Victim Falls For Rapist: Difference between revisions

Added Page Image and example.
m (revise quote template spacing)
(Added Page Image and example.)
 
(23 intermediate revisions by 12 users not shown)
Line 1:
{{trope}}
[[File:Souma and Ryo 1 and 8.png|350px|thumb|right|link=Fire in His Fingertips|Left: Episode 1 Right: Episode 8 <ref> Source:Episode 1 and 8 of [[Fire in His Fingertips]] </ref>]]
{{quote|'''Shuichi''': Anyone would cry after what you did! You're a ''rapist,'' you big jerk!
'''Yuki''': Admit it, you liked it! You masochist punk!
'''Shuichi''': [["It's Not Rape If You Enjoyed It"|I--I couldn't help it! It felt... well... nice.]] ([[Luminescent Blush|blushes]])|'''''[[Gravitation]]''''' manga}}
|'''''[[Gravitation]]''''' manga}}
 
 
The idea that people can enjoy being raped and/or will [[Love Martyr|fall in love]] with their rapists as a consequence of the rape. More often than not, the rapist turns out to have acted out of pure love, or winds up loving his/her victim emotionally too.
Line 9 ⟶ 10:
According to many sexologists, this is a common submissive ''fantasy'' for both women and men, although it certainly does '''NOT''' mean that s/he wants to get raped for real. After all, people who play paintball don't really want to shoot and kill each other. The "rape" remains a fantasy or a [[Safe, Sane, and Consensual|game]].
 
It is a staple of published [[Yaoi]] and [[Slash Fic]], in which a disproportionate amount used a rape scene to bring the two male characters together, but can also extend to heterosexual couples and [[Psycho Lesbian|women]]. Also popular in "bodice ripper" [[Romance Novel|romances]], in which resistant women are overwhelmed with passion as men force themselves upon them, though it should be noted that these types of stories were mostly popular in the 70s and 80s and are now, for the most part, considered a [[Dead Horse Music Genre]] in the romance novel community. The receiving end may rant, protest, push away, cry [[Sparkling Stream of Tears|glistening tears]]... but before the first half of the scene is over, they'll have started cooperating and acknowledging their enjoyment, probably while [[Luminescent Blush|blushing furiously]] . As a famous [[Memetic Mutation|meme goes:]] "[[No Except Yes|It wasn't rape, it was just surprise sex you didn't know you wanted.]]"
 
Nearly all [[Boys Love|yaoi]] manga published in English contain some element of this. Plots have become almost frighteningly predictable too, often beginning with Mr. [[Seme]] either raping, or at least [[Near-Rape Experience|getting halfway]] with Mr. [[Uke]], freaking poor Mr. Uke out and therefore leaving some room for the two to collect their thoughts, whereupon they admit their love for one another and make love consensually. A somewhat unconventional series might have Mr. Seme realize that he also needs to reach out emotionally before Mr. Uke comes to accept him, but very few yaoi series (shonen-ai ones don't count, as they don't focus on the sex) ''completely'' avoid this trope. A (short) list of yaoi manga not involving this trope can be found [http://helen-damnation.livejournal.com/8744.html here.] (Since 'seme' means 'attacker' and 'uke' refers to someone who receives attacks, this tendency is somewhat built into the terminology.) Some [[Shojo]] series are also taking part, with a cold and very masculine hero bullying the far more passive female protagonist into having barely consensual sex or even outright taking advantage of her, only for her to discover that she wanted this and he only did it out of uncontrollable love for her.
 
Whichever genre, a [['''Victim Falls For Rapist]]''' scene is used as a convenient plot device to give the victim an arousing experience without actually [[My Girl Is Not a Slut|soiling their innocence]], because it wasn't their choice to have sex in the first place. There's something kinky in forcing a person to realize his/her love. And if the victim falls in love with the rapist, that ups the angst meter.
 
And if the goal isn't to bring the rapist and his victim together, it'll make the victim a walking angst magnet, perfect for being [[Rescue Romance|saved by his/her soulmate.]]
 
A subtrope of [[Stockholm Syndrome]] and [[Hollywood Sex]]. See also [[Prison Rape]], [[Naughty Tentacles]]. Compare [[Stalking Is Love]], [[Black Comedy Rape]], [[Rape as Drama]]. Contrast [[Rape Is a Special Kind of Evil]], [["It's Not Rape If You Enjoyed It"]]. For the G-rated but no less creepy (and no less [[Don't Try This At Home|illegal]]) version of this trope, see [[Abduction Is Love]]. Contrast [[Marital Rape License]], where the rape is generally portrayed as heinous although the rapist may [[From a Certain Point of View|consider]] the rape to be an act of love and also his husbandly right -- whichright—which in some cultural contexts it actually is. Often results in an [[Esoteric Happy Ending]].
 
{{noreallife|First, this is a [[:Category:Rape Tropes|rape trope]], and All The Tropes does not care to [[squick]] its readers. Second, this is a trope about how characters are depicted in media. Please don't use this page to smear the reputations of real people.}}
 
[[No Real Life Examples, Please]]
{{examples}}
 
== Anime and Manga ==
* An alarmingly common trope in [[Boys Love|BL]] manga, where the [[Seme]] will often repeatedly attempt to force an [[Uke]] to make out with or even have sex with him, much to the uke's anger and [[Have I Mentioned I Am Heterosexual Today?|protests that he's straight]] (which often leads to the seme trying harder just to prove him wrong). It's considered justified in the end because it turns out the seme was right about him, [[Karma Houdini|which apparently invalidates any need for his consent]].
* ''[[Winter Demon]]'' from Yaoi Press featured this with the titular winter demon Fuyu raping a young (male) monk before the manga begins. The monk is forced to seek Fuyu's help in the actual beginning and the pair fall in love. And then as if this counts as [[Rape as Redemption|redemption]] Fuyu is also raped in the first volume.
* In ''[[Okane ga Nai]]'', Kanou rapes Ayase in an attempt to convey his feelings, but Ayase eventually falls in love with him anyways. Then it's played for [[Black Comedy Rape|comedy]] in an extra by having Kanou travel back in time back to the moment of the rape and proceed to attack his past-self for what he is about to do to Ayase. Ayase also gets hit with this trope at nearly every corner, where ''every single straight male'' in this manga either falls in love with and wants to or attempts to rape Ayase. And Ayase, being the living embodiment of [[Too Dumb to Live]] and [[The Ingenue]], only narrowly avoids said rape--whenrape—when it's not [[Karma Houdini|Kanou]]--by—by virtue of the people around him who ''don't'' want him to get raped noticing the danger signs. Ironically, the only men who aren't interested in Ayase at all are the gay guys. Who are interested in Kanou.
* It is up to debate whether Shizuru raped Natsuki in her sleep in ''[[MaiMy-HiME]]'', as the details are sketchy and the plot never goes back and addresses it and exactly how far she went. However, the [[Victim Falls For Rapist]] plot is used straight in the same series between Yukariko the nun and the art teacher Ishigami. Many fans [[Hand Wave]] actions done in the series as the "dark influence" of various plot devices, as most everyone is [[Easily Forgiven|miraculously forgiven in the end]].
** [[Mai-Otome]] [[Zig-Zagging Trope|sends the trope through a blender]] in one incident. Tomoe, at one point, received Shizuru as a [[Sex Slave]] through betrayal and [[Scarpia Ultimatum|false pretenses]]. Shizuru enjoyed every minute of it. {{spoiler|Shizuru set Tomoe up to take her as a [[Sex Slave]], so she'd be in position to break out when the fighting started, and felt nothing for Tomoe as anything more than fun while it lasted, but [[Was It All a Lie?|made Tomoe believe otherwise]].}}
* In ''[[Kannazuki no Miko]]'', Chikane rapes the love of her life, Himeko, as part of a [[Plan]] to destroy the [[Big Bad]] without killing Himeko [[Because Destiny Says So]].
Line 32 ⟶ 33:
** There are also some non-explicit sex scenes in Volume 2 of the ''Gravitation'' manga between Shuichi and Yuki that are borderline non-consensual with Yuki very much being the [[Seme]]; the quote at the top of the page comes from one of these scenes. In contrast, the anime implies that whatever sex occurred off-screen was consensual.
* In Saki Hiwatari's Shoujo classic ''[[Please Save My Earth]]'' The ''concept'' is used for Big Drama, as well as propelling much of the plot. The two characters end up in love and together. However what actually happened is moot as everyone is an [[Unreliable Narrator]] due to unclear memories heavily influenced by emotions. This causes the characters and readers to be uncertain about how much blame to impart and who to feel sorry for. See [[Please Save My Earth/YMMV|Please Save My Earth]] YMMV section for possible interpretations.
* ''[[Hot Gimmick]]'' romanticizes an abusive relationship: readers are expected to support the heroine's [[Love Martyr|decision to remain]] with her [[Troubled but Cute]] love interest at the end -- hisend—his blackmail, physical force, and coerced sexual encounters with her are supposed to be how he expresses his love for her. {{spoiler|And then it's subverted in the novels, where Hatsumi is paired up... with Shinogu.}}
* Just-about-averted in ''[[Rose of Versailles]]'', in which the male romantic lead Andre forces himself on the heroine Lady Oscar--heOscar—he does come to his senses and [[Near-Rape Experience|stop short of actual rape]], however, and repeatedly tells her he's sorry. The whole incident is treated as evidence of his unrequited passion for her, and doesn't stop her from falling in love with him in return by the end of the series.
** In the anime version, anyway, Andre's actions are also supposed to be evidence of his ''immaturity'', and one of the reasons Oscar doesn't (yet) return his feelings. (The title of the episode wherein it occurs is "Andre, a Green Lemon")
** It's also an indication of the extreme stress he's been under ever since he {{spoiler|lost his eye, and potentially going completely blind}}. The anime makes it very clear [[Not Himself|that he snapped and that what he did was wrong]], hence why their relationship is (for a while) ruined by it.
* Nearly half of hentai mangas and animes start in this way, when guy/girl/child gets raped and likes that in the next page, then comes back for more in the end.
* In the [[Hentai]] OVA ''[[Dragon Knight]] IV: Wheel of Time'', the [[Lady of War|warrior princess]] Bianca doesn't know her place in the army of good guys and is unwilling to submit to [[The Hero]], Eto. So when she challenges him, he easily defeats her, and then rapes her to put her in her place. It works, and she enjoys it. And that's enough about hentai or this page will never stop.
** Hentai in general tends to take things even farther to the extreme (duh), with rape not just being love, but being some sort of fetish. A number of hentai involve a woman who is raped and/or degraded, and is turned into an insatiable sex addict because of it, and become willing to do almost ''anything'' for it.
* In ''[[After School Nightmare]]'', Sou sexually assaults Mashiro twice--firsttwice—first forcing a kiss on him and later actually attempting to rape him. Mashiro nevertheless falls for him.
* More or less the entire plot of ''[[System Of Romance]]''.
* One [[Girls Love]] example can be found in the manga ''[[Gokujou Drops]]''. [[Moe Moe]] Komari gets frequently molested quite explicitly by [[Tall, Dark and Bishoujo]] Yukio despite Komari's protestations. Komari eventually admits to herself that she enjoys it and starts developing strong feelings for Yukio.
Line 46 ⟶ 47:
* One of the later chapters of ''[[Karin]]'' has her brother Ren {{spoiler|forcing a vampire named Bridget to be bent over sticking out a window so she can be burned by the sun wearing, ''very'' revealing clothes. He's crouched over behind her holding her down in a scene that looks a lot like a rape but apparently isn't one. That is, until she calls later and announces she is now pregnant with his son, so they get married.}} ...kay.
* ''[[Rapeman]]'', a superhero who punishes heartless villainesses with his legendary (nonconsensual) lovemaking prowess! It's supposed to be edgy satire.
** It was mentioned in a [[BigNon LippedSequitur Alligator MomentScene]] of ''[[Law and Order SVU]]''.
* In the ''[[The Tyrant Falls in Love]]'' AU manga ''Aru Hi Mori No Naka'', once Ookami (Souichi) is back to health and Kuma (Morinaga) has made it through the winter, Morinaga thinks the best way to show his love for Souichi is to, you guessed it, rape him. Although, throughout the rape, Souichi believes that Morinaga is actually ''just trying to kill him''. The next morning, after realizing what happened and also being confessed to, Souichi comments, "Are you telling me that you'd force yourself on someone you love?"
* In the ''[[Asatte no Houkou]]'' manga, Amino forces Karada to give him a hand job, and clearly believes that he's doing this out of "love." He later realizes that he was very ''very'' [[My God, What Have I Done?|wrong]].
Line 53 ⟶ 54:
** Respected as he is, [[Osamu Tezuka]] seems to have had a disturbing fondness for this trope. It also appears in ''[[MW]]'' (in which the victim spends the rest of the book pining for her sociopathic rapist without ever doing anything important) and ''[[Ayako]]'' (in which a spy exploits this trope to "ensure" the allegiance of another agent sent to kill him).
* This happens to all of the kidnapped girls in ''[[Bondage Queen Kate]]''. After they go through their captors "special training", they soon become loving and compliant sex slaves.
* ''[[Hana Yori Dango]]'', Tsukasa sends some boys to rape Tsukushi, who is saved by Rui. Later Tsukasa develops feelings for Tsukushi and {{spoiler|he is shown a recording of Tsukushi talking to Rui and obviously in love with him}}. This causes him to go into a jealous rage and he almost forces himself on Tsukushi, but comes to his senses before finishing the deed.
* In ''[[Aki Sora]]'' the number of girls that Sora has slept with voluntarily for the first time is one however he has had consensual sex with at least 3 of the girls after they raped him and he shows no ill effects of the rape. As a matter of fact a classmate of his that was one of the women who gang raped him at the party was angry this did not happen to her.
* [[Tanaka Yutaka]] pretty much puts this concept to the sword in ''Doubt'' (from the [[Virgin Night]] anthology). The first part shows a ''very'' unpleasant impelled sex scene which proves to be [[Poor Communication Kills]]-catalyzed (Tsutsui was making a ''bad'' assumption about Motoko's hesitancy to respond to his desire for sex as merely playing hard-to-get; she wasn't, she was just nervous about proper broaching), and leaves ''both'' Tsutsui and Motoko feeling degraded. The second part, once both participants open up about their desire for each other, is affection and pleasure distillate--anddistillate—and not so much as a cubic micron of anything forced (or, for that matter, hurried). Tanaka isn't really leaving any question as to which form actually fits with long-lasting love.
* The H manga ''Yanagida-kun to Mizuno-san'' plays this not quite straight, but not quite averted either. [[Tsundere|Mizuno]] technically started it, but Yanagida ends up going farther than she wanted. Later, when Mizuno's boyfriend starts badmouthing her to other people at their school, Mizuno sees Yanagida stand up for her (and get beat up for his trouble, naturally). Mizuno later states that it was this situation that made her think better of him, rather than anything directly related to the rape. Not a full aversion, but for an H manga, the slightest aversion to this trope is noteable.
* [[Zig-Zagging Trope|Zigzagged]] all over the place with ''[[Corsair]]''. Canale has never began a relationship consensually, and yet distinguishes between Ayace and Sesaam's treatment of him ([[Rape Is Love]]) and everybody else ([[Rape as Drama]]/[[Rape as Backstory]]). Whether he [["It's Not Rape If You Enjoyed It"|enjoyed it]] or not has nothing to do with it. On top of that, there is one instance with Ayace where it is treated as rape, but the earlier sex scenes aren't, and they resume their relationship as usual afterwards.
** He tends to distinguish it as Ayase and Sesaam being gentle and caring while they have sex with him while everyone else literally tied him up and drugged him. [[Nightmare Fuel|From the age of 10]]. The one time that Ayase is incredibly rough with him out of jealousy is the one time he calls it rape.
* ''[[Bitter Virgin]]'' takes its plot and throws it into the face of this trope, not exactly subverting it, but definitely going against all its different types and forms. As [[The Woobie|Hinako]] could tell you, [[Tear Jerker|rape is definitely not love]].
Line 71 ⟶ 72:
* Discussed in the [[Josei]] manga [[Rouge Noir]]. {{spoiler|The female lead Ayane aknowledges that her and the male lead Kou's sexual encounter, years ago, ''was'' rape, and yet she also admits to having feelings for him when she finds him again. Later, when Kou and Ayane declare their mutual love and have consensual sex, Kou reveals that [[My Greatest Failure|he has been feeling guilty ever since then]] and apologizes profusely to her. After some more hardships, they get married.}}
{{quote|{{spoiler|Ayane}}: "Six years ago, {{spoiler|Kou violated me.}} (...) [[Lampshade Hanging|Even I think there's something wrong with me.]] (...) {{spoiler|That sound and Kou himself}}, despite the calamitous past that we have, are drawing me in."}}
* Yukiha falls hard for her own rapist, Masami, in ''[[The Girl in the Library: Until The Pure You Falls From Grace]]'' after being disappointed by her boyfriend's [[Speed Sex|poor performance]] and [[Teeny Weenie|small penis.]] She becomes Masami's [[Sex Slave]] of her own [[Happiness in Slavery|free will]] and ends up [[Babies Ever After|pregnant with his child.]] By chapter six, she's [[Undying Loyalty|completely devoted to him]] and ends up as [[Sex Face Turn|evil as he is.]]
 
* Souma Mizuno from ''[[Fire in His Fingertips]]'' has raped Ryo Fujihashi before and after she becomes his girlfriend. He is nevertheless [[Sex God|really good at sex]] and aside from his perversion is still a good man and a loyal boyfriend becoming a rare justified example. They are the page image.
 
== Ballads ==
Line 77 ⟶ 79:
* In ''The Knight and the Shepherd's Daughter'', the title daughter chases after the knight to insist that he marry her.
* In ''The Wylie Wife of the Hie Toun Hie'', when the rapist returns several years later and sees the beautiful child his victim bore, he marries her.
 
 
== Comic Books ==
Line 85 ⟶ 86:
* Recently over at DC, the decision was made to make the ''Son of the Bat'' mini-series canon again, but decided to retcon Batman and Talia Al-Ghul's consensual encounter into Talia drugging and raping Bruce in order to conceive their son, Damien. Talia still acts like Bruce was a willing participant, so in at least in her mind it was love. Bruce however isn't all that amused and all but called it rape.
** Note that his entire take on the matter is reduced to two small panels and then never dealt with again.
* In ''[[Nexus (fanfic)|Nexus]]'', Ursula drugs Horatio and sleeps with him while he believes that she is his girlfriend Sundra. Later, when Ursula shows up on Ylum with Scarlet and Sheena, her twin daughters by Horatio, the four of them live together as a family. It must be noted that, at first Horatio, as much as he loves his daughters, neither feels nor expresses any affection for Ursula, but he eventually does seem to warm up to her, to the point where they do make love consensually. Also, Ursula does seem to develop feelings for Horatio.
* Averted, oddly enough, by [[Red Sonja]] whom was gifted with incredible skill in battle by a goddess after her family was slaughtered by evil soldiers and she was raped and left for dead. But this blessing required Sonja to swear a holy oath to never love any man who could not beat her in fair, single combat. While some feel this would require Sonja to repeat the rape that ruined her life and put her on the warrior's path it hardly seems logical, [http://comicsnexus.com/2007/02/12/64703/ as one writer pointed out]{{Dead link}}, that a compassionate goddess would bless a woman with fighting prowess only to turn her into a trophy concubine for any well-muscled idiot with a sword.
** Indeed, the current ''[[Red Sonja]]'' series has shown the oath to be rather more nuanced. For example, she's in no way compelled to sleep with a man who defeats her--ither—it's an option, but she doesn't have to submit if she finds him odious. (Fighting a demigod along with two allies, she was still trounced, but he had no knowledge of her oath; later, when she comes to admire him as a person, she comes to him at night.) Similarly, she can love anyone she chooses, but cannot be physically intimate with the man. It is not just a gift, but a test of Sonja's own willpower in staying true to her quest at the expense of a permanent home, family and love--onelove—one story outright said that Sonja was free to give up her skills any time she wanted, should she find a worthy man she wished to spend her life with who was not capable of besting her in battle.
*** Of course, she could duck the whole thing by running off with [[Conan the Barbarian|Conan]], who is openly attracted to her and whom they both know is capable of besting her.
**** Conan has bested her at least once, and was expecting to bed her. She told him "I don't have to enjoy it", which convinced him to give up the attempt.
Line 102 ⟶ 103:
* An early version of ''Sleeping Beauty'' has this. {{spoiler|The Prince, upon seeing Beauty, so overcome by her beauty, rapes her. She wakes up nine months later when she gives birth to twins, and they all live [[Happily Ever After]].}}
 
== Fan Works ==
 
== Fanfiction ==
* The German fanfiction community Fanfiktion.de averts this. As stated in their guidelines for authors, [[Rape Is Love]] stories are not endorsed and get consequently blocked.
* The ''[[Neon Genesis Evangelion|NGE]]'' fanfic of ''Shinji and Asuka'' starts pretty normally: the two are at home alone, she is berating him again... but for some miraculous reason, he finds the courage to stand up to her. She doesn't like it of course and compares Shinji to his father. Which turns out to be a '''HUGE''' mistake as Shinji snaps and rapes Asuka on the spot Of course it happened because {{spoiler|Gendo drugged Shinji's LCL with testosterone and confidence-boosting drugs in order to try and hook him up with Rei}} but it backfired because the incident caused unforeseen side-effects (boosting Shinji's confidence and breaking Asuka's ego); even though {{spoiler|Misato got suspicious and ordered a full physical examination, revealing their secret}}, soon they were still having sex. Until she suffered from [[Mind Rape]]-induced amnesia courtesy of Arael, anyway (which presented another problem: she thought she still was a virgin so {{spoiler|Shinji had to resort to subterfuge--which hurt and pissed her off, naturally}}).
* What starts the events in ''[[Troperworks/The Ruffling Ofof Fur And Feathers|The Ruffling Of Fur Andand Feathers]]'', though the rape only really happens once {{spoiler|or twice...}}.
* the ''[[Death Note]]'' fic ''[[Poison Apple]]'' by [[Robbin Rocks]] and Narroach; first Light rapes L, then L rapes Light for revenge, Light drugs L and they have drugged "making love". . . somehow.
* Appears a bit too commonly in fanfiction in general.
* Poison Apple by [[Robbin Rocks]] and Narroach; first Light rapes L, then L rapes Light for revenge, Light drugs L and they have drugged "making love". . . somehow.
* [[Ax Crazy|Flippy]] from the''[[Happy Tree Friends]]'' rapes [[Fan-Preferred Couple|Flaky]] in most stories and fanart. Or kills her.
* Sasuke rapes ''[[Naruto]]'' in almost 80% of the yaoi fics in which they appear.
* Sierra from ''[[Total Drama Island|Total Drama World Tour]]'' will do this to Cody in a lot of fanfics (and probably to a lesser extent, she'll do this to the rest of the characters)
* ''[[Celebrian]]'', full stop. No more need be said.
* Rape-obsessed author [https://web.archive.org/web/20120419172124/http://www.fanfiction.net/u/520793/Akenaten Akenaten] has written a bunch of stories for different fandoms that all have the same plot: a young, innocent woman is repeatedly raped and brutalized by a man who loves her deeply in his own way; in the end, they get married and have kids.
* In the ''[[Axis Powers Hetalia]]'' fanfic "Let Me Be Your Savior", this is Lovino's (Romano) justification for his raping of Feliciano (Italy).
** Also occurs in many fics for love/hate pairings that focus on the "hate" part a little too intensely, especially for Russia/Lithuania or Turkey/Greece. One example of these [[Sarcasm Mode|lovely gems]] has Turkey tying up Greece and raping him because he loves him but believes that Greece will never love him back [[Insane Troll Logic|and hence that raping him is the best way to make sure that the one he loves never forgets him]].
** There's more than one Japan/China fanwork where Japan is a rapist because he was madly in love with his older brother but couldn't confess it all those centuries before 1894 because it was incestuous. Hell, there's a doujinshi called "Midare Botan" where China realizes these feelings after being ''slashed across the back and raped while still bleeding'' and asks to have reconciliation sex when their bosses reconcile some years later.
** Not even pairings that are seen as "fluffier" get free of this. There's a Germany/Italy doujinshi in which Germany had raped North Italy during the last times of [[World War Two]] (presumably the Salo Republic days), but Italy not only forgave this, but similarly to ''Midare botan'' he asked for reconciliation sex when he snuck in to check on a captured Germany who was in the hands of the Allies after his defeat. And this is despite a very remorseful Germany's initial reluctance to go through sexual therapy.
* The horrific ''[[Tenchi Muyo!]]'' fanfic ''[[Fan Fic/Kanashii No Imi|Kanashii Nono Imi]]'' has its main character, Jeff, want this to be seen with his victim. However, her final, defiant words not only prove him wrong, it also shows how the audience thinks of him: "I--hate...you."
* ''Beautifully'' ''''subverted'''' in the ''[[Fate/stay night]]/[[Sekirei]]'' crossover ''[[In Flight]]''. When [[Lightning Bruiser|Musubi]] tries to convince Shirou to take any measure necessary to wing [[Making a Splash|Tsukiumi]]--who—who is reluctant to accept an Ashikabi--[[Badass|Shirou]] isn't so impressed and compares the process--essentiallyprocess—essentially a mating ritual to the alien species--tospecies—to rape. He asks Musubi whether he would have approved of her being winged by someone she didn't want as an Ashikabi, and then turns to [[Playing with Fire|Homura]] and reminds him of his own reluctance to be winged by Shirou. Both become suitably uncomfortable at this. Incidentally, it is Shirou's willingness to let her ''choose'' whether she wants to be winged that convinces Tsukiumi to let herself be winged (particularly since the story establishes her as ''Agoraphobic''--fearful—fearful of sexual assault).
* In a Pokemon''[[Pokémon]]'' fanfiction named ''[[Captured]]'', a 17 year old teenager named Ike is caught in a unwanted harem of female PokemonPokémon who rape him. The harem consists of a Mightyena, a Ninetails, a Zangoose and a Lucario who were all outcasts from their clans for one reason or another and in their mating season felt lonely and found Ike wandering in the woods near his home town and captured him to make him their collective mate. The dynamic mentioned in the story is that Lucario is the dominant female. In Lucario's mind she finds Ike's refusal of her love as insulting, all she wanted was a mate but Ike simply views this as a deep-rooted psychological desire on her part to have someone who she can control. Eventually Ike befriends the Zangoose and out of regret for her earlier actions helps him escape the other Pokemon and get back home where his life finally returns to normal.
* In ''[[The Girl Who Lived]]'' series, the [[It Makes Sense in Context|druid community]] has a ceremony for when the women come of age, which involves them performing a complicated sex ceremony with their boyfriends while said boyfriends are put under a mind-altering spell that halts their sentience temporarily. It only ''narrowly'' squeaks past this trope because the guys agree to it ahead of time, but it's still very squicky.
* In ''[[Naruto Veangance Revelaitons]]'', Ronan essentially commits many rapes of a few different kinds, whether statutory rape (Sakura is presumably as young as she is in canon), the [[Dude, She's Like, in a Coma]] variety, and even straight-up raping a conscious and unwilling woman. The author seems to believe in this trope and [["It's Not Rape If You Enjoyed It"]], though, and the female characters do, as well.
* Nine times out of ten, any fanfiction of ''[[Kingdom Hearts]]'' involving Kairi getting raped usually ends with her falling in love with the guy who raped her... such as Pete for instance.
* Subverted/Averted with the ''[[Sherlock]]'' fic "''A Reliable Man"''. (Chapter 1 can be found [http://randomly-rusted.livejournal.com/559.html here].) Mycroft is disturbing, but still sympathetic particularly when he {{spoiler|realizes the [[Break the Cutie|effect]] that his [[What the Hell, Hero?|threats]] [[Be Careful What You Wish For|have]] on [[My God, What Have I Done?|Lestrade]].}}
* [[Zig-Zagging Trope|Zig-zagged]] in ''[https://forum.questionablequesting.com/threads/troop-of-beasts-dragon-ball.6675/ Troop of Beasts]''{{Dead link}}. While some of the girls and women Kakarot rapes (Colonel Violet, Hasky, Chi-Chi, etc.) fall in love with him before long, others (notably Bulma) [[Averted Trope|don't]].
 
== Film ==
Line 132:
* In ''[[Gone with the Wind]]'', Scarlett and Rhett's unbelievably tumultuous relationship has reached a point where, after the birth of her first child and continuing to pine after the unattainable Ashley (who she "only thinks she loves"), she tells Rhett that she no longer wants to have sex with him. Some time later, after one of their vicious rows the drunken Rhett picks Scarlett up and carries her upstairs to the bedroom, declaring that she won't turn him away this time. Cut to Scarlett waking up (alone) in bed the next morning, looking ''extremely'' happy, indicating that she thoroughly enjoyed the experience, although Rhett soon comes in and makes an apology for his behaviour, partly blaming it on drink.
* Played quite disturbingly in ''[[Straw Dogs]]''. As in many cases, the viewer respects the "[[Asshole Victim|victim]]" a lot less, but here, it appears quite intentional.
* [[Rutger Hauer]]'s and [[Jennifer Jason Leigh]]'s characters in ''[[Flesh Andand Blood]]''. Here, at least, she doesn't seem to suffer this with any of her ''other'' rapists.
* ''[[Young Frankenstein]]'' features a [[Black Comedy Rape|comedic]] version of this with The Monster and Elizabeth. Borderline: Elizabeth is pleasantly impressed when she gets her first sight of The Monster's [[Gag Penis|"very large shvanstocke"]]; however, the Monster doesn't seem particularly interested in her consent, and she continues to protest right up until the moment of, er, union.
{{quote|'''Elizabeth:''' ''(singing)'' Oh, sweet mystery of life, at least I've found you!}}
Line 156:
* ''[[Marianna Ucria]]'''s uncle. He claimed he raped her when he was 9 out of love.
* In ''[[Wedding Crashers]]'' Jeremy is raped by Gloria. He later falls in love with her and marries her.
 
 
== Literature ==
* Though seduction plays its part, is it cruelly subverted in ''Tess of D'Urbervilles.'' Sadly, the rapist, Alec, is the only one who can make Tess's and her family's life financially better.
* Played straight AND played for laughs in Piers Anthony's "[[Bio of a Space Tyrant]]." When Hope Hubris is carrying out his anti-piracy crusade during the course of his military career in the second book, he eventaully elects to cut a deal with one of the "nicer" pirate clans, responsible for gambling and boozing and other "victimless" crimes, but not human trafficking and spaceship hijacking. The pirate clan leader requires that Hubris marry his daughter to seal the deal. The catch? Space pirate marital ceremonies consist of the groom breaking onto the bride's ship, fighting his way to the girl's chamber, kidnapping her onto his own vessel, and then raping her into submission. Of course, since marriages are usually arranged beforehand the ship's corridors are conveniently empty... but since the bride expects to have a "real man" for a husband, she's given a knife for protection. By the time it's over Hubris has done the deed--anddeed—and he's the one who needs medical attention, not her. What makes it even more hilarious is that the culture turns the women into masochists; he finds it nigh impossible to convince his new wife to consent to gentle lovemaking. And when Hubris is finally court martialed by corrupt admirals to punish him for destroying the pirate clans that had been paying them bribes, the prosecutor is stunned when Hubris' pirate bride mentions the marital rape. "He raped you?" Her contemptuous response, "like you wouldn't if you had the chance!"
* Kathleen E. Woodiwiss' acclaimed historical romance ''The Flame and the Flower'' is quite well-written but has an exceptionally disturbing rape-to-love conversion. The heroine stabs a man who is attempting to rape her and flees, believing she has killed him. The so-called "hero" has men wandering the streets looking for a prostitute to bring to him, and when they see her on the streets they grab her. She goes with them thinking they are police. The hero rapes her, dismissing her resistance as "mere coyness". She escapes and goes back to her abusive aunt, only to find out that she is pregnant. Her aunt forces her to wed her rapist... whom she eventually falls in love with, and bears the child, and they all live happily ever after. However, ''he never apologizes for the rape,'' and the novel leaves the reader with a distinct impression that because she was out on the street alone, she deserved it. Even for a novel set in the early 1800s, this seems excessively misogynistic and left a bad taste in many readers' mouths.
* In Margery Allingham's [[Genteel Interbellum Setting|1930s]] [[Albert Campion]] murder mystery ''The Fashion in Shrouds'', one character is depressed over losing her love to a rival. Her brother recommends "a nice rape" to make her feel better.
Line 166 ⟶ 165:
* Reversal in the ''Mode'' series from [[Piers Anthony]]. The protagonist couple finally get married, but after having been raped in her past, the female lead finds herself psychologically unable to submit to sexual intercourse, even in a consensual relationship. She offers to let the male rape her to consummate their marriage. {{spoiler|He declines.}}
* Averted massively in [[Lois McMaster Bujold]]'s ''Shards of Honor'': Sergeant Bothari, during a period of severe mental illness, is forced to participate in his commanding officer's rape and torture of a female POW. After she goes into a catatonic state he keeps her in his own quarters for several days, playing out a fantasy relationship with her; the experience leaves her pregnant and nearly destroyed by the mental trauma, and when they meet him again nineteen years later in ''The Warrior's Apprentice'' she promptly shoots him dead. Bothari, by this point much saner, seems to regard it as [[Karmic Death|cosmic justice]].
** Played with in ''Barrayar'', too. Koudelka and Drou have an unplanned, er, encounter, on the couch; Kou then takes to avoiding Drou. When finally confronted, he miserably apologizes for raping her. She is offended both by the implication that she couldn't have fought him off--Drouoff—Drou being the Empress's personal bodyguard, after all--andall—and by the realization that Kou was so caught up in his own actions he didn't even notice Drou was participating (though perhaps being cold-shouldered after the fact confused him -- hehim—he didn't realize she was worried about pregnancy). She didn't enjoy the sex much, since it was her first time and neither of them were much good at it, but she ''absolutely'' wanted to be there. They eventually get things straightened out, and go on to marry, have four daughters, and live happily ever after.
* Inverted in Jacqueline Carey's ''[[Kushiel's Legacy]]'' series. Phedre, the main character, is a high class masochist-courtesan, whose patron god has ordained that she be "pleased" by her own suffering, physical or mental. When {{spoiler|she's raped by Melisande and sold into slavery to the Skaldi}} in the first book, and {{spoiler|made the prisoner of a mad king}} in the third, she's repeatedly coerced into sex, and her body can't help but enjoy it, even as her mind is emotionally traumatized. However, Phedre's never in danger of fully falling in love with her rapists, and gets back at all of them. {{spoiler|Using her spying and planning skills, she foils the Skaldi invasion of her home country, gets Melisande banished from the realm, and assassinates the mad king with a hairpin.}} All of her former rapists suffer because they mistake a physical weakness on her part for mental submission.
* Played for [[Squick]], or at least tragedy, in ''The [[Chronicles of Thomas Covenant]]''. After Lena is raped, the trauma of the experience leaves her no longer entirely sane, and she imagines herself as having been in a romantic relationship with her rapist.
Line 172 ⟶ 171:
* In Paul Gallico's ''[[The Poseidon Adventure]]'', Susan is searching for her brother alone in a darkened corridor, when she is brutally raped by a panicking teenage crewman, afraid to die a virgin. Not only does Susan grow to like the boy after a brief conversation, she mourns his death and hopes that she's pregnant with his child so that he'll leave a legacy.
* Variation in Jim Grimsley's ''Dream Boy''. The rape of one of the main characters by a third party somehow causes he and his boyfriend to become closer and solve all their relationship problems. Possibly [[Rape as Redemption]].
* In [[Robert A. Heinlein]]'s novel ''[[Friday (novel)|Friday]]'', the titular heroine eventually ends up with one of the men who raped her in the beginning of the book as part of an interrogation. This is partially justified, as (a) said rapist <s>was only following orders,</s> and is willing to fall on his sword to beg forgiveness when they meet again, (b) the rape scene was meant to show that Friday herself was [[The Stoic]], even in that situation (she's mostly annoyed while she plans to exploit [[Rape Is Love]] to her advantage), (c) as a covert agent, rape was considered a routine part of capture and interrogation so he was doing what his role demanded, (d) this specific rapist also allowed her to go to the bathroom, a kindness Friday doesn't forget and counts in the guy's favor; and (e) the real reason for the rape scene is to show how Friday (an [[Artificial Human]]) has been indoctrinated to think of herself as ''not'' human after her dehumanizing childhood. In any case, readers may still find the pairing fairly cringe-worthy.** It is made explicit throughout the novel that Friday, and indeed all Artificial Persons (genetically engineered human beings) are raised to be "indentured" (read "slaves"), with "doxy" (read "sex slave") training being part of basic schooling, and had extremely permissive and casual attitudes about all sex. As a result, since {{spoiler|1=both she and her rapist were Artificial Persons (APs)}}, not only does Friday consider being forced into sex to be pretty much a non-issue, but {{spoiler|both undoubtedly had been in the position of being ordered to have sex in their training with other [[A Ps]]APs, and "willingness" was never an issue, while they were growing up}}. This makes even more sense when you realize how stupid it would be to make a sex slave who was superhumanly strong, fast, ''and'' objected to rape.
** She actually did threaten to castrate Pete with her bare hands when she first met him again... until she found {{spoiler|he was also an Artificial Person, at which point she immediately empathized with him. Apparently their common origin and sex-slave training had Friday realizing that she couldn't really hate him without also in a way hating ''herself''... when her [[Character Development]] over most of the book is that she's slowly been learning ''not'' to do that.}}
** Pete explains very specifically that his rape of Friday was ''not'' a matter of "only following orders"; he raped her, he explains, "because I ''wanted'' to. Because you are so sexy you could corrupt a [[wikipedia:Stylite|Stylite]]. Or cause Venus to switch to Lesbos." This is, if not [[Rape Is Love]], at least rape as compliment.
Line 191 ⟶ 190:
** Similarly, at least one Catherine Cookson novel involves a rich young rake carelessly raping a poor young girl, who from no fault of her own has a reputation as the town tramp. She then bears his child, which she is forced to give up to him. She is eventually married to a kindly local miller... but the story downplays his selflessness in favour of an ending wherein he dies and the rake, far from being repentant, realizes he's loved her all along, and deigns to marry her. Yechhh.
** Come to that, the sheer volume of post-feminist "romance" novels that have fallen in love with this trope is... disturbing. See also: Jennifer Blake's ''The Storm and the Splendor''. Shirlee Busbee's ''Gypsy Lady''. At least one story called ''The Reluctant Bride''...
*** In ''The Storm and the Splendor'' the hero saves the heroine from attempted rape by the villain, marries her (more or less against her will) and then explicitly resists the urge to consummate the marriage until she is truly willing (at one point, after they've been kissing and she gets upset, he abruptly leaves the bed and stands at the window, to, uh, de-arouse himself). A better example is ''Royal Seduction'' which can only be characterized as a guilty pleasure--nopleasure—no matter how witty and poetic Prince Rolfe is, no matter how noble his quest to find his brother's murderer, no matter how devastatingly good-looking he is, there is no getting around the fact that he ''explicitly'' rapes Angeline! And does so repeatedly in the days to follow. Other Blake examples include ''Golden Fancy'' (Ward at least apologizes to Serena immediately afterward) and ''Embrace and Conquer'' (Morgan rapes Felicite after believing her to have conspired with her half-brother to ambush him). And as for other authors, Rosemary Rogers is ''notorious'' for this; her books in the '70s frequently have heroines who ask (half-fearfully/half-coquettishly) "Are you going to rape me?" ''Love Play'', ''Sweet Savage Love''... The worst example is ''The Insiders'', a portrayal of '70s decadence at its worst -- Eveworst—Eve ends up marrying Brant, the gajillionaire who earlier had orchestrated her gang rape. Eve is also the victim of date-rape in anal form. Both Blake and Rogers are terrific writers whose books are certainly products of their times...
* Used more as "love is rape" in Diane Pearson's ''Summer of the Barshinskeys'', in which Ivan Barshinskey rapes the protagonist in anger out of not being able to have her beautiful sister, but she goes along with it because she loves him. It seems that it would count as rape because he is not aware of her consent, as he later apologizes and she soothes him. They later become contentedly married.
* [[Ayn Rand]] is rather notorious for ([[Useful Notes Objectivism|amongst other things]]) her very "bodice-ripper" style sex scenes. In ''[[The Fountainhead]]'', the first sex scene between Roark and Dominique Francon is arguably an instance of this trope being played straight (although a legitimate, if not necessarily correct, case can be made for the sex being dubiously or implicitly consensual given the rather obvious flirting between Roark and Dominique that occurred beforehand). Certainly to a [[Values Dissonance|modern reader that considers the no-means-yes-coy courtship game to be ridiculous]], the scene can plausibly be read as [[Victim Falls For Rapist]]. In ''[[Atlas Shrugged]]'' on the other hand, this trope is averted, because although the sex scenes are clearly on the rough and violent side, they are all explicitly consensual. Arguably this is a subversion since most modern readers ''expect'' an Ayn Rand sex scene to be a [[Victim Falls For Rapist]] scenario.
* Used realistically in [[John Ringo]]'s ''[[Council Wars]]'' series when the Big Bad kidnaps one of the heroines (along with a bunch of other women) for his harem. All are raped repeatedly until [[Stockholm Syndrome]] sets in, at which point the heroine is horrified to realize that she actually loves him, though that doesn't stop her from killing him in a [[Karmic Death|particularly nasty and gruesome fashion]]. Unusual in that the victim is fully aware of what has happened to her and recognizes that she's undergone a form of brainwashing. A later book shows that all of her harem-mates also suffered severe psychological trauma from the experience.
* Played fairly straight in Frank Herberts [[Dune]] series. The novels include various characters who are manipulated or forced into sexual situations and then end up in love with their partner. Of particular note are clones (called gholas) who lack the memories of their clone-parent until they are awakened through extreme trauma or awesome Jedi ninja sex. Since it is easier to awaken a clone through sex than trauma, "surprise sex" becomes the method of choice.
** In the fifth book, ''Heretics of Dune'', a sixteen year old Duncan Idaho ghola is raped by Murbella. Murbella and her Honored Matres sisters are so good at sex that they enslave men and planets they land on by having sex with them. Somehow, [[Ass Pull|Duncan is so good at sex that he and Murbella become addicted to each other.]]. This also has tones of [[Shotacon]] and [[Double Standard Rape (Female on Male)]] since Duncan is sixteen and Murbellla is substantially older than he is and Duncan is not ever asked if he is okay after being raped.
* Subverted in the French science fiction juggernaut (11.500+ pages without counting the sequel and spinoffs) ''La Compagnie des Glaces'' (''The Ice Company''): The "Rail Pirate" Kurts and his crew rape the powerful [[Corrupt Corporate Executive|Corrupt Corporate]] [[European Union|European]] [[Femme Fatale]] Floa Sadon, who acts as if she was enjoying it. The subversion comes from the fact that Kurts then falls in love with Floa, but she starts to love him only once their relationship becomes consensual and she has him wrapped around her little finger. Well, since they both are [[Magnificent Bastard|Magnificent Bastards]]s, maybe they were meant to be together...
** Another example comes from the fact that the protagonist, Lien Rag, is captured by a repulsive female mob leader who wants to have a child by him (she enjoys being pregnant, and Lien is supposed to have some specific genetic material that the mob leader would like to "implement" into her offspring). The mob leader then uses her younger and much better-looking daughter to make Lien "ready" and switch with her at the last minute. Lien Rag does not fall in love with the mob leader, but when it comes to her daughter, the fact that she was the accomplice in his rape does not bother him... or her, for that matter.
* Subverted in ''[[Atonement]]'' -- {{spoiler|Lola marries Paul due to societal pressure, and can't bear to admit that he raped her.}}
Line 210 ⟶ 209:
* In [[Bertolt Brecht]]'s novelization of ''[[The Threepenny Opera]]'', Polly Peachum is raped, but starts enjoying it almost right away. It's commentary, though, on how some people's overly lustful nature can lead to decadence and consequently a lack of understanding of the capitalist system. And on how capitalism is basically rape already, because workers in the two class system of early 1900's England had to use their body as their tool because the industrialisation had taken the traditional workplace tools and guild system from the common man.
* Subverted HARD in Richelle Mead's ''Dark Swan'' series, particularly the second novel, ''Thorn Queen''--{{spoiler|Eugenie is captured and drugged so that Leith, previously thought to be a [[Dogged Nice Guy]], can force himself on her and try to impregnate her}}. {{spoiler|Leith}} genuinely ''believes'' that he's doing it out of love, and is bewildered when {{spoiler|Eugenie}} has finally escaped and is confronting him about it at gunpoint, believing that what he did "wasn't rape." So, it's ultimately incredibly satisfying when {{spoiler|Dorian [[Impaled with Extreme Prejudice|introduces him to the pointy end of his sword]]}}.
* The entire ''plot'' of the ''[[Anita Blake]]'' series seems to revolve around this. The ''ardeur'' forces her, previously a [[Chaste Hero]] to have sex with people -- nonconsensualpeople—nonconsensual on ''both'' sides more frequently than not -- andnot—and afterwards usually they're somehow in love and fanatically loyal to her. Not helped by the fact that in later books (when the ''ardeur'' is introduced) she's a [[Canon Sue]]. Not to mention in the first appearance of the ''ardeur'', Micah finds Anita in the shower and, despite Anita repeatedly saying NO, has sex with her. From that point on apparently he's the most perfect giving forgiving partner ever, and they love each other.
* Toyed with by [[Roald Dahl]] in the short story ''Bitch''. A woman casually consents to being 'raped' for a scientific experiment, but it's much more forceful than she expected it would be. She loves it so much she ends up stealing the experiment's components.
* In [[Peter Benchley]]'s novel ''Jaws'' Brody's wife admits to having had rape fantasies in which she finds it horrible at first but really likes it "once she's...you know...into it."
* The flashback to Sedric's first encounter with Hest in Robin Hobb's Dragon Keeper is this. Hest manhandles him and kisses him roughly enough to make his lips bleed, then says that he can tell Sedric wants this and the sooner he admits that the easier it will be. Sedric stops struggling, and over the next few weeks Hest completely takes over his life. Sedric views this as a good thing, and many years later is still hopelessly in love with him.
* In Victor Pelevin's ''The Sacred Book of the Werewolf'', Alexander Sery goes berserk and rapes A Hu-Li after her attempt to hypnotize him goes awry. This causes them to realize they're both werecreatures, and they start a relationship soon after. {{spoiler|It doesn't last}}.
** The late 70's/early 80's spawned a new genre of historical romance novels which became known as 'bodice rippers'. Invariably, this was the entire plot of all of them. Our hapless heroine was raped by the hero--sometimeshero—sometimes as the result of a 'misunderstanding' (he mistakenly thought she was a prostitute was a common excuse) but enjoyed the experience so much that she eventually fell in love with him and they rode happily into the sunset by the end of the book.
* In the novel of [[Mildred Pierce]], Mildred and Monty are having one of their furious fights, and as they sit there fuming, he says "Damn it, what this needs is the crime of rape!" He then attempts to take her to bed and yank her clothes off, but she gets away. Several of their romantic encounters are kind of questionably ambiguous, but that is the most 'WTF' example.
* Played with in Nabakov's ''Lolita''. Humbert believes that his relationship with Lolita is love, even though Lolita herself refers to it as rape, {{spoiler|as does Humbert himself at the end of the book}}. Even ignoring how she is well below the legal age of consent in their state (twelve years old), given how she believed that he killed her mother and how terrified he was after that first night together, when she found out he drugged her, the relationship was not consensual in any way. Even at seventeen, she also has more confused and loving opinions about the man who molested her (and most likely groomed her so she'd behave like a [[Fille Fatale]]) when she was ten, and the older children (a boy and a girl) who raped her at her summer camp.
Line 228 ⟶ 227:
* The narrator of Chris Lynch's ''Inexcusable'' fully believes in this trope, but he has a habit of unintentionally undermining his own arguments. This is ''entirely'' deliberate on Lynch's part.
* In Megan Barker's ''Black-Eyed Susan'', a [[The Alcoholic|horribly drunk]] {{spoiler|Roderick Brandon}} mistakes {{spoiler|the title character}} for the streetwalker with whom he had been...attempting to negotiate. He rapes and [[Child by Rape|impregnates]] her; furthermore, while pawing at her face, he [[Eye Scream|claws her left eye severely enough that she loses the use of it]]. Later�[[Alcohol-Induced Idiocy|not remembering the incident clearly]]�he falls in love with her. {{spoiler|She, on the other hand, remembers every moment of it (and, more to the point, ''him'') all too clearly, and ''[[Subverted Trope|hates his guts]]'' for it�at least, until he [[Heroic Sacrifice|gives his own life to save hers]] at the end of the book.}}
* The ''[[Gor]]'' novels by John Norman. There are examples in all the books of the series, usually many examples apiece.
 
== [[Live -Action TV]] ==
 
== [[Live Action TV]] ==
* Soulless vampires in ''[[Buffy the Vampire Slayer]]'' often have a tendency to see rape and torture by their mates as a playfully kinky sign of affection. This is epitomized by Spike and Drusilla's relationship; when they break up at one point, Spike mopes and worries about how to win her back, before cheerfully realizing that he just needs to step up, take charge and "torture her until she likes me again".
** Subverted and toyed with to the breaking point by Spike's later relationship with Buffy. Both inflict rape-like behavior on one another until Spike ''actually'' tries to rape Buffy in her house--athouse—at which point, both realize that, even for them, lines have been crossed. (They still love one another, though. Maybe. He has a soul now, so it blurs things a little)
*** Relating to the Spike/Buffy example, it is interesting to point out that Spike tried to rape Buffy in an attempt to "use this very trope." He even said it outright to Buffy: He's going to force himself on her so she'll see she does loves him.
**** To go with the Spike/Dru example, don't forget the Dru/Angelus- Angelus raped, tortured, killed her family, drove her insane and then turned her, and yet Dru completely loves her 'daddy'.
* Done with disturbing frequency on soaps:
** Luke and Laura of ''[[General Hospital]]''. Despite Luke's rape of Laura while drunk, the two fell in love and eventually got married. Critics weren't too pleased with the [[Unfortunate Implications]], but fans ate it up.
*** Subverted years later when the show FINALLY dealt with the issue by having their teen-aged son Lucky find about the incident. Lucky was furious and disgusted with BOTH parents--callingparents—calling his father a monster and coldly insinuating to his own mother that she had sick sexual fetishes. (It didn't help that one of his best friends had recently been raped, in a storyline that had shown the trauma in a realistic manner.) His separate confrontations with both parents was an acting tour-de-force for the young actor, Jonathan Jackson. (This being a soap opera, the subversion might itself have been subverted many times over since then--thisthen—this trouper stopped watching shortly afterward.)
*** At the time the original plan of the writers was for Luke to die in atonement for his crime. Then the character got too popular to kill off and the the rape was retroactively defined a seduction.
** A similar reaction happened in [[The Eighties]] with Venezuelan [[Soap Opera]] ''Leonela'', whose titular protagonist fell in love with the man who raped her (although, to be fair, the man ''was'' in prison for many years and redeemed himself before even trying to have a second encounter with the heroine). The soap was so popular that it got a Peruvian remake fifteen years later, firing up the controversy again.
Line 246 ⟶ 244:
** The head writer of the soap ''[[One Life to Live]]'' originally planned on pairing up Marty with the leader of her gang-rape, Todd. Both actors so vehemently protested the story that it never got off the ground. However, both characters have been [[The Other Darrin|recast]] since then and Todd himself has fallen victim to [[Double Standard Rape (Female on Male)|rape himself]] as [[Rape as Redemption|penance]] so who knows what's going to happen next.
*** At present, Marty is again being played by the original actress. The character has amnesia and Todd is manipulating her into falling in love with him. Todd remains one of the show's most popular characters, possibly because those offended by his continued presence and supposed "redemption" have stopped watching.
** Frequently seen as the motive behind many of soaps [[Double Standard Rape (Female on Male)]] storylines--thestorylines—the woman is often desperately in love with the man whom she gets into bed via drugs and/or alcohol and hopes that the sex or resulting pregnancy will make him reciprocate the feelings.
** On [[Another World]], Jake raped Marley when she tried to end their relationship. Fast-forward a few years and not only is Jake engaged to Marley's sister Vicky, Marley is [[Clingy Jealous Girl|insanely jealous]] and gushing and fawning over Jake to the point where HE seems genuinely disturbed by this.
* ''[[The Tribe]]'': Lex tries to rape Zandra. She responds, on the advice of the advice of the group's new [[Granola Girl]], by proposing to him. And in case this wasn't weird and uncomfortable enough, they're both 14.
Line 255 ⟶ 253:
* At the end of 2002, in it's Year End Issue, Soap Opera Digest listed the Worst Trend as 'Romanticizing Rape", citing two infamous soap storylines. One, on [[Guiding Light]], in which a man nearly raped his girlfriend upon learning that she had cheated on him. The girl not only forgave him because [[Near-Rape Experience|he stopped before actually raping her]], she blamed herself for the incident because of her infidelity. The second storyline was on [[The Young and The Restless]], where Paul, who had cheated on his wife Christine and left her for the other woman was so incensed and distraught at the news of Christine's engagement that he showed up at her apartment to half-demand, half-beg that she not marry the other man, eventually telling her that he still loved her and beginning to make advances to her. Although she initially responded, when he began removing his clothes, she shifted gears and stated, "Wait, wait, this is wrong. I want you to leave." He grabbed her and threw her on the bed. Writers split hairs by pointing out that Christine never said the word "no", and completely ignored the fact that she made it explicitly clear that she wanted Paul to leave. In both cases, the assaults were presented as the result of a man's unbridled lust and passion, not the violent act it truly was.
** Which is interesting because [[Guiding Light]] did a deconstruction of this in 1979, with Roger and Holly. Holly had been cheating on Roger with Ed. When Roger found out, he raped her, in his mind, to prevent her from leaving him. Holly, needless to say, did not see it that way, and filed charges against him. Look it up on Google or Yahoo.
* Inverted in ''[[Penn and& Teller: Bullshit!]]'' in their war on porn episode. One of their guests suggested that porn will dehumanize women and thus make men think rape won't hurt them. This was met with an angry rebuttal by Penn saying (yelling) "Rapists fucking know they're hurting their victims! Hurting is the fucking idea, fucking isn't the fucking idea! You're trying to take away our porn by telling us that rapists are sensitive lovers who are simply misled by fiction?! No! No! No! No! Rapists are violent criminals who must be stopped."
* In the television version of [[Pretty Little Liars]], {{spoiler|Jenna}} had been forcing {{spoiler|Toby}} to have sex with her, but she insisted that they were in love, and that there was nothing wrong with it.
* In ''[[Being Human (UK)]]'', Saul tries to invoke something like this on Annie, after the voices of the dead secretly egg him on through the TV. She doesn't fall for it, and teleports out. {{spoiler|This was all a [[Kansas City Shuffle]] on the part of the dead, who planned on it leading to Saul drinking, having a car accident, and nearly dragging Annie into the afterlife.}}
* In the ''[[Criminal Minds]]'' episode "The Slave of Duty", the Unsub's second victim does this. However, it was merely a ploy in the hope he would let her go {{spoiler|and, unfortunately, it didn't work}}.
 
 
== Music ==
* Songs about rape or stalking or general "Ha ha we'll subvert [[Intercourse with You]]!" themes from the point of view of the rapist, stalker etc. are so common that they are a common go to interpretation for some people. Hence [http://www.cracked.com/article_18431_8-romantic-songs-you-didnt-know-were-about-rape.html this cracked article].
* "Gimme The Night" by eurobeat alias Dave McCloud sounds like [[Crowning Music of Awesome]] at first, but listen to the lyrics closely and you get creepy lines like "[[Does This Remind You of Anything?|Like a nice empty shell]] / Such a beautiful girl" and "[[Victim Falls For Rapist|You're my beautiful toy]]".
* [[Katy Perry]]'s E.T. has [http://smartiepops.wordpress.com/2011/02/21/katyperrykanyeet/ received some flack] for its "Stockholm Syndrome" like lyrics such as "Wanna be a victim, Ready for abduction" not helped by [[Kanye West]]'s additional lyrics of "I�I'mma disrobe you, Then I�I'mma probe you, See, I abducted you, So I tell you what to do."
* The Decemberists' song "We Both Go Down Together", a Romeo-and-Juliet-esque story of love and tragedy, reveals in the lines "I laid you down in the grass of a clearing/You wept, but your soul was willing" that their love initially begins when the narrator of the story rapes Miranda, and she likes it.
 
 
== Mythology ==
Line 271 ⟶ 268:
 
== Professional Wrestling ==
* On one episode of ''[[World Wrestling Entertainment|WWE]] [[Monday Night Raw]]'', [[Vince McMahon]]'s daughter Stephanie was all set to marry Test live in the arena, until [[Triple H]] interrupted, played a video showing that he had roofied Stephanie the night before and then married her at a drive-through chapel in Vegas while she was drugged, and then taunted Vince by claiming to have raped her afterwards ("It's not ''if'', but ''how many times'' we consummated the marriage!") At the next Pay-Per-View, Test fought Triple H to defend Stephanie's honor... until Steph had a [[Face Heel Turn]] and joined up with Trips, both out of newfound love and just to piss her daddy off.
 
== TheaterTheatre ==
 
* The original version of Eve Ensler's ''[[The Vagina Monologues]]'' features an ''extremely'' controversial section about a teenage girl who is given massive amounts of booze by an adult woman, who then takes advantage of her while she's drunk. The character in question finds herself ''enjoying'' the experience, and closes the monologue with the line, "If it was rape, it was a ''good'' rape." Later versions of the script attempt to rectify it by making the girl sixteen and removing the good rape line... but still portraying a [[Victim Falls For Rapist]] scenario.
== Theater ==
* The original version of Eve Ensler's ''The Vagina Monologues'' features an ''extremely'' controversial section about a teenage girl who is given massive amounts of booze by an adult woman, who then takes advantage of her while she's drunk. The character in question finds herself ''enjoying'' the experience, and closes the monologue with the line, "If it was rape, it was a ''good'' rape." Later versions of the script attempt to rectify it by making the girl sixteen and removing the good rape line... but still portraying a [[Victim Falls For Rapist]] scenario.
** [[Broken Aesop|Which makes it puzzling, as the play is the cornerstone of the "V-Day" movement, which attempts to raise rape awareness...]]
* The titular character in [[David Mamet]]'s ''[[Edmond]]'' seems in the final scene to have developed a strangely close bond with the [[Scary Black Man]] who raped him just two scenes earlier. Of course, this case is... well, not [[Justified Trope|justified]] ''per se'', but... well, [[Gainax Ending|part of something altogether bizarre anyway.]]
* In the original play of ''[[Spring Awakening]]'' by Frank Wedekind, Melchior rapes Wendla in the hayloft of his family's barn. In subsequent scenes, Wendla doesn't appear to be too troubled by the experience, but Melchior angsts over it, worried that Wendla will be angry with him.
* In ''[[Phantom of the Opera]]'', there has been much speculation about what happens between Christine and the Phantom when the lights go out after "Music of the Night". If there * was* sex, it was rape, as Christine was alternately unconscious/in a trance the entire time, but the lyrics of "Music of the Night" make it very obvious that the Phantom intends this a seduction, not an assault. In fact, the way the Phantom lovingly tucks her in and steps away after she falls unconscious was probably intended to show that he was not going to violate her. The film takes this a step further by showing her asleep from the Phantom's point of view with a curtain coming down between them.
*** The original script called for the Phantom to ''get into bed with her'' as the song ended and for the scene to fade out as he drew the curtain around them, leaving little doubt as to his intentions. Probably changed as it would have been hard to continue presenting him as a romantic hero after such a blatant violation.
* In [[Ayn Rand]]'s early play ''Night of January 16th'', Karen Andre is raped by and falls in love with Bjorn Faulkner in essentially the same way as Dominique Francon.
* Greek/Roman comedy often centred on the plight of a guy who had knocked up the girl next door, whom he loved deeply, before he'd got parental consent (whose he needed varied with the situation) to marry her. This wouldn't be too uncomfortable with modern audiences- however, the ''contemporary'' audience would have been extremely uncomfortable with a guy continuing to want any woman who consented to premarital sex... so the plot was almost invariably that the guy had got drunk at a festival, come home and committed this trope. (The girlfriend/victim would usually be [[The Unseen]]). Sort of overlap with [[Black Comedy Rape]], though more a case of [[Rape Baby]] As Comedy rather than the attack itself.
* ''[[Aida]]'': In at least two scenes before she willingly goes to bed with him, Radames hints at forcing himself on the title character, even though by the time of the second scene, it's obvious that he's attracted to her.
 
 
== Video Games ==
* In ''[[Crescendo]]'', this looks like it's played straight in {{spoiler|Ayame's}} path, but it actually winds up being a rather gut wrenching, traumatic inversion. {{spoiler|Your hero has a MAJOR [[Heroic BSOD]] on discovering he adopted, and find out his stepsister purposely [[B Sed]] him for years into believing otherwise sends his already depressed psychological state over the edge, and proceeds to ''rape'' her, or so it appears and looks like. In truth, she had feelings for you, and her massive lack of resistance was this combined with her guilt for lying to you, so it not entirely nonconsensual. It's still traumatic and messed up, but it eventually gets resolved in the good ending, where they both acknowledge their feelings, and you both manage to overcome the trauma together.}}
* Not quite rape, but sexual harassment--Ifharassment—If you allow Ocelot to grab Snake from behind during the final battle in ''[[Metal Gear Solid]] 4'', Ocelot {{spoiler|moans 'Snake...' and gives him a tender kiss.}} ''It restores Snake's Psyche''. Considering Snake's [[Love Hurts|weird romantic issues]], this makes sense.
** Snake can also be on the molesty end of the equation if the player decides to pat down a [[Amazon Brigade|FROG]] and touches their breasts or crotch. They hate it--[[I Was Quite a Looker|unless he looks young]].
* In the [[Touhou Project]] [[Hentai]]-[[Doujinshi]] ''Love-Reign'', [[Badass Bookworm|Alice's]] love for her doll Shanghai is portrayed in this manner. To quote one of [[Yandere|Alice's]] [[Nightmare Fuel|most disturbing lines ever]] (said when she as forcing a soul into Shanghai):
{{quote|"Your gestures of fright, pained behaviour, even your lovely voice are all so superb. Well, it's natural to expect it from something I've made with love.
There, it's done.
I love you, Shanghai." }}
** In ''Ningyou Kakumei'', [[Yandere|Alice]] tricks the naive [[Artificial Human|Medicine Melancholy]] into helping her with her ''[[This and That|research]]'' in making self-reliant dolls with a little help from a special drug made by [[Deadly Doctor|Eirin.]]
** In ''Fragile Prismatic Colors'', [[Marionette Master|Alice]] decides the only way she can get [[Miko|Reimu]] to accept her love is by using a spell that [[People Puppets|controls her like a puppet]]... Seriously? What's with all these authors turning Alice into a disgusting creep who can only get love if she rapes someone?
Line 310 ⟶ 305:
** Rance plays with this trope in unusual ways in that he very clearly believes that it applies in-universe, so much so that when Kenshin falls for him the ''normal'' way he has no idea how to handle it. And yet various comments scattered throughout the game make it clear that Rance has no evil in his heart, and ''honestly doesn't understand'' that rape is harmful, at least not when he does it.
** Rance, while he doesn't comprehend that rape is wrong, believes that regardless of the situation, both parties should be at least physically satisfied at the end of it. Hence why when he found out a character was raped in order to traumatize them, he was enraged beyond imagination.
* Subverted in ''Rapelay[[RapeLay]]'', by ILLUSION, a game which is about stalking and raping women. The entire game is actually an affirmation of the this trope, where the player trains the victims into loving his attacks.
* [[Embric of Wulfhammers Castle]] has the Duchess of Elstwhere raped by Carmina, a dark elf sorceress, in an elaborate [[Nightmare Fuel]] ritual surrounded by skeletons and dark-elf attendants. Since it happens [[All Just a Dream|in a dream]], [[Double Standard Rape (Female on Female)|Carmina is a woman and the Duchess is a lesbian]], and [["It's Not Rape If You Enjoyed It"|Duchess describes the encounter in detail to titillate her maid]], Carmina is easily forgiven, and the two fall in love; they're the only couple that gets a truly "happily ever after" ending.
* In ''[[Alice: Madness Returns]]'', {{spoiler|Angus Bumby was infatuated with Alice's sister Lizzie. Lizzie however hated Bumby since she could see that he was [[Obviously Evil]]. Believing that she was playing hard to get, he then sneaks into her room, rapes her and then burns down the Liddel household in order to cover his tracks.}}
 
 
== Web Comics ==
* ''[[Dominic Deegan]]: Oracle For Hire''. Adolescent Stonewater ([[Noble Savage]] orc) leapt in to save the outlawed Melna ([[Noble Savage]] orc) from being butchered along with her parents by a tribe of [[Always ChaoticExclusively Evil]] orcs. He invoked the ancient traditions or whatever to claim her as his wife and thus ineligible for butchery; they insisted with sharp pointy things that said traditions require knowing one's wife in the hot & heavy Biblical sense; she was too catatonic for a by-your-leave (and the tribe wouldn't have let him anyway). She knocked him out cold and legged it afterwards. Sparks fly when they meet up as adults and have to fight evil together, but Stonewater's grown up to be a hero with the power of nature and of [[Positive Discrimination]]. Through her disgust Melna realizes that she's fallen in love with him. Her reaction involves violence and alcohol. A honest attempt to depict very sensitive issues? Crossing a line that just shouldn't be crossed? A ham-fisted attempt to be "deep" and "edgy?" Opinions vary, but "'''orc rape!'''" has still become associated with ''Dominic Deegan''.
** Later revisited, where Melna admits that it wasn't Stonewater himself she was falling for, but the way he's grown into a Orc much like her father.
** This finally got a more satisfying conclusion in the Rebirth Of Maltak arc.
** It's also made clear that "[[Dirty Business]]" doesn't even ''begin'' to describe Stonewater's feelings about that day, which softens the [[Unfortunate Implications]] of this trope a bit.
* Viciously averted in the ''[[Tally Road]]'' story arc [https://web.archive.org/web/20100120145642/http://www.tallyroad.com/t/tallyroad-294.html Darkest Before The Dawn] where Finn practices his [[Black and Gray Morality]] by raping 'Eight' with hefty doses of BDSM expertise to {{spoiler|break her spirit and sell her into prostitution for money}}. Finn can and will cause her to respond sexually by patience and technique, but his final act of violation is explicitly {{spoiler|demanding her consent on the grounds that the rape will go faster and be over sooner, to which she assents, in despair}}. He causes her to just about explode with orgasm, setting up the trope perfectly- then [[Took a Level Inin Badass|takes a level in badass]] by reverting to his spirit-breaking mode and scorning her wordlessly, with the intended result. 'Eight' is depicted as way too smart not to figure out what is happening, and plainly does not fall in love. Of course, the trope is twisted further when Finn {{spoiler|lets her leave forever but reveals he's gone all softhearted over her anyhow}}... perhaps an ur-example of a [[Trope Backfire]]?
* ''[[Penny and Aggie]]'' had insecure Karen assault her boyfriend Marshall in the shower. She completely blew off a philosophical chat to grope him. All of which was portrayed as okay because she's insecure, because [[Double Standard|men are not victims]], and because Marshall is portrayed as too insecure to have sex because of his nymphomaniac mother. This is still fiercely debated in the fandom.
* Subverted in the comic [[All Roses Have Thorns]]. The vampire protagonist gets attracted to a human, then turns him into a vampire and rapes him repeatedly after killing his entire family. Needless to say the poor guy became a miserable terrified shell for quite a few years and retreated into himself, and after a few centuries now only silently hates his master.
* Arguably [[Deconstructed Trope|Deconstructed]] in ''[[Something *Positive]]'' with [[Obfuscating Stupidity|Ollie]], who was raised and repeatedly molested by his cruel, abusive uncle Avogadro. Though it's familial rather than romantic, he honestly ''does'' seem to be the only person who cares about his uncle or wants to honor his memory now that he's dead; apparently Ollie was beaten by his own parents constantly before Avogadro took him in, and so he continues to view his uncle as a "savior" despite the years of sexual and verbal abuse. This is presented as being a sign of Ollie's instability, however; Avogadro ''himself'' even noted once that when his nephew finally had a nervous breakdown, [[Kick the Dog|it would be "his greatest artistic achievement."]]
* In a [[Date Rape Averted]] example, taking the [[Love Chart]] into consideration, {{spoiler|Augustus}} had this in mind for [[Bittersweet Candy Bowl|Daisy]].
* Peter of ''[[Niels]]'' firmly believes in this trope, and says that he [[Depraved Bisexual|loves everyone even if they don't love him]].
* ''[[Ghastly's Ghastly Comic]]'' had a short 'arc' wherein a hentai schoolgirl is raped at the bus stop by an (apparently) passing tentacle monster. The succeeding strips show the unforeseen consequences when his watch gets left inside of her and culminate in her berating him for this and him buying her flowers to apologize, revealing their boyfriend/girlfriend relationship.
 
 
== [[Web Original]] ==
* Occurs in the [[Whateley Universe]] at least twice in the ''Second Book of Jobe''.
* Inverted in [https://web.archive.org/web/20100314111907/http://www.theonion.com/content/video/crime_reporter_man_had_sex_with this Onion video] where the reporter characterizes a mostly-happy 10 year marriage as if the husband was holding the wife hostage.
* Relationships between humans and [[Pokegirls]] tend to start this way, due to the [[Deus Sex Machina|mechanics of the setting]]. [[Property of Love]] is the best possible outcome. [[Sex Slave|It's not the only one, though]] . . .
* Played for intentionally creepy laughs with [[The Nostalgia Critic]] and Spoony, with the Critic acting like a [[Tsundere]]; one minute he'll be trying to kill Insano and actually being glad that Spoony's in there, being so traumatized he can't speak at the actual rape, or making him review an awful game as punishment - the next he'll be masturbating over the prospect of the Spocker again, lovingly daydreaming about how giving Spoony was, or having drunk sex with the guy again.
 
 
== Western Animation ==
Line 345 ⟶ 337:
 
{{reflist}}
[[Category:Victim Falls For Rapist{{PAGENAME}}]]
[[Category:Older Than Dirt]]
[[Category:Rape Tropes]]