Extra-Strength Masquerade: Difference between revisions

Content added Content deleted
m (update links)
m (clean up)
Line 4: Line 4:
This is when a story has a [[Masquerade]] in place that, based on the events of the plot, should have been [[Broken Masquerade|broken]], but somehow [[Status Quo Is God|isn't]]. Maybe a dragon terrorized the populace of Manhattan. Maybe aliens landed in London and had [[Spot of Tea|tea with]] the Queen. Or maybe the Sphinx came to life and led a mummy army against Cairo. Whatever the specifics may be, it seems like the world of the story should have become [[The Unmasqued World|unmasqued]], yet the general public seems as ignorant as ever.
This is when a story has a [[Masquerade]] in place that, based on the events of the plot, should have been [[Broken Masquerade|broken]], but somehow [[Status Quo Is God|isn't]]. Maybe a dragon terrorized the populace of Manhattan. Maybe aliens landed in London and had [[Spot of Tea|tea with]] the Queen. Or maybe the Sphinx came to life and led a mummy army against Cairo. Whatever the specifics may be, it seems like the world of the story should have become [[The Unmasqued World|unmasqued]], yet the general public seems as ignorant as ever.


Normally this sort of thing gets a [[Hand Wave]] about the [[Ancient Conspiracy]] or [[The Men in Black|some other entity]] erasing everyone's memories of the event, passing the whole thing off as a hoax, or at least claiming people's [[Weirdness Censor|Weirdness Censors]] take care of the [[Masquerade]] for them. Sometimes, though, we don't even get that. The [[Masquerade]] just seems to [[Snap Back|repair itself]] of its own accord. This is, of course, the [[Viewers are Morons|most insulting]] way to handle it.
Normally this sort of thing gets a [[Hand Wave]] about the [[Ancient Conspiracy]] or [[The Men in Black|some other entity]] erasing everyone's memories of the event, passing the whole thing off as a hoax, or at least claiming people's [[Weirdness Censor]]s take care of the [[Masquerade]] for them. Sometimes, though, we don't even get that. The [[Masquerade]] just seems to [[Snap Back|repair itself]] of its own accord. This is, of course, the [[Viewers are Morons|most insulting]] way to handle it.


This has the additional benefit of lifting responsibility off the shoulders of the heroes; who now don't have to actively suppress anyone who knows the secret via methods above or passively promote ignorance by not warning [[Muggles]] about the supernatural beasties who want to control or kill them.
This has the additional benefit of lifting responsibility off the shoulders of the heroes; who now don't have to actively suppress anyone who knows the secret via methods above or passively promote ignorance by not warning [[Muggles]] about the supernatural beasties who want to control or kill them.
Line 11: Line 11:


== Anime and Manga ==
== Anime and Manga ==
* ''[[Digimon Adventure]]'' had digital monsters terrorizing [[Tokyo Is the Center of the Universe|Japan]] and, later, the rest of the world, for approximately 3 days. People could look up in the sky and see another world going on. Yet not only does [[Digimon Adventure 02|the world return to normalcy within the next three years]], ''nobody'' remembers any details about the events. They seem to recall that the events happened, but nobody seems to know exactly what. Either that, or their [[Weirdness Censor|Weirdness Censors]] are set too high.
* ''[[Digimon Adventure]]'' had digital monsters terrorizing [[Tokyo Is the Center of the Universe|Japan]] and, later, the rest of the world, for approximately 3 days. People could look up in the sky and see another world going on. Yet not only does [[Digimon Adventure 02|the world return to normalcy within the next three years]], ''nobody'' remembers any details about the events. They seem to recall that the events happened, but nobody seems to know exactly what. Either that, or their [[Weirdness Censor]]s are set too high.
** [[Digimon Savers]] manages to get away with a ''lot'' because DATS has memory erasing technology and enough pull to spin the media. Where it gets ridiculous is when an army of Digimon invades Japan. Hundreds of thousands, if not millions of people see the army of giant monsters with their own eyes. The only mention it ever gets is that the city is seen rebuilding in later episodes.
** [[Digimon Savers]] manages to get away with a ''lot'' because DATS has memory erasing technology and enough pull to spin the media. Where it gets ridiculous is when an army of Digimon invades Japan. Hundreds of thousands, if not millions of people see the army of giant monsters with their own eyes. The only mention it ever gets is that the city is seen rebuilding in later episodes.
* ''[[Mahou Sensei Negima]]'' takes full advantage of this, especially during Mahorafest. CGI handwaves notwithstanding, you'd think someone would catch on, what with the teleportation bullets and 100-foot-tall demon mecha. Then again, this is a school where the robotics club makes a full size robot T-Rex and a [[World Tree]] dominates the center of campus, so anything goes I guess.
* ''[[Mahou Sensei Negima]]'' takes full advantage of this, especially during Mahorafest. CGI handwaves notwithstanding, you'd think someone would catch on, what with the teleportation bullets and 100-foot-tall demon mecha. Then again, this is a school where the robotics club makes a full size robot T-Rex and a [[World Tree]] dominates the center of campus, so anything goes I guess.
Line 96: Line 96:
*** Also noteworthy is that it doesn't seem to be just a trick of the mind, as even people that believe in the supernatural and have actively fought it can't always see through it. The 'partially aware' can see the supernatural, but the more out there it is, the more likly they need it pointed out to them first by a 'fully aware'. They can see the more relatively mundane things like a goblin or a zombie just fine, but a psychic squidman or a demon made out of a swarm of maggots? Not so much. It's worth noting that creatures of Shadow, even the unintelligent ones, seem to instinctively know just how 'aware' a person is.
*** Also noteworthy is that it doesn't seem to be just a trick of the mind, as even people that believe in the supernatural and have actively fought it can't always see through it. The 'partially aware' can see the supernatural, but the more out there it is, the more likly they need it pointed out to them first by a 'fully aware'. They can see the more relatively mundane things like a goblin or a zombie just fine, but a psychic squidman or a demon made out of a swarm of maggots? Not so much. It's worth noting that creatures of Shadow, even the unintelligent ones, seem to instinctively know just how 'aware' a person is.
**** In addition, when a creature of Shadow dies, its body dissolves, leaving behind no evidence.
**** In addition, when a creature of Shadow dies, its body dissolves, leaving behind no evidence.
* Noteworthy in the ''[[Old World of Darkness]]'', especially ''[[Werewolf: The Apocalypse]]'' where rampaging and crazy [[Our Werewolves Are Different|wolfmen]] are just a fact of life. In most cases, this is canon -- said werewolves inspire a horrible and mind-numbing panic in normal humans, the vampires are secretive and have fingers everywhere, and the mage willing to try magic on television will just blow his own head off in a way that everyone ''believes'' is natural. Still, the canon events alone seem like they'd have made more people aware, never mind what a careless GM can cause.
* Noteworthy in the ''[[Old World of Darkness]]'', especially ''[[Werewolf: The Apocalypse]]'' where rampaging and crazy [[Our Werewolves Are Different|wolfmen]] are just a fact of life. In most cases, this is canon—said werewolves inspire a horrible and mind-numbing panic in normal humans, the vampires are secretive and have fingers everywhere, and the mage willing to try magic on television will just blow his own head off in a way that everyone ''believes'' is natural. Still, the canon events alone seem like they'd have made more people aware, never mind what a careless GM can cause.
** The most clear example of [[Extra-Strength Masquerade]] is found in a [[Splat]] where a Son of Ether descends over the World Science Fair in early 20th-century Paris with a fleet of robot-guided airships. He declares world dominion by right of higher knowledge. Airplanes sent up to fight him are useless, but eventually the Technocracy manages to drive him away by using flying Mark robots. The breach in the Masquerade is total, but so is the Technocracy's propaganda machine, working around the clock for years to eradicate all memory of the incident.
** The most clear example of Extra-Strength Masquerade is found in a [[Splat]] where a Son of Ether descends over the World Science Fair in early 20th-century Paris with a fleet of robot-guided airships. He declares world dominion by right of higher knowledge. Airplanes sent up to fight him are useless, but eventually the Technocracy manages to drive him away by using flying Mark robots. The breach in the Masquerade is total, but so is the Technocracy's propaganda machine, working around the clock for years to eradicate all memory of the incident.
** Vampires' [[Extra-Strength Masquerade]] is backed by them having the most thorough organization for maintaining the [[Masquerade]] of all supernatural splats, an organization which at least ''claims'' every vampire in existence as a member, and by said Masquerade also being the lynchpin of their political maneuverings. Individual vampires try to avoid even the most trivial Masquerade breach for fear that their enemies might use it to bring them down, young vampires try to curry favor with their elders and eliminate the competition by cleaning up everyone else's breaches, and every elder vampire who lasts long enough to become an elder fervently agrees with maintaining the status quo. Also, entire campaigns can be made out of playing [[The Men in Black|Archons]] responsible for cleaning up after [[Off the Rails|neonates gone Michael Bay]].
** Vampires' Extra-Strength Masquerade is backed by them having the most thorough organization for maintaining the [[Masquerade]] of all supernatural splats, an organization which at least ''claims'' every vampire in existence as a member, and by said Masquerade also being the lynchpin of their political maneuverings. Individual vampires try to avoid even the most trivial Masquerade breach for fear that their enemies might use it to bring them down, young vampires try to curry favor with their elders and eliminate the competition by cleaning up everyone else's breaches, and every elder vampire who lasts long enough to become an elder fervently agrees with maintaining the status quo. Also, entire campaigns can be made out of playing [[The Men in Black|Archons]] responsible for cleaning up after [[Off the Rails|neonates gone Michael Bay]].
** And notably averted in fan game ''[[Genius: The Transgression]]'':
** And notably averted in fan game ''[[Genius: The Transgression]]'':
{{quote|While [[Muggles|mere mortals]] will screw up a [[Applied Phlebotinum|Wonder]] [[Stuff Blowing Up|something]] [[Turned Against Their Masters|fierce,]] there is no [[Weirdness Censor|cosmic principle]] or [[Ancient Conspiracy|conspiracy]] at work that relates to Wonders or [[Touched by Vorlons|Inspiration.]] There is nothing in a Wonder that "clouds men's minds" or that will cause them to grow confused. Wonders [[Invisible to Normals|show up fine on cameras and videos.]] There are no vast conspiracies to hide the truth from regular mortals. In fact, the vastest conspiracy out there, [[Path of Inspiration|Lemuria,]] [[They Called Me Mad|wants to make regular mortals aware of their brilliance.]]<br />
{{quote|While [[Muggles|mere mortals]] will screw up a [[Applied Phlebotinum|Wonder]] [[Stuff Blowing Up|something]] [[Turned Against Their Masters|fierce,]] there is no [[Weirdness Censor|cosmic principle]] or [[Ancient Conspiracy|conspiracy]] at work that relates to Wonders or [[Touched by Vorlons|Inspiration.]] There is nothing in a Wonder that "clouds men's minds" or that will cause them to grow confused. Wonders [[Invisible to Normals|show up fine on cameras and videos.]] There are no vast conspiracies to hide the truth from regular mortals. In fact, the vastest conspiracy out there, [[Path of Inspiration|Lemuria,]] [[They Called Me Mad|wants to make regular mortals aware of their brilliance.]]<br />
Line 105: Line 105:
** In the story at the beginning of ''[[Hunter: The Reckoning]]'', one of the characters tries to reveal himself to the world on Chicago's WGN News by creating a magic sword and destroying a chair with it. Unfortunately, the sword is invisible to the television cameras, and later on several illusionists go on the news showing how his "trick" was done.
** In the story at the beginning of ''[[Hunter: The Reckoning]]'', one of the characters tries to reveal himself to the world on Chicago's WGN News by creating a magic sword and destroying a chair with it. Unfortunately, the sword is invisible to the television cameras, and later on several illusionists go on the news showing how his "trick" was done.
** The [[New World of Darkness]] (of which ''Genius'' is part) has every supernatural race contain at least one subgroup with the job description "Hide the evidence". However, when the masquerade ''does'' slip... well, then you have the [[Hunter: The Vigil|Hunters]]. Network Zero, in particular, is devoted to ''breaking'' the masquerade.
** The [[New World of Darkness]] (of which ''Genius'' is part) has every supernatural race contain at least one subgroup with the job description "Hide the evidence". However, when the masquerade ''does'' slip... well, then you have the [[Hunter: The Vigil|Hunters]]. Network Zero, in particular, is devoted to ''breaking'' the masquerade.
*** Also keep in mind that, in the New World of Darkness, [[Muggles]] '''DO''' [[Broken Masquerade|start to believe in the supernatural]] when they see monsters come around their backyards. However, when those enlightened muggles try to make their discoveries public, they are viewed as cranks and [[Conspiracy Theorist|conspiracy theorists]] by the world at large. Add to that the fact that both the [[Government Conspiracy]] and the various non-human [[Masquerade|Masquerades]] systematically erase the evidence, and it's easy to see why people remain largely unaware. [[Hunter: The Vigil|The Union]] is a good example of such enlightened muggles.
*** Also keep in mind that, in the New World of Darkness, [[Muggles]] '''DO''' [[Broken Masquerade|start to believe in the supernatural]] when they see monsters come around their backyards. However, when those enlightened muggles try to make their discoveries public, they are viewed as cranks and [[Conspiracy Theorist|conspiracy theorists]] by the world at large. Add to that the fact that both the [[Government Conspiracy]] and the various non-human [[Masquerade]]s systematically erase the evidence, and it's easy to see why people remain largely unaware. [[Hunter: The Vigil|The Union]] is a good example of such enlightened muggles.
** Then there are the powers/side effects of said powers that automatically lead to an [[Extra-Strength Masquerade]]. As mentioned above, ''[[Werewolf: The Apocalypse]]'' has the Delirium, where the vast majority of humans who see werewolves in their war form get overwhelmed with ancestral memories of fear and dread and automatically blank out memories of what they experienced; this carries over into ''[[Werewolf: The Forsaken]]'' as Lunacy, a blessing from the werewolves' patron goddess. ''[[Changeling: The Dreaming]]'', meanwhile, has The Mists, a side effect of widespread Banality where any observation of fae magic will usually slip out of a mortal witness's mind by the end of the scene. ''[[Mage: The Awakening]]'', in addition to [[Weirdness Censor|Paradox]] (which targets vulgar magic as it goes off), has Disbelief, which means anything obviously magical (like, say, a rampaging fire elemental crafted by an Obrimos) will rapidly degrade under observation by [[Muggles|Sleepers]].
** Then there are the powers/side effects of said powers that automatically lead to an Extra-Strength Masquerade. As mentioned above, ''[[Werewolf: The Apocalypse]]'' has the Delirium, where the vast majority of humans who see werewolves in their war form get overwhelmed with ancestral memories of fear and dread and automatically blank out memories of what they experienced; this carries over into ''[[Werewolf: The Forsaken]]'' as Lunacy, a blessing from the werewolves' patron goddess. ''[[Changeling: The Dreaming]]'', meanwhile, has The Mists, a side effect of widespread Banality where any observation of fae magic will usually slip out of a mortal witness's mind by the end of the scene. ''[[Mage: The Awakening]]'', in addition to [[Weirdness Censor|Paradox]] (which targets vulgar magic as it goes off), has Disbelief, which means anything obviously magical (like, say, a rampaging fire elemental crafted by an Obrimos) will rapidly degrade under observation by [[Muggles|Sleepers]].
* In the more technologically-advanced domains of ''[[Ravenloft]]'', many natives doubt the existence of supernatural threats that are readily acknowledged in distant backwater domains. Justified in that the Dark Powers create each domain to reflect its resident darklord's prejudices and biases, so if Lamordians don't believe in magic or Dementlieuse assume that sahuagin are just fishermen's tall tales, blame the local darklord's own skepticism.
* In the more technologically-advanced domains of ''[[Ravenloft]]'', many natives doubt the existence of supernatural threats that are readily acknowledged in distant backwater domains. Justified in that the Dark Powers create each domain to reflect its resident darklord's prejudices and biases, so if Lamordians don't believe in magic or Dementlieuse assume that sahuagin are just fishermen's tall tales, blame the local darklord's own skepticism.
* The Palladium Books game ''<s>Nightspawn</s> Nightbane'' for the most part is a normal [[The Masquerade|Masquerade]], but the event that started it all was literally seen by everyone on Earth. On March 6th, 2000, also known as Dark Day, the entire Earth seemed to be cut off from the Cosmos. No sun, no moon, no stars, for 24 hours. To those with knowledge of the supernatural, it was the day evil beings from parallel dimension breached the wall between the two worlds and began a covert operation to control the whole world. To everyone else, it was a freak occurrence they'd all rather forget about. A number of excuses for the event were put forth, and people accept that there must have been some natural explanation, regardless of how flimsy it is.
* The Palladium Books game ''<s>Nightspawn</s> Nightbane'' for the most part is a normal [[The Masquerade|Masquerade]], but the event that started it all was literally seen by everyone on Earth. On March 6, 2000, also known as Dark Day, the entire Earth seemed to be cut off from the Cosmos. No sun, no moon, no stars, for 24 hours. To those with knowledge of the supernatural, it was the day evil beings from parallel dimension breached the wall between the two worlds and began a covert operation to control the whole world. To everyone else, it was a freak occurrence they'd all rather forget about. A number of excuses for the event were put forth, and people accept that there must have been some natural explanation, regardless of how flimsy it is.
* ''[[Cthulhu Tech]]'' has a [[Masquerade]] that, by all logic, should have been shattered into little pieces, but somehow the very ''existence'' of the Aeon War and the Eldritch Society side plot are kept secret from the people of the NEG-controlled Earth, thanks to [[Government Conspiracy|at least]] [[Ancient Conspiracy|three conspiracies]] working as [[The Men in Black]]. Attempting to bust things open will just get the entire NEG dropped on your head without actually breaking through the censorship.
* ''[[Cthulhu Tech]]'' has a [[Masquerade]] that, by all logic, should have been shattered into little pieces, but somehow the very ''existence'' of the Aeon War and the Eldritch Society side plot are kept secret from the people of the NEG-controlled Earth, thanks to [[Government Conspiracy|at least]] [[Ancient Conspiracy|three conspiracies]] working as [[The Men in Black]]. Attempting to bust things open will just get the entire NEG dropped on your head without actually breaking through the censorship.


Line 145: Line 145:


== [[Real Life]] ==
== [[Real Life]] ==
* Whether or not there are any [[Extra-Strength Masquerade|Extra Strength Masquerades]] in the [[Real Life|Real World]] is debatable, depending on one's personal [[Properly Paranoid|level of paranoia]]. There is, however, a rich tapestry of [[wikipedia:Fringe theory|fringe hypotheses]] in which Masquerades could hide. [[Powers That Be|Western academia and law enforcement]] are skeptical to say the least, arguing that extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence. Many of our credentialed intelligentsia have been defamed and discredited for giving mere [[Epileptic Trees|consideration to fringe theories]], often in fields at most tangentially related to the one they study.
* Whether or not there are any Extra Strength Masquerades in the [[Real Life|Real World]] is debatable, depending on one's personal [[Properly Paranoid|level of paranoia]]. There is, however, a rich tapestry of [[wikipedia:Fringe theory|fringe hypotheses]] in which Masquerades could hide. [[Powers That Be|Western academia and law enforcement]] are skeptical to say the least, arguing that extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence. Many of our credentialed intelligentsia have been defamed and discredited for giving mere [[Epileptic Trees|consideration to fringe theories]], often in fields at most tangentially related to the one they study.
* [[wikipedia:Tlatelolco Massacre|The Tlatelolco Massacre]]. Inverted, since back then the population never knew that 250 people were killed. Now everybody with internet access knows what happened (few people defend the then-president and then-secretary of State by calling the students communists).
* [[wikipedia:Tlatelolco Massacre|The Tlatelolco Massacre]]. Inverted, since back then the population never knew that 250 people were killed. Now everybody with internet access knows what happened (few people defend the then-president and then-secretary of State by calling the students communists).
* This is a popular theory about why uninvolved civilians in Germany and Nazi-occupied territory allowed the shoah/holocaust to take place. The theory goes that, given that hordes of people were being murdered, and that death and slave labour camps were all over the place, a lot of civilians must have known. They just pretended not to due to racism, the personal tragedies and stresses of being involved in war, how unbelievably horrific the atrocities were and how dangerous it would have been to look too deeply into the matter ( giving that they were living in a fascist dictatorship). If this was the case, then the holocaust was everybody's 'open secret".
* This is a popular theory about why uninvolved civilians in Germany and Nazi-occupied territory allowed the shoah/holocaust to take place. The theory goes that, given that hordes of people were being murdered, and that death and slave labour camps were all over the place, a lot of civilians must have known. They just pretended not to due to racism, the personal tragedies and stresses of being involved in war, how unbelievably horrific the atrocities were and how dangerous it would have been to look too deeply into the matter ( giving that they were living in a fascist dictatorship). If this was the case, then the holocaust was everybody's 'open secret".