Star Trek: The Next Generation/YMMV: Difference between revisions

no edit summary
No edit summary
No edit summary
 
(7 intermediate revisions by 5 users not shown)
Line 4:
* [[Artistic License: Biology]]: "Genesis". '''AND HOW.'''
* [[Artistic License Physics]]: "The Royale". -291 degrees Celsius. (Absolute Zero, the coldest temperature theoretically possible, is -273 degrees.)
** [[Science Marches On]]: It is [possible to go below 0 Kelvin, but it requires adding energy to the item instead of taking energy away.
* [[Author's Saving Throw]]
** 'I, Borg', in which they study a Borg drone separated from the collective. Changes them from [[Ninja Pirate Zombie Robot|cyborg zombies]] into [[Starfish Aliens]].
** [[Gene Roddenberry]] never liked that he used the Klingons as the "Race of Black Hats" in [[Star Trek: The Original Series|The Original Series]], and thus made Worf as a Klingon main character and the first season episode "Heart of Glory" completely redefined their place as a [[Proud Warrior Race Guy|Proud Warrior Race]].
* [[Base Breaker]]: Captain Edward Jellico from the two-part episode "Chain of Command" is one of ''[[Star Trek]]''{{'}}s most polarizing characters. His fans see him as a bold, effective officer who magnificently outwitted the Cardassians. His detractors consider him a huge [[Jerkass]] who had no business [[Replacement Scrappy|filling in for Picard]] and [[Tyrant Takes the Helm|making changes to the way things were run]] on the ''Enterprise''.
** Considering that he was depicted as an actual military officer in a [[Mildly Military]] service, ''both'' viewpoints are accurate.
* [[Complete Monster]]: Data's brother Lore from ''[[Star Trek: The Next Generation]]'' is a thoroughly unsympathetic android who {{spoiler|kills his creator, reprograms his brother to follow his every command, and threatens to set Wesley on fire}}.
{{quote|Lore {{spoiler|(to Wesley): "Are you prepared for the kind of death you've earned, little man?"}}}}
** {{spoiler|And no, [[Creator's Pet|trying to immolate Wesley]]}} does not make up for all the other stuff he did.
** Oh, yeah, he also {{spoiler|tried to make the Borg (or at least a certain segment thereof) an even greater threat than they already were}}.
** He also {{spoiler|summoned the Crystalline Entity to his creator's colony when the other colonists petitioned Soong to deactivate him out of fear that he would turn on them. It could be argued that he acted in self-defense, but given everything else we see of his true nature it's obvious that he mostly did it for his own sick amusement. He tried to do the same thing to the Enterprise too.}}
*** The closest Lore ever comes to having a [[Pet the Dog]] moment is when he almost breaks down crying [[Even Bad Men Love Their Mamas|when his father is revealed to be dying]]. Of course, considering the content of the first spoiler, it should tell you how that goes.
** Kivas Fajo from ''The Most Toys''. At first, he seems to be just another [[Smug Snake]] villain who thinks [[Screw the Rules, I Have Money|Screw The Rules, I Have ... well, something anyway]]. Then he talks very matter-of-factly about how he'd like to try out a particularly cruel [[Death Ray]] called a Varon-T Disruptor -- illegal in [[The Federation]] because of how it slowly destroys the body from the inside out -- {{spoiler|and later does use it on his broken, codependent slave girlfriend and threatens to shooting as many subordinates as necessary to coerce Data into obeying him}}. When your actions {{spoiler|drive the emotionless android good guy to attempted murder}}, you're a [[Complete Monster]].
*** His [["The Reason You Suck" Speech]] to Data afterwards is particularly devastating. Data's response is to override his own ethical programming, because he knows he cannot desire justice and so must enact it for those who do.
{{quote|Fajo: "Murder me - go ahead, it's all you have to do. Fire! If only you could...feel...RAGE over Varria's death - if only you could feel the NEED for revenge, maybe you could fire...But you're...just an android - you can't feel anything, can you? ''It's just another interesting...intellectual puzzle for you'', another of life's...curiosities."
Data: "I cannot allow you to continue." -Fires- }}
** Armus, the disgusting, hateful thing that killed Tasha Yar. It was actually ''made of hate'' -- He was [[Made of Evil|formed from the evil emotions]] cast off by a race of aliens that [[Ascended to A Higher Plane of Existence]]. He kills, torments, and tortures as a matter of course -- and it's all [[For the Evulz]].
*** Once again, even Data who has no emotions, sees Armus for what it truly is.
{{quote|Data: "You are capable of great sadism and cruelty. Interesting. No redeeming qualities."
Armus: "So, what do you think?"
Data: "I think ''you should be destroyed''." }}
* [[Creator's Pet]]: Wesley Crusher, the former [[Trope Namer]], also [[Exaggerated Trope|an especially severe case]] since, by varying amounts, he fits ''EVERY'' criterion of both [[Creator's Pet]] and [[The Scrappy]].
** He might have been more tolerable if he hadn't been given an "important" role in so many episodes. Indeed, the episodes that actually focus on him are [[So Okay It's Average]], so he's alota lot better when he's not shoehorned into the spotlight in everyone else's episodes.
** Despite her being [[Dr. Jerk]], crewmembers would often mention how "caring" and "nice" Dr. Pulasky was. [[Informed Attribute|Not that we really saw it]].
** In the case of Wesley himself, they alternated between praising Wesley for no reason and [[Not Now, Kiddo|rudely dismissing]] Wesley for no reason, depending on which would make Wesley look better.
** Back in the days before he parlayed hating the character into his new career, [[Wil Wheaton]] actually pointed out that Wesley's reputation for saving the ship was ridiculously overblown, having actually done so "one and a half times"... and then going on to say it was the character's general level of pretentiousness and involvement in the rest of the crew's lives that was more the problem.
* [[A Day in the Limelight]]
* [[Designated Villain]]: See [[Base Breaker]] above.
** "Face of the Enemy" is the reason that TNG is the previous [[Trope Namer]], "Good Troi Episode".
* [[Establishing Character Moment]]: ''The Child'' for Dr. Pulaski. Her highly irregular entry onto the ship and her treatment of Data establish her as the [[Dr. Jerk|polar opposite]] of Dr. Crusher.
* [[Fan Dumb]]: Many fans complain about how "pointless and offhanded" Tasha Yar's death was. [[Completely Missing the Point|That was the point]], to show how arbitrary and cruel the universe could be. Considering that many of these fans are also the ones who sneer about disposable redshirts, you'd think they'd appreciate the show for once taking a chance and showing the same thing happening to a main character... but no.
* [[Mr. Fanservice]]: First Officer William T. Riker, and he knows it.
* [[Good Troi Episode]]
** "Face of the Enemy" is the reason that TNG is the [[Trope Namer]].
** "Dark Page" is not only a Good Troi Episode for both Deanna and Lwaxana, but one of the few good episodes from TNG's seventh season.
* [[Designated Villain]]: See [[Base Breaker]] above.
* [[Ensemble Darkhorse]]: Both Data and Worf came to share the spotlight with Picard among fans. Originally the series focused more on Picard, Riker and Dr. Crusher.
** Then, there's Miles O'Brien, a completely minor character, but got so much fan attention, he became a main character in ''Deep Space Nine''.
** Q seems to have a good fanbase despite him appearing in only eight episodes on TNG and then four episodes outside of it.
** Reg Barclay, who was initially written as a one-shot character, but kept coming back as a recurring character and ended up featuring briefly in ''Star Trek: First Contact'' and played a significant recurring role in ''Voyager''.past
* [[Establishing Character Moment]]: ''The Child'' for Dr. Pulaski. Her highly irregular entry onto the ship and her treatment of Data establish her as the [[Dr. Jerk|polar opposite]] of Dr. Crusher.
* [[Fan Dumb]]: Many fans complain about how "pointless and offhanded" Tasha Yar's death was. [[Completely Missing the Point|That was the point]], to show how arbitrary and cruel the universe could be. Considering that many of these fans are also the ones who sneer about disposable redshirts, you'd think they'd appreciate the show for once taking a chance and showing the same thing happening to a main character... but no.
* [[Foe Yay]]:
** Picard/Q.
Line 53 ⟶ 39:
*** Apparently this was, in large part, due to Marina Sirtis' request. She was tired of the goofy/fanservicey jumpsuits and wanted to be in uniform like everyone else. When she saw the plot of the episode she jumped on the opportunity to suggest it to the production staff.
** Also in the first episode of season two Geordi and Worf received promotions to Chief of Engineering and Chief of Security, which allowed their characters to grow and arguably had a much greater impact on the show's quality than Riker's beard (since, even beardless, Riker already had a reputation as a badass).
<!-- %%% -->
<!-- %% This isn't literally about beards. -->
<!-- %%% -->
* [[Harsher in Hindsight]]: Watching Picard break down while bonded to Sarek in the episode "Sarek", is a bit more difficult to watch knowing that Picard may very well share the same fate in his future.
* [[Hatedom]]: Wesley, obviously, but Riker also has one going on... apparently some of the awkward, shy young males watching the show were ''deeply'' resentful of his success with women. There's an entire subgenre of TNG fanfiction that focuses on humiliating him (sexually, socially, and professionally), usually in order to build up another character that better fits with the writer's idea of someone who "deserves" sex (usually Geordi or Data).
Line 67 ⟶ 50:
* [[Magnificent Bastard]]: Q in all his appearances, to one degree or another, often with [[Hilarity Ensues|very entertaining results.]] Omnipotent, yet petty; cruel but not vicious; causing devastation yet helpful at times, you really couldn't help but love the bastard(s).
** As Tim Lynch [http://timlynchreviews.wikia.com/wiki/Conundrum points out], "MacDuff" in "Conundrum" is a pretty extraordinary villain. He boards the Enterprise, manipulates the crew, and comes very, very close to single-handedly winning the war his race has been fighting. His only real miscalculation was {{spoiler|overestimating Worf's blood-lust and underestimating his devotion to duty}}.
* [[Mary Sue]]: For no readily apparent reason, the entire creative staff thought Whoopi Goldberg was God's greatest gift to humanity. This led to them not only forcing Guinan scenes into any episode whose filming coincided with an availability in her schedule, but to them having Guinan as (apparently) the wisest person in the entire galaxy, and capable of taking an omnipotent being in a fight if she actually wanted to.
* [[Memetic Mutation]]: Picard has become an image for the [[Face Palm]] ([[Gallifrey Base]] actually has a Picard facepalm [[Emoticon]]) and general disbelief on the stupidity of a situation.
** '''[[ThisPunctuated! IsFor! SpartaEmphasis!|THERE... ARE...]]''' '''''[[ThisPunctuated! IsFor! SpartaEmphasis!|FOUR...]]''''' '''[[ThisPunctuated! IsFor! SpartaEmphasis!|LIGHTS!]]'''
*** It's also a [[Shout-Out]] to [[Nineteen Eighty-Four|1984]].
** The [http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=X6oUz1v17Uo Picard Song]. It also more or less works as his [[Image Song]].
Line 75 ⟶ 59:
** The Tamaranian sayings from "Darmok", especially "Darmok and Jalad at Tanagra!" and "Shaka, when the walls fell".
** When Wil Wheaton is being an idiot online (which is often), a frequent reply by commenters is "[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d3Y6SUh8saQ Shut up, Wesley]."
* [[Mr. Fanservice]]: First Officer William T. Riker, and he knows it.
* [[MST3K Mantra]]: In literal effect in "The Next Phase".
* [[My Real Daddy]]: The series truly came into its own after Michael Piller took over the writing staff in Season 3.
Line 100 ⟶ 85:
*** In Riker's defense, he tolerates it all. Jellico just senses Riker's fuming underneath his calm exterior.
*** The other officers didn't like the changes either, but they eventually got with the program. Riker has no excuse for his perpetually [[Wangst|wangsty]] behavior during that episode.
*** Not just wangsty. The other officers (except for Troi, whose consummate professionalism in this episode was a welcome surprise) merely had attitude problems. Riker was outright insubordinate to a legally actionable degree (by the contemporary Uniform Code of Military Justice, at least) and had to effectively blackmail Jellico in the final part of the episode ('I won't fly this mission if you don't let me off the hook') to avoid an efficiency report that would have been a career-killer, if not actual court-martial charges.
** Really, this happens a ''lot'' when the series (or really any such episodic series) tries to do moralizing. The writers would tend to get so focused in on trumpeting one aspect of their pet causes or issues that they wouldn't realize they'd wandered over into the characters [[Accidental Aesop|accidentally]] arguing for issues they opposed at the same time.
* [[Surprisingly Improved Sequel]]: While ''[[Star Trek: The Original Series]]'' was good, it wasn't consistently good and still had out-there episodes, particularly toward the end. This show, especially after [[Growing the Beard]], has none of the camp factor of the original series, and has more actual continuity and story arcs.
Line 106 ⟶ 92:
* [[Took the Bad Film Seriously|Took The Bad Episode Seriously]]: [[Patrick Stewart]] is this trope incarnate; his greatest strength as an actor, as the old cliche goes, is his ability to deliver bad dialogue with utter conviction. Nowhere was that more evident than during the low points of this series.
* [[Tough Act to Follow]]: Averted ''and'' played straight. It managed to step out of TOS's shadow as a highly successful series, but it made every subsequent Trek franchise feel rather lacking.
* [[Unfortunate Implications]]:
** The intent may have been to show the new era is more peaceful, but in retrospect it may not have been a good idea to have the ''French'' Captain [[Cheese-Eating Surrender Monkeys|surrender to the enemy]] in the very first episode.
** Keiko and O'Brien in ''Rascals''. Miles is understandably disturbed that his wife now has the body of a child. She doesn't seem to get it.
Line 117 ⟶ 103:
** So how do you explain "Justice", which has the Edo repeatedly described as a "perfect society" and populated solely by blond haired, blue-eyed, ''white'' people?
** In "Who Watches the Watchers", Picard has an anti-religious rant that ''seems'' to not-so-lightly imply that, on Earth, every bad thing ever was because people believed in God/religion.
** "The Drumhead" explicityexplicitly states that just because Simon Tarses' ''grandfather'' is revealed to have been Romulan, it will be the end of his Starfleet career. Remind me again, the Federation is a ''supposed'' to be a ''tolerant'' society that has long since eliminated ''[[Fantastic Racism|racial discrimination]]'', right?
** Not quite so. It is stated it is because he ''lied'' about his heritage that is what might jeopardize his career.
* [[The Woobie]] - Several throughout the series' run, but special mention has to go to medical technician Simon Tarses in the episode ''The Drumhead''. {{spoiler|Accused of conspiracy against the Federation, put through a witch-hunt trial, and suspended for 6 months for falsifying his application - those adorable ears came from a Romulan grandfather, not a Vulcan one... but admitting that would have made a career in Starfleet out of the question.}} Sure, lying is bad, but holy disproportionate punishment. [http://images1.wikia.nocookie.net/__cb20060421065535/startrek/images/3/31/SimonTarses.jpg And just look at that face.]
Line 124 ⟶ 110:
** [[Iron Woobie]]: Captain Picard.
** Troi. She's been raped no less than three times throughout the franchise (once when she was impregnated by an energy being and twice mentally but still represented as a sexual assault) and frequently falls victim to the psychic powers of the [[Villain of the Week]].
* [[What Measure Is a Non-Badass?]]: Alexander is [[Non-Action Guy|not a warrior type]], and this causes both tension with his father and {{spoiler|a plot to change this by a time-travelling future incarnation}}.
 
{{worksubpagefooter}}
{{reflist}}
[[Category:Star Trek: The Next Generation]]
[[Category:YMMV]]
[[Category:Pages with comment tags]]