No Party Given: Difference between revisions

m
no edit summary
mNo edit summary
(9 intermediate revisions by 3 users not shown)
Line 6:
If, for example, a movie features a [[President Evil]], identifying their party might make a political statement that the writer does not intend to make. It may simply be a lack of commitment on the writer's part—the character might espouse views from both sides. In any case, it avoids unnecessarily offending a large portion of the audience.
 
It sometimes stretches credibility, but sometimes not. [[Real Life|Real-life]] politicians in the US often say "Smith for Congress" without mentioning party affiliation, but in Britain campaigns often give the party name, e.g. "Vote Labour/Conservative - vote [[wikipedia:John Smith (Politician)|John Smith]]". Some ballot papers don't name the candidates' parties, as in Britain until 1968, and [http://www.washingtonpost.com/local/dc-politics/virginia-ballots-skimp-on-party-id/2011/10/21/gIQAHYuuGM_story.html some US elections today]. On the other hand, if a work is set in a fictional or unnamed part of the US, this is relatively easy to get away for local office (up to and including mayor) as these positions are often, at least nominally, non-partisan, with some areas so often dominated by one party multiple top candidates can actually belong to the same party. Judicial elections tend to take the non-partisan thing somewhat more seriously, but political parties remain free to endorse any candidate without their open consent.
 
InvertedAverted when the character belongs to a real party. [[Take a Third Option|A third option]] is to invent a [[Fictional Political Party]].
 
{{examples}}
Line 32:
* In ''[[Escape from New York]]'', the President's political party is never mentioned or indicated. There's no mention of his political positions: he's just an uncaring self-absorbed bastard.
** There are several interviews with [[John Carpenter]] in which he says the political climate in the film was based on (what he believes to be) both parties moving away from individual liberty as their core value. This interpretation is also supported by the fact that Snake Plissken is played by [[Kurt Russell]], who is a noted Libertarian.
* In [[State of Play (film)|the movie adaptation]] of ''[[State of Play (TV series)|State of Play]]'', [[Ben Affleck]]'s character is a congressman whose political party is not mentioned, although he has a painting of [[Dwight D. Eisenhower]] in his office. That probably isn't as big a hint as you might think, as Affleck's character is a former military man from Pennsylvania who went into politics while Eisenhower is regarded as a very non-partisan moderate President.
* That [[Disney Channel]] movie ''My Date with the President's Daughter''.{{context}}
* The 1993 film ''[[Dave]]'', where Kevin Kline plays both a U.S. President and an impersonator of the same, never mentions a political party. Only a cameo by known Republican Ben Stein (although not even his party is actually mentioned) as himself can allow parties to be indirectly determined.
* In ''[[Bob Roberts]]'' the title character is frequently identified as conservative, but rarely as an actual Republican.
* The unnamed and almost unseen President in ''[[In the Line of Fire]]'' doesn't identify with a political party. Signs at his campaign rallies just say "Re-Elect The President".
* President Whitmore in ''[[Independence Day]]'' has no identified political party. We know he's a Gulf War fighter ace, and a brief reference to a failed "crime bill" is made, but otherwise all we know is that he wants to kick some alien ass.
* [[Taxi Driver]]-Senator Palantine, although his comments suggest that he is a Democrat.
* ''[[The Dish]]'' has the Prime Minister mention a party, but he doesn't identify which one. The real PM of the time was John Gorton of the Liberal Party.
* The president in ''[[Buckaroo Banzai]]'' can't decide whether he's hawkish or diplomatic. The only pertinent executive decision is in how to resolve the alien crisis and prevent [[World War III]], which would presumably be in any American party's interest. If only a [[Marty Stu]] could solve everything and save the world in 30 minutes!
Line 50 ⟶ 49:
=== [[Live-Action TV]] ===
* In ''[[24]]'' Season 7, President Allison Taylor is not explicitly identified by party (at least so far). Since her predecessor is presumably Democrat, she is presumably Republican - and yet her idealism tends to be more of a liberal trait, and her predecessor appears to have mostly GOP traits.
* Arguably lampshaded by the entire short-lived series "[[Mr. Sterling]]", in which Josh Brolin's character (a prison teacher) is assumed to be a Democrat when he is appointed to finish the term of a Democratic Senator, but declares himself an independent. (In real life a freshman independent, appointed to fill a term, would be a political cipher, but Sterling ends up getting appointed to key committees almost immediately, presumably because a show about a Senator with no power at all would be pretty boring.)
* Jim Hacker, in ''[[Yes Minister]]'', had Conservative views as well as looking and acting very much like the stereotypical Conservative MP, but was not identified as such. His party HQ was called "Central House", an amalgam of Central Office and Transport House, the locations of the Conservative Party and the Labour Party in real life at that time. In fact, many of the plot points in ''Yes Minister'' are based on real incidents, but they occurred under both Conservative and Labour ministries.
** On one occasion, in fact, Hacker is heard musing on what the Conservative or Labour parties would do in a similar situation, implying he is neither.
Line 56 ⟶ 55:
** This is actually part of the point of the show — that regardless of party and ideology, the elected leaders are hamstrung by the career bureaucrats (who, for their own part, may honestly believe that they serve the people best by preventing well-intentioned politicians from gumming up the works).
{{quote|''"The Opposition aren't really the Opposition. They're just called the Opposition. But in fact they are the Opposition in exile. The Civil Service are the Opposition in residence."''|Journalist Anthony Jay, paraphrased in an early episode of ''[[Yes Minister]]''}}
*:* In the [[Novelization|novelisation of the episode]] "The Skeleton In The Cupboard", Hacker refers to the opposition being in power at the time of Humphrey's mistake. The episode was made in 1982 and is set no later than 1984, setting Humphrey's mistake during Churchill's first administration. This would seem to rule out the Conservative Party... except that the [[w:Churchill war ministry|war ministry]] was a coalition that contained the leaders of both the Conservative and Labour parties, and members of the Conservative, Labour, National Labour, Liberal, and Liberal National parties. In essence, ''all five'' of the major parties were in power during [[World War II]].
* Governor Gatling of ''[[Benson]]'' only ever refers to his party as "The Party". For that matter, we're never even told [[Where the Hell Is Springfield?|what state he's the governor of.]]
* Harriet Jones from ''[[Doctor Who]]'' repeatedly introduces herself as "MP for Flydale North" without ever mentioning what party she represents. Certain clues have led fans to believe she belongs to either the Labour (the reference to "the babes" in "Aliens of London") or Conservative (the Margaret Thatcher allegory in "The Christmas Invasion").
Line 64 ⟶ 63:
* The mayor in ''[[Spin City]]''. Some of his properties were those of a strawman Liberal, while others were that of a strawman Conservative.
* Throughout season one of ''[[Heroes (TV series)|Heroes]]'', Nathan Petrelli is running for Congress. His party and political views are never discussed. The show also makes a much bigger deal out of a congressional election than is typical of real life.
** He's like the X-Men's Senator Kelly; his main opinions are to do with [[Differently-Powered Individual]]s. Except, unlike Kelly, he's in a world with [[The Masquerade]] in force, so he can't have official policies based on that...
** Subtle hints indicate that he is a Republican, particularly the fact that his campaign is based on "family values", which at the time was a phrase more vocally used by Republicans.
** Tracy Strauss, a political consultant and [[Blonde Republican Sex Kitten|Blonde Maybe Republican Sex Kitten]] would also fit this trope. She says that her boss, the governor of New York, has trouble with the far right but that does not rule out him being a Republican. She is likely of the same party as Nathan Petrelli as she helped him become a Senator.
Line 78 ⟶ 77:
** Notably, this contrasts [[Kelsey Grammer]]'s own political affiliation, and that of his most vocally (straw) political character, [[The Simpsons (animation)|Sideshow Bob]].
* ''[[The Thick of It]]'' simply has "The Party" and "The Opposition", but it isn't hard to guess who their real-life equivalents are (Labour and the Tories, respectively).
* Vice President Selina Meyer's party on ''[[Veep]]'' is never stated. However, in the grand tradition of [[Armando Iannucci]] (who also did ''[[The Thick of It]]''), it's pretty obvious that the Administration is something of an [[Expy]] of the one in power (i.e. that of [[Barack Obama]], i.e. the Democrats).
** Selina isn't an expy of Joe Biden, however, as having a good-natured, [[Fee Fi Faux Pas|gaffe-prone]], unambitious elder statesman of a VP wouldn't make for good comedy, or at least not as good as an ambitious and embittered ex-Senator who had made a serious presidential run in the previous election. Hey, [[Hillary Rodham Clinton|wait a minute...]].
* Irish political sitcom ''Val Falvey T.D.'' never mentioned the lead's party. His logo is green, implying Fianna Fáil, but the opening titles are blue, implying Fine Gael.
* The panel show ''If I Ruled the World'' had a Blue Team consisting of Graeme Garden and a teammate versus a Red Team consisting of Jeremy Hardy and a teammate, all playing politicians, but not corresponding to the Conservative or Labour parties, and mostly sticking to satirizing the political process in general.
Line 86 ⟶ 83:
* The Politician's party that Carrie from ''[[Sex and the City]]'' dates for a brief period is kept intentionally vague... because, hey, that's not what The Girls are about.
* In an episode of ''[[The Monkees (TV series)|The Monkees]]'', Mike runs for mayor in order to unseat the corrupt incumbent; neither the party of Mike nor the incumbent mayor is ever given (though Mike can possibly be assumed to be running as an Independent). As a Mayoral race it could have plausibly been non-partisan if not for a slightly awkward bit of dialogue early on where Mike threatens to take his complaint with the mayor and "dump it in the opposing party's lap".
* [[The Sheriff|Sheriff Andy Taylor]] on ''[[The Andy Griffith Show]]''. However, as an elected official in a [[Sweet Home Alabama|Southern state]] during the sixties, it's most likely that he's a [[Fox News Liberal|conservative Democrat]].
* Naturally, no party was assigned to Mayor Richard Wilkins III in any ''[[Buffy the Vampire Slayer]]'' episode; even if [[Affably Evil| he ''was'' a pretty decent fellow]] if you overlook all the stuff about building the Hellmouth and sacrificing infants to demons.
 
=== [[Music]] ===
* "Won't Get Fooled Again", by [[The Who]], makes reference to a change in government without actually saying who the political parties are, just that they trade sides of the House of Commons. ("The party on the left" is the opposition, and "the party on the right" is the government, both nicknamed after on which side of the Speaker of the House's chair their own chairs are located.)
 
=== [[Theatre]] ===
Line 105 ⟶ 104:
=== [[Web Comics]] ===
* When ''[[Walkyverse|Shortpacked!'s]]'' Robin DeSanto gets elected to congress, this is lampshaded as a "Non-Partisan Romp!". Later, an unlabeled campaign leaflet blends caricatures of both sides with "Robin DeSanto is out of touch with core American values! Voted yes on CANCER! Voted yes on TERRORISTS!" Voted no on BABIES! Voted no on FREEDOM!"
* Dylan/USA Patriot Act and Jenny/American Eagle, two of the pupils at the ''[[PS238]]'' School for [[Differently-Powered Individual|meta-prodigies]], are candidates from opposing parties to replace the aging Freedom Fighter (the [[PS238]]-verse's [[Captain America (comics)]] [[Expyexpy]]). Their parties are, how ever, never named, and since they both sprout the same [[Patriotic Fervor|patriotic platitudes]] it is difficult to tell who is who.
** [https://web.archive.org/web/20080819225820/http://nodwick.humor.gamespy.com/ps238/comics/index.php?date=2007-10-03 However, Dylan's favorite color is red and Jenny's is blue].
** The other time you can actually tell their politics apart is when they light directly into each other, when Dylan will call Jenny a pinko commie and she responds by calling him a backwards neanderthal (or something of the sort).
Line 130 ⟶ 129:
* All three Presidents in ''[[My Fellow Americans]]'' are identified as either Democrat or Republican in the opening scenes.
* Every character in ''[[The Contender]]'' has his/her party and general political stances made very explicit.
* Senator Palantine in ''[[Taxi Driver]]-Senator'' Palantinedoesn't have a party specifically identified, althoughbut his comments suggest that he is a Democrat.
 
=== [[Literature]] ===
Line 148:
* Hybridised in ''[[The Amazing Mrs. Pritchard]]'', where Ros Pritchard forms the Purple Democratic Alliance out of dissatisfaction with both Labour and the Conservatives after they start a fistfight outside her supermarket (purple = Labour red + Conservative blue, of course), pinching members from both parties in the process. [[Take That]], Lib Dems! (She persuades a Lib Dem to defect, too.)
* Despite being a legal and not a political drama, ''[[Rumpole of the Bailey]]'' manages to avert this: Guthrie Featherstone is a Labour (implied) MP who later (explicitly) joins the SDP, Rumpole's third client in the series is a Labour backbencher, Charles Hearthstoke self-identifies as a Tory, and Liz Probert...well...let's just say that her father's name is "Red" Ron Probert, shall we? Rumpole himself doesn't clearly have a party affiliation, but, iconoclast and sympathizer with the poor that he is, it would appear that he's somewhere on the left (likely voting Labour at the beginning of the series in 1967 and voting Liberal Democrat by the end in 1992).
* Vice President Selina Meyer's party on ''[[Veep]]'' is never stated. However, in the grand tradition of [[Armando Iannucci]] (who also did ''[[The Thick of It]]''), it's pretty obvious that the Administration is something of an [[Expy]] of the one in power (i.e. that of [[Barack Obama]], i.e. the Democrats).
** Selina isn't an expy of Joe Biden, however, as having a good-natured, [[Fee Fi Faux Pas|gaffe-prone]], unambitious elder statesman of a VP wouldn't make for good comedy, or at least not as good as an ambitious and embittered ex-Senator who had made a serious presidential run in the previous election. Hey, [[Hillary Rodham Clinton|wait a minute...]].
* [[The Sheriff|Sheriff Andy Taylor]] on ''[[The Andy Griffith Show]]''. However, as an elected official in a [[Sweet Home Alabama|Southern state]] during the sixties, it's most likely that he's a [[Fox News Liberal|conservative Democrat]].
 
=== [[Theatre]] ===
* Most of the characters in the play and movie ''[[State of the Union (play)|State of the Union]]'' are Republican politicians and make no bones about it. (Though one of the party hacks explains that the essential difference between the parties is: "They're in--and we're out!")
 
=== [[Western Animation]] ===
* President Richard Nixon's Head in ''[[Futurama]]'' is not one bit less Republican than the real Richard Nixon.
* Mayor Quimby from ''[[The Simpsons]]'' is a member of the Democratic Party.
** The [[Strawman Political|straw-evil]] Republican Party, on the other hand, counts Montgomery Burns (obviously), Rainer Wolfcastle (seeing as he is an [[Expy]] of [[Arnold Schwarzenegger]]), Birch Barlowe (again an Expy, this time of [[Rush Limbaugh]]), Sideshow Bob (for comic effect) and surprisingly Doctor Hibbert.
 
=== [[Real Life]] ===