Bait and Switch Lesbians: Difference between revisions

Content added Content deleted
m (Mass update links)
m (Mass update links)
Line 2: Line 2:
[[File:lucia-sumire-bait.jpg|link=Venus Versus Virus|frame|[[Not What It Looks Like]]]]
[[File:lucia-sumire-bait.jpg|link=Venus Versus Virus|frame|[[Not What It Looks Like]]]]


{{quote|"''[[Girl On Girl Is Hot|We like our ladies to go les]]... but not [[But Not Too Gay|full]] les.''"|'''Brian Safi''', ''[http://current.com/items/90732681_thats-gay-lady-kisses.htm That's Gay]''}}
{{quote|"''[[Girl-On-Girl Is Hot|We like our ladies to go les]]... but not [[But Not Too Gay|full]] les.''"|'''Brian Safi''', ''[http://current.com/items/90732681_thats-gay-lady-kisses.htm That's Gay]''}}


In the eyes of fandom, a show's major selling point is that its principals are [[Schoolgirl Lesbians]]... but oops, it was just a [[Romantic Two-Girl Friendship]] after all! The viewers have been [[Ship Tease|Ship Teased]]; and now that the writers got their attention, they can write more comfortable (to them) relationships. The lesbian [[Subtext]] may [[Bait and Switch Credits|not even last beyond the opening credits]].
In the eyes of fandom, a show's major selling point is that its principals are [[Schoolgirl Lesbians]]... but oops, it was just a [[Romantic Two-Girl Friendship]] after all! The viewers have been [[Ship Tease|Ship Teased]]; and now that the writers got their attention, they can write more comfortable (to them) relationships. The lesbian [[Subtext]] may [[Bait and Switch Credits|not even last beyond the opening credits]].


The is pretty common in [[Moe|Bishoujo fandom]], where the [[Romantic Two-Girl Friendship]] develops for a number of unintentional factors. One could say that [[Girl On Girl Is Hot|audience likes girls in large quantities, and seeing two girls acting cute, even at each other, is better than one]]. One could also point out that ''far'' more attention is put into the interaction and communication between the girls; while a relationship with a guy just "happens" with most development offscreen. And if they're the [[Improbably Female Cast|only people you see]] but the show still maintains particular tropes, the audience is sometimes led toward an imagined payoff that might not be there. Often, this is coupled with a young age for both characters as well as the lack of any actual 'sexuality' in either character, barring [[If It's You It's Okay|concessions]], as this outcome is harder to rationalize for an adult character. Note that any romantic relationship with boys, on the other hand, is considered completely serious at any age. Yes, it's [[Double Standard|hypocritical]].
The is pretty common in [[Moe|Bishoujo fandom]], where the [[Romantic Two-Girl Friendship]] develops for a number of unintentional factors. One could say that [[Girl-On-Girl Is Hot|audience likes girls in large quantities, and seeing two girls acting cute, even at each other, is better than one]]. One could also point out that ''far'' more attention is put into the interaction and communication between the girls; while a relationship with a guy just "happens" with most development offscreen. And if they're the [[Improbably-Female Cast|only people you see]] but the show still maintains particular tropes, the audience is sometimes led toward an imagined payoff that might not be there. Often, this is coupled with a young age for both characters as well as the lack of any actual 'sexuality' in either character, barring [[If It's You It's Okay|concessions]], as this outcome is harder to rationalize for an adult character. Note that any romantic relationship with boys, on the other hand, is considered completely serious at any age. Yes, it's [[Double Standard|hypocritical]].


Tends to raise the hackles of a show's [[Yuri Fan|Yuri Fandom]], who tend to crop up more infrequently, but also makes them paranoid in the long run. Any male friend of one of the girls becomes the [[Sword of Damocles]]; a possible route of escape for the writers via [[Last Minute Hookup]]. So [[Die for Our Ship|expect malevolence.]] It takes frustratingly little for a male character to become a love interest. A single scene, a [[Where Are They Now? Epilogue]], can instantly make [[Canon]] to overturn entire seasons of interaction.
Tends to raise the hackles of a show's [[Yuri Fan|Yuri Fandom]], who tend to crop up more infrequently, but also makes them paranoid in the long run. Any male friend of one of the girls becomes the [[Sword of Damocles]]; a possible route of escape for the writers via [[Last-Minute Hookup]]. So [[Die for Our Ship|expect malevolence.]] It takes frustratingly little for a male character to become a love interest. A single scene, a [[Where Are They Now? Epilogue]], can instantly make [[Canon]] to overturn entire seasons of interaction.


An ironic result of this is making a relationship explicit can result in enough fuel for viewers who oppose the [[Shipping]] to simply scoff that any evidence of the pairing is "just [[Fan Service]]." The fact that a great many shows avoid [[Unfortunate Implications|portraying relationships in significant detail muddies it further: so many other shows cop out at the last minute, so why should this one be different?]] The writers won't ever [[Hide Your Lesbians|admit anything anyways]].
An ironic result of this is making a relationship explicit can result in enough fuel for viewers who oppose the [[Shipping]] to simply scoff that any evidence of the pairing is "just [[Fan Service]]." The fact that a great many shows avoid [[Unfortunate Implications|portraying relationships in significant detail muddies it further: so many other shows cop out at the last minute, so why should this one be different?]] The writers won't ever [[Hide Your Lesbians|admit anything anyways]].


Outside of canon this trope is invoked a lot especially in H-doujins due to a rather persistent tendency for [[Most Writers Are Male|male writers]] to be intimidated by the idea of girls who don't find them sexually attractive (though generally only mildly). This is the reason why a disturbingly large number of popular lesbian characters and characters who are popular in part because of their [[Romantic Two-Girl Friendship|near lesbian tendencies]] are depicted in huge amounts of heterosexual porn with a random [[Author Avatar|male insert]] or more and very frequently in the form of rape instead of [[Girl On Girl Is Hot|with each other]].
Outside of canon this trope is invoked a lot especially in H-doujins due to a rather persistent tendency for [[Most Writers Are Male|male writers]] to be intimidated by the idea of girls who don't find them sexually attractive (though generally only mildly). This is the reason why a disturbingly large number of popular lesbian characters and characters who are popular in part because of their [[Romantic Two-Girl Friendship|near lesbian tendencies]] are depicted in huge amounts of heterosexual porn with a random [[Author Avatar|male insert]] or more and very frequently in the form of rape instead of [[Girl-On-Girl Is Hot|with each other]].


Compare [[Faux Yay]]. Related to the [[Sweeps Week Lesbian Kiss]].
Compare [[Faux Yay]]. Related to the [[Sweeps Week Lesbian Kiss]].
Line 19: Line 19:
== Anime and Manga ==
== Anime and Manga ==
* While the original ''[[Maria-sama ga Miteru]]'' novels are a bit more lenient in [[Subtext]], the anime only has one canonical pairing, derailed when one member ''went off to become a nun,'' and when two girls are about to kiss, the camera cuts away as if it were [[Sexy Discretion Shot|something much more]] [[Harmful to Minors]]. This is especially unusual, as ''[[Portmanteau Series Nickname|Marimite]]'' is pretty much defined by its [[Girls Love]] fandom.
* While the original ''[[Maria-sama ga Miteru]]'' novels are a bit more lenient in [[Subtext]], the anime only has one canonical pairing, derailed when one member ''went off to become a nun,'' and when two girls are about to kiss, the camera cuts away as if it were [[Sexy Discretion Shot|something much more]] [[Harmful to Minors]]. This is especially unusual, as ''[[Portmanteau Series Nickname|Marimite]]'' is pretty much defined by its [[Girls Love]] fandom.
* ''[[Bubblegum Crisis]]: Tokyo 2040'' spent its first half building the [[Sempai-Kohai]] relationship -- and [[Romantic Two-Girl Friendship]] -- between Priss and Linna. The final half of the series drops this subplot like a hot potato for a [[Last Minute Hookup|sudden romance between Priss and Leon]] that fits the "offscreen explanation" part of the trope to a T; Leon shows up at her club while she's on stage, does a smarmy clap for her, Priss grins a bit, and from thereon in they're treated as dating.
* ''[[Bubblegum Crisis]]: Tokyo 2040'' spent its first half building the [[Sempai-Kohai]] relationship -- and [[Romantic Two-Girl Friendship]] -- between Priss and Linna. The final half of the series drops this subplot like a hot potato for a [[Last-Minute Hookup|sudden romance between Priss and Leon]] that fits the "offscreen explanation" part of the trope to a T; Leon shows up at her club while she's on stage, does a smarmy clap for her, Priss grins a bit, and from thereon in they're treated as dating.
** Ironically, it was the original ''[[Bubblegum Crisis]]'' [[OAV]] that gave rise to the mantra among many early anime fans that "All women in anime are lesbians. Unless they're bisexual."
** Ironically, it was the original ''[[Bubblegum Crisis]]'' [[OAV]] that gave rise to the mantra among many early anime fans that "All women in anime are lesbians. Unless they're bisexual."
* ''[[Nana]]'' has, at its core, the interesting relationship between the two titular Nanas: [[Tomboy and Girly Girl|one a tough punk-rocker, the other a girly girl who likes frilly fashion]]. Disappointingly, most of the manga depicts the two girls' relationships with comparatively bland or annoying guys, to the point where the carefully set up romantic tension between them is all but thrown overboard--which isn't helped by the fact that one of them {{spoiler|gets knocked up.}}
* ''[[Nana]]'' has, at its core, the interesting relationship between the two titular Nanas: [[Tomboy and Girly Girl|one a tough punk-rocker, the other a girly girl who likes frilly fashion]]. Disappointingly, most of the manga depicts the two girls' relationships with comparatively bland or annoying guys, to the point where the carefully set up romantic tension between them is all but thrown overboard--which isn't helped by the fact that one of them {{spoiler|gets knocked up.}}
Line 56: Line 56:


== Cross-Media ==
== Cross-Media ==
* In the TV ''[[Doctor Who (TV)|Doctor Who]]'' there was some fairly strong innuendo that [[Mad Bomber]] [[Action Girl]] companion Ace was bisexual if not preferentially lesbian, especially in the stories ''Ghost Light'' and ''Survival''. But when the TV show ended and the [[Virgin New Adventures|New Adventures]] spin-off novels were allowed to go for a [[Hotter and Sexier|more]] [[Darker and Edgier|"adult"]] tone, she was depicted as entirely straight.
* In the TV ''[[Doctor Who]]'' there was some fairly strong innuendo that [[Mad Bomber]] [[Action Girl]] companion Ace was bisexual if not preferentially lesbian, especially in the stories ''Ghost Light'' and ''Survival''. But when the TV show ended and the [[Virgin New Adventures|New Adventures]] spin-off novels were allowed to go for a [[Hotter and Sexier|more]] [[Darker and Edgier|"adult"]] tone, she was depicted as entirely straight.




Line 84: Line 84:


== Video Games ==
== Video Games ==
* Since your typical [[hentai]] [[Eroge|game]] has one or two major male characters and boatloads of pretty girls, the marketing images often involve multiple female characters looking mighty friendly, even if there's not even a romantic friendship between them in-game. For that matter, several games play up a romantic friendship between two girls and teasingly suggest that one of them may be gay for the other, only to eventually drop that subject without so much as a girl/girl kiss ever being shown. Obviously some authors do not agree that [[Girl On Girl Is Hot]].
* Since your typical [[hentai]] [[Eroge|game]] has one or two major male characters and boatloads of pretty girls, the marketing images often involve multiple female characters looking mighty friendly, even if there's not even a romantic friendship between them in-game. For that matter, several games play up a romantic friendship between two girls and teasingly suggest that one of them may be gay for the other, only to eventually drop that subject without so much as a girl/girl kiss ever being shown. Obviously some authors do not agree that [[Girl-On-Girl Is Hot]].




Line 96: Line 96:
[[Category:Always Female]]
[[Category:Always Female]]
[[Category:Bait And Switch Lesbians]]
[[Category:Bait And Switch Lesbians]]
[[Category:Trope]]