Aristocrats Are Evil: Difference between revisions

→‎Literature: Added Example.
(→‎Video Games: adding to example.)
(→‎Literature: Added Example.)
 
(9 intermediate revisions by 3 users not shown)
Line 42:
For more information on the British title system, see [[Knight Fever]]. Not to be confused with [[The Aristocrats]], a "stock joke" based on this premise.
 
 
----
{{examples}}
== Kings/Queens ==
Line 60:
** And naturally, her [[Bastard Understudy|protege]], the Evil Queen from ''[[The Tenth Kingdom]]''.
* The Emperor of ''[[Dune]]'' is only good in comparison to [[Complete Monster]] Baron Harkonnen. The Emperors throughout the series fall under this trope, even the Necessary Evil ones—God Emperor Leto made himself the most reviled being in history, distrusted and despised even by his closest supporters.
* Downplayed with the Queen of Hearts in ''[[Alice's Adventures in Wonderland]]''; she has a foul temper and very fond of ordering executions for petty reasons (her timid husband the King quietly pardons anyone she orders beheaded), but isn't as evil as she is depicted in most adaptations.
 
=== [[Live-Action TV]] ===
Line 73 ⟶ 74:
* ''[[World of Warcraft]]'':
** The Lich King, evil, [[Arc Villain]] no less.
** Sylvanus the Banshee Queen, [[Sociopathic Hero]] initially, regresses to [[Byronic Hero]], then true[[Nominal villainHero]], then [[Knight Templar]], and finally (as of ''Battle for Azeroth'') true villain, {{spoiler|but eventually redeemed.}}
** Queen Azshara, evil Queen of the Naga and later [[God of Evil|their goddess]]
** Grand Magistrix Elisande in ''Legion'', Queen of the Highborne, [[Dragon-in-Chief]] of the arc, and [[A Nazi By Any Other Name]].
Line 105 ⟶ 106:
* Downplayed with the Duchess in ''[[Alice's Adventures in Wonderland]]''. She's an [[Abusive Parent]] and in a foul mood when she an Alice first meet, but she's far friendlier the second time, although she also has [[No Sense of Personal Space]].
 
=== [[Live -Action TV]] ===
* ''[[Power Rangers Wild Force]]'' had [[Co-Dragons]] Jindrax, Duke of Orgs and Master of Blades and Toxica, Duchess of Orgs and Mistress of Magic; both evil, both [[Card-Carrying Villain]]s, both [[Large Ham]]s.
 
Line 139 ⟶ 140:
 
=== [[Western Animation]] ===
* DuchnessDutchness [[Raven Waves]] from ''[[Lady Lovely Locks]]'' is pure evil.
* Duke Igthorn from ''[[Adventures of the Gummi Bears|Duke Igthorn]]'' is an evil duke and would-be usurper.
* [[I Love Nuclear Power|Duke Nukem]] (not [[Duke Nukem|that one]]) from ''[[Captain Planet and the Planeteers]]''.
* Duchess from ''[[Foster's Home for Imaginary Friends]]'', evil initially, but later [[Villain Decay|just annoying.]]
 
 
== Marquesses/Marchionesses (Marquis) ==
Line 156 ⟶ 157:
* The Marquis de La Tour d'Azyr in [[Scaramouche]] is a ruthless, manipulative killer.
* Marquis de Carabas from [[Neil Gaiman]]'s ''[[Neverwhere]]''. A {{spoiler|good guy}}, and a scheming [[Magnificent Bastard]]. Though technically, he's not even really an aristocrat, as he is said to have taken his title from "a lie in [[Puss in Boots (novel)|a fairy tale]]". He's also only technically a {{spoiler|good guy. More on the 'helping the heroes because there's a lot in it for him' side}}.
* ''[[Discworld/The Fifth Elephant|The Fifth Elephant]]'' by [[Terry Pratchett]] makes references to a "Marquis of Fantailler", who got into a lot of fights (mostly by way of being called the Marquis of Fantailler), and felt this entitled him to write a book. This book was called "The Noble Art of Fisticuffs" and was mostly a list of places where people weren't allowed to hit him. Whether he was particularly good or bad is never brought up, but it's implied that he was kind of an idiot because, as Vimes notes when Carrot tries to fight according to Marquis of Fantailler rules against an opponent who would have to back off a bit to qualify as dangerous, it only works when both people think so.
** This is of course a parody of the real life 9th Marquess of Queensberry, whose name was given to rules for boxing codified in the 1860's1860s, i.e. the Marquess of Queensberry rules. The real life Marquess was the father of Lord Alfred Douglas ('Bosie'), outspoken (or reckless, considering the times and who his father was) lover of Oscar Wilde. Angered by his son's relationship with Wilde, he was central to the trial and prison sentence which led to Wilde's early death. If you're a fan of Oscar Wilde, it makes this Marquess pretty evil.
* From the ''[[Carrera's Legions|Carreras Legions]]'' series, the Marchioness of Amnesty (as in Amnesty International), as part of a future UN that's become a true world government, and over the centuries became a [[Feudal Future]] government. The original Marquis of Amnesty<ref>who basically bought the title and position with gold from Terra Nova, paid by Carrera's ancestor to buy arms to fight the proto-United Earth forces</ref> and the two marchionesses who have been shown to hold the title prior to {{spoiler|Captain Wallenstein}} being made Marchioness of Amnesty in ''The Lotus Eaters'' resemble the stereotypical depiction of the [[Marquis de Sade]].
 
=== [[Theater]] ===
Line 212 ⟶ 213:
* Count Ugo Carifex from the [[Young Bond]] novel ''Blood Fever''.
* Viscount Hundro Moritani in the ''[[Dune]]'' prequels. As much, if not more, of a bastard than Baron Vladimir Harkonnen (see below). Most of his subjects take after him. His ambassador shoots a rival at a state dinner. He orders the bombing of civilian targets despite the declaration of Kanli, a war limited to military targets. He has his rival's son and daughter kidnapped and publicly executed. When another House condemns these actions, he orders the assault on their planet to steal their most holy relic. An ally of the viscount's assassinated the rival's second daughter at her wedding to Duke Leto Atreides (the ally was himself a Duke, by the way). He gets what's coming to him, though.
* Counts in the ''[[Vorkosigan Saga]]'' vary. Most of them are presented as fairly normal politicians though the worst of them grind down on their fiefdoms tyranically.
 
=== [[Live-Action TV]] ===
Line 241 ⟶ 242:
* Count Bleck from ''[[Super Paper Mario]]'' is evil, {{spoiler|at least for most of the game.}}
* Countess Alcina Dimitrescu from ''[[Resident Evil: Village]]''; evil vampire and cultist.
* Lara Croft from ''[[Tomb Raider]]'' is Countess of Abbingdon; [[Lovable Rogue]] and [[Anti-Hero]], definitely, but whether she is Good or Evil [[Alternative Character Interpretation|depends on whose opinion you believe.]]
 
=== [[Web Original]] ===
Line 319 ⟶ 321:
* ''[[World of Warcraft]]'' features a boss named Baron Rivendare, who appears in the dungeons Stratholme and Naxxramas. Before he was raised into a Death Knight, he was a wealthy land owner who fell under the sway of the lich Kel'Thuzad and helped him structure the Cult of the Damned.
* Baron Spider, the second boss in ''[[Ninja Gaiden II]]'', evil, probably insane, and not a real Baron.
* The Black Baron from ''[[MadWorld]]'', evil, a [[Large Ham]], the [[Final Boss]], and according to Keese, not a real Baron.
 
=== [[Western Animation]] ===
Line 371 ⟶ 374:
**They are however many surprisingly ''blackmailable'' Manticoran aristocrats and a mole is able to stalemate the House of Lords by the whisper of the vast hoard of information she has. Which does not make them evil precisely, but it does mean that some of them have something to hide and enough cowardice to let that manipulate them against their countries interest.
**At the same time they are as likely as anyone to be found on the front lines either fighting well, or if they can't do that, getting blown up [[Family Honor|to prove a point.]] Pavel Young(one of the series' most distasteful villains) of course is an exception and not only is he a miserable person he does not even have the grace to get killed in a gentlemanly way.
* In [[Belisarius Series]] there are a number of aristocrats some of whom are sadistic to the point of stupidity and others of whom are attractive enough. As this is the Middle Ages no one is to squeemishsqueamish about ruthless behavior.
** Neither aristocrats nor commoners are particularly gentle though not all of them are precisely cruel. But the villain is a demon robot from the future. Making normal earthly class and tribal rivalries petty.
 
=== [[Live-Action TV]] ===
Line 407 ⟶ 410:
** There are a couple exceptions in the manga: not counting Serpico (who was not really born a noble) or Farnese (whose [[Heel Face Turn]] coincided with her abandoning her renouncing her status), Roderick is pretty nice, while Laban and Owen actually give a crap about protecting commoners.
* ''[[Mobile Suit Gundam]]'' has the entire [[Big Screwed-Up Family|Zabi family]], including [[Non-Action Big Bad|Sovereign Degwin]], [[Evil Prince|Prince]] [[Complete Monster|Gihren]], [[Four-Star Badass|Prince Dozle]], [[Evil Genius|Princess]] [[Manipulative Bastard|Kycilia]], and [["Well Done, Son" Guy|Prince Garma]].
 
=== Comedy ===
* ''[[The Aristocrats]]'' joke plays on this trope, the disgustingly [[squick]]y performance being triumphantly named "The Aristocrats."
 
=== [[Film]] ===
Line 436:
* The [[Kingkiller Chronicle]] books play with this somewhat. Ambrose Jakis is the son of a rich baron and uses his birth and wealth as an excuse to be a colossal douchebag to everyone and especially Kvothe. On the other hand, Willem and Simmon are both sons of minor nobility and Kvothe's best friends, while Count Threpe is a [[Cool Old Guy]] who occasionally helps Kvothe and serves as a patron to a number of musicians and entertainers.
* The [[Low Fantasy]] novel ''Gerfalcon'' by Leslie Barringer subverts this as rank isn't noticeably indicative of goodness or evil; there are two [[Complete Monster]] counts (one's actually a [[Mood Swinger]] who seems more-or-less reasonable '''most''' of the year, but [[Nightmare Fuel|then]]....) and one [[Evil Uncle]] count, but also some good and plenty of neutral counts. The hero starts out waiting to be given the title of baron when he turns eighteen, but becomes a viscount before he can claim his barony ... and within a year is himself a count. His cousin, a viscount, lazy and thoughtless but good-natured, was one of the few people at his uncle's castle who showed him any friendship. Also, one of the kindest men in the story is a baron throughout.
* [[Older Than Radio]], Prince Dakkar, aka Captain Nemo, from ''[[Twenty Thousand Leagues Under the Sea]]''; [[Affably Evil]], [[Tragic Villain]], and [[Well-Intentioned Extremist]].
 
 
=== Meta ===
Line 444:
=== [[Massively Multiplayer Online Role Playing Game|MMORPG]]s ===
* Trade Prince Maldy in the goblin starting zone in ''[[World of Warcraft]]'' Cataclysm is shaping up to be quite the scumbag.
 
=== [[Recorded and Stand Up Comedy]] ===
* ''[[The Aristocrats]]'' joke plays on this trope, the disgustingly [[squick]]y performance being triumphantly named "The Aristocrats."
 
=== [[Tabletop Games]] ===
Line 455 ⟶ 458:
* ''[[Assassin's Creed: Brotherhood]]'' features the [[Real Life]] evil Pazzi family, as well as Rodrigo Borgia. It also adds the rest of the Borgia family, as well as fictional Silvestro "The Noble" Sabbatini who engaged in human trafficking.
* ''[[Embric of Wulfhammers Castle]]'' has several nobles, some good, some bad, some minor characters not worth talking about. The Duchess of Elstwhere is a perfectly nice and helpful aristocrat, despite her [[Abusive Parents|childhood]], even willing to milk a cow as part of relieving the fears of the peasants. Her uncle, meanwhile, Bad King Greyghast the Terrible, well, managed to get himself called Bad King Greyghast the Terrible. And Duke Theremin is basically a bit of an entitled snot.
* In ''[[Darkest Dungeon]]'', the Ancestor (who is the [[Narrator]], [[Evil Mentor]] to the player, and {{spoiler|possibly the [[Big Bad]]}}) certainly fits, but his title is not stated. Also, in the Crimson Curse DLC, the Bosses include the Baron, the Viscount, and the Countess.
 
=== [[Web Comics]] ===
Line 471 ⟶ 475:
* The very existence of aristocracy is based on oligopoly of violence. The concept of nobility is the elite of violence—be they knights, samurai, sipahis, rajputs, narts or savaran—that is, elite soldiers who are stronger than the oppressed masses and are able to subjugate them and live off their work. The alternative for aristocracy is usually either [[plutocracy]] (domination of elite of economy), theocracy (rule by the clergy), or [[Anarchy Is Chaos]].
**Every state is based on an oligopoly of violence. More to the point, no one can help their ancestry and it is not unknown for any given aristocrat to be harmless or even useful in the present. What is closer to making this [[Truth in Television]] is that aristocracies tend to reflect conquests or robberies in the past. In other words aristocrats are hardly automatically evil but a good many of their ancestors were.
* A lot of the problem that created the abuses of aristocracy in the past stemmed from combining proprietary, familial, political, military, and ceremonial authority in the same persons causing them to be [[Drunk with Power]]. Later when the ceremonial aspect was emphasized more and other aspects downgraded the ugly side grew less. In other words a queen whose portrait is on your wall is better then a queen who can [[Off with His Head|cut off your head.]]
 
{{reflist}}
[[Category:{{PAGENAME}}]]
[[Category:Royalty and Nobility Tropes]]
[[Category:Meaningful Titles]]
[[Category:Naming Conventions]]
[[Category:{{PAGENAME}}]]