Ignored Expert: Difference between revisions

removed excess boldface on title drops
(link markup, copyedits)
(removed excess boldface on title drops)
Line 4:
The scientific subtrope of [[Cassandra Truth]], the '''Ignored Expert''' is a scientist or expert who predicts a major disaster to happen, but is not believed by his contemporaries.
 
No matter [[The Professor|how qualified]] he is and how urgent and relevant his expertise is to the problem at hand, his warnings will be treated like [[They Called Me Mad|madness]] or [[Cassandra Truth|lies]]. The '''Ignored Expert''' will be [[Department of Redundancy Department|ignored]] by [[Muggles|his peers]], or [[All of the Other Reindeer|reviled and ridiculed]] regardless of evidence, credibility or persuasiveness. If he's lucky, he'll manage to persuade a philanthropist to help, or make [[The Hero]] aware of the problem. In extreme cases, he will be fighting nearly alone to stop (or at least expose and delay) a nigh unstoppable disaster. His situation isn't helped if he has a reputation as (or is) an [[Agent Mulder]].
 
In natural [[Disaster Movie|disaster movies]] or [[Science Is Bad]] stories, expect the '''Ignored Expert''' to be the [[Only Sane Man|lone voice of sanity]] warning against a particular course of action that will, of course, be taken. That action could be entrusting the [[A.I. Is a Crapshoot|newborn AI]] with control over [[Nuke'Em|nuclear missiles]], releasing [[The Virus]] in a field test, administering [[Super Serum]] to criminals, or the use of machines [[Powered by a Forsaken Child]].
 
If the '''Ignored Expert''' himself created the phenomenon he is warning against, he's the [[Engineer Exploited For Evil]].
 
This trope was previously named after [[Superman]]'s father, Jor-El, a Kryptonian scientist whose dire warnings that their home planet [[Earthshattering Kaboom|would die]] were ignored. Famously, he managed to [[Fling a Light Into the Future|save his son]], Kal-El, by putting him on an escape pod and sending him to <s> Earth</s> [[Superman|one of the most successful media franchises in history]].
 
The '''Ignored Expert''' is very similar to [[The Cassandra]], but he also he has an impressive track record to back himself up. Of course, this doesn't help him one bit, and he can still be subject to [[Cassandra Did It]]. If the "expert" is someone totally unrelated to a situation who manages to notice something all the experts working on it have missed, he is an [[Einstein Sue]]. An "expert" whose credentials or expertise aren't too clear but is a [[Designated Hero]] nonetheless is [[The Worm Guy]].
 
Note that while this trope can be [[Truth in Television]] in certain cases, reality is always far more complex. Scientific discoveries need to be ''repeatedly'' proven experimentally, so there is a reluctance to immediately accepting new information as fact. The release of findings may also be subject to political pressure, and may thus be suppressed or heavily controlled for political or ideological reasons.