Muggles Do It Better: Difference between revisions

→‎Fan Works: potholes, added example
No edit summary
(→‎Fan Works: potholes, added example)
 
Line 39:
== [[Fan Works]] ==
* In [http://www.fanfiction.net/s/3735743/1/The_Moment_It_Began The Moment It Began], instead of being defeated by [[The Power of Love]], Lord Voldemort, the most powerful Dark Wizard in the world, is defeated... {{spoiler|by Snape's Muggle father Tobias and his trusty handgun.}}
* This is one of the running themes of ''[[Harry Potter and the Methods of Rationality|Harry Potter And The Methods Of Rationality]]'' where Harry has learned all about the scientific method and critical thinking before going to Hogwarts.
** The series plays with it a ton. While the magical world rarely if ever applies the scientific method to magic, just like in canon, that's because sometimes [[Magic Versus Science|science doesn't]] [[Wild Magic|work on magic]]. But once in a while characters find out that it ''does'' work, which usually leads to an [[Awesome Moment]].
* This is the [[Anvilicious|Anvil]] in ''[[The Return (fanfic)|The Return]]'' The Demons and [[Eldritch Abomination]]s have all these fantastic powers, but Humans have [[Humans Are Special|inventiveness]] and are much better at being [[Humans Are the Real Monsters|bastards]] and normal military tech more than levels the field.
* ''[http://www.fanfiction.net/s/2784825/1/Old_Soldiers_Never_Die Old Soldiers neverNever Die]'' is made of this trope. It's also doubly ironic because Voldemort was defeated almost entirely by a force of [[Badass Grandpa|80+ year old]] squib [[Retired Badass|veterans]] using technology that at its most modern dates back to [[World War Two]].
* Sort-of-done in ''[[My Immortal]]''. Instead of telling Ebony to kill Vampire/Harry via magical means, Vloxemort gives her a gun to shoot him. Of course, given [[Cloudcuckoolander|Tara]] [[The Ditz|Gilesbie]] hasn't displayed any real understanding of how the actual series ''works''...
* In ''[[Harry Potter and the Invincible Technomage]]'', Reed Richards of the [[Fantastic Four]] and Tony Stark ([[Iron Man]]) discover how [[Potter Verse]] magic works, and manage to make it work ''with'' their technology rather than against it (and Tony uses the magic as a cheap energy source for his various armours, such as the one he gives to Harry).
* The ''Book of Dobby'' by [[Doghead Thirteen]] (both [https://www.fanfiction.net/s/4571312/1/The-Book-of-Dobby-Per-Arcana-ad-Astra the original version] and [https://www.fanfiction.net/s/5093023/1/The-Book-of-Dobby-Reboot-Per-Arcana-ad-Astra the reboot]) focuses on Harry fighting the Death Eaters with [[World War II]] era bomber and fighter planes. Of course, he's basically going [[Magitek]], what with the dragon-hide coatings and the de-ruster spells and so forth, but it's the same idea.
* An example appears in ''[[Oh God, Not Again|Oh God Not Again]]'' to explain why Theodore, a Slytherin, is in Muggle Studies. When asked why he was there, Theodore noted that his father learned the hard-way that Muggles weren't as harmless as he thought after being shot on a trip to Las Vegas, and wanted his son to learn as much about Muggles as possible.
* Subverted by a few [[Heroic Bystander]]s who have tried to defend themselves with their guns in both the ''[[Ultimate Sleepwalker]]'' and ''[[Ultimate SpiderWoman: Change With the Light]]'' series, rather than waiting for the heroes to rescue them. Unfortunately, [[Failure Is the Only Option]] for these Muggles.
* Discussed in the ''[[The Familiar of Zero]]''/''[[Prototype (video game)|Prototype]]'' crossover ''[[Unfamiliar]]'', while magic can do many thing technology can't it's also [[Awesome but Impractical|inefficient]] for more [[Mundane Utility|mundane]] things. For example an earth mage can do the work of ten farming machines, however it takes years to train a earth mage whereas you can build farming machines in days.
* Subverted in some ''[[Axis Powers Hetalia]]'' fics involving human beings trying to take on the Nations themselves. As it turns out, all conventional weapons (whether it's a knife or a .50 caliber rifle) could do is simply stall them long enough for the Muggles to escape with their lives.
* Makes multiple appearances in the ''[[Harry Potter]]'' fic ''[[White Knight, Grey Queen]]'':
** The Parkinsons show no hesitation about using anything Muggle if it makes life more comfortable, convenient or profitable for them.
** Definitely in play in the final battle. Harry, Pansy and Ginny are all trained in firearms (and use them), and thanks to one of their trainers they are able to call in a platoon of British special forces to help take out Voldemort's non-human forces. And at the climax, Ginny, Pansy and the Marines using massed semi-auto rifle fire to bring down the shield Voldemort's shield.
 
== [[Film]] ==