Values Dissonance/Literature: Difference between revisions

Shooting a dangerous animal that has already killed at least one innocent person and is impossible to safely relocate is considered normal wildlife management even today, let alone back then.
m (update links)
(Shooting a dangerous animal that has already killed at least one innocent person and is impossible to safely relocate is considered normal wildlife management even today, let alone back then.)
Line 96:
** In a story from ''The Case-Book Of Sherlock Holmes'', a man confesses to concealing his sister's death so he can retain use of her properties long enough to clean up at the track. These days, his hiring someone to impersonate her smacks of identity theft, and would be prosecuted as fraud. Holmes lets him walk, apparently not considering it objectionable once he's confirmed the sister was not murdered. The fact that both he and the suspect refer to his creditors as "the Jews" doesn't help.
** Quite a few culprits are allowed to go unprosecuted on the condition that they leave Britain, or are treated as if the crimes they've committed outside of Europe are none of Holmes' affair. Crimes outside the U.K. may not be ''Lestrade's'' jurisdiction, but Holmes takes pride in not having the same constraints as the police, so it seems hypocritical when his commitment to justice ends at the British coastline.
** In the "Lion's Mane" case, upon realizing that the killer was a giant jellyfish, Holmes immediately locates the creature trapped in a tide pool and kills it ''in the name of justice'', regardless of the fact that it's a mindless organism that didn't even know it'd poisoned somebody and is in no position to harm anyone else.
* In one of Doyle's "Professor Challenger" stories, [[wikipedia:The Poison Belt|The Poison Belt]], the Earth passes through a toxic region in the [[wikipedia:Luminiferous aether|Ether]], which gradually kills {{spoiler|knocks out}} the entire population of the world... in order of darkest to lightest skin. Professor Challenger's plan to protect people from its effects was offered to his friends, but not to his servants.
** The skin-tone ordering is somewhat alleviated by the fact that the story suggests the order was more on the lines of 'the equator first, then outwards from there' rather than ordered by skin-tone alone.