Unskilled but Strong: Difference between revisions

More entries
mNo edit summary
(More entries)
(12 intermediate revisions by 6 users not shown)
Line 2:
[[File:Trope - Unskilled But Strong 2 6669.jpg|link=Incredible Hulk|frame|Are you really going to criticize his poor form?]]
 
{{quote|''This is the dreaded Damien? He moves like an amateur! Wait... [[Playing with Fire|that fire]] could easily win him most fights, [[Healing Factor|he can regenerate]], and he's supposed to have [[Super Strength]]... he's never ''needed'' skill before! [[Superpower Lottery|His fighting style is totally dependent on his powers!]]''|'''Elliot, on [[Big Bad|Damien]]''', ''[[El Goonish Shive]]''}}
{{quote|''[[Superpower Lottery|Your speed and your strength makes you a beast at fighting! You might even be better than me at that... but you have no experience with fighting techniques!
I'am a [[The Gift|prodigy]], I can easily read the moves of an amateur like you]]''|'''[[Big Bad|Garou]] on [[The Hero|Saitama]]''', ''[[One Punch Man]]''}}
 
[[Exactly What It Says on the Tin|As the name implies]], this is the inverse of [[Weak but Skilled]].
 
A character who is '''Unskilled but Strong''' lacks the knowledgerefined ortechnique abilityof to properly use their powers or abilities informal combattraining, but compensates in various ways through raw power. They may [[Made of Iron|eat anti-tank missiles the way a glutton goes through an all-you-can-eat buffet.]] They may be [[Super Strength|so strong they kick tanks around like footballs]] or [[More Dakka|have the firepower to crush the US, China and Russia in a conventional conflict.]] They may [[Super Speed|make a Bugatti Veyron look slow]] or [[Super Reflexes|waltz through a]] [[Dodge the Bullet|point-blank crossfire of]] [[Gatling Good|Gatlings]] with ease that makes [[The Matrix|an Agent]] envious. They may have won the [[Superpower Lottery]]. However it is, they are [[The Gift|so very naturally talented]] they don't ''need'' skill. They tend to have the attitude that if brute force doesn't work, [[When All You Have Is a Hammer|it's just because]] they [[Gonna Need More Trope|didn't use enough of it.]]
 
When seen in a protagonist, their lack of skill is typically only because it's the first episode and they've only just discovered their powers. The initial stages of the series, if not the series as a whole, will then focus on improving the protagonist's innate talents. It also gives the series a justification for why a complete newbie to whatever power they've uncovered is able to fight with or against people who have more experience, or why they can come along in training relatively quickly. One common type of this is the [[Super Prototype]] that the [[Ordinary High School Student]] is [[Falling Into the Cockpit]] of.
Line 13 ⟶ 12:
In an antagonist, an Unskilled But Strong character is commonly either the very first foe the protagonist faces or one of the last. In the former case, they're a [[Starter Villain]] and may be fond of [[Badass Boast]]s but prove all talk in the face of the much more skilled protagonist. In the latter, they provide a hurdle against which the protagonist must disprove the theory that [[Hard Work Hardly Works]].
 
Compare [[Skilled but Naive]]. and contrastContrast [[Weak but Skilled]]. Often pursues a [[Bigger Stick]]. Can also overlap with [[Brilliant but Lazy]] (the character does possess some skill, but doesn't bother to use or hone it), or [[Incompletely Trained]] (the character had some formal training but not as much as the other characters), or sometimes both (the character neither wants to use or train more than he/she already did with his/her power). This character is often the Goliath in [[David Versus Goliath]]. Characters with explicitly superhuman abilities but with no real skill can leavehave this tropecured with [[Boxing Lessons for Superman]]. If they never get formal training but do become more proficient at using their powers and combat, they may instead be [[Taught By Experience]].
 
{{examples}}
Line 23 ⟶ 22:
* Many young heroes in the ''[[Gundam]]'' series are notably less skilled than their more experienced [[Ace Pilot]] adversaries, but manage to survive due to [[Falling Into the Cockpit]] of a [[Super Prototype]]. Generally, though, they survive enough battles through the series to become experienced and an ace in their own right.
** In a specific example, in [[Mobile Suit Gundam|the original series]], Amuro Ray (who's been piloting the Gundam for roughly a month and a half at this point) manages to defeat Ramba Ral, a veteran soldier who's been piloting a mobile suit since they were first introduced to the battlefield four years ago. Ral praises Amuro, but tells him not to get cocky, since it was the Gundam's power and not his own skill that won the day; Amuro just calls him a [[Sore Loser]].
* Berserker in ''[[Kenichi: The Mightiest Disciple]]'' is [[The Dragon]] to Odin in Ragnarok, despite not having any formal martial arts training like everyone else. He has his rank purely due to his natural talent as a fighter.
** A shadowy figure in the Yomi base hints that Berserker may be coming back, although without the "unskilled" part.
* Similarly, Bunshichi Tawara in ''[[Tenjho Tenge]]'' is reported to be entirely self-taught, but was able to defeat a powered up Shin Natsume in a fight.
* [[Blood Knight|Kenpachi]] from ''[[Bleach]]'' relies on raw power and bloodlust, and it works out quite well. No [[Super Mode|bankai]], no functional ''shikai'', no kido, no special techniques. He acquired his position simply by [[Klingon Promotion|killing his predecessor]]. His idea of a sword technique is ''[[Crowning Moment of Awesome|using both hands to hold his sword]]''—and when he does, {{spoiler|he ''easily'' defeats an opponent who had been fighting him to a standstill for several episodes}}. However, this gets downplayed throughout the series, in particular the manga, {{Spoiler|where he learns how to properly control his power and even gets access to his bankai=}}.
** Ichigo, as well. His incredibly high spiritual power is remarked upon from the very beginning, yet he is often completely outclassed by more experienced opponents. However, he relies on being [[Taught By Experience]], something remarked on multiple times in the series.
** Wonderweiss is so fast and strong that he can take on [[Badass Grandpa|Yamamoto]]. The old man complements his power, but quickly reveals that his vastly superior skill and experience is more than enough to turn the tide.
Line 30 ⟶ 31:
* ''[[Dragon Ball]]'' villains sometimes fell into this category. Pretty much all of them were highly-trained fighters, but often lacked knowledge of certain techniques. Freeza was one of the few villains who knew how to raise and lower his power level, but lacked knowledge on how to sense ki without a scouter. The over reliance on scouters caused his army to underestimate their enemies. A few like Fat Buu relied on raw power and healing to win.
** To expand, Freeza had spent so much time toying with opponents far weaker that he never learned how to stand up in a protracted battle against someone of equal strength. Once raw power was proven not to be enough, it was only a matter of time before the more highly trained (and now more powerful) Goku defeated him.
** This was also Piccolo's reasoning for training Gohan after witnessing Gohan's hidden power first hand against Radditz. Gohan gets better over the course of the series, becoming not only a powerful warrior but also an skilled martial artist.
* Yoshimori is this way in ''[[Kekkaishi]]'', although he's improving, in contrast to his [[Weak but Skilled]] counterpart, Tokine.
* Due to unusual circumstances ''[[Beet the Vandel Buster]]'' can use five of the powerful magical weapons called Saiga, when most individuals can use only one. However, early parts of the series are spent with Beet learning how to fully utilize his five Saiga and Beet has zero ability in the more basic magical skills which are supposed to be the lead up to obtaining a Saiga in the first place. One character even comments that he learns everything backwards.
Line 39 ⟶ 40:
* Takeshi Sendo from ''[[Hajime no Ippo]]''. His raw power and fighting instincts are top-notch. His biggest weakness is lack of technical skill.
** Subverted and played straight with Brian Hawk. It is the very lack of skillfull boxing that makes him so incredibly dangerous. He doesn't have the limits of the textbook boxing techniques and, combined with naturally insane power, speed and reflexes, becomed completely unpredictable. His fighting style is even described by his trainer as not being boxing but "simply violence." Takamura spends the first half of their fight trying to prove that boxing skill ''is'' of use. It is eventually played straight when Hawks trainer learns how very superior Takamura is through having learned the proper technique and how much of a backbone Brian Hawk lacks because of his lack of proper training.
* The eponymous girls in ''[[Zettai Karen Children]]'' are theoretically some of the most his powerful people in existence, but as otherwise ordinary ten-year-old girls their lack of training and experience means they sometimes struggle against [[Weak but Skilled]] opponents.
* ''[[Kinnikuman]]'s'' Buffaloman was not a great fighter at all until he made a [[Deal with the Devil]] and gained his ten million Choujin Power.
* Luffy's victory over Boa Sandersonia and Boa Marigold in ''[[One Piece]]'' falls into this. The sisters' mastery of [[Ki Attacks|Haki]] allows them to predict Luffy's movements and deflect his attack. Once Luffy goes into his Gear 2nd power-up, however he's able to move so fast that predicting him is useless and his attacks are powerful enough to overwhelm any attempt to block.
** In addition, Luffy doesn't really have any "training" (it's confirmed by Oda that he never actually trains outside battle) in his fighting style nor does he possess any skill with weapons or sword-fighting, he is just extremely creative with his rubber powers and makes up techniques on the spot.
** Furthermore, he has the same level of Haki that Hancock does, which is stronger than theirs, but can't control it and can't do anything more than render people without sufficient force of will unconscious. Luffy's shown occasional flashes of other types of Haki use (against Mihawk, he avoided losing a hand because he saw a flash of what Mihawk's next attack would be), but they too were uncontrolled and he didn't even seem to realize what had happened. [[Boxing Lessons for Superman|After training with Silvers Rayleigh, this has now changed as he's become both skilled AND strong.]]
** Zoro was also this to an extent in the earlier parts of the storyline, his idea of swordfighting being "Swing your swords at your opponent really, ''really'' hard until they stop moving". With his absurd [[Charles Atlas Superpower]], this worked pretty well... until he faced off against a guy with steel-hard skin who was basically immune to this strategy. Zoro got better about this after the experience.
**Post-timeskip, Luffy has received training by Rayleigh on his haki and rubber powers, but his overall fighting style is the same.
** Of the Post-[[Time Skip]] villains, {{spoiler|Hody Jones}} gets accused of this by Jimbei, who effortlessly blocks a powerful attack from him. He's also proven to be absolutely ''no'' match for Luffy whatsoever when they finally begin to throw down.
* Takashi Kawamura from ''[[Prince of Tennis]]''. He considers himself the burden of the Seigaku team, yet can fight [[Genius Bruiser]] Kabaji to a standstill. He then does it again, but against {{spoiler|Gin Ishida from Shitenhouji}}.
Line 62 ⟶ 63:
* Kouichi in ''[[Kurogane no Linebarrel]]'' is this [[Character Development|at first]]; most of his early victories are entirely due to Linebarrel being a [[Lightning Bruiser]], and he causes extreme amounts of collateral damage from inexperience. [[Weak but Skilled|Reiji]] points all of this out when ''he hands Kouichi his ass'' in the fourth episode of the anime.
* Yoshika from ''[[Strike Witches]]'' starts out as one of these, selected by Mio for her immense raw power. Her inability to focus her power causes problems early on.
* ''[[Holyland]]'':
** Yuu from ''[[Holyland]]'' starts out with only a one-two straight combo and no footwork or other technique. He gets better. The Strong part comes from how various more experienced fighters note that his raw power and speed are very high, while he also takes beatings that put down lesser men and keeps going.
** Katou also applies. Despite his lack of real training, he wins through brute strength, [[Combat Pragmatist|fighting dirty]] and drug-taking that makes him [[Feel No Pain]]. {{spoiler|He gets utterly destroyed later on when a MMA exponent decides to get serious.}}
* Noted by Touma during his first fight with Accelerator in ''[[ToA AruCertain Majutsu noMagical Index]]''. Accelerator's powers are among the most powerful in the series, but is at a bit of a loss when he can't just [[Curb Stomp Battle|curb stomp]] Touma like he has all his previous opponents.
{{quote|'''Touma:''' The strongest esper in Academy City... really has no skills at all, huh? Then grit your teeth, weakling. Because a punch [[Badass Normal|from the weakest]] ''[[Did You Just Punch Out Cthulhu?|is gonna hurt]]''.}}
** Touma himself is tough as nails and an experienced street fighter, but he gets his ass handed to him when he faces trained martial artists like Kaori and Motoharu.
Line 96 ⟶ 98:
* Whenever there is a [[Batman]]/[[Superman]] face off then Bats is the [[Weak but Skilled]], with Supes this trope.
** Superman is often subject to this. Other writers recall just ''how much time'' he has spent fighting other superpowered beings as strong or even stronger than he is, and decide he would probably be long dead if he charged at them all the time. This was spelled out with a fight between Superman and [[Evil Counterpart|Ultraman]], where Superman [[Curb Stomp Battle|squashed]] him because Ultraman's method of killing his enemies as soon as he could (as well as presumably sending out his minions) meant that he got very little practice fighting beings on his level.
*** Also Batman taught him some martial arts. And Ali gave [[Boxing Lessons for Superman]]
**Actually, and totally opposite to what many people think, Superman is not this trope (in the comics, at least). He's learned from every battle he's had with other equally-powerful supervillains, becoming an experienced and clever fighter. He's been learning his whole life how to control and use his powers efficiently, so he'd never hurt or kill any innocent bystander or enemy during his fights. Lastly, he's been trained by some of the best combatants and warriors on earth (Wonder Woman, Batman, Wildcat, among others) on hand-to-hand, so in any case he'd be depowered, he might be able to hold his own with his fighting skills alone.
*** One story even had him learning kriptonian martial arts.
***Also Ali gave [[Boxing Lessons for Superman]]
* Most of the Gauls in ''[[Asterix]]'' have shades of this, but Obelix is the only ''true'' example. Due to being permanently [[Super Strength|superpowered]], he hasn't even had the benefit of unpowered combat training the others had. This is demonstrated abundantly in the (non-canon) comic ''The Twelve Tasks of Asterix'', where one of the trials pits him and Obelix against a Germanic Judo-master. Obelix's attempts to smash through him with brute force are effortlessly redirected, and he quickly proves entirely unable to hurt the little man. Fortunately, Asterix is there to effectively ''talk'' the man into submission... or, rather, distract him with talk and an interest in the man's fighting style that gets the poor German to give Asterix instructions and allow himself to be used as a training dummy, realising he's helped Asterix subdue him only after having his arms and legs tied into knots.
* Galactus, at least in "Top Trumps". Super high stats in everything but weapon Skill. He doesn't seem to have much technique other than draining the enemy to death, but when you eat planets...
Line 151:
* The Evil Queen / Regina from ''[[Once Upon a Time (TV series)|Once Upon a Time]]'' is the [[Manipulative Bastard]] version of this. She's not very smart, and completely [[Genre Blind]]. But she has tools to make up for that—in the fairy tale realm her army and her magic, in the real world she can cower everyone with her status as mayor. With her hate driving her, she uses these to plow through any obstacle in her path.
* ''[[Kamen Rider Fourze]]'' protagonist Gentaro Kisaragi starts off like this, having no fighting skills when he [[Jumped At the Call|straps on the belt]] and starts fighting [[Monster of the Week|Zodiarts]]. This puts him at a disadvantage when he comes up against more skilled opponents, like the Unicorn Zodiarts (a member of the school's fencing club) and [[Second Rider|Kamen Rider Meteor]] (a practitioner of [[Bruce Lee|Jeet Kun Do]]). Eventually he [[Took a Level in Badass|takes a level in badass]] thanks to some training from his homeroom teacher Haruka Uesugi, who's a talented kickboxer.
* The title character of the South Korean series ''[[Strong Girl Bong-soon]]'' has literally [[Super Strength|superhuman strength]], from a divine gift granted to all the women in her family. She is so worried about losing it by violating the strictures on its use, though, that she does virtually nothing with it, let alone train in its use.
 
== New Media ==
* Draschine from ''[[Descendant of a Demon Lord]]'' has waved around a 2 handed sword using one hand. She also had a tendency to just swing the blade at opponents without even trying to make the edge concurrent with the swing and properly slice into the foe. Her skill has been improving as the story goes on.
 
== Sports ==
Line 182 ⟶ 185:
* {{spoiler|[[Runaway Brain|Julius]]}} as he appears in ''[[Kingdom Hearts 3D]]'' uses only punches, body slams, and charges for his attacks. However, the fact that he's a [[Bonus Boss]] in a ''[[Kingdom Hearts]]'' game should give you a good idea about how tough he is.
* ''[[Fire Emblem]]'': The Fighter and Warrior classes are the embodiment of this trope, with loads of raw strength and HP but poor speed and skill. This is further perpetuated in their battle animations, where half of the time they're practically stumbling over themselves. The fighter's axe and warrior's bow criticals, for example, consist of nothing more than the unit flailing his weapon around uselessly before attacking.
* ''[[Ryu ga Gotoku|Yakuza]] 0'' has the [[Four Is Death|Four]] Mr. Shakedowns. Tall as basketballers and built like houses, their attacks are highly telegraphed and theoretically easy to see coming. With damage that will defeat early-game Kiryu or Majima in one hit plus [[Finishing Stomp]] and boss-level health that leaves plenty of opportunities for players to make that one mistake, though, they don't need much finesse at all.
 
 
== Webcomics ==
Line 194 ⟶ 197:
* Bob the Beholder in ''[[Yet Another Fantasy Gamer Comic]]'' isn't terribly bright and lacks finesse. He succeeds at his tasks in spite of this because he's... [[Eye Beams|well, a beholder.]]
* Subverted in ''[[Spinnerette]]'', where the titular hero's [[Super Strength|spider strength]] is no match for a black belt in aikido.
* ''[[Girl Genius]]'' with Lucrezia, controlling Agatha's body, and got [http://www.girlgeniusonline.com/comic.php?date=20100224 enhanced] for a while, but still [http://www.girlgeniusonline.com/comic.php?date=20100308 fought to standstill with Zeetha] who ''was'' trained only because it prevents her from being knocked out.
 
== Web Original ==
Line 204 ⟶ 208:
== Western Animation ==
* Bamm-Bamm in ''[[The Flintstones]]''.
* [[Superboy]] in ''[[Young Justice (animation)|Young Justice]]'', who has halfall of Superman's powersstrength and speed but lacks the controldiscipline to use them to their full extent.
** It turns out that Megan's psychic powers are the same way, after {{spoiler|she accidentally causes a psychic simulation to go awry, ultimately putting the rest of the team into a coma}}. [[Martian Manhunter|J'onn]] speculates that she could be one of the most powerful Martian psychics ever.
** He is not a very good combatant neither. This is very well showed on his training fight with Black Canary, he is far stronger and faster than him, but she has far more training and ability at fighting unarmed. The fight is quick, and Superboy lands no hit on Black Canay, who doesn't even need to use her scream power to beat him up. He decides to train after that.
**It turns out that Megan's psychic powers are the same way, after {{spoiler|she accidentally causes a psychic simulation to go awry, ultimately putting the rest of the team into a coma}}. [[Martian Manhunter|J'onn]] speculates that she could be one of the most powerful Martian psychics ever.
* The ''[[Superfriends]]'' episode "The Evil From Krypton" featured a General Zod [[Captain Ersatz]] called Zy-Kree. He had all of Superman's powers, but no skill. [[Aquaman]] is able to hold his own and outmaneuver him with tactics. When he and Superman clash, Superman demonstrates that he actually knows how to fight, and pwns him before sending him back to the [[Phantom Zone]].
{{quote|'''Aquaman''': You did it! You defeated him!
Line 217 ⟶ 220:
{{quote|'''Katara:''' She's strong.
'''Other Master:''' She lacks restraint. }}
* In ''[[The Avengers: Earth's Mightiest Heroes]]'', Steve Rogers criticizes Tony Stark for this, saying Tony's primary solutions to battle include either tackling things or blasting them. Tony does not really appreciate the criticism.
 
== Real Life ==
* New military technology often came out before the tactics to use it were fully developed but sometimes it remains effective because of its sheer power. One of the most prominent examples is that commanders in [[World War I]] rarely knew how to use tanks effectively, but simply sending them forward to attack was incredibly potent. This is less common with modern technology as modern weapons design has hit a plateau without many entirely new innovations that actually work <ref>The 70 years following the introduction of smokeless powder first in 1847 saw the first modern cartridge appeared in 1869, the box magazine in 1879, the machine gun in 1883, the semi-automatic in 1892, chromed barrels in 1911 and the man portable full automatic in 1916 among many other innovations. By contrast the 70 years proceeding 2016 have largely been refinements of the existing concepts and failed experiments outside of optics and artillery, which don't require substantially different different tactics from their predecessors, and vehicles, which seem to be hitting similar plateaus</ref> and the modern R&D process has learned to include steps to avoid this.
* Computer hardware often falls into a similar problem where drivers and programs aren't yet optimized to the new hardware, but as new hardware it is still substantially more powerful than its predecessors.
* Despite what [[Never Bring a Knife to A Fist Fight]] might have led you to believe, it doesn't take much technique at all for someone to wildly swing a bat, knife or other melee weapon and still inflict injuries that demand medical attention, while the skill floor to win while unarmed and take minor or no injuries in the process is much higher. Any martial arts or other hand-to-hand training that's honest will tell you to run first thing if your opponent pulls a weapon.
 
{{reflist}}