Death By Pragmatism: Difference between revisions

Content added Content deleted
m (Mass update links)
m (clean up)
Line 1: Line 1:
{{trope}}
{{trope}}
One of the wonderful things about [[Horror]] [[Film|Films]] is that the [[Jerkass]] ''[[Sorting Algorithm of Mortality|will]]'' [[Asshole Victim|die]] a gory and satisfying death, usually by machete or eating crow. However, it's not always the obvious things like [[Death by Sex|sex]], [[Death by Mocking|mockery]], or [[Death by Materialism|materialism]] that can do characters in, but... pragmatism?
One of the wonderful things about [[Horror]] [[Film]]s is that the [[Jerkass]] ''[[Sorting Algorithm of Mortality|will]]'' [[Asshole Victim|die]] a gory and satisfying death, usually by machete or eating crow. However, it's not always the obvious things like [[Death by Sex|sex]], [[Death by Mocking|mockery]], or [[Death by Materialism|materialism]] that can do characters in, but... pragmatism?


The thing is, anyone even ''approaching'' behaviour that is reasonable and appropriate to continued survival in the [[Slasher Movies|Slasher Movie]] will die. This isn't necessarily because of [[Wrong Genre Savvy]] or them being an anti social [[Crazy Survivalist]]. Instead, it serves two purposes:
The thing is, anyone even ''approaching'' behaviour that is reasonable and appropriate to continued survival in the [[Slasher Movies|Slasher Movie]] will die. This isn't necessarily because of [[Wrong Genre Savvy]] or them being an anti social [[Crazy Survivalist]]. Instead, it serves two purposes:


First, it serves as an easy way to bring up and dismiss 'obvious' solutions, often via what amounts to a strawman -- it often wouldn't be a very long movie if the pragmatic character calls the authorities, has everyone sit together someplace safe until they arrive, and resolves everything in the first half-hour, would it? So the pragmatic character has to be dealt with, often accompanied by [[The War On Straw|excessive vilification]] to try and [[Straw Vulcan|tar their sensible ideas along with them]]. [[It Only Works Once]] is applied in spades here, too -- often the pragmatic character will be shown attempting to do some obvious thing that could ruin the movie (call the cops, [[Closed Circle|leave the area]], [[Never Split the Party|keep everyone from splitting up]], whatever); they'll fail and die gruesomely, and nobody will ever mention the pragmatic solution again.
First, it serves as an easy way to bring up and dismiss 'obvious' solutions, often via what amounts to a strawman—it often wouldn't be a very long movie if the pragmatic character calls the authorities, has everyone sit together someplace safe until they arrive, and resolves everything in the first half-hour, would it? So the pragmatic character has to be dealt with, often accompanied by [[The War On Straw|excessive vilification]] to try and [[Straw Vulcan|tar their sensible ideas along with them]]. [[It Only Works Once]] is applied in spades here, too—often the pragmatic character will be shown attempting to do some obvious thing that could ruin the movie (call the cops, [[Closed Circle|leave the area]], [[Never Split the Party|keep everyone from splitting up]], whatever); they'll fail and die gruesomely, and nobody will ever mention the pragmatic solution again.


Second, while leading a group to safety or simply survival, [[Good Is Not Nice|the leader]] rarely has the chance to be [[Officer and a Gentleman|polite]], or allow the [[Sliding Scale of Idealism vs. Cynicism|"niceties"]] of [[Disaster Democracy|democracy]] and [[Rule of Empathy|universal empathy]]. Things that, to the fellow characters and the viewer, make them [[The Chew Toy|decidedly unpopular.]] And yes, this is just as big a wall banger as [[Death by Genre Savviness]], as those surviving are [[Too Dumb to Live]] [[Nice Guy|(but usually nicer).]]
Second, while leading a group to safety or simply survival, [[Good Is Not Nice|the leader]] rarely has the chance to be [[Officer and a Gentleman|polite]], or allow the [[Sliding Scale of Idealism vs. Cynicism|"niceties"]] of [[Disaster Democracy|democracy]] and [[Rule of Empathy|universal empathy]]. Things that, to the fellow characters and the viewer, make them [[The Chew Toy|decidedly unpopular.]] And yes, this is just as big a wall banger as [[Death by Genre Savviness]], as those surviving are [[Too Dumb to Live]] [[Nice Guy|(but usually nicer).]]