Malcolm Xerox: Difference between revisions

Content added Content deleted
mNo edit summary
(update links)
Line 2: Line 2:
{{quote|''"I marched two million strong in [[Washington DC|D.C.]] Lookin eye to eye with brothers that I used to think below me."''|'''[[Ice T]]''', "I Must Stand"}}
{{quote|''"I marched two million strong in [[Washington DC|D.C.]] Lookin eye to eye with brothers that I used to think below me."''|'''[[Ice T]]''', "I Must Stand"}}


The opposite counterpart to [[Strawman Political|white conservative strawman]], this trope is specific to black characters.
The opposite counterpart to [[Strawman Political|white conservative strawman]], this trope is specific to black characters.


These characters are often very far to the left of the political spectrum, and usually militant. These black radicals or activists are depicted as a bunch of [[Straw Hypocrite|hypocritical]], irrational, paranoid, unreasonable, lazy, bigoted, [[Everything Is Racist|race-card-playing]], [[Conspiracy Theorist|conspiratorial]] raving loons. Even within black TV shows and movies, they're very rarely depicted as respectable or intelligent people whose opinion is of any real merit. When it comes to black TV and films, this could be an attempt by some black writers to subvert the stereotype of black people agreeing with these particular views. In the process, they ended up creating a [[Strawman Political]].
These characters are often very far to the left of the political spectrum, and usually militant. These black radicals or activists are depicted as a bunch of [[Straw Hypocrite|hypocritical]], irrational, paranoid, unreasonable, lazy, bigoted, [[Everything Is Racist|race-card-playing]], [[Conspiracy Theorist|conspiratorial]] raving loons. Even within black TV shows and movies, they're very rarely depicted as respectable or intelligent people whose opinion is of any real merit. When it comes to black TV and films, this could be an attempt by some black writers to subvert the stereotype of black people agreeing with these particular views. In the process, they ended up creating a [[Strawman Political]].


The [[Trope Namer]] is [[Malcolm X]], who achieved fame during the American civil rights movement for his aggressive and hard-line views on race; however, he was actually a subversion in that after going to Mecca he started to promote racial equality and unfortunately got killed for it.
The [[Trope Namer]] is [[Malcolm X]], who achieved fame during the American civil rights movement for his aggressive and hard-line views on race; however, he was actually a subversion in that after going to Mecca he started to promote racial equality and unfortunately got killed for it.
Line 15: Line 15:


== [[Comic Books]] ==
== [[Comic Books]] ==
* The character of Muhammad X from the ''[[Superman]]'' comics.
* The character of Muhammad X from the ''[[Superman]]'' comics.
* [[Aquaman|Aquaman's]] arch nemesis Black Manta, whose motivation was to conquer Atlantis so he could slaughter the inhabitants and make the kingdom a haven for black people who'd been so repressed on the land. Or so he says - he's shifted goals multiple times and has outright stated he's just pretending to do this in order to get funds and men. He really just wants money and to see Aquaman dead.
* [[Aquaman|Aquaman's]] arch nemesis Black Manta, whose motivation was to conquer Atlantis so he could slaughter the inhabitants and make the kingdom a haven for black people who'd been so repressed on the land. Or so he says - he's shifted goals multiple times and has outright stated he's just pretending to do this in order to get funds and men. He really just wants money and to see Aquaman dead.
* A [[The Sixties|1960s]] ''Little Annie Fanny'' comic, satirizing the ideological conflict between MLK Jr.'s and Malcolm X's followers, ends with "Marvin X" and his followers donning surplus [[Godwin's Law|Nazi uniforms]] and "Marvin" shouting "We must build a superior race! Let the liquidations begin!" At this, the unnamed MLK Jr. stand-in, whom Marvin's ship had rescued from the ocean, swims off saying, "I think I'll take my chances with the sharks."
* A [[The Sixties|1960s]] ''Little Annie Fanny'' comic, satirizing the ideological conflict between MLK Jr.'s and Malcolm X's followers, ends with "Marvin X" and his followers donning surplus [[Godwin's Law|Nazi uniforms]] and "Marvin" shouting "We must build a superior race! Let the liquidations begin!" At this, the unnamed MLK Jr. stand-in, whom Marvin's ship had rescued from the ocean, swims off saying, "I think I'll take my chances with the sharks."
Line 24: Line 24:
* Subverted in ''[[Chasing Amy]]'' by Hooper X, a comic book artist character who used this trope, playing a [[Proud Warrior Race Guy|proud Nubian]] and [[Strawman Political]] when promoting his comic book; but was in fact a [[Camp Gay|flamboyant homosexual]].
* Subverted in ''[[Chasing Amy]]'' by Hooper X, a comic book artist character who used this trope, playing a [[Proud Warrior Race Guy|proud Nubian]] and [[Strawman Political]] when promoting his comic book; but was in fact a [[Camp Gay|flamboyant homosexual]].
* A straight example from ''[[Jay and Silent Bob Strike Back]]'' is the film director, though he ''is'' played by Chris Rock, [[Actor Allusion|who has spent his career lampooning these kinds of characters]].
* A straight example from ''[[Jay and Silent Bob Strike Back]]'' is the film director, though he ''is'' played by Chris Rock, [[Actor Allusion|who has spent his career lampooning these kinds of characters]].
* The Mau Mau gang from [[Spike Lee|Spike Lee's]] ''[[Bamboozled]]''. They fit the "hypocrisy" aspect of this character. The Mau Maus angrily denounce the [[Blackface]] entertainers with "Painted faces, disgrace to the races!" - but they are, in their own way, [[You Are What You Hate|just as buffoonish as what they condemn]]. And they're even more hypocritical when they execute one of the show's performers while wearing some of the "Mantan" Halloween masks they so despise (which makes them [[Dirty Coward]]s as well).
* The Mau Mau gang from [[Spike Lee|Spike Lee's]] ''[[Bamboozled]]''. They fit the "hypocrisy" aspect of this character. The Mau Maus angrily denounce the [[Blackface]] entertainers with "Painted faces, disgrace to the races!" - but they are, in their own way, [[You Are What You Hate|just as buffoonish as what they condemn]]. And they're even more hypocritical when they execute one of the show's performers while wearing some of the "Mantan" Halloween masks they so despise (which makes them [[Dirty Coward]]s as well).
* Buggin' Out from ''[[Do the Right Thing]]''. Many of the other characters are angry about race issues as well, which is kinda the point of the movie.
* Buggin' Out from ''[[Do the Right Thing]]''. Many of the other characters are angry about race issues as well, which is kinda the point of the movie.
* The Wayans brothers like the comedic version of this trope, with the addition that the more outspokenly afro-centric the character is, the more obsessed he is with [[Where Da White Women At?|banging white chicks]]—most notably in ''[[I'm Gonna Git You Sucka]]'' and ''[[Don't Be a Menace to South Central While Drinking Your Juice in the Hood]]''.
* The Wayans brothers like the comedic version of this trope, with the addition that the more outspokenly afro-centric the character is, the more obsessed he is with [[Where Da White Women At?|banging white chicks]]—most notably in ''[[I'm Gonna Git You Sucka]]'' and ''[[Don't Be a Menace to South Central While Drinking Your Juice in the Hood]]''.
* Mitch Mullany's ''The Breaks'' includes a scene reminiscent of ''[[I'm Gonna Git You Sucka]]'' when the main character, Derrick, attends a spoken word performance. After a dreadlocked black man recites an angry Afrocentric poem, the hostess says, "Thank you very much, Stokely Ungawa, and your lovely wife, Betsy..." at which point the camera cuts to the same poet, embracing a very [[White Anglo Saxon Protestant|WASPy]] looking blonde.
* Mitch Mullany's ''The Breaks'' includes a scene reminiscent of ''[[I'm Gonna Git You Sucka]]'' when the main character, Derrick, attends a spoken word performance. After a dreadlocked black man recites an angry Afrocentric poem, the hostess says, "Thank you very much, Stokely Ungawa, and your lovely wife, Betsy..." at which point the camera cuts to the same poet, embracing a very [[White Anglo Saxon Protestant|WASPy]] looking blonde.
* Martin Lawrence plays an especially obnoxious example of this trope in ''National Security''.
* Martin Lawrence plays an especially obnoxious example of this trope in ''National Security''.
* Dave Chappelle playing "Conspiracy Brother" as a comedic subversion of this in ''[[Undercover Brother]]''.
* Dave Chappelle playing "Conspiracy Brother" as a comedic subversion of this in ''[[Undercover Brother]]''.
Line 40: Line 40:
* [[Names to Run Away From Really Fast|Ras the Exhorter]] from Ralph Ellison's ''[[Invisible Man (novel)|Invisible Man]]''.
* [[Names to Run Away From Really Fast|Ras the Exhorter]] from Ralph Ellison's ''[[Invisible Man (novel)|Invisible Man]]''.
* The X-Man from Minister Faust's superhero novel ''From the Notebooks of Doctor Brain''. Played straight {{spoiler|until the ending, when it's revealed pretty much all his paranoid delusions about The Man are true.}}
* The X-Man from Minister Faust's superhero novel ''From the Notebooks of Doctor Brain''. Played straight {{spoiler|until the ending, when it's revealed pretty much all his paranoid delusions about The Man are true.}}
* An interesting example from [[What Do You Mean It's for Kids?|youth literature]] is Axon Befal from the [[Green-Sky Trilogy]]. The Erdlings are [[Ambiguously Brown]], and {{spoiler|the decendants of exiled Kindar (Kindar being the race with "privledges")}}. When this all is revealed and the Erdlings are freed from their imprisonment [[Beneath the Earth]], Befal is preaching for ''violent'' retribution against the Kindar, including those ignorant of the Erdling's existence. Most Erdlings want nothing to do with him and consider him a criminal. In the game, his "wand" (a machete) makes the game [[Unwinnable]] if you [[Video Game Cruelty Punishment|use it on anything other than briar bushes]].
* An interesting example from [[What Do You Mean It's for Kids?|youth literature]] is Axon Befal from the [[Green-Sky Trilogy]]. The Erdlings are [[Ambiguously Brown]], and {{spoiler|the decendants of exiled Kindar (Kindar being the race with "privledges")}}. When this all is revealed and the Erdlings are freed from their imprisonment [[Beneath the Earth]], Befal is preaching for ''violent'' retribution against the Kindar, including those ignorant of the Erdling's existence. Most Erdlings want nothing to do with him and consider him a criminal. In the game, his "wand" (a machete) makes the game [[Unwinnable]] if you [[Video Game Cruelty Punishment|use it on anything other than briar bushes]].


== [[Live Action TV]] ==
== [[Live Action TV]] ==
* ''[[A Different World]]'': Lena James and, to a lesser extent, Winifred 'Freddie' Brooks (who was also a [[Hippie Chick|hippie]] and a [[Soapbox Sadie]]), though this was somewhat realistically (or cynically) toned down when she became a lawyer. Although some who have a [[Alternate Character Interpretation]] of her believes she became toned down do to her somewhat becoming a realist after she got her law degree. [[Silly Rabbit, Idealism Is for Kids|And thus became less overbearing. And to some less likable]].
* ''[[A Different World]]'': Lena James and, to a lesser extent, Winifred 'Freddie' Brooks (who was also a [[Hippie Chick|hippie]] and a [[Soapbox Sadie]]), though this was somewhat realistically (or cynically) toned down when she became a lawyer. Although some who have a [[Alternate Character Interpretation]] of her believes she became toned down do to her somewhat becoming a realist after she got her law degree. [[Silly Rabbit, Idealism Is for Kids|And thus became less overbearing. And to some less likable]].
* Tashim from ''[[Martin]]'', though mostly played for comedy.
* Tashim from ''[[Martin]]'', though mostly played for comedy.
* A decent number of black characters from ''[[Law and Order]]'' qualify. Basically, if there's a black prosecutor/lawyer/defendant/minister/activist/etc. opposing the lead cast, s/he is likely to hit ''at least'' some parts of this trope and [[Angry Black Man]].
* A decent number of black characters from ''[[Law and Order]]'' qualify. Basically, if there's a black prosecutor/lawyer/defendant/minister/activist/etc. opposing the lead cast, s/he is likely to hit ''at least'' some parts of this trope and [[Angry Black Man]].
** Specifically defense attorney Shambala Green. Although not as over the top.
** Specifically defense attorney Shambala Green. Although not as over the top.
** Paul Robinette when he became a defense attorney. Alternatively there's the [[Unfortunate Implications]] theory that he was turned into a [[Strawman Political]] of the Malcolm Xerox variety so the writers could make a point.
** Paul Robinette when he became a defense attorney. Alternatively there's the [[Unfortunate Implications]] theory that he was turned into a [[Strawman Political]] of the Malcolm Xerox variety so the writers could make a point.
** Defense attorney Carl Halpert, defense attorney Jerome Bryant....(notice a pattern here??)
** Defense attorney Carl Halpert, defense attorney Jerome Bryant....(notice a pattern here??)
** Then there's Congressman Eaton, A terrible Al Sharpton [[Expy]].
** Then there's Congressman Eaton, A terrible Al Sharpton [[Expy]].
** Perhaps most notorious is the Reverend Ott, who incites a riot in an episode based on the Crown Heights riots.
** Perhaps most notorious is the Reverend Ott, who incites a riot in an episode based on the Crown Heights riots.
* Ahmad Zaire from ''[[The Parent Hood]]''.
* Ahmad Zaire from ''[[The Parent 'Hood]]''.
* Senator Clay Davis in ''[[The Wire]]'' manages to fool most of Maryland into ''thinking'' he is this guy, the best example being his [[Glurge]] Unleaded defense speech in court. In realiy he's an embezzling, selfish, corrupt piece of [[Catch Phrase|sheeeeeeeeeeeit]]...
* Senator Clay Davis in ''[[The Wire]]'' manages to fool most of Maryland into ''thinking'' he is this guy, the best example being his [[Glurge]] Unleaded defense speech in court. In realiy he's an embezzling, selfish, corrupt piece of [[Catch Phrase|sheeeeeeeeeeeit]]...
* Awesomely nuanced in a ''[[New York Undercover]]'' episode "''The Reckoning''", with a Nation of Islam minister (Minister Malik) who shows heavy shades of this, BUT is also very fleshed out and humanized. Even giving him a [[Crowning Moment of Heartwarming]] towards the end of the episode when a young black kid approaches him on the street and tells him "''I'm ready to be a man''" and Malik smiles and nods, then says "''Then you will be''".
* Awesomely nuanced in a ''[[New York Undercover]]'' episode "''The Reckoning''", with a Nation of Islam minister (Minister Malik) who shows heavy shades of this, BUT is also very fleshed out and humanized. Even giving him a [[Crowning Moment of Heartwarming]] towards the end of the episode when a young black kid approaches him on the street and tells him "''I'm ready to be a man''" and Malik smiles and nods, then says "''Then you will be''".
Line 66: Line 66:


== [[Video Games]] ==
== [[Video Games]] ==
* In ''[[Grand Theft Auto San Andreas]]'', there's a ped in the San Fierro section that fits this trope. He's even wearing a kente cloth dashiki and hat.
* In ''[[Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas]]'', there's a ped in the San Fierro section that fits this trope. He's even wearing a kente cloth dashiki and hat.


== [[Western Animation]] ==
== [[Western Animation]] ==
* Dewey from ''[[The Boondocks]]'' is a hypocritical counterpart to Huey Freeman, who takes "down wit' the struggle" much further than even Huey by reading poetry, wearing capris, headwraps and sandals, even going as far as to become a Muslim...and yet he doesn't even know the basic Islamic greeting.
* Dewey from ''[[The Boondocks]]'' is a hypocritical counterpart to Huey Freeman, who takes "down wit' the struggle" much further than even Huey by reading poetry, wearing capris, headwraps and sandals, even going as far as to become a Muslim...and yet he doesn't even know the basic Islamic greeting.
** Huey himself arguably could be seen as a subversion (or even a reconstruction) of this trope.
** Huey himself arguably could be seen as a subversion (or even a reconstruction) of this trope.
** [[Star Wars|"Jabari Jabari Binko"]] in an early ''Boondocks'' strip can be a parody of this.
** [[Star Wars|"Jabari Jabari Binko"]] in an early ''Boondocks'' strip can be a parody of this.
* Chef during the town flag controversy (fittingly called 'Chef Goes Nanners') in ''[[South Park]]'', right down to becoming Muslim and changing his "slave name" into a long, pseudo-Arabic one which no longer fit on his apron, so that he had to have someone follow him around, bearing a sign with the rest of his new name.
* Chef during the town flag controversy (fittingly called 'Chef Goes Nanners') in ''[[South Park]]'', right down to becoming Muslim and changing his "slave name" into a long, pseudo-Arabic one which no longer fit on his apron, so that he had to have someone follow him around, bearing a sign with the rest of his new name.


Line 82: Line 82:
[[Category:The War On Straw]]
[[Category:The War On Straw]]
[[Category:Race Tropes]]
[[Category:Race Tropes]]
[[Category:Malcolm Xerox]]
[[Category:No Real Life Examples, Please]]
[[Category:No Real Life Examples, Please]]
[[Category:{{PAGENAME}}]]