Revolutionary Girl Utena/Analysis: Difference between revisions

no edit summary
m (remove bogus category)
No edit summary
 
(3 intermediate revisions by 3 users not shown)
Line 1:
{{Analysis}}{{work}}
== This analysis is examining differences in the three primary variations of ''Revolutionary Girl Utena'' (All of which are canon in their own universe.). ==
 
Line 8:
Has very [[Shoujo]] styled writing.
 
The characters aare more down to earth in this version. Saito makes it hard to dislike one character too much, but doesn't develop the minor characters as thoroughly or examine the major players to nearly the same extent.
 
For example, Ohtori Akio is more of a [[Chessmaster]] then a [[Magnificent Bastard]]. This makes sense for a more realistic stting, where he'd get in huge trouble anywhere else but in the nearly alternate world of the anime Ohtori Academy for his schemes. In the manga, he's only acting as the Chessmaster because he has been literally separated from his good half.
Line 41:
One of themes in Utena is the idea that you can lead a horse to water but you can't make them drink, or in the case of the show you can rescue a princess but not free her, and this is why Anthy stays at Ohtori. We see at the end of the series that she simply can and does walk out, but the reason she didn't before is that she didn't ''believe'' she could. The coffin is part of the metaphor of her being confined there; she sees it as safety even though it's restricting her. That's another big part of battering: convincing the victim that they do not have the power to leave and that it's in their best interests to stay. The batterer sets themselves up as the sole focus of the victim's world, and a big part of helping the victim is showing them that this isn't the case, so removing them from the batterer's presence is usually a critical step. That's why orders of protection are so important.
 
The end of the series is essentially Utena breaking through the illusion that keeps Anthy there and breaking through her brother's control over her, hence the whole bit with opening the coffin. But -- andBut—and this is key -- Utenakey—Utena just reaches out a hand, she doesn't actually pull Anthy out. Anthy does it herself. Likewise, it's been shown that unless the person who has been battered breaks free of the lock the batterer has on them they will very likely end up in the same situation again.
 
=== Utena and Feminism ===
Line 56:
Another series metatrope: Damsels in Distress and Wicked Witches in ''Revolutionary Girl Utena'' are ''very'' interchangeable. It only makes sense that the average person who stays helpless for too long will inevitably find unscrupulous ways of seizing power. It's also brilliant commentary on stories, because writers (and people) have traditionally been unable to imagine women outside the "Madonna/Whore Complex".
 
== The Characters each Represent a Constellation in the Winter Sky ==
{{reflist}}
 
[[Category:Revolutionary Girl Utena]]
[[User:Labster]] wrote a very long analysis of ''Utena'' characters compared to constellations: [http://blog.brentlaabs.com/2015/11/postmodern-constellation-apocalypse.html Postmodern Constellation Apocalypse: Classical Mythological Themes of Utena]. In summary, we had this table:
[[Category:Analysis]]
 
{|class="wikitable"
!Character
!Constellation
!Aspect
|-
|Utena Tenjou||Orion||Huntress
|-
|Wakaba Shinohara||Canis Major||Faithful companion
|-
|Miki Kaoru||Gemini (Pollux)||Twin, demigod
|-
|Kozue Kaoru||Gemini (Castor)||Twin, tree-climber
|-
|Juri Arisugawa||Andromeda||Chained maiden
|-
|Shiori Takatsuki||Aquarius||Ganymede
|-
|Ruka Tsuchiya||Pegasus||Divine aid
|-
|Touga Kiryuu||Perseus||Prince
|-
|Nanami Kiryuu||Cassiopeia||Haughty queen
|-
|Mitsuru Tsuwabuki||Cepheus||Queen's consort
|-
|Aiko||Pleiades||Sister maiden
|-
|Yuuko||Pleiades||Sister maiden
|-
|Keiko Sonoda||Pleiades||Merope
|-
|Kyouichi Saionji||Taurus||Sacred bull
|-
|Mikage Souji||Ophiuchus||Asclepius
|-
|Kanae Ohtori||Cygnus||Leda
|-
|Dios||Hercules||Hero
|-
|Akio Ohtori||Venus||Lover, fallen star
|-
|Anthy Himemiya||Virgo||Persephone
|-
|The plot||Eridanus||Journey, monomyth
|-
|Akio car||Auriga||Chariot
|-
|Castle||Draco, Ursa||Emperor's palace
|-
|The shell||Genbu||Black turtle
|}
 
{{worksubpagefooter}}