Neutral Good: Difference between revisions

no edit summary
No edit summary
No edit summary
 
(4 intermediate revisions by 3 users not shown)
Line 1:
{{trope}}
{{quote|''"I would unite with anybody to do right and with nobody to do wrong."''|'''Frederick Douglass'''}}
|'''Frederick Douglass'''}}
 
The [[Character Alignment]] of sweetness and light. A '''Neutral Good''' character will usually comply with laws if doing so benefits the greater good, but rebel against those they consider unjust or which conflict with the greater good.
Line 6 ⟶ 7:
Their are different kinds of Neutral Goodness:
 
'''Neutral Good''' can be the best alignment you can be because it means doing what is good without bias for or against order. '''Neutral Good''' characters value freedom and will protect others' freedom as long as it's not used to do harm.
 
A '''Neutral Good''' character is not too caught up in [[Order Versus Chaos]]; they are concerned with moral goodness, but often not willing to enforce it in others. Something of a 'classic' hero or adventurer alignment as seen in many RPGs and JRPGs, as well as many anime series, particularly [[Shonen]] (although most of them are [[Chaotic Good]] nowadays) or more idealistic Seinen works.
 
A '''Neutral Good''' character is sometimes a [[Friend to All Living Things]] and/or a [[Technical Pacifist]], but they don't necessarily have to be either. Just think "basically good person" and you've probably got it. If they do decide to take up arms, they may have a particular affinity with kneecap and other non-lethal shots.
 
One of the differences between [[Lawful Good]] and '''Neutral Good''' is that [[Lawful Good]] will ''always'' hate [[Chaotic Evil]], and even when the [[Chaotic Evil]] character is the resident [[Token Evil Teammate]] they will just barely tolerate them. On the other hand, '''Neutral Good''' characters may accept and sometimes even be friends with a [[Chaotic Evil]] character (as long as they're on the same team).
 
'''Neutral Good''' states may be [[Utopia|really nice places to live]], but depending on how [[Sliding Scale of Idealism Versus Cynicism|idealistic]] the setting is, they may be [[Crap Saccharine World|deluding themselves]]. '''Neutral Good''' characters tend to suffer more personal conflicts in [[Grey and Grey Morality]] settings with [[Order Versus Chaos]] themes.
 
However, before you all run up to this alignment expecting it to hand out unconditional love and [[The Cake Is a Lie|free cake]] a small word of [[Beware the Nice Ones|caution]]: if this alignment is combined with [[Good Is Not Soft|Good Is Not]] ''[[Good Is Not Soft|Soft]]'', things can get [[Vigilante Man|interesting]] and you could end up with a [[Discworld|Granny Weatherwax]] Type neutral good character. That is to say, someone who will always, always do what they believe is right, and won’t let either [[Lawful Good|laws]] or [[Chaotic Good|personal freedoms]] get in their way. If played properly alongside [[Good Is Not Nice|Good Is Not]] ''[[Good Is Not Nice|Nice]]'', this trope can be downright [[Knight Templar|scary]].
Line 20 ⟶ 21:
----
 
If you have a difficulty deciding which alignment a good-aligned character belongs to, then they're probably too nuanced to have an alignment at all. The main difference between [[Lawful Good]], '''Neutral Good''' and [[Chaotic Good]] is not their devotion to good, but the methods they believe are best to promote it:
 
* Even though there are some situations where they can't always use this method, [[Lawful Good]] characters believe the best way is to have a specific, strict code of conduct, whether self-imposed or codified as a law. Their first impulse when making a moral decision is to refer back to this code; those with externally imposed systems (codes of laws, hierarchies, etc.) will try to work within the system when those systems go wrong. Depending on whether they are more Lawful or more Good, they will either refuse to break the code even though it would hurt someone, or else break it only very reluctantly, and only when it would hurt someone if they kept their code. [[Lawful Good]] characters have to be very good at [[Taking a Third Option]].
* '''Neutral Good''' characters are indifferent to [[Order Versus Chaos]], and their only interest is in doing good. They will use whatever means will promote the most good, whether that means tearing down a code of laws, following a code of laws, creating an orderly society, causing the breakdown of harmful kinds of order, or staying away from society altogether. Their only goal is to do good, full stop.
* Most [[Chaotic Good]] characters don't constantly break the law, but they cannot see much value in laws (or, for weaker-CCGs, do not see the value in laws that do not function solely to punish evil). They believe that their own consciences are their best guides, and that tying themselves to any given code of conduct would be limiting their own ability to do good. They do not get along with anyone who tries to instill any kind of order over the [[Chaotic Good]] character or others, believing these people to be restricting their freedom and the freedom of others; however, most [[Chaotic Good]] characters will respect the right of others to impose strong codes of conduct on themselves. [[Chaotic Good]] characters often focus very strongly on individual rights and freedoms, and will strongly resist any form of oppression of themselves or anyone else.
 
----
 
'''Neutral Good''' character types include:
* [[Superhero]]es who have to deal with an [[Untrusting Community]]
* [[Badass Pacifist]]
Line 42 ⟶ 43:
* [[Knight in Shining Armor]], if not [[Lawful Good]]
 
Others, such as the [[Ideal Hero]], [[The Messiah]], and [[Friend to All Living Things]], can vary between [[Lawful Good]], '''Neutral Good''' and [[Chaotic Good]].
 
{{noreallife|this is a trope about how characters are depicted in media. Real people are far more complex than fictional characters, and cannot be pigeonholed this way. (For that matter, many if not most fictional characters cannot be pigeonholed this way, either; see below for the standards on whether to use this trope at all.}}
Line 90 ⟶ 91:
* [[Hajime no Ippo|Ippo]] is so polite, nice and well-meaning that it almost hurts sometimes, feeling sympathy to almost all of his opponents. That said, his devotion to winning even during the toughest of odds leaves him to do whatever it takes, but he still is extremely polite to his opponents even after they lose.
* [[Liar Game|Nao Kanzaki]] is about as Neutral Good as it gets - yes, she'll trick people, but only if they don't trust her enough to believe that she's really looking out for them. And she is - she pays off all her opponents' debts after beating them, even though this will almost certainly leave her with an unpayable (in the 'billions of yen' range) debt at the [[Dark Tournament|Liar Game Tournament's]] end.
* Alphonse Elric from ''[[Fullmetal Alchemist (manga)|Fullmetal Alchemist]]'' is definitely Neutral Good, conscience-driven and kind. His brother Edward is [[Chaotic Good]].
** Winry is also Neutral Good.
* Gintoki from ''Gintama'' fits in this alignment. Usually, he is a useless lazy bum who is happy to go along with rules. However, he won't hesitate to break all rules and throw himself in fire when it comes to protecting those he cares about, whether it is his [[True Companions]] in danger or a child Gintoki promised to reunite with his mother.
Line 162 ⟶ 163:
* In ''[[The Dresden Files]]'', Sanya, the Russian Knight Of The Cross, appears to be more ambivalent about following laws and order, and is more devoted to the simple act of rescuing innocents and fighting evil.
 
== Live -Action TV ==
* Captain Kirk of ''[[Star Trek: TOSThe Original Series]]'' has just enough respect for the Federation to not violate its laws unless he has a ''damn'' good reason, as he understands it's probably the best government out there.
** In his later days (in the movies, mayhaps) Spock tends to flow a bit in to this as well, actually allowing emotion in order to quell his internal conflicts.
* Miles O'Brien from ''[[Star Trek: Deep Space Nine]]'' has no problems with orders and laws but will break or bend them for the greater good.
* Karl ("Helo") Agathon from ''[[Battlestar Galactica]]'', probably the most purely ''good'' character on the show. A strong case might be made for his being [[Lawful Good]], but his willingness to go beyond or disobey orders puts him more in the Neutral Good category.
* Shepherd Book and Simon Tam from ''[[Firefly (TV series)|Firefly]]''. Both seem to have a decent amount of respect for law and order, but have no problems breaking any law which endangers their friends or family.
** Also, Kaylee and Wash from the same show. Though they may have chaotic good leanings. They are just generally good, happy (for the most part) people who always try to do what they believe is right. They are also the two least violent people in the show making them [[Technical Pacifist]].
* Hercules, as depicted in ''[[Hercules: The Legendary Journeys]]''.
Line 268 ⟶ 269:
* Lee Free Sr. in ''[[Everyday Heroes]]'' balances out here. His motivation, defense of the little guy against the system is Chaotic Good but as a skilled and knowledgeable lawyer he uses the law
* Criminy in Sinfest. Jesus being here should be a no brainer. Fuschia started as [[Chaotic Evil]] but eventually moved to Neutral Good by 2010.
 
 
== Web Original ==
* Penny of ''[[Doctor Horribles Sing Along Blog|DoctorDr. Horrible's Sing-Along Blog]]'', the crush of Dr. Horrible due to the fact that she's the only one who proves to him that [[Humans Are the Real Monsters|Humans Aren't All Bastards]] with her efforts of helping the homeless, as well as being the idealist to Billy's cynic. Caring little for the conflicts of heroes and villains, she chooses to help the helpless and offer a caring hand to those who need it. {{spoiler|Her death would complete Billy's [[Start of Darkness]] as Dr. Horrible}}.
* [[The Medic|Codex]] and [[Genki Girl|Clara]] from ''[[The Guild]]'' both seem to fit into this, or at least balance out Vork's [[Lawful Good]], Zaboo's [[Chaotic Good]], and the [[Neutral Evil]] of Tink and Tordek
 
 
== Western Animation ==