Wouldn't Hit a Girl: Difference between revisions

no edit summary
m (restored deleted characters)
No edit summary
 
(12 intermediate revisions by 6 users not shown)
Line 1:
{{trope}}
{{cleanup|The page image is a "Pretty Much [[JAFAAC]]". If you're wondering why, ask yourself "where's the girl that he wouldn't hit?"}}
{{cleanup|[[Examples Need Sorting]]}}
 
[[File:change123 6 058 8758.jpg|link=Change 123|frame|[[Beware the Nice Ones|Probably]] [[Action Girl|a good]] [[Blood Knight|idea.]]]]
 
Line 24 ⟶ 25:
 
{{examples}}
== [[Live Action TVAdvertising]] ==
* Spoofed mercilessly in [https://web.archive.org/web/20121130074541/http://www.kidfenris.com/cyborgs2.html this ad] for the Super Nintendo game ''The Combatribes''. Remember, cyborgs ain't ladies!
** The arcade version doesn't have that little "cyborg" plot element, but the final boss is still the same woman. One can only imagine the scolding if the author of the article ever catches wind of ''that''.
 
== [[Anime]] and [[Manga]] ==
* ''[[Maken-ki!]]'' The main character has this philosophy. He also feels that women shouldn't even fight amongst themselves for any reason.
* Used brilliantly in the ''[[Hellsing]]'' manga and OVA. After assisting Integra in a fight against [[Those Wacky Nazis|Nazi]] vampires, some Iscariot members insist on her coming along as their prisoner. She refuses to do so, and, baffled about what to do, they propose knocking her out or tying her up. Integra points out that attempting this would be unfair because they outnumber her, and implies that there would be something thuggish and perverse about them attempting it because she's a woman. Anderson agrees, and instead the group settles on escorting her wherever she wants to go.
* ''[[Ranma ½]]'' has the titular character, who [[Fanon]] usually considers averse to fighting women no matter what the cause is. In canon, not so much; while there are one or two times he expresses the sentiment that he doesn't particularly like to fight girls, it mostly seems to be fans reading too much into the fact that Akane and his [[Love Dodecahedron|unwanted girlfriends]] can all give him the "total beatdown" version of the [[Armor-Piercing Slap]] despite being inferior martial artists. [[Overshadowed by Awesome|Compared]] to [[Can't Catch Up|him]]. Perhaps fuelled by heresay about a comment Ranma makes to Akane the first time in the series that the two of them are sentenced to [[Standing in the Hall]], where he mildly suggests that the reason Akane always beats Kuno is because when a guy is fighting a girl he likes, he might decide to let her win. The reality is that Ranma is [[Would Hit a Girl|quite willing to fight women]], will leap into battle with them without thinking, and only fights them on a relatively "low level" because:
## They are invariably less powerful than he is (barring Cologne, Kiima, Herb before [[The Reveal]], and [[Monster of the Week|Rouge]] in her [[Physical God|Ashura form]]).
## He usually has to face them in goofy [[Martial Arts and Crafts]] challenges where he can't use his best attacks.
## He normally only fights at his best and/or most brutal when against the nastiest or most annoying opponents, such as Happosai and Herb.
## There is a shown cultural stigma against fighting girls, which he knows about (shown in multiple arcs, such as the arc with Miss Hinako).
*:* Even the "turn into a girl to be able to fight a girl" thing gets played with; though one anime episode has him lampshade this type of thinking, he usually does it either because he ''has to'' in order to fight in the first place (competing in Martial Arts Rhythmic Gymnastics or Cheerleading, for example) or because the fight was started specifically because of his being in female form (first fight against Shampoo, or the manga version of the Martial Arts Tea Ceremony where he was abducted ''because'' he appeared to be a strong female martial artist). He even daydreams of bitchslapping Akane into shutting up and listening to him when he plans out how to explain being caught naked in the tub with Shampoo in the manga. Most tellingly, before [[The Reveal]] about Herb's [[Gender Bender|true gender]], Ranma was perfectly willing to go all-out with devastating attacks by ambushing ''a naked woman in the bath''—and Herb barely had time to block and divert a kick that pulverized a boulder. So yeah, if you prove you're a threat, and you prove you can take it, Ranma ''will'' fight back with everything he's got, regardless of age, gender, or size.
*:* That said, the general attitude that guys shouldn't hit girls does seem to have some place in the background of the series. Akane tries to stop Ryoga from fighting back against Ukyo, who is attacking him for attacking Ranma, by yelling out that [[Wholesome Crossdresser|she's really a girl]], clearly expecting Ryoga to back off at that. [[Embarrassing First Name|Pantyhose Taro's]] revelation that he [[Would Hit a Girl]] is used to emphasize just what a ruthless person he is and confirm his nature as a villain.
* ''[[Guilty Crown]]'': Dan Eagleman is ''disgusted'' when Segai points a gun at Haruka Ouma. {{spoiler|Even when hindered by the cancerous crystals caused by the Apocalypse Virus}}, he throws himself at Segai and punches him in the face, giving Haruka a chance to escape.
* ''[[Inuyasha]]'' Jakotsu, the flamboyantly gay villain with a crush on Inuyasha, was originally supposed to be female. The author changed him to male because she didn't want Inuyasha to kill a girl. The numerous minor female villains always either transform into monster form(Looking at you Mistress Centipede) during the fight or are dispatched by the female cast, like when Kagome killed Yura of the Hair by destroying the red skull that was her true form. Similarly, the two major female villains (Kagura and Kanna) get hit by the heroes' combined weapons only a handful of times despite being introduced very early in the series, and being dispatched very late in the storyline. In the end {{spoiler|Kagura is murdered by Naraku for betraying him, and Kanna is killed by taking the damage from the monster she was controlling while the heroes were pleading with her to not die for Naraku. Both deaths are treated as an example of what an abomination that Naraku was}}.
Line 45 ⟶ 49:
* ''[[Yu Yu Hakusho]]'' Kuwabara is revealed to have "don't fight girls" as part of his personal moral code. He even refuses to fight the demon Miyuki during the Rescue Yukina arc, despite the fact that she is both deliberately challenging him and quite offended by this attitude. Yusuke, meanwhile, promptly steps up and reveals that [[Would Hit a Girl|he has no problems with fighting girls]], declaring that he doesn't understand what the problem is with refusing to fight somebody who wants to fight you just because they're a different sex and proceeding to brutally finish her off. In the unedited dub, after beating her senseless, Kuwabara starts to protest Yusuke's actions in outrage, for which Yusuke reluctantly explains that Miyuki isn't a woman at all. She's female-dressed and [[Transgender]] (presumably male to female, though comments made could be taken as making her to be a female to male) with breasts and male sexual organs, leading to the following amusing quote:
{{quote|'''Yusuke''': The family jewels have ''not'' been stolen.}}
*:* Yusuke explains that he opened the fight by groping Miyuki on both the chest and crotch, the latter because something didn't quite feel right about the breasts. When Kuwabara asks if this means that Yusuke would have taken it easier if Miyuki had really been a girl, Yusuke refuses to answer. When Miyuki herself claims that Yusuke was actually extra rough because of her true nature, Yusuke batters her unconscious and insists he treated her exactly the way he would have treated any of his opponents, male, female or in-between.
** In essence, the scene manages to play the trope straight, avert it, and then subvert it in rapid succession.
* ''[[One Piece]]'' Sanji chivalrously refuses to fight women, or in one case a Shapeshifter taking the form of a woman (Nami, although that was partially because he couldn't stop swooning over how cute "she" was) even if it means his death, and was once severely beaten as a result, with Nami being sure to let him know how stupid he's being. He does point a gun at Nico Robin on one occasion, but admits that it was a reflex to protect Vivi.
Line 52 ⟶ 56:
*** This gets [[Deconstructed Trope|deconstructed]] in his fight with Kalifa, who beats him up, [["The Reason You Suck" Speech|and then lectures Sanji on how idiotic his moral code is.]]
** Sanji actually has to continually trick Mr 2 Bon Clay into touching his face with his left hand to keep the opponent from averting Sanji's attack because he takes Nami's form. Even mid-kick.
** It's easy to see where Sanji got this mindset from; his mentor "Red-Leg" Zeff is the same. Zeff refuses to hire women as cooks or waitresses in his restaurant, because he knows that if he did, he'd either have to treat them the same as he does his male employees - as in, like a [[Drill Sergeant Nasty]] does to soldiers - or show them favoritism, which is just as bad. It's much easier not to hire them at all.
** Notable occurrence in Usopp's fight with Perona. Usopp never actually hit Perona, instead using his various tricks and gadgets to frighten her into unconsciousness. Well, he did hit her with an inflatable hammer, but it didn't actually hurt her.
*** He tried to hurt her though at the start of the fight. Then, till the very end, she was not even tangible.
Line 87 ⟶ 92:
** This was nearly averted by Ryoma in the anime, though. When an [[Alpha Bitch]] from Jyousei Shonan and her [[Girl Posse]] were harassing Sakuno and Tomoka (and said [[Alpha Bitch]] [[Kick the Dog|pushed poor Sakuno to the ground and threatened to do the same to Tomoka when she stood up for her friend]]), he does ''not'' hit them... but throws balls ''dangerously'' close to them to scare them off. The [[Alpha Bitch]] has to dodge one of the balls, and had she not done so she ''would'' have been hit.
** In his backstory, a young Nanjiroh Echizen is ''extremely'' upset when he finds out that Rinko Takeuchi, the girl he fancies ([[Love At First Punch|in a rather sui-generis way]], has been physically abused [[Sadist Teacher|by her tennis coach]] (and for extra [[Kick the Dog]] points, she took a beating to protect a little child whom he has been mistreating) and settles things with a tennis match in which [[Curb Stomp Battle|he completely crushes him.]]
* ''[[Basilisk: The Kouga Ninja Scrolls]]'' Brutalhas a brutal and ''bloody'' subversion. [[Master of Disguise|Saemon Kisaragi]] of the Koga Ten says it's not in him to hit or kill women... {{spoiler|right after he kills [[Woman Scorned|Hotarubi]] of the Iga Ten by ''cutting off both of her hands and stabbing her in the chest, then letting her fall down a cliff''}}.
** In fact, out of all the Basilisk girls, only ''two'' aren't horribly killed by male fighters in the middle of the bloody feud between Igas and Kogas. One is killed by a fellow [[Action Girl]], and the other is [[Driven to Suicide]].
* ''[[Fullmetal Alchemist (manga)|Fullmetal Alchemist]]'': Greed refuses to fight Izumi, saying "I don't fight women, it's not my style." This doesn't stop him from making the side of his face as hard as diamond when Izumi tries to punch him, causing her to break several of her fingers.
* ''[[Eyeshield 21]]'' The Deimon Devil Bats go up against the Teikoku Alexanders, whose quarterback is female. Hiruma senses misplaced chivalrous intent in his team and cuts the problem off at the knees by making up a story to them about Karin, the female quarterback—her name's really Karinrou and she's a man, so you'd better go all out on her. It works.
* ''[[Yu-Gi-Oh! GX]]'' There'shas a rather curious variation where the one refusing to duel against [[The Chick|Asuka]] [[Hello, Nurse!|Tenjouin]] was... ''another woman''. Sure, Taniya is a [[Amazonian Beauty|buff]] and scarred [[Hot Amazon]], but she's still doesn't duel against other women - primarily since [[The Red Sonja|she was dueling in part to find a femalehusband]]. yetWhen saysTaniya activates a card that causes images of the duelists to strike each other, Jaden thought he'd fight her for real and tried to invoke the trope, which she doesnthankfully didn't dueltake againstas otheran femalesinsult.
* ''[[Haruhi Suzumiya]]'': Subverted in the second season (and the second novel), during the production of the Brigade-movie. Haruhi did her worst [[Kick the Dog]] act to Mikuru and then said to Kyon's face that it was okay for her to do such things. Kyon went ballistic on her... but then Koizumi stopped his punch. After that event, Koizumi also remarked that he "always thought [Kyon was] a calm person", and Kyon notes [[Not Himself|that it was not in him to be violent]],
** Then again, given [[The Red Sonja|she was dueling in part to find a husband]]... though if they had duelled anyway... [[Les Yay|it would've been HOT]].
** OneIn one of the most well-known (if not THE most) well-known Haruhi hentai doujins involves Kyon, after watching Haruhi performing even MORE heinous acts toon Mikuru, Kyon not only goes through with punching her, but he then proceeds to beat the crap out of her when she fights back, and culminates the beating by showinghumiliating her the same kind of humiliationway Mikuru went throughwas. His method of choice? Well, it's [[Hentai]], so take a guess.
*** Even worse, when Taniya activated a card that made images of the duelists strike each other and Jaden thought he'd fight her for real and tried to invoke the trope, she didn't take it for an insult.
* ''[[Haruhi Suzumiya]]'' Subverted in the second season (and the second novel), during the production of the Brigade-movie. Haruhi did her worst [[Kick the Dog]] act to Mikuru and then said to Kyon's face that it was okay for her to do such things. Kyon went ballistic on her... but then Koizumi stopped his punch. After that event, Koizumi also remarked that he "always thought [Kyon was] a calm person", and Kyon notes [[Not Himself|that it was not in him to be violent]],
** One of the most well-known (if not THE most) Haruhi hentai doujins involves Kyon, after watching Haruhi performing even MORE heinous acts to Mikuru, not only goes through with punching her, but he then proceeds to beat the crap out of her when she fights back, and culminates the beating by showing her the same kind of humiliation Mikuru went through. His method of choice? Well, it's [[Hentai]], so take a guess.
* ''[[Bleach]]'': Aramaki feels guilty about knocking Orihime out when she tries to bite him in order to go back and assist Uryu. Mayuri suggests that part of the "honor of the Quincy" involves protecting women- even enemies- after Uryu protests his mistreating his female lieutenant and "daughter," Nemu.
** Lampshaded and then averted by Renji. {{spoiler|Jackie}} asks him if he's not attacking her just because she's a woman, but; Renji calmly says it's not about gender, but about him not being willing to attack first. {{spoiler|Considering both his [[Curb Stomp Battle]] ''and'' [["The Reason You Suck" Speech]] against her...}}
** During his training with Uruhara, Ichigo shows a lot of reluctance to spar with Ururu, which overlaps with [[Wouldn't Hurt a Child]] because Ururu looks like a young girl. He quickly changes his mind when he finds out she's a lot stronger than she looks.
* When Hime-chan from ''[[Hime-chan no Ribon|Himechan no Ribon]]'' asked Daichi to hit her (because she hit him earlier and she felt guilty) he refused to hit a girl. So she grabbed his fist and punched herself with it.
* ''[[Death Note]]'': Mostly played straight with Light - he has no qualms whatsoever about killing women (at times brutally) with the Note, but he never physically harms them in person, though usually because it's too risky to be justified. He considers using physical force against Naomi Misora, for instance, but decides against it because it would be too likely for him to be seen doing so, or for him to make a mistake and let her escape, and that would really ruin his reputation as a model citizen. (It wouldn't have worked anyway: Misora was an expert martial artist... but Light didn't know that.)
** Only because it's too risky to be justified. He considers using physical force against Naomi Misora, for instance, but decides against it because it would be too likely for him to be seen doing so, or for him to make a mistake and let her escape, and that would really ruin his reputation as a model citizen. (It wouldn't have worked anyway: Misora was an expert martial artist... but Light didn't know that.)
* ''[[Kongoh Bancho]]'' Partially averted, where the protagonist Akira Kongoh has no problem fighting a girl, but often either underestimates them or intentionally holds back because of their gender. Although in both cases shown so far it's proven to be a rather bad idea, and he doesn't actually win until he goes all out.
** ''[[Durarara!!]]'' subverts this: Izaya isn't one for hitting girls—that's why he makes it a hobby of his to stomp on their cellphones instead. Shizuo, on the other hand, is a straight example, with rather tragic reasons for why: {{spoiler|throughThrough the majority of his adolescence, Shizuo tended to develop one-sided crushes on girls and women that inevitably ended with him trying to protect or save them... [[Hero with an F In Good|and accidentally hospitalizing]] [[Does Not Know His Own Strength|most of them in the process]]}}. The consequences drilled the idea of "hurting girls is bad" so deep into his head ([[Heroic Self-Deprecation|at the cost of any sort]] [[I Am a Monster|of self -esteem he might have]]) that even his [[Hair-Trigger Temper]] can't stand against it.
* ''[[Durarara!!]]'' Subverted: Izaya isn't one for hitting girls—That's why he makes it a hobby of his to stomp on their cellphones instead.
* Played with in ''[[Change 123]]'' Played with. Most characters in this manga don't have a problem hitting girls, including a biker gang that [[Blood Knight|Hibiki]] must confront to save her [[Non-Action Guy]] [[Love Interest]]. After the other [[Split Personality]], [[Lady of War|Fujiko]], takes care of the underlings, Hibiki confronts the leader and puts him in the hospital for a few weeks. Much later, the gang leader's girlfriend asks them to beat up this annoying girl she ran into... [[Oh Crap|who happens to be Hibiki]]. [[Crowning Moment of Funny|The entire gang spontaneously decides they don't hit women]].
** Shizuo, on the other hand, is a straight example, with rather tragic reasons for why: {{spoiler|through the majority of his adolescence, Shizuo tended to develop one-sided crushes on girls and women that inevitably ended with him trying to protect or save them... [[Hero with an F In Good|and accidentally hospitalizing]] [[Does Not Know His Own Strength|most of them in the process]]}}. The consequences drilled the idea of "hurting girls is bad" so deep into his head ([[Heroic Self-Deprecation|at the cost of any sort]] [[I Am a Monster|of self esteem he might have]]) that even his [[Hair-Trigger Temper]] can't stand against it.
* ''[[Change 123]]'' Played with. Most characters in this manga don't have a problem hitting girls, including a biker gang that [[Blood Knight|Hibiki]] must confront to save her [[Non-Action Guy]] [[Love Interest]]. After the other [[Split Personality]], [[Lady of War|Fujiko]], takes care of the underlings, Hibiki confronts the leader and puts him in the hospital for a few weeks. Much later, the gang leader's girlfriend asks them to beat up this annoying girl she ran into... [[Oh Crap|who happens to be Hibiki]]. [[Crowning Moment of Funny|The entire gang spontaneously decides they don't hit women]].
** Aizawa plays this trope straight. Although he is a [[Japanese Delinquents|"Yankee" Delinquent]] who fights very ungentlemanly against guys, he is unwilling to hit a girl, even if a girl (usually unintentionally) offenses him. The only exception is when he deals with the tomboyish Ginga, whose fighting skills are, however, on par with his.
* In ''[[Bakuman。]]'', when Miyoshi demands that Mashiro and Takagi let her into their office, Takagi reluctantly decides to answer the door, saying that she would beat him up later. He says that he would fight back and win, but can't because she's a girl, and Mashiro doubts this statement.
Line 115 ⟶ 116:
** [[Subverted]] in ''High School Boys and Seniority'', Motoharu didn't hit his sister's classmates that are bullying him...not because they're girls, but because they're [[Sempai-Kohai|senior to him]].
* Even though Guts from ''[[Berserk]]'' [[Would Hit a Girl|averts this]] when it comes to VERY LETHAL female apostles, he fiddles with this trope at best. You see, Guts isn't exactly the poster child of a [[Knight in Shining Armor]] and has done a BIG share of morally questionable actions, but he's still too decent of a guy to sink to level of battering women and girls just because. At most, he'll just hurt their feelings, traumatize them, threaten them, or hold them hostage, and in those instances, that was back when Guts was almost a [[Villain Protagonist]] before [[Morality Chain|he found his light again.]] A good example would be with his own future [[Love Interest]], Casca. When they were stranded in the rain after a battle and Casca feel ill (which was induced by her fighting during her period), [[Intimate Healing|Guts had to save her life by taking off their clothes and warming her.]] Casca, who didn't like Guts back then, didn't take too kindly to this gesture the next morning and attacked him. In his aggravation, Guts began to yell at her and told her that had she been a man, he would have dislocated her jaw. [[Stay in the Kitchen|Guts said a bunch more pretty hurtful things to Casca]] - which resulted in her crying and him feeling sorry for doing so - but it was most likely because he was hurt that he always tried to get on Casca's good side but she never approved of him, so he just popped.
* In the ''[[My-HiME]]'' manga, this is averted when Yuuichi tries a [[Get a Hold of Yourself, Man!]] punch on a brainwashed and insane Shiho, but this only makes things worse.
 
== [[Comic Books]] ==
 
== Comic Books ==
* ''[[Sin City]]'' Played straight in the comic book and film; Marv has some (albeit a very few) moral lines in the sand, which he crosses only with extreme reluctance - hitting a woman is one of them. He crosses this line on only two occasions in the series: {{spoiler|to spare his companion Wendy, Goldie's twin sister, from having to watch him torture Goldie's killer Kevin to death}}, and {{spoiler|executing a female slave trader who was planning to sell a girl who Marv was trying to find and bring back to her mother into sexual slavery}}.
** Marv also takes this trope one step further, as other people hitting women is his [[Berserk Button]], particularly in regards to Nancy Callahan, his favorite among the strippers at Kadie's. He mentions an episode from his past when some frat boy asshole roughed up Nancy, and Marv "straightened him out but good," implying that the other guy didn't survive the beatdown.
* ''[[Superman]]'': Subverted (sort of; there's notno "hitting"...) early in the John Byrne reboot: Superman faces a gang which includes a violent, glasses-wearing, heavily armed female member spouting revolutionary phrases. She tries the double-powered "You wouldn't hit a lady with ''glasses'', would you?". Superman gently removes her glasses and flicks his finger on her forehead, knocking her cold. He then says, "A lady? No, but then I've never met a ''lady'' who carries dynamite under her coat."
** And yet after that, Superman backslides into being bound by this trope. Fortunately for Metropolis, most of his opponents are male because, when he fights a woman, he gets slapped around a lot because he can't be shown striking her, even when she's clearly powerful enough to take one of his punches. He'll restrain her or attack her in an indirect fashion (like pouring water on Livewire), or a female superhero will step in (often after he's been dropped) and beat the villainess up for him.
* In ''[[Asterix]] and the Secret Weapon'' The villain attempts to use this trope to defeat the invincible-yet-honourable Gauls - by employing a whole ''centuria'' of women to fight them. The gauls respond by transforming their village into a giant mall. The "trap" succeeds flawlessly; [[Unfortunate Implications]] ahoy, though one can also attribute their lack of military discipline (evidenced in their first on-page appearance) to a rushed training.
Line 128:
* ''[[Wonder Woman]]'' volume 3 #20, Diana ticks off [[Beowulf]], and he attacks her. After she punches him in the face, Beowulf apologises and says he doesn't fight women. Then they see Grendel's worshippers approaching, and Diana asks him if he ever fights ''beside'' women. Cue the pair readying themselves for battle.
** Which is odd, because in the original Legends, one of the monsters Beowulf kills is Grendel's ''mother''.
*** ...who was less a woman, and more a man -eating monster who just happened to be female.
** ''[[Green Lantern]]'' When Kyle Rayner went on a Hero Quest (asking established heroes questions on being a hero), one of [[Wonder Woman]]'s lessons to him was "never underestimate a woman." (The comic opens with Kyle beating Wonder Woman in a staged fight.)
* The first time [[Spider-Man (Comic Book)|Spider-Man]] encountered a female villain, he said that he couldn't hit a girl. Few of his villains even today are female.
** He gets over this later. In ''[[Secret Wars]]'' especially when he takes on Titania (who was about kill [[She Hulk]]) and throws her through a wall.
** He had definitely gotten over this by the videogame based on the third movie; not only can you pummel Shriek, there are also Apocalypse Gang Grenadiers, who are female, and there's nothing stopping you from catching them in a web line and slamming them at high speed into the pavement.
* ''[[Captain America (comics)|Captain America]]'': Used and subverted in an issue. Going up against Anaconda, a rare female villain who is muscular, does not possess the [[Most Common Superpower]], and genuinely enjoys a fistfight, Cap pulled a punch "in deference to her womanhood", then decided not to make that mistake again. He then realized that she could shrug off punches that "could shatter bone", and had to resort to his shield. As said in the comments for the entry, "Dude, it's Captain America. He believes in freedom, justice, civil liberties, gay rights, gender equality and yeah, that means punching men and women without discriminating."
** Used again in another comic. A supervillain and a supervillainess have escaped from prison. Long story short, Cap hits her with his elbow hard enough to knock her out briefly while saying "Sorry, lady!"
* ''[[Shazam|Captain Marvel]]'' In a 1970s comic, the Marvel Family storms Hell itself. They fight various mythological monsters there; when they run into Lamia, neither Billy nor Freddy dare hit her, despite her being a half-snake monster. Luckily the brought Mary Marvel along. * Pow*
* ''[[The Punisher]]''—for a while. Prior to Garth Ennis, Frank had a habit of going easier on women than men. He once laments that he doesn't know why, given all the evil women he's met. They usually try to kill him despite his mercy, making it a moot point.
** Both subverted and played straight in a fairly recent ''[[The Punisher|Punisher]]'' Christmas Special (2005, I think), wherein a [[Dark Action Girl|hitwoman]] is hired by the wives of New York mafiosos killed by the Punisher. She has a decoy gun down civilians at Times Square on New Years Eve to draw Frank out, then they engage in brutal fight. Frank wins, and the hitwoman reveals she has a bizarre [[Stalker with a Crush]] attitude towards Castle. She reveals her employers, Frank apparently kills her by tossing her out a window, and then confronts the wives. The lead one pulls a gun and is killed, while the others plead with Castle, who agrees to let them go, as long as they leave the country after donating money to the victims of the Times Square massacre.
Line 146:
* [[Fantastic Four (Comic Book)|The Thing]] explains [http://www.comicvine.com/jean-grey/29-3552/earth-616-jeanphoenix/108-26/jean_grey1/105-1712956/ his predicament] in a [[Let's You and Him Fight]] with the [[X-Men (Comic Book)|X-Men]].
 
== [[Film]] ==
 
== Film ==
* ''[[Small Soldiers]]'' Chip Hazard references the trope, but he's very selective about how he applies it. His statement is in reference to a bunch of Barbie dolls he and his fellow toys roboticized. He really has no problem killing human women if necessary.
* ''[[Batman Returns]]'' When Batman and Catwoman are fighting for the first time, she pummels him and he refuses to counterattack - for a moment. When finally he does punch her out, she whimpers, "How could you? I'm a ''woman!''" Immediately contrite, Batman moves to help her up... and she knocks him off the rooftop. "As I was saying, I'm a woman, and can't be taken for granted!" In later encounters, Batman has learnt his lesson and does hit her.
Line 171 ⟶ 170:
* In ''[[Superman II]]'', Ursa says, "What? ''You'd'' hit a woman?" to get Superman to hesitate.
 
== [[Literature]] ==
 
== Literature ==
* Played to the hilt in ''[[The Wheel of Time]]'' series. Although many of the women of [[Fan Nickname|Randland]] wield more political power than men, and are frequently seen physically abusing men, most cultures are extremely protective of women, causing many men to refuse to harm a woman for any reason. Many women, however, protest this behavior.
** Rand al'Thor is the most prominent example. He refuses to harm a woman even if she's an immortal agent of [[Ultimate Evil]] and trying to kill him using legendary [[Black Magic|magical powers]]. He also goes out of his way to avoid putting women in danger, which upsets his Amazonian bodyguards immensely. In fact, Rand has memorized the name or identifying characteristic of ''every woman'' who died because of him or while in his service. He once goes into a [[Heroic BSOD]] after a woman who tried to steal his throne and betray him commits suicide. The 12th book suggests that his behavior is the result of his growing insanity, which magnifies his chivalrous upbringing.
Line 183 ⟶ 181:
* In ''[[The Great Brain|More Adventures of the Great Brain]]'', the kids all taunt a 12-year old girl named Dottie, who dresses like a boy and has never been to school before. Ringleader Sammy gets a little too close, so she punches him in the nose. He says he'd fight back if she weren't a girl, but she tells him to go ahead. Sammy ends up eating dirt, and once she learns to fit in, Dottie becomes a celebrity among the other girls for beating up a bigger boy in a "fair and square fight."
* In [[Lois McMaster Bujold]]'s ''[[Chalion|Paladin of Souls]]'', Arhys {{spoiler|kills seven enemy sorcerers before being defeated by the eighth. Ista tells the others that the last sorcerer was probably a young and beautiful woman, and Arhys couldn't overcome his chivalry in time to win the fight. His brother remarks sadly that it is an appropriate death for him.}}
* ''[[Harry Potter (novel)|Harry Potter]]'' generally averts this as the majority of duels are done with wands instead of fists. Notable is from [[Harry Potter/Harry Potter and Thethe Order of Thethe Phoenix (novel)|the fifth book]] where Harry wants to outright kill Bellatrix and is able to knock her off her feet for a moment. However from the same book there is a DA session where Michael Corner appears unwilling to try and disarm Ginny though she is his girlfriend. Interestingly, this is subtly presented as evidence of his jerkassery, rather than chivalry.
* Subverted in ''A World Gone Mad''. Jerkass [[Anti-Hero]] Griffin, when confronted by teen [[Action Girl]] Tanya, raises his hands and tells her "I'd never hit a girl." He then promptly whips out his gun and shoots her in the head while she's occupied preparing to give him a "you sexist idiot" speech.
** He later tries to pull the exact same move on Kyra, but she's quick enough and smart enough to dive for cover before he can clear his holster.
* Played completely straight in another of [[David Weber]]'s book series, the [[Hell's Gate]] series where both empires have big, big issues with harming women.
* ''[[Discworld]]'':
** Lobsang Ludd from the ''[[Discworld]]'' novel ''[[Discworld/Thief of Time|Thief of Time]]'' met 3 humanly disguised auditors. He beat two of them, but he couldn't beat up the third one. Why? Obviously, for no other reason than that the auditor had dressed itself as a woman. Lucky Susan Sto-Helit took it out.
** Banjo, a brutish but childlike thug from ''[[Discworld/Hogfather|Hogfather]]'', had deep objections to hitting girls because of his monstrously domineering mother's rules.
** The Librarian usually [[Berserk Button|gets aggressive]], when he's called a monkey, but when Ginger does it in ''[[Discworld/Moving Pictures|Moving Pictures]]'', he just pats her hand.
*** He also just wags a finger at Agnes in ''[[Discworld/Maskerade|Maskerade]]'', to which another character says "He likes you. He doesn't usually go in for warnings."
* In [[Dan Abnett]]'s [[Gaunt's Ghosts]] novel ''Traitor General'', when the [[La Résistance|resistance member]] Sabbatine Cirk baits and snipes at the members of Gaunt's team, it is Ana Curth who finally slugs her.
* In [[Sandy Mitchell]]'s [[Ciaphas Cain]] novel ''The Traitor's Hand'', the colonel of the Tallarn regiment refuses to participate in an interregimental competition of unarmed combat because the women in the Vallahan regiment would participate, which is "unseemly." Whereupon their regimental champion was "promptly and informally challenged" by a female Vallahan.
Line 213 ⟶ 212:
* ''Sisterhood'' series by [[Fern Michaels]]: Harry Wong in ''Lethal Justice'' apparently has this attitude towards Yoko Akia when they spar against each other. She non-hesitatingly kicks his ass, but she is still willing to have a relationship with him anyway!
 
== [[Live-Action TV]] ==
 
== [[Live Action TV]] ==
* ''[[Star Trek]]'' plays this straight a lot. Which is weird, since the Federation (especially from the TNG era on) is generally portrayed as a liberal utopia free from all gender prejudice.
** ''[[Star Trek: Deep Space Nine]]'' In the episode ''Dax'', [[Dogged Nice Guy|Dr Bashir follows Dax to her quarters]] and sees her being kidnapped by a [[Terrible Trio]]. [[Crowning Moment of Awesome|After punching]] [[The Scrappy|their leader]], one of the other two goes for him. He is about to punch when the hood comes down and he sees it's a woman. Needless to say, the poor guy got his ass handed to him.
Line 231 ⟶ 229:
* ''[[Batman (TV series)|Batman]]'' the 1960s series. The villains' girlfriends never got involved in the fights, Batgirl never got hit, and in one especially goofy moment, the villain uses a ''gang of schoolgirls'' to capture Robin, knowing that he's 'too much of a gentleman' to hit a woman.
** Revealing exception: In "The Entrancing Dr. Cassandra," Batgirl actually takes several punches... all from invisible opponents.
* ''[[Lois and& Clark]]'': (a.k.a. ''The New Adventures of [[Superman]]''): In one episode a female villain yells at Superman "You can't hit a lady can you?". She is then, however, promptly hit on the head by one of her male victims. The lady in question had just acquired Superman's powers and was just as strong and tough as him.
* ''[[Ashes to Ashes]]'' Taken more or less as a given—while the two male leads of ''[[Life On Mars]]'' could and did knock each other around as a regular means of conflict resolution, for Gene to raise a hand to his new female opposite number would be [[Crossing The Line]]. Not that they actually fight any less often, you understand—he's just forced to resort to verbal baiting and blatant sexual harassment.
** It's probably a side-effect of this trope that leads to Gene's sidekicks being astonished when she hits him with a fist, instead of with an open hand.
Line 240 ⟶ 238:
** Apparently averted at least once... because Conan used that clip on his show, acting shocked after it was over.
** [[Would Hit a Girl|The exact opposite of this trope]], however, was regularly used with the villains, who frequently batter women in many episodes, always without fear of the consequences. (Children and elderly people have also been known to be hit and injured by the bad guys in episodes.)
* ''[[Firefly (TV series)|Firefly]]'' Given a speech about 'shooting girls' Mal gives in the pilot, you'd think that this is alive and well in the Old West [[In Space]]. {{spoiler|Right up to the end of 'Our Mrs Reynolds', when he corners would-be ship thief and title character Saffron. He asks her what her real name is in a moment that seems full of emotional tension. She pauses, starts to speak ... and he slugs her. Then again, this is well after she poisoned him and left him and his crew to die, so he's probably feeling a mite justified.}} The brawl at the start of 'The Train Job' suggests that this doesn't apply anyway. (And seeing what usually happens to people who so much as threaten Mal's crew, let alone put them in actual danger, {{spoiler|Saffron}} really got off lightly.)
* Subverted in ''[[The Wild Wild West (TV series)|The Wild Wild West]]'': The second (In Color!) [[Animated Credits Opening]] changed a scene of Jim West incapacitating a female assassin with a kiss to incapacitating her with a right cross. That's right: Woman-punching was specially added for the new-and-improved credits sequence. Though given he shot all other opponents, it's still a step down on violence: [[Double Subversion|James West wouldn't shoot a girl.]]
* Played with in ''[[Chuck]]'':
Line 284 ⟶ 282:
'''Mary''': I can't believe you'd hit a girl!
'''Marshall''': You're no girl. }}
* Another amusing subversion occurs in ''[[Stargate Atlantis]]'' when Vala punches Daniel then exclaims "You hit me!" when he returns the favor. He exasperatedly points out "''You'' hit ''me''!"
 
== [[Newspaper Comics]] ==
 
== Newspaper Comics ==
* Subverted in an early ''[[Peanuts]]'' strip, where Charlie Brown is fed up with Lucy, and shouts at her. She challenges him to a fighting match, but he declines. Linus says that Charlie Brown should've slugged Lucy. Schroeder explains that Charlie Brown "would never think of hitting a girl, so he deliberately humiliated himself to hold on to his high moral standards". Charlie Brown responds that he was just afraid that she would beat him up.
** In another ''Peanuts'' strip from the late 1950s, Linus takes Lucy on in a backyard boxing match but takes two hard lefts before he knows it. Stunned, Linus begins to get serious and then Lucy lowers her gloves and says "You wouldn't hit a girl, would you?" while Linus, saying "Huh?" then lowers his gloves upon which Lucy rips a left hook to Linus' jaw to knock him out.
Line 294 ⟶ 291:
* In ''[[Dick Tracy]],'' when the female villain Quiver has threatened to blow up an airliner, Tracy ends up having to sock her in the jaw before she can hit the button. Afterward, he looks embarrassed, and tells the stewardess he doesn't normally go around hitting women. The stewardess quips, "That's alright, Detective Tracy. Haven't you heard of equal rights?"
 
== Professional Sports ==
* The reason why intergender boxing/MMA fights aren't promoted. [[Professional Wrestling]] occasionally subverts it for entertainment value, such as Chyna's Intercontinental title reign.
** Some women in MMA and boxing have a problem with this, arguing that however unlikely they'd be to actually beat most male opponents, competing in the same leagues would give women's MMA a better chance of being taken seriously and making more money.
 
== [[Professional Wrestling]] ==
* A longtime trope in [[Professional Wrestling]] (at least among [[face]]s), averted when [[Triple H]] (then Hunter Hearst Helmsley) hired a female bodyguard ([[Chyna]]), who was more muscular than most of the men on the roster. She established her position early on by beating up [[Bret Hart]] in one of her first appearances, without giving him a chance to hit her back. Then they went up against [[Stone Cold Steve Austin]], who had no such qualms, and thus made it OK for men to get physical with her (and occasionally, other women). She would go on to regularly wrestle men and win the Intercontinental title.
** Often times if a heel has a female manager or girlfriend, they'll [[Dirty Coward|use her as a human shield]] when being chased by a face with a steel chair, because they know the face would never hit a woman.
Line 312:
* During the WWF's kayfabe era, this trope's most frequent use centered on Miss Elizabeth, the valet of [[Randy Savage]]. During Savage's heel run in 1985-1987, particularly when he was wrestling [[Hulk Hogan]], Savage would pull Elizabeth in front of him, using her as a shield while he had a chance to regroup; Hogan would simply pick Elizabeth and gently move her out of the way, giving Savage ample opportunity to blindside Hogan. Also during Savage's heel run, he came close several times to striking Elizabeth himself (usually when he perceived her to be paying too much attention to an opponent, not opening the ropes or folding his robe correctly or some other minor misdeed) but always stopped short of actually striking her. Apparently, Savage (and the WWF) agreed that they wanted him to be a heel, but not such an outwardly despicable one.
: The rule of "never touch Elizabeth" began to be thrown out when Savage turned face at the end of the summer 1987, and while the heels never struck or punched her, Elizabeth was shoved and grabbed by both the wrist and ankle on many occassions, by such dastardly heels as The Honky Tonk Man, [[Andre the Giant]], the Big Bossman and Akeem. Savage's other opponents during his face run -- Butch Reed, "Million Dollar Man" Ted DiBiase, Haku, Bad News Brown and Dino Bravo -- were satisfied with simply trash-talking Elizabeth. During Savage's second face run starting in 1991, Jake "the Snake" Roberts completely threw out the trope by slapping Elizabeth across the face during a memorable match.
 
* This was averted in the [[Attitude Era]] and Ruthless Aggression Era in a few intergender tag matches where men and women on
separate teams would get in some offence against their opposite gender. The likes of [[Lita]], Jacqueline, Molly Holly, Ivory and later [[Trish Stratus]] would have no objections to taking a few hits from the men.
** Bubba Ray Dudley completely averted this in a tag match in late 2002 where he dished out body slams and clotheslines to Victoria with no hesitation along with both her male partners.
 
== [[Recorded and Stand Up Comedy]] ==
* One Canadian stand-up comic has a bit he does where he announces that under no circumstances should a man hit a woman. But there should be women who a man could ''hire'' who could hit a woman...
* Hilariously subverted by the comedian [[Titus]]:
{{quote|'''Titus''': "Now, I don't think a man should ''EVER'' hit a woman! ...Until the fifth time she's cracked him in the face."}}
 
== [[Video Games]] ==
* ''[[Bully (video game)|Bully]]'' allows you to hit girls, but your alert bar goes to maximum and prefects spawn out of nowhere to attack you. Justified, since it's a Western game, after all. This has a side-effect of turning Zoe {{spoiler|who doesn't appear until very late in the game and fills the conspicuously-empty Bully clique girl's slot}} into a [[Faux Action Girl]], because although she's stated to a formidable fighter and really likes to fight, you can't fight her; the girl-type AI has them run away if struck.
* The ''[[Final Fantasy]]'' series. Every character is willing to hit a girl, but there are a few exceptions;
Line 353 ⟶ 356:
* In [[Fallout 2]], if your Chosen One is female, Enclave patrols will occasionally express their displeasure about having to kill a woman. Doesn't stop them from tearing her a new one with their hi-tech weapons though.
* In ''[[BlazBlue]]'', this is one of the [[Pet the Dog|nicer traits]] of [[Badass|Ragna]] [[One-Man Army|the]] [[Anti-Hero|Blood]][[Jerk with a Heart of Gold|edge]]. Granted, he won't hold back if a woman attacks him or tries to apprehend him, but he states several times that he doesn't enjoy fighting them, and when he does defeat them, he is usually quite sympathetic and regretful.
 
 
== [[Web Comics]] ==
* Justified in the [[Web Comic]] ''[[Fans]]'' with Will Erixon: {{spoiler|he feared becoming like his father, who beat his mother to death.}}
* Noted in ''[[The Order of the Stick|Order of the Stick]]'': when a dire situation requires heroic warrior Roy Greenhilt to magically [[Gender Bender|change his gender]], and his friend Haley gives him some grief about it, he/she warns her: "[http://www.giantitp.com/comics/oots0236.html You know, technically it's now OK for me to hit a girl. I'm just saying.]"
* ''[[Ozy and Millie]]'' plays with this trope [https://web.archive.org/web/20100713130208/http://www.ozyandmillie.org/d/19990310.html here].
* Used straight in ''[[Misfile]]'' [http://www.misfile.com/index.php?page=33 when Emily slaps Ash and tells her she can only hit back if she's willing to accept being a girl.] Semi-averted later when Ash picks a fight with Tom and he fights back (offscreen) until they're pulled apart. (It's not a true aversion since Tom is never actually shown striking Ash.) Naturally, the [[Double Standard]] ensures that Tom gets punished and Ash doesn't even though she started the fight, which both relieves her and annoys her to no end. Fully averted later [http://www.misfile.com/?page=1312 here], when Ash loses her cool and actually ''does'' hit a girl full-force in the face, only to freak out about it afterwards.
Line 365 ⟶ 367:
** Mr. Verres, however, follows this trope completely as shown [http://egscomics.com/?date=2010-11-01 here.] Even though he knows that the "girl" in question is [[Gender Bender|normally a guy]] he still won't deliver the much-deserved [[Dope Slap]].
* The [[Villain Protagonist]] Hunter Ravenwood of [[Suicide for Hire]] claims that [[Even Evil Has Standards|"I draw the line at the unwarranted violent abuse of the fairer sex."]] This does not stop him accepting female clients of the eponymous business, however, nor did it stop him from planning the most grotesque death yet for a female client. {{spoiler|His plan involved, in Arcturus' words, "having metal hooks shoved up [her] ass to forcibly remove [her] innards". When Arcturus argued that this was too close to rape, Hunter amended the plan and shoved the hooks down her throat instead.}} Evidence suggests he tries not to think of the clients as people in the first place.
* Parodied in ''[[Girly]]'' in [https://web.archive.org/web/20130602103120/http://girlyyy.com/go/511 this strip].
* ''[[Last Res0rt]]'', being a (reasonably) egalitarian [[Cyberpunk]] future setting, sees very few problems with women fighting alongside men on the show, or shoving people into a pit full of [[Mecha-Mooks|robotic chickens]] for a job interview... but when [http://www.lastres0rt.com/?p=53 Jason slaps Daisy upside the head], almost every other woman in the room is still shocked and appalled, to the point that Jigsaw's overly dramatic [[Freak-Out]] is [http://www.lastres0rt.com/?p=54 dismissed as a bad reaction to the scene], ignoring the [[Red Eyes, Take Warning|dead eyes]] she just showed off... Daisy was chained to the wall by her hands and foot, and was helpless when it happened. She was trying to provoke him at the time anyway...
* Played straight AND averted in [http://gunshowcomic.com/347 this] [[Gunshow]] comic
Line 374 ⟶ 376:
'''Torg:''' Ouch. Is that policy too?
'''Crushestro:''' Ever since my re-divorce? Yes! }}
* [[Lampshade Hanging|Lampshaded]] in [http://missmab.com/Comics/Vol_666.php this] ''[[DMFADan and Mab's Furry Adventures]]'' strip. No, Wildy, Jyrras probably wouldn't hit you if you were a guy either; but by all means jump to conclusions anyway.
* In a flashback arc of ''[[General Protection Fault]]'', Fooker makes some sexist remarks to Ki disparaging her studying Computer Science, and gets beaten up as a result, being unable to fight back because of this trope. Averted with Sam, who backhands Ki when she can't go through with having sex with him, and then [[Attempted Rape|tries to]] [[Moral Event Horizon|rape her]].
* In ''[[Our Little Adventure]]'', [http://danielscreations.com/ola/comics/ep0131.html Lenny asks Julie to hit her sister for him, because of the double standard and everything.]
 
== [[Web Original]] ==
 
== Web Original ==
* Sarge of ''[[Red vs. Blue]]'', despite his usual willingness to shoot or hit anything Blue (or Grif). In Reconstruction, when the blue soldiers of Blood Gulch consist of only Sister, Sarge insists that he can't attack Sister because she's a woman, and thus they are locked in an 'epic stalemate'.
* In ''[[Epic Rap Battles of History]]'', [[Ludwig Van Beethoven]] says this is why he won't smack [[Justin Bieber]].
 
== [[Western Animation]] ==
 
== Western Animation ==
* ''[[Avatar: The Last Airbender]]'' By and large averted but played with in-story [[Kayfabe]] no less, in the episode "The Blind Bandit":
{{quote|'''The Boulder:''' [[Third Person Person|The Boulder]] feels conflicted about fighting a young, [[Disability Superpower|blind]] girl.
Line 427:
* Judge Mills Lane subverts it during his fight with [[Judge Judy]] in ''[[Celebrity Deathmatch]]''. Although he does make it known that he doesn't hit women, he puts a blindfold on as a handicap and proceeds to fight her.
 
==Other Real Life ==
* Commonly [[Truth in Television]]; many parents do teach their sons this rule. Men who break this taboo, even in self-defense against a woman who poses a credible threat, are treated with contempt in many cultures.
** Fortunately, some parents are now realizing the danger of teaching this rule and are instead teaching their sons not to hit a girl UNLESS''unless'' it's self-defense.
* Spoofed mercilessly in [http://www.kidfenris.com/cyborgs2.html this ad] for the Super Nintendo game ''The Combatribes''. Remember, cyborgs ain't ladies!
** The arcade version doesn't have that little "cyborg" plot element, but the final boss is still the same woman. One can only imagine the scolding if the author of the article ever catches wind of ''that''.
* One Canadian stand-up comic has a bit he does where he announces that under no circumstances should a man hit a woman. But there should be women who a man could ''hire'' who could hit a woman...
* Hilariously subverted by the comedian [[Titus]]:
{{quote|'''Titus''': "Now, I don't think a man should ''EVER'' hit a woman! ...Until the fifth time she's cracked him in the face."}}
* In a real-life example, during the New York newsboys' strike of 1899, the striking newsboys used violence against scabs (i.e. boys selling papers in defiance of the strike) and against the delivery wagons that distributed the newspapers, but they never used violence against the women who owned and ran newsstands that sold the boycotted newspapers. Kid Blink, leader of the strike, said "A feller can't soak a lady."
* The reason why intergender boxing/MMA fights aren't promoted. [[Professional Wrestling]] occasionally subverts it for entertainment value, such as Chyna's Intercontinental title reign.
** Some women in MMA and boxing have a problem with this, arguing that however unlikely they'd be to actually beat most male opponents, competing in the same leagues would give women's MMA a better chance of being taken seriously and making more money.
* A metaphorical example: ''[[The Gruen Transfer|Gruen Nation]]'' commented, that in the leadup to [[Australian Politics|the 2010 Australian Election]], the Coalition seemed unwilling to run ads attacking Prime Minister Julia Gillard herself, as opposed to the Labor Party (albeit probably more because they were worried about how the public would react than any moral qualms on their own part). It was only near the end of the campaign, as things got increasingly frenetic, that ads attacking Julia Gillard appeared.
* [http://rivals.yahoo.com/highschool/blog/prep_rally/post/For-first-time-Iowa-girl-wins-a-state-wrestling?urn=highschool-322846 This guy wouldn't wrestle with a girl.]
** Not altogether uncommon. To quote a teammate of mine from high school: "There's no good way to wrestle a girl. You don't want to lose to a girl and look like a wimp, but if you beat her, you just look like a bully.
* Although Angel Eyes, the villain from ''[[The Good, the Bad and the Ugly]]'' had no problem with hitting girls, [[Lee Van Cleef|Lee Van Cleef,]], the actor portraying him, absolutely refused to, requiring the director to use a stunt man in the scene where it happened.
* In a real-life example, duringDuring the New York newsboys' strike of 1899, the striking newsboys used violence against scabs (i.e. boys selling papers in defiance of the strike) and against the delivery wagons that distributed the newspapers, but they never used violence against the women who owned and ran newsstands that sold the boycotted newspapers. Kid Blink, leader of the strike, said "A feller can't soak a lady."
 
{{reflist}}
[[Category:Wouldn't Hit a Girl{{PAGENAME}}]]
[[Category:Women Are Delicate]]
[[Category:Morality Tropes]]
[[Category:Stock Phrases]]
[[Category:Double Standard]]
[[Category:Wouldn't Hit a Girl]]
[[Category:Examples Need Sorting]]