrade]] for when this is applied to historical rather than mythological figures. See also [[The Theme Park Version]] and occasionally [[Mythology Upgrade]].
 
Named after the [[Greek Mythology|Greek God of the Underworld, Hades]], who is often a victim of this in modern times.<ref>Probably the worst thing Hades did is kidnap his niece and maker her his wife. The tale of which is normally called "The Rape of Persephone". He did this with the approval of his brother Zeus, who among other things was the god of justice and a serial rapist. So while not a paragon of virtue by todays standards, if you use most other [[Jerkass Gods|greek gods]] as a baseline, he was a pretty nice dude.</ref>. In the original Hercules myth, Hera (Zeus's wife) was the antagonist, because Hercules was the product of Zeus's... um... "[[Anything That Moves|extra-marital activities]]". Poor Hades had nothing to do with the operation. [[Hercules (Disney film)|But that just wouldn't set well with Disney's lovely-lovely family image now, would it?]] Much easier to make the creepy death dude the bad guy.
 
{{examples}}
Line 28:
== Anime and Manga ==
 
* Both ''[[Mazinger Z]]'', ''[[Great Mazinger]]'' and ''[[Shin Mazinger Shougeki! Z-hen]]'' involve [[Greek Mythology]], and Hades is the villain. In ''Shin'', Mazinger Z [[Rocket Punch|Rocket Punches]]es him in the face. Zeus does like-wise with ''his severed arm''.
* Hades is a major antagonist in the ''[[Saint Seiya]]'' anime/manga series. His "evil" is apparently off the charts.
* '[[Astro Boy (manga)|Astro Boy]]'': [[Anti-Villain|Pluto]], of pretty much every incarnation, including one where he's the [[Pluto|title character]].
Line 42:
* Played dreadfully straight by the [[Marvel Universe]] version of Hades, who's referred to by his Roman name of Pluto. Pluto has earned the enmity of both [[The Incredible Hercules]] and [[The Mighty Thor]], and has been shown as trying to overthrow Zeus and seize control of the Greek pantheon for himself.
** This is also the case of [[The Mighty Thor|Hela]], the Norse goddess of the dead (well, the dead who didn't die in heroic battle, anyway). Sometimes it is justified, as she on occasions took the role of a villain and tried to take over Valhalla (the Norse equivalent of heaven), but it still doesn't justify the hatred she gets when she only tries to care for the souls under her charge.
* Other Marvel characters subvert this. The Marvel universe contains the embodiment of Death, who is often depicted as [[True Neutral]] -- she—she takes ''all'' life, good or bad (as she told [[New Mutants|Danielle Moonstar the Valkyrie]], who said "you cause pain!" -- "and end it."), though has ordered the deaths of billions just to take back the balance. Hela (The Norse goddess of the Dead) is more or less neutral as well, though she leant towards evil back in the day, and selfishly punished Thor several times for perceived slights; however, its her fathr Loki who is the ''actual'' Asgardian [[God of Evil]], and they don't get along ''at all''. There are also other "reapers" in the MU that aren't really evil, like Doorman from the Great Lakes Avengers.
** Also, in [[The Thanos Imperative]], we see a dimension literally without Death (Somehow, someone managed to kill ''her'', and [[Cosmic Horror|it's not pretty]].
* ''[[The Sandman]]'' averts this, with a [[Perky Goth]] Death who is arguably [[Neutral Good]] (or a sunny [[True Neutral]] at worst). She used to be a lot more [[Incredibly Lame Pun|grim]], but now that she spends one day per century as a mortal, she seems rather fond of people. However, she shares [[The DCU|a universe]] ([[Vertigo Comics|tenuously]], anyway) with [[Blackest Night|Nekron]], who plays this trope straight. Debate still rages on which is the "true" Death.
Line 84:
* Averted by [[Piers Anthony]] in ''On A Pale Horse'', in which Death/Thanatos is not only a human being tapped to fulfill a necessary duty, but is actually the protagonist and one of the nicest characters in the [[Incarnations of Immortality|Incarnations]] series.
* ''[[The Silmarillion]]'': [[Zig-Zagging Trope|Played around with]] with Mandos. While he's completely in line with the will of Eru Iluvatar (like the rest of the Valar), he tends to be a little harsh regarding the interpretation, something of a "devil's advocate".
** Basically, Mandos is a fairly standard "grim, gloomy, fatalistic, but not that bad of a sort" death god, and is portrayed as being without mercy but also without malice. ''Morgoth'', Middle-earth's actual [[God of Evil]], is also associated with death, but he's more accurately the god of the ''fear of'' death (among other things), rather than death itself. Indeed, ''natural'' death is called the "Gift of Men" and is supposed to be a blessing--asblessing—as the Elves would tell you [[Who Wants to Live Forever?|immortality isn't all it's cracked up to be]].
* In ''[[Discworld/Mort|Mort]]'' when Death is testing out the pleasures of being human, he allows himself to get drunk at which point he starts drunkenly moping about how everyone hates him and he has no friends. Death is portrayed as being incredibly lonely.
** Discworld's Death in general is a pretty nice guy, likes humanity, and is [[Discworld/Hogfather|usually on the hero's side]] or [[Discworld/Reaper Man|one of the main heroes himself.]] [[Discworld/Thief of Time|He even convinced the other Horsemen to ride out for humanity instead of against it once.]]
Line 102:
** Though Pluto/Hades wasn't an evil deity per se, but invoking his name was an extreme taboo, only done when swearing an unbreakable oath. Vorenus basically declares himself utterly relentless and merciless, as well as desperate enough to call upon the Stygian deity.
* ''[[Hercules: The Legendary Journeys]]'' and ''[[Xena: Warrior Princess]]'': Completely averted. Hades is one of the nicest gods in the pantheon, and except for that one early bit with Persephone, tries to help out his nephew when he shows up to [[Death Is Cheap|turn those revolving doors]]. It's just, well, there are rules to follow. They also show that the underworld is ''not'' the equivalent of the Christian Hell. Yes, souls are being tortured, but if they truly repent, then they will be sent to the Elysian Fields instead, which is their version of Paradise. This is shown to happen to Iolaus' father, whose soul admits to his son that he was wrong in focusing on his military career instead of his family. Hades, who is present, immediately offers to transfer him to the Elysian Fields.
* ''[[Charmed]]'' never used Hades (except for a rather dishonorable mention as the father of the demon Nikos in the novel), but Hecate, another underworld god(dess), came off particularly badly, being [http://charmed.wikia.com/wiki/Hecate turned into a demon]. (Way to go, [[Did Not Do the Research|have witches fight the matron of witches]].) Yama also got this treatment, becoming the totally amoral gatekeeper of Chinese hell who tried to snatch whatever spirits were not "properly buried" and drag them to hell, regardless of whether they were good or evil.<br /><br />The Angel of Death on the other hand, is portrayed more or less sympathetically, especially during his first appearance. He does his job in ensuring that everyone dies at the appropriate time. If somebody who ''must'' die does not, it will cause the natural flow of death to halt and put the entire world in chaos.
 
The Angel of Death on the other hand, is portrayed more or less sympathetically, especially during his first appearance. He does his job in ensuring that everyone dies at the appropriate time. If somebody who ''must'' die does not, it will cause the natural flow of death to halt and put the entire world in chaos.
* ''[[Stargate SG-1]]'': Though none of them are actually the gods they've adopted the personae of, Anubis of the Goa'uld is considered the most evil of the bunch.
* ''[[Buffy the Vampire Slayer]]'':
** Mostly averted with Osiris. Sure, resurrecting Buffy involved a dark, creepy ritual involving baby deer's blood and vomiting up snakes, but Osiris himself doesn't seem like such a bad guy in his brief on-screen appearance. Just a bit of a stickler for rules.
** Also averted with Hecate who is [[Shown Their Work|portrayed favorably in this show as the patron deity of witches]].
* ''[[Smallville]]'', on the other hand, did an episode where Lois got possessed by Isis and tried to bring Osiris back into the world -- whichworld—which, despite him being the just ruler of the dead, was treated as a very bad thing.
** Although it wasn't a very bad thing because Osiris himself was bad, it was a very bad thing bercause calling him up would bring the Underworld into the real world.
* ''[[The Twilight Zone]]'' played this straight and subverted it, depending on the episode. If it was [[Don't Fear the Reaper|death personified]], he was usually nice and just wanted to help people move on but was feared. When someone made a [[Deal with the Devil]], he was usually trying to create an [[Fate Worse Than Death|ironic fate]] with an overconfident person.
Line 120 ⟶ 122:
** But Hades couldn't have been hated that much his wife was goddess of springtime and flowers plus Hades was god of Precious metals meaning both of them must've been worshiped a lot.
** Hell, Disney didn't exactly start making him outright evil - you can really blame [[The Dung Ages|Medieval Christians]] for their common practice of demonizing pagan deities. Hades had his name lent to Hell, while aspects of Pan were put into [[Satan|the Devil himself]].
*** Some other common "demons", such as Baal, Dagon and Beelzebub, were demonizations of Semitic deities. Beelzebub and Ba'al were both corruptions of the same god, in fact! Dagon's demonization is a fair bit more recent, and comes from the pen of [[H.P. Lovecraft]], who made him into one of the [[Eldritch Abomination|Eldritch Abominations]]s of the [[Cthulhu Mythos]].
* Egyptian mythology presents two good examples in the form of Seth, god of the desert. The portrayal of Seth as a demonic figure was actually a political response to the unification of the Upper and Lower Kingdoms. As the Upper Kingdom, represented by Seth, resisted the union their patron's name was smeared and his darker aspects were emphasized in later myths; this is what inspired modern depictions. However, while Seth was jealous of his brother Horus' position and a harbinger of doom with no love for humans, he would help the other gods and play a key role in defeating Apophis, the actual devil-equivalent. This makes him one of the earliest mythological [[Anti-Hero|Anti-Heroes]]es.
** Anubis, god of the afterlife, has also gotten the [[Villain Ball]] more often in the recent years. Considering his position as a neutral entity interested only in ensuring proper administration of the deceased, this is completely out of character.
** Some mythologists actually theorize that Loki, the default [[Big Bad]] of [[Norse Mythology]], got hit with this as soon as Vikings started embracing Christianity - unfortunately, this was around the same time the Vikings started ''writing down their mythology.''
Line 136 ⟶ 138:
*** Orcus is actually the Roman name for Thanatos, but it's pretty much the same anyway.
**** Not so, Thanatos was the Greek god of DEATH, not of the DEAD, as in Thanatos was the god of the act or action, the moment of death, Hades was the lord of the Underworld, where the dead stayed after their lives ended.
* ''[[Scion]]'': Utterly averted -- Hadesaverted—Hades is presented as he is in the myths - probably [[Only Sane Man|the only level-headed person in the Dodekatheon]]. Aside from mild tendencies towards greed and [[Pluto Is Expendable|irritation at being a "dwarf planet"]], he's an all right guy. On the other hand, Miclantehcuhtli of the Atzlanti is portrayed as being evil in a spiteful, petty bureaucrat sort of way; Hel of the Norse Aesir is cold, cruel and unfeeling, and the Ragnarok supplement mocks players who want to make her happy through the power of true love (although it does leave open the possibility); and Izanami of the Amatsukami torments other gods and Scions for being unable to save her from her tortured and rotten state as ruler of the Japanese underworld. All of these are pretty close to their respective myths, no less. White Wolf likes to do the research.
* The ''[[Fighting Fantasy]]'' universe has Death as the ultimate [[God of Evil]], with his brothers Disease and Decay just a step behind him in power.
* The ''[[Freedom City]]'' setting for ''[[Mutants and Masterminds]]'' has Hades as a criminal mastermind trying to extend his reach on Earth, complete with an invasion by the forces of Tartarus back in the Silver Age. For bonus point, [[Hollywood Voodoo|Baron Samedi]] is also a douchenozzle in setting, though that may have something to do with his choice of mount.
* Palladium's ''[[Rifts]]'' is particularly bad about this. Here's a breakdown by pantheon:
** '''Aztec''': Predictably, the cultural [[Values Dissonance]] wreaks havoc. With the exception of Quetzalcoatl and his pal/sidekick Xolotl, the entire pantheon is made up of [[Complete Monster|Complete Monsters]]s and a few gods who feel they don't have a choice in following them. Mictlan, the lord of the dead (well, [[Did Not Do the Research|it's actually the name of the underworld]], but by this point, who cares, right?) deserves special mention, as it's the [[Eldritch Abomination]] co-ruler of Hades (the place, which is crawling with [[Our Demons Are Different|a bunch of demon races]]; Hades the god rules another chunk of it) with fellow abomination Modeus.
** '''Babylonian''': Apsu (an obscure water god mentionned in the [[Enuma Elish]] as Tiamat's husband) is a titanic, even-more-overpowered-than-usual [[Cosmic Horror]] [[Sealed Evil in a Can|sealed]] just prior to the gods' rebellion; Ereshkigal (goddess of the dead) and her husband Nergal (god of the sun and destruction; both rule over the underworld) are secretly but gleefully on Apsu and Tiamat's side and wait for the moment when they can rejoin them and destroy th rest of the pantheon.
** '''Egyptian''': Anubis is [[The Dragon]] within the Pantheon of Taut (the "evil" half of the pantheon, led of course by Set), who for lack of other evil forces besides Apep/Apophis had to be filled with other rather ridiculous choices such as [[wikipedia:Anhur|Anhur]] (who's there mostly because of [[Honor Before Reason]]), [[wikipedia:Bes|Bes]] (who supposedly became an evil psycho sometime in the past), and [[wikipedia:Amun|Amon]] ([[Gender Bender|who's now a woman]] who became [[Beauty Equals Goodness|evil and ugly]] pretty much "just because").
** '''Greek''': Ironically, Hades gets off the easiest, coming off mostly as a [[Jerkass]] [[Knight Templar]]; Ares is a bullying jerk, but that's pretty much the same as in actual myth. Hera is basically a [[Soap Opera]]-style Queen Bitch who's finally gone insane from Zeus' philandering, and is actively fomenting strife between Olympus and other pantheons, as well as thinking about [[Sealed Evil in a Can|freeing the Titans]]. The Titans themselves are either [[Eldritch Abomination|Eldritch]] or [[Humanoid Abomination|Humanoid Abominations]]s - Cronos is a black blob of eyes and tentacles who created the first olympian gods as edible power batteries, and Hecate, while more or less human in appearance, is a ruthless power-hungry pragmatist who's mercenary enough to deal with the Splugorth (a ''species'' of eldritch abominations whose [[Planet of Hats|hat]] is being [[Corrupt Corporate Executive]] imperialistic slave-traders).
** '''Norse''': Mostly untouched (Loki's a bad guy, of course), but Hel (goddess of the dishonorable dead)'s bad side is turned [[Up to Eleven]]: She's an [[Ax Crazy]] [[Omnicidal Maniac]] who wants to ally herself with the Mechanoids (think [[Doctor Who|Daleks Lite]]) to exterminate all humanoid life in [[The Multiverse]].
** '''Hindu''': Of course, Kali gets the full treatment ([[Ax Crazy]] [[Blood Knight]] who betrayed the pantheon to the aforementionned Splugorth [[For the Evulz]]), but then so does Yama, god of death (psychopathic, sadistic [[Omnicidal Maniac]]; notice a pattern yet?). Even Varuna is a bitter [[Bitch in Sheep's Clothing]] who'll stoop to any level to get back his former power.
** '''Maya''': Barely touched upon, but all we see (the lords of the underworld of Xibalba and bat-god Camazotz) are basically demon lords.
** And then there's a bunch of pretenders and impostors passing themselves for existing legitimate gods, usually for less-than-virtuous reasons, many of whom are actually [[Eldritch Abomination|Eldritch Abominations]]s (notice another pattern?)
 
== Theater ==
 
* Subverted in Stephen Sondheim's ''The Frogs.'' [http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8xeTSecKRho Listen for yourself].
* The main antagonist of ''[[Once On This Island]]'' is Papa Ge, a Vodou Loa associated with death whom the actual lore seems to portray as [[wikipedia:Gu%C3%A9d%C3%A9Guédé|a pretty decent guy]] (at least as far as [[The Other Wiki]] can be trusted on the subject).
** Even in the play's storyline, this trope is played with- Papa Ge is implied to just do his job and isn't entirely evil. He even hangs out with the three other gods like good friends.
{{quote|''And Papa Ge was gentle, as he carried her to shore...''}}
Line 173 ⟶ 175:
* {{spoiler|Izanami}} is revealed to be a villain in ''[[Persona 4]]''. Somewhat appropriate in that she ''is'' kind of a villain in Shinto myth.
* Meanwhile, [[Persona 3]] has a rather interesting take on the trope. {{spoiler|While Death is responsible for causing [[The End of the World as We Know It]], it's not actually a ''malevolent'' being, as seen with Pharos and Ryoji. Nyx will only initiate the Fall as long as people keep wishing for death.}}
** And even then {{spoiler|s/he doesn't want to. S/he was content with sleeping away until a bunch of [[Death Seeker|Death Seekers]]s in the Kirijo Group wanted to end the world. Only the [[Heroic Sacrifice]] of Yukari's father and the Main Character buys enough time for humanity to get its shit together.}}
** Flat-out averted in [[Persona 2]] - Hades is the Ultimate Persona of one of the characters.
* Played with in ''[[Age of Mythology]]''. While some of the villains will choose to worship him early in the campaign, Hades himself never shows up. Also the real villains are {{spoiler|Poseidon}}, who actually ''did'' try to overthrow Zeus in the myths, and {{spoiler|Kronos}}.
Line 179 ⟶ 181:
** The first ''may'' come from Pluto's other portfolio, being the god of wealth. This doesn't make the game's [[They Just Didn't Care|butchering of the rest of Greek mythology]] any more sensible, though.
** In ''Kid Icarus Uprising'', {{spoiler|Hades makes his debut as the ''true'' leader of the Underworld Army. Thanatos, the actual god of ''Death'', shows up as well, but Hades manages to both outrank and out-evil Thanatos. His only motivation for anything he does in the game is to cause death and destruction to expand his realm}}.
* ''[[Shin Megami Tensei]] [[Devil Survivor]]'' has Yama, Buddhist judge of the underworld, making a contract with one of the people inside the Tokyo Lockdown. He reveals himself to be a [[Hanging Judge]] to whom [[All Crimes Are Equal]] (and death being the only sentence). To be fair, though, we only see him interact with people guilty of crimes like murder, abuse of authority and similar -- hesimilar—he ignores the party, who are not guilty of anything, until you attack him.
* ''[[King's Quest]]'': Both Samhain in ''[[King's Quest VI]]'' and Lord Azriel in ''[[King's Quest: Mask of Eternity|King's Quest Mask of Eternity]]'' avert this Trope. They are quite helpful once the heroes are able to prove themselves worthy of their assistance.
* An in-universe example actually happens in ''Pokémon'': While Darkrai is normally portrayed as a rather decent creature despite having a bad reputation due to it's tendency to create nightmares (it only does this if threatened in any way, the [[Pokémon (anime)|anime]] actually averted this by making one such member of this species the hero of [[Pokémon: The Rise of Darkrai|one of its films]]), in the ''[[Pokémon Mystery Dungeon Explorers]]'' games, {{spoiler|he's the [[Big Bad]], and is [[Complete Monster|pure evil.]] He even tries to kill the main characters over the course of the games!}}
10,856

edits