Star Trek: The Next Generation/Headscratchers: Difference between revisions

Line 233:
**** Both men committed the same crime: ethnically cleansing an entire planet using illegal chemical weapons. Eddington did so to free his people, Sisko did so because Eddington was making him look bad.
**** Its important to note that neither Eddington or Sisko used the sort of chemical weapons that killed on contact. Lines of dialogue make it very clear that their attack will simply make it impossible for Cardassians or Humans to inhabit the affected worlds for several decades. Both populations have time to evacuate, and the Cardassians even are shown to be doing so--Eddington goes so far as to fire on one of the refugee ships as a distraction while he escapes. While its clear that both mens' actions are in fact crimes, these crimes are not on the order of mass murder.
***** Firing on, or even ''at'', a ship full of civilian refugees is a separate war crime all by itself and still puts Eddington distinctly on the moral low ground compared to Sisko.
 
== Data Can't Say Can't? ==