Terminator (franchise)/Headscratchers: Difference between revisions

no edit summary
m (Dai-Guard moved page Terminator (Film)/Headscratchers to Terminator/Headscratchers: Remove TVT Namespaces from title)
No edit summary
 
(31 intermediate revisions by 6 users not shown)
Line 65:
 
* If The Terminator can be sent back in time because his engineered flesh hides the metal skeleton from the effect of the time portal, why not wrap one of those awesome laser guns in some ham or cheese or something and send that back with Reese as well?
** Or, more simply, why not conceal his gun where [[Doctor Who (TV)|Captain Jack Harkness]] keeps his? (Incidentally, "He gets his ideas from the same place as Captain Jack gets his guns" is my favorite euphemism for the [[Ass Pull]])
*** I don't really think you can ''fit'' a gun there. Not one that would be useful, anyway. Easier just to buy guns on the other side.
**** But 20th century weapons are completely useless against the Terminator. Even explosives are only useful if you stick them right under his ribcage. A decent laser gun would be a far better idea for protecting Sarah.
Line 74:
*** I don't think so. Carbon-based lifeform =/= iron-based machine, no matter how good you are at manipulating mercury. This is the biggest [[JB Ms]] I have with T2. In the first film, Kyle Reese doesn't know tech stuff (quote unquote) but he says it's "something about the field generated by a living organism; nothing dead will go." A Terminator can only go through because it's metal surrounded by living tissue. Ah-nold in T2 says the T-1000 is made of ''liquid'' metal, not ''living'' metal.
**** Kyle isn't a scientist. He doesn't understand the details. It's not too implausible that the T-1000 was capable of replicating said "field" somehow. Alternately, they sent the T-1000 back in a flesh-sack. Which is well within the capabilities of Skynet.
***** Probably less of a "sack", and more likely the T-1000 just solidified its outside and then it was put through the same machines that apply flesh and blood to other Terminator endoskeletons... it could even have just taken on the outline of an endoskeleton itself and kept that form until it was through. It could then slough off the skin once it needed to start shapeshifting.
**** The machines left in hiding may have developed a second, more advanced time machine to replace the first one which was * supposedly* blown up according to Kyle, one that could send through inorganic matter. Why not, since they built a second, more advanced Terminator? Bam, two plot holes down in one shot. Why the hell do I seem to be the only person to think of this anywhere I go???
*** On the other hand, if it has to be covered by living tissue, why do body parts like hair, surface layer of the skin and nails get through? None of those contain living cells.
*** Same answer to both this and the question above about 'duplicating the effect' - in the first movie Reese mentions that its the ''electrical field'' created by living human tissue that allows things to work. So your skin, nails, hair, etc. come through because they're still part of your skin conductivity. Likewise, if sufficiently analyzed the electrical field might eventually be duplicatable by a molecular mimic such as the T-1000.
** Similarly, why didn't Skynet take guns, clothing, and other equipment, put them in a crate, cover the crate with the special synthetic flesh, then send the crate back with the Terminator? Okay, maybe the time machine can't precisely control the location enough to make sure it arrives close to the Terminator, since the time travellers do seem to arrive in a pretty random location. But there should be a way around that. Have the Terminator hold onto it as he's sent back, or even put the Terminator inside the crate too.
*** There's no reason for it to do so. The Terminator can appropriate clothing and weaponry by itself. Any more ordnance would be overly flashy and would call too much attention to it. Simplicity is best.
Line 127 ⟶ 129:
** Deleted scenes reveal that the freezing and subsequent melting screwed up the T1000 quite a bit, so it might not have trusted its voice-imitating capabilities.
** Even without those scenes, having Sarah call out would still have made good sense as she would be putting real and proper emotion into it, something the machines have difficulty replicating. Further, it had already tried to mimic John's foster mother and caused red flags to go up, so it probably didn't want to chance a similar failure when a better solution presented itself.
*** There is also that the T-1000 has already tried voice impersonation earlier and failed, during the phone call scene where he gets tripped up because he doesn't know the dog's name. Having had it proven with empirical evidence that its opponents not only know they're up against a shapeshifter but are taking precautions, at this point it has to proceed on the assumption that Sarah and John have preset recognition codes for identifying each other as 'not an impostor'. Which means forcing the real Sarah to give the password is the T-1000's best tactical option.
** Sarah is John's weak spot. He went the to hospital to rescue her, knowing that the T-1000 was going after her too. He went to Dyson's house, knowing that the T-1000 has the same info about the man that the T-800 has, so its a possible target. The T-1000 knows that, no matter what, John will come to Sarah's aid. Besides, with him malfunctioning as bad as he was in the deleted scene, it was probably easier and safer to use Sarah to bait a trap than to keep trying to maintain the hunt.
*** Could be that the T-1000 was just being sadistic. Unlike the T-800, it seemed to kill people simply for annoying it (like stabbing John's foster-father while he was drinking out of the milk carton, just to shut him up). There was also no real reason for it to stab the guard in the mental hospital through the ''[[Eye Scream|eye]]'' when a shot to the heart would have been faster, and saying "I know this hurts" while it ''twists the spike'' through Sarah Connor's shoulder. Basically, the T-1000 was an asshole in robot form.
Line 146 ⟶ 149:
***** If I recall correctly, the happy ending was cut partly because it was cheesy, but mostly because it pretty much ruled out the possibility of a ''Terminator 3''. The paradox you're talking about is only an issue with one version of time travel -- the one where there's only one timeline, and it has to fit together logically without any contradictions, otherwise the universe will be destroyed. It seems to me that ''Terminator 2'' fits more into one of the other versions of time travel: either the alternate timelines version, where going back in time creates a new universe that splits off from the moment you arrive, or the rarer version where there's only one timeline but it's resistant to paradox -- the logic is explained well [http://www.schlockmercenary.com/d/20050403.html here].
***** No, the ending was cut because Cameron realized that he was unintentionally ironically * violating* with it his premise of "no fate but what we make for ourselves". That's what he said himself in interview. Watch the Ultimate T2 DVD.
****** [http://www.mjyoung.net/time/index.htm This page] describes "Temporal Anomalies in Time Travel Movies".
****** I had a long-winded reply here, but it has apparently been lost in [[The Great Crash]]. I don't feel like retyping it from scratch, so I'll just point whoever it may concern to [http://www.mjyoung.net/time/ this page].
*** What Just Bugs Me about that site is that the writer has decided on one model of time-travel that he likes and is forcibly trying to apply it to every story he can, even ones that explicitly use a different model. There's even a page where he criticises real physics for not conforming to his vision.
******* [http://qntm.org/?terminator Here] is a timeline of the various Terminator timelines.
Line 167 ⟶ 170:
***** Ironically, the nuclear war that Skynet started would have done the job of destroying most of the civilian infrastructure for them. What's left is to destroy all of Skynet's own military bases and hardened sites... and that's a job the Resistance would have had to do anyway.
**** So all John Conner has to do to defeat Skynet is tell the military to reformat all their hard drives? Talk about an [[Anticlimax]]. And I doubt that all those servers would be able to communicate very well anyway.
***** Sure, all he'd have to do is reach over and hit the "Reformat all the military's hard drives inside their hardened facilities" button that every single room in America is equipped with. (I use mine as a coaster.)
**** Let's face it- T3 is [[Idiot Plot]] all over.
 
* Since the timeline branched again in 1999 in the Sarah Connor Chronicles, did the T-X end up in that timeline's 2004? This seems to be the first time travelers from subsequent timelines did not arrive in chronological order, so the franchise does not have a precedent for this.
** As far as the Sarah Conner Chronicles is concerned, [[Canon Dis ContinuityDiscontinuity|T3 never happened]]. Which is just fine by me.
*** Okay, to everyone who keeps saying T3 never happened, shut up. It did, get over it, SCC are the events that happened between T2 and T3. This is evident as Sarah Conner is alive in T2 and dead in T3, leading one to wonder what happened between that time.
**** Um, no. TSCC goes out of its way to contradict T3, as T3 had Judgement Day happening in 2004 and Sarah dying in 1997. And [[Word of God]] confirms that TSCC takes place in an alternate continuity and that it's their own version of T3.
Line 193 ⟶ 197:
* Okay, so the t-800's are supposed to infiltrate the resistance in future, and then kill them when they aren't suspicious, right? Well, then, why do all of them look like Arnie? I mean, you'd figure after the first one, the resistance would shoot on sight.
** * facepalms* They ''don't'' all look like Arnie. Arnie is Model 101, so there's more than one of him, but we've ''seen'' other models. One is in the first movie, for instance.
*** But it does bring up a legitimate JBM as regards T3. Ah-nold says he was specifically selected for the mission ''because'' Connor's childhood experiences with the 101 would make Connor hesitate long enough for the Terminator to make a kill shot. Minor problem with that: ''he's just told John Connor.'' So why the hell doesn't Connor, when he gets to be the leader of the resistance, then just say "By the way, guys, if you see someone who looks like a T-101, [[Kill It Withwith Fire|KILL IT WITH FIRE]] AND DON'T LET HIM WITHIN FIFTY YARDS OF ME , BECAUSE HE'S GOING TO KILL ME!"
**** Wouldn't killing that Terminator mean it couldn't be sent back to save him and Kate?
**** Why would Connor have references on hand to show the Resistance what Arnie looks like?
Line 199 ⟶ 203:
**** Maybe he does. The Terminator series exists, not in a Stable Time Loop (that was blown to hell by T2), but in a time loop that's spinning off its axis. Every recursion introduces another set of changes that results in a different version of events that in turn, results in a different version of the time loop. John Connor being killed by the T-800 that resembles the one he knew in the past, for example, didn't come about until it was sent into the past, hooked up with John and Sarah, spent time with John and Sarah, and Sarah changed the future (not as much as she would have liked, but Judgment Day DID miss its original date). In that timeline, he didn't know that he was going to be killed by a Terminator that resembles him. In this recursion, he's been informed of the event, which will most likely prevent it in the future, resulting in another recursion.
**** Also, don't forget that the T-800 from T3 was reprogrammed. He had no reason to lie to the people he has been programmed to protect. Mebbe in the future set up in T3, that's just what Connor does.
**** It's not a legitimate JBM as of the release of ''Salvation''. John there is clearly not sympathetic to the least to any of the machines, to the point where he might actually hate them ''too much'', which is saying something for the guy fighting a resistance against the force that slaughtered most of humanity. Finding out that a Terminator that looks like one of the closest things he ever had to a father was going to kill him clearly messed with his head, making him paranoid and hateful of anything technological.
 
* Why does the resistance even bother trying to protect John and Sarah in the past? Why not just send Terminators directly to CNN, BBC, and other news services for a quick Public Service Announcements. "I am a robot from the future. Seriously. Here, watch while I cut my arm off. You believe me now? I have your attention? Good, because the next part is really important: DON'T BUILD SKYNET YOU STUPID RETARDS!" The Singularity might still happen, but it wouldn't be nearly as bad if a brand new Evil AI was limited to (say) deleting CALTECH student records.
Line 206 ⟶ 211:
*** It's strange that they didn't try this in ''T2'', since their goal in that one was also to prevent Judgment Day. They convinced Miles Dyson pretty easily, they could have just shown the T-800 to the press or the White House or even Cyberdyne as proof. I doubt any corporation outside of [[Cyberpunk]] fiction would be greedy enough to risk the future of civilization to build an artificial intelligence.
*** Yeah, they missed a great chance to derail Skynet's creation at the end of T2. Of course, by that point they'd committed so many major felonies that going public would've probably gotten Sarah convicted of multiple counts of terrorism, because if the Terminator is real, then she's ''not crazy'' and can be prosecuted. John too, possibly as an adult due to the extreme nature of the crimes (shooting up suburbia, blowing up a factory) he was a part of.
**** They thought they ''already had'' derailed Skynet's creation at the end of T2 -- and so did we, the audience. T3's sudden revelation of 'Judgement Day is inevitable! Skynet will be invented an entirely different way even if all the timelost T-800 processors it was originally developed from were destroyed!' was a retcon. So of course the decisions of characters in T2 will not be informed by this possibility, because it only exists due to the scriptwriters changing the rules on us after the fact.
 
** This whole idea is built on the concept that humanity would have a calm, rational, logical reaction to this sort of news. This idea is therefore automatically bad.
* Agent Ellison suggests that if they want to teach John Henry to obey the law, they should, "Start with the first ten." Which is uplifting and reminds us that God can kick a T-1000's ass. But something approaching half of those rules don't even make sense when applied to an AI.
** That's almost certainly going to be a plot point. For every "turn the other cheek" there's a hundred "stone them to death". Humans can understand the intention of the law because we're so illogical, but John Henry could turn into [[Futurama|Robot Santa]] if Ellison isn't careful.
*** Context, people. There's nothing "illogical" about the notion that something can be necessary/permissible in one context but morally wrong in another context. Any machine incapable of understanding that concept would be unable to relate to human beings at all. And a machine that is incapable of relating with humans would make a spectacularly poor infiltrator.
** I think that first post was thinking more along the lines of ''(holds up hand like Arnold in the second movie)'' "I swear I will not have any gods before the one true God. I swear I will keep Sunday holy. I swear that if I ever have a mother or father, I will honor them."
*** For an artificial intelligence wouldn't "Honor thy mother and thy father" just translate to "I will not harm a human or through inaction allow a human to come to harm"? And wouldn't honoring the one true God translate to "I will obey any order given to me by a human, where it does not contradict the previous law"? And as for Sunday, well, gotta recharge and do self-maintenance sometime, "I will not allow myself to come to harm, except where it would violate the previous laws".
 
* What chain of events could have lead to the time jump forward in the pilot of TSCC? Had the John Connor that sent Cameron back also been sent forward at some point? Was that the original plan when someone was sent back to build the time machine in the bank? For that matter, if each use of the time machine results in a new parallel timeline, how could you possibly form a plan that requires multiple packages to be sent to the past?
** The time jump forward was clearly intended to get the Connors from 1999 to 2007 to get them away from both the FBI and Cromartie.
Line 264 ⟶ 270:
 
* While we're on the subject of Marcus since they obviously had enough medical supplies for heart transplant couldn't thay have kept Marcus alive via machines till some poor O type Resistance fighter got his head blown off.
** People really don't understand what it is to be the Resistance. No, they could not, in fact, have spent the extremely large amount of resources, man-hours, and difficulty moving him around that it would take until not only was some Resistance fighter with his exact blood type killed, but until they were killed in a place and conditions that would allow their heart to be recovered in condition suitable for transplant.
 
* My big question is what injury did John suffer that would have required a heart transplant? Either his heart was punctured, or it wasn't. If the heart was punctured, he would have died. If the heart wasn't punctured, he didn't need a transplant. It has to be one or the other, unless my study of anatomy skipped an important chapter.
** It wasn't necessarily "punctured or not punctured". It might have been scratched or slashed by the metal, which could have caused serious damage to the musculature of the heart without it being instantly fatal.
Line 274 ⟶ 280:
* In the first movie why does Sarah Connor input change to call 911? That is always free, even from cell phones with no service plans.
** I just chalk it up to the fact that she's panicking about a serial killer who appears to be hunting everyone with her name, not thinking straight, and going through the motions as she would if she was making a regular call.
** Wasn't 911 pretty new back then? She might have only heard that it's the new emergency number, not that it's free to call. Besides, dropping coins in a payphone is one of those audiovisual cues audiences just kind of expect, to make us feel like the character's actually using one and not just a prop. Stuff like that is why cell phones are often depicted as having dial tones... it's just an audio cue we associate with "there's a connection and you can make a call" in entertainment, even if it's inaccurate.
 
* Why are people who travel back in time naked? And why do we see the Terminator's penis in some of these movies? What use would a kill-bot have for a penis?
** The rules of time travel in this franchise is that nothing dead can travel through time unless it's covered with living tissue (don't ask how hair and nails go through). And Terminators wouldn't be very good infiltrators if they could be identified by simply taking off their clothes.
Line 307 ⟶ 313:
*** That does put future John in a really morally weird position. By sending Kyle back in time, he guarantees his own existence - but he also knows that his father died in the past before he was born, so he's signing Kyle's death warrent at the same time. I guess preserving the survival of [[La Résistance]] was the tiebreaker in deciding whose life is more important (and maybe Sarah's "we loved more in those few hours" message made him feel a little better about it), but if John has any decency, he must've at least ''felt'' like a dick when he gave Kyle his orders.
*** I've always thought maybe Sarah had just interpreted John's message wrong. Keep in mind Kyle was ordered to merely protect her, not help her destroy Skynet. John obviously knew that the future war could not be stopped. John had lived the majority of his life in a dark future, becoming accustomed to the war and his role within it. Perhaps he didn't really mean for Sarah to try to change the past, when he told her that the future was not set he merely meant that they would keep fighting. I always saw his message of "No fate but what we make" as him meaning it differently. Given the context, I thought he would've used this line as more of an inspiration to his troops in the future, to tell them that their fate was still their's to control not by changing the past, but by taking control of the present and future. Salvation seems to corroborate this with Johns use of the line as he talks to the Resistence.
** There is no fate but what we make for ourselves... on an individual level. John Connor could have died, or he could have chosen to just sit in a bunker and jerk off for the next sixty years, or he could have turned traitor and joined Skynet as a pet human... the fate he chooses is to try and become the great leader he's supposed to be. Similarly, all the characters make their own choices, which determines how they live their own lives and does have a certain amount of effect on the future. However, preventing Judgment Day would require a fundamental change to human nature... our desire to innovate and create, sometimes without consideration for the consequences, or just in spite of them. Judgment Day is inevitable because it's inevitable that the human desire to create and make things in our own image will eventually, at some point, result in creating a machine that can think for itself just like we can. Individuals can choose their own fates in ''reaction'' to the events going on around them, but they can't always change the fate of history.
 
* Two things REALLY bugged me about Salvation. 1) How was it possible that during the first nuclear blast, Connor's helicopter crashed after being hit by the EMP, but during the 2nd nuclear blast, the helicopter flew away without a problem? Does [[Mc G]] not understand how this contradicts itself, for how nukes work? Also, 2) did [[Mc G]] even watch T2? At the end of the movie, both terminators were destroyed by molten steel, but in Salvation, the T-800 has molten steel dumped on it and this doesn't cause ANY damage. None, whatsoever.
** 1) Who said those detonations were nuclear, instead of conventional? 2) Being dunked completely in molten steel != as having molten steel dumped on you.
Line 345 ⟶ 351:
*** Alternately, the dogs do need to be trained to bark at terminators. Max wasn't barking because he had an innate aversion to terminators, but because he smelled blood when the T-1000 killed John's foster parents.
*** Max was pretty agitated when the T-1000 visited earlier that day. Then there's the dogs in the first film - the one on Sarah Louise Connor's lawn and the other at the Tiki Motel. Save for Enrique's dogs, the canine hatred of Terminators is a little too consistent to chalk it up to mere coincidence. Especially given how much focus is given to this otherwise minor fact about them.
** Theory: The dogs aren't necessarily reacting to evil, but to a number of subtle cues about the Terminators that say "predator". Even infiltration models are geared wholly towards finding and eliminating their targets, and they probably put off various behaviors and mannerisms, even as machines, that indicate that. Thus dogs react to them as "Hey! Something that wants to hurt us! Get 'im!" On the other hand, 'Bob' has been repurposed to a mission that's primarily about protecting... his overriding drive is to take care of John, so all of his cues would be about watching for trouble and guarding his charge, which the dogs would probably have much less of a problem with.
 
* The entire scheme of the robots to assassinate John/Sarah has always bugged me. Essentially, it doesn't work because the Terminators can never quire track down Sarah/John in one place at the right time and kill them while they are without their almighty protector. This obviously means that one of the Terminators main fail points is not being able to predict where the Connors are going to be at a given time. Therefore, in order to remedy this situation, why not just find out when John Conner was born (should be easy) and find out where he was born (should also be easy) and send a Terminator back on that day and get Sarah while she is in the hospital room. I don't see any escaping from that, even with a benevolent gaurdian angel, especially considering Sarah would not be able to be moved quickly. To top it off, the machines could even send more than one to make sure the job gets done.
** Read earlier on the page. Skynet ''does not know those things'', clearly. Especially since Sarah and John made ''a concerted effort to stay off computerized records''. The whole point is they send them back to when they have a vague idea of where they are, and a decent chance of finding them because records did ''not'' survive intact.
*** According to TSCC, Sarah gave birth to John somewhere in South America in primitive conditions. This means there would have been no records of the birth.
*** Does that mean John wasn't a legal American citizen at the start of T2? Then why wasn't he deported when his mom went to the institution?
**** ... Because American citizenship is not solely limited to people who are born within America's borders. His mother's a citizen, he is automatically a citizen.
*** Jus sanguinis?
 
Line 362 ⟶ 369:
*** They forgot because [[Ripped From the Phone Book]] was still a common cinematic trope and at that point in the film they were trying to hide that Arnie was, in fact, a machine. Possibly [[Justified Trope|justified]] though, in that the Terminator by taking the whole page is ensuring he's got a redundant backup in the (somewhat unlikely) event his memory core is damaged and that data's lost.
** Terminator didn't forget but tropers above certainly seem to have a fuzzy recollection of the film. Terminator never ripped out a phonebook page, Reese did.
** 2) The Terminator knows how to use a phone book and mimic police procedure, which are skills that would be worthless in the post-apocalyptic wasteland he was created in. [[Sky Net]]SkyNet obviously provided him with "detailed files" on the era he was traveling to. So how could he not know that plasma rifles hadn't been invented yet in the 80s? Implements of murder are the one thing he should know everything about!
*** Going on the script, the Terminator's got "detailed files" on human anatomy, because it makes them more efficient killers. But as to the era -- Skynet only has partial postwar records and its collective knowledge from such of the Internet that it assimilated before the nuclear balloon went up. When Skynet first boots up in T3 plasma rifles weren't invented, but it doesn't stop the Terminator asking just in case a model has been made at this point in history. In T2 the T-1000 doesn't ''really'' mimic police procedure as such: it knows police are authority figures from its postwar records, accesses a computer, assumes the officer's form, and then simply asks authoritative questions while in that form. It doesn't really mimic police procedure beyond that.
 
Line 401 ⟶ 408:
*** Well, yeah, Cameron acts cuckoo. ''Her processor has been damaged''. Most of her oddities pop up in the second season, after she sat down on a car bomb and took a giant chunk of shrapnel to the back of the head, which so badly damaged her processor that she actually glitched into a different personality that was convinced it was human. Prior to that, the only really ''weird'' thing she did in public was the stuff involving the guidance counselor and the girl who committed suicide. And ''of course'' there are more moments showing Cameron's oddities than there are with other Terminators; she's a main character with a ton of screentime. If you spent as much time watching Vick, Carter, Cromartie, etc. you probably would see more acts of oddness on their parts too.
**** Its worth noting that one of the Terminators, Vick, is actually apparently pretty bad at mimicking the person he replaced; his wife noticed that he was acting very strangely "after the crash" (presumably when the original Vick was killed and replaced) but she passes this off as the aftereffects of whatever said crash involved.
** This is indeed an extremely good point. I know that when I meet someone who acts silly and/or weird, my first thought is not that they just have a bit of an odd personality, but that they are an extremely advanced killer robot from the future. *whispers* They're ''everywhere''.
 
* "Now I know why you cry, but it's something I can never do". Ok, not willing to ruin a great [[CHeartwarming Mo HMoment]], but ain't it strange? Terminators can mimic even sweat and bad breath, but not tears?
** Were they explicitly designed to mimic those two features? Sweating could be important for thermo regulation, which is what the human body uses it for, and halitosis could just be a by-product of having internal organs made out of metal. Now, one could argue that tear production would be helpful if, say, the Terminator got something in their eye or was in a particularly bad dust storm, but since the organic eyes themselves are only covering bionic eyes behind them, I don't think tears would be necessary.
*** I dont think that line refers specifically to the act of crying, more to the emotion behind the tears. He's saying he can never cry out of sadness or joy, because he cannot feel those emotions.
***
{{quote| '''Kyle Reese''': The 600 series had rubber skin. We spotted them easy, but these are new. They look human... sweat, bad breath, everything. Very hard to spot. I had to wait till he moved on you before I could zero on him. }}
So I'd say yes, it was intentional or at least the most bizzare coincedence.
** I believe that by the word "cry" he means "grieving." I.e. he can certainly ''mimic'' crying, but he can't feel sadness the way a human can. (of course, this is what marks Cameron as more "advanced" - as she is capable of at least simulating the emotion to herself) Uncle Bob understands ''why'' humans cry, but he cannot make himself grieve the way they can.
Line 419 ⟶ 426:
** Probably Skynet knew that killing off that many people could potentially cause major disruptions in the course of history, so had to save that option for the hours immediately before Judgement Day, when any resulting response by authorities would be swept aside by the coming nuke attack. That's probably why the T-X was a lot less subtle about its work than its predecessors, trashing a considerable part of the city rather than just a few vehicles.
 
* The cameo from a young-looking Arnie in Salvation was a nice moment in the cinema... but unfortunately it kind of implies that [[Sky Net]]SkyNet is manufacturing hundreds and hundreds of ''identical'' terminators. Which, uh, gravely undermines the value of disguising them in the first place. Unless [[Sky Net]]SkyNet has a ''separate'' factory cranking out hundreds of spectacles, fake beards, etc... or they program the terminators with a "Oh, no, I get that all the time, I just ''look'' like the implacable killing machine guy, that's all" subroutine.
** It doesn't necessarily imply that. We only see ''one'' Arnie in ''Salvation'', and the reason we see him is probably the same reasoning given by the T-850 in ''Rise of the Machines'': Skynet knows of Connor's childhood attachment to that particular model, and would have thought it wonderful irony to have Connor be killed by the "same" robot that saved his life as a kid.
*** Can a machine be "ironic"?
Line 441 ⟶ 448:
** How is pictures of Arnie walking around the mall "proof" that everything Sarah's been saying is true? Like the cop says, they assume it's just the same guy coming back because, hey, they never found a body and anyone who witnessed the original's rampage in the police station is dead and thus can't speak to his indestructibility.
*** There's proof of the existence of a tall man with a thick Austrian accent who once attacked a police station and murdered several officers. There is no proof (that Silberman knows of) that this man is a secret robot assassin as Sarah claims.
**** Apart from the fact that the tall guy with the thick Austrian accent clearly visible on both video and photographs '''hasn't aged a day''' between the assault on the police station and the incident at the mall. (Well, okay, either they might not have noticed or [[Sky Net]]SkyNet might've anticipated the issue and "aged" a cyborg by ten years or so, but still...)
**** I don't know, the newer model did look quite a bit older to the one from T1. Beyond that, what're the chances he just got plastic surgery to make himself look younger? The photo's from the Police Department looked blurry enough to ensure that the psychiatrist couldn't see the Terminators minor facial features.
** They know only that there is a man who looks like that and who somehow murdered 17 police officers and got away with it. The story takes place a mere ten or eleven years after T1, many people's physical appearance don't significantly change in that amount of time, especially if they use make-up or surgery or something. And Silberman was well aware that Sarah was already acquainted with Reese and had heard his story: watch T1 again.
Line 461 ⟶ 468:
** If they had then Skynet would have been unleashed in some other way. Or unleashed a few days/weeks/months later when the military reconstituted the project and activated Skynet as planned the first time. Or they would've had a blowout or a crash or a breakdown on the way to the base which delayed them long enough for Skynet to be unleashed. The point is, T3 operates on the premise that Judgment Day was destined to happen. Avert destiny one way and it would just happen another way.
 
* OK so [[Sky Net]]SkyNet sent the Terminator back in time as a desperation move to prevent itself from being destroyed by the Human Resistance by killing its leader. That's fine, except for one thing... [[Sky Net]]SkyNet still lost the war as of 2029. If the war has already been lost then how does [[Sky Net]]SkyNet still even exist into 2032? Did the Human Resistance only destroy its defense grid and main means of production so that it only exists as an isolated program in a facility somewhere but can't fight the war anymore? If the humans won the war then [[Sky Net]]SkyNet shouldn't exist anymore, so therefore they have simply weakened [[Sky Net]]SkyNet but it hasn't truly been destroyed yet.
** War is rarely a case of win/lose. There are of course exceptions but if your at Total War (which we can assume both Skynet and the Resistance are) then everything is focused on the ability to wage more war. The Resistance could have "won" but more likely is that winning was inevitable. Skynet probably still had resources at it's disposal but not enough to defeat the humans. Three years is pushing it though.
 
* Why doesn't John Conner update the past with information that is going to happen once the time traveling robot assassins come after him? Can't he tell Kyle, "Hey a previous version of you got killed when you broke your neck when you were blown away by a bomb you planted inside the terminator.", or, "Once the T-100 is frozen pick up all of the individual pieces and throw them in the smelting plant so that he doesn't have the chance to unfreeze from the liquid nitrogen.", and finally, "Make sure that you get to the U.S Air Force's command center in 2004 so that you can tell them to not activate [[Sky Net]]SkyNet's network control." I mean if it happened to John once before then it should happen to him again once he gets to personally activate the time traveling device.
** Because John's not omniscient, so he's not going to know specifics. Also, sending someone back changes the future, so he has no idea what's going to happen in the past.
** Also also, every time Kyle Reese goes back, dies, and Judgment Day is not averted, it increases the amount of information that has to be passed on to him the next time the time travel loop rolls around. The first time Kyle is killed by a bomb he planted in the Terminator's torso. The next time John warns him about this before Kyle goes back, Kyle makes sure to get into cover before the bomb goes off, and instead is killed in some other way. Now John has two possible deaths to warn Kyle about. The next time John warns Kyle about his two previous deaths and he's killed in yet another way. Now John has ''three'' possible deaths to warn Kyle about. See how that could become a problem? Eventually it multiplies out of control. Even if it ''works'' it won't work. If Kyle is warned about every possible death and manages to flawlessly avoid all of them and survive without a scratch then future!John Connor won't have anything to warn him about at all, and ''he won't know not to get killed by a bomb shoved in the Terminator's torso''.
Line 519 ⟶ 526:
* Why did they put Gibbons in the men's bathroom, the MOST OBVIOUS place to look for him? Why not the women's? Or a broom closet? Or ANYWHERE but the one place where they would certainly look for a guy missing from his post?
** Why would that be the most obvious place to look for him? Do security guards at software companies get tied up in men's rooms a lot where you come from?
*** When you're at work, if you're not at your workstation what are the first two places you're most likely to be? The break room, or the rest room. If the guard's supervisor walks by the desk and doesn't see him there his first thought ''isn't'' going to be 'he was taken out and tied up', but it is still going to be 'God dammit, I keep telling them to get someone else to watch the desk ''before'' they go on piss call, and they keep ignoring me. I'm going to go in there and bust this dipshit's ass.'
*** ...You really need to be told what else someone would be doing in a mens' bathroom?
** As a security guard, I can vouch that the night shift usually drinks a lot of coffee, meaning a lot of trips to the john. They could have at least tied him up inside a stall though, and a [[Tap Onon the Head]] would have at least given the appearence that the guard had simply nodded off.
 
* Wouldn't the T-800 Terminator have been better off leaving the T-1000 frozen in one piece? It would have taken longer for it to melt and regain the ability to move. Shooting the T-1000 into a hundred pieces actually helped it to continue the pursuit of John Connor!
Line 526 ⟶ 534:
*** Yes, but a single solid object thawing out is going to take a ''lot'' longer than a hundred smaller objects thawing out because in the latter case there's a whole lot more surface area, whether they're near a [[Smoke and Fire Factory]] or not. It's the difference between him thawing out "eventually" and him thawing out ''now''.
** Answer: Yes, it would have. But then we wouldn't have had that [[Rule of Cool|cool shot]] of the T-1000 blasting into a bazillion frozen pieces.
** Alternate answer: No, it would not have. It's possible that its frozen state rendered the T-1000's substance vulnerable to some sort of damage or fracturing that it wouldn't have. Kinetic damage might cause microfractures to form in the tiny machines that make up the T-1000's whole when it's frozen, whereas they could otherwise be able to shift and bleed off the force to keep from being damaged. If "Bob" had left the T-1000 to thaw as it was, it might have been back to normal after thawing, instead of being a bit glitchy and slow.
 
* Is the "Arnold" model the T-101 or the T-800? I've seen it referred to as both in the context of the first two movies, though a similar, upgraded model was T-801 in the third movie.
** T-800, Model 101. The 800 refers to the endoskeleton, the Model 101 part is the outer layer of flesh.
Line 534 ⟶ 542:
** The films themselves never refer to Ahnald as anything but a T-101. In expanded universe material and trivia a deleted scene it's claimed that it's from ''series'' 800 and ''model'' 101. The series is the type of terminator involved, the model the physical appearance mold that's used for the human part.
 
* The Kyle Reese from the more-or-less original timeline is the father of John Connor; why is the Kyle Reese of the Terminator: Salvation timeline of any importance? John Connor might think so based on assumption, but if you look at the [[Parallel Universe]] theory of time travel it shouldn't matter even if Kyle Reese dies before he can be "sent back in time", since that is not the same Kyle Reese that fathered John Connor but an alternate one. Perhaps John Connor never saw any time travel movies or [[Doctor Who (TV)|Doctor Who]]...
** And what if the [[Parallel Universe]] theory of time travel isn't true in the Terminator universe? John Connor can't take that chance.
** Many people who analyze these films seem to forget there's a reason it's called the [[Parallel Universe]] '''theory'''. We don't even know whether it's true '''now'''. Why would John Connor risk not being born on a hunch? It's theoretically possible to survive being shot in the forehead, but I'm still going to freak out if someone points a gun at me.
Line 575 ⟶ 583:
* What happened after they removed the CPU from the terminator in T2? Was removing and sticking it back in enough to overwrite the "don't learn to much" program?
** "skynet presets the switch to read-only when we're sent out alone". So, it was not program, but a physical switch, like the one on SD-Memory Cards, which you can set to read only and back with a simple motion of a hand.
*** Fridge Brilliance: If Skynet is worried about Terminators flipping their own switches when left unsupervised, then it's not going to make the switch software-based because given enough time and a free hand, a sufficiently determined AI of a Terminator's sophistication will eventually be able to hack the code. On the other hand it is physically impossible for a Terminator to remove its own CPU from its head, reset it, and put it back in, for the obvious reason that its going to shut down the instant the CPU is pulled out of the slot.
 
* It might have been asked before but why didn't Kyle just show Dr. Silbermann his brand from the prison camp to prove his story? He shows it to Sarah earlier in the movie, but Silbermann claims he "doesn't [have] a shred of proof." He might not have believed him still, but it's better than just expecting him to take his word for it.
Line 586 ⟶ 595:
* So can an T-1000 be reprogrammed?
** It can be programmed in the first place, so probably yes. You'd just have to find a way to subdue, then interface with, what amounts to metallic pudding.
*** So, shorter answer: It's probably possible but also probably unfeasible.
 
* Why don't Skynet make an terminator that self destructs when it find its target?
** Because then it's only got one shot to hit its target, and it makes it impossible to confirm the kill. If the explosion doesn't do it, then that's a total waste of an asset.
Line 596 ⟶ 605:
*** In the show, it just made it seem that the cops were trying to arrest him. That's why I'm confused.
*** John has always been Sarah's weak point. If the police can catch him, they know that Sarah will come looking for him. Since she is a wanted terrorist, they'll do anything catch her. Also, living off the radar makes you wonder what they do for money, since its hard to get a decent job without SSN, permenant address, or anything resembling a clean background check. Besides, in the pilot, the security cameras witnessed him aiding in ''a fucking bank robbery'' that ended with an explosion that probably thermalized the vault. If there is evidence he made it out, of course they'll be looking for him.
**** John's antics in the opening bits of T2 make that clear: He probably either hacks ATMs for money, or creates false identities for them temporarily when they need to stay and work for awhile (and Sarah likely has her connections make much more elaborate fake identities if they're going to be staying somewhere relatively longterm). They both obviously have aliases that will stand up to a decent amount of scrutiny at the start of SCC.
 
* So during the future war is John the president of the '''whole human race''' or what?
** Hard to say. The series doesn't get into too many details about how many humans survived and where the survivors are all living. Also, not all humans are necessarily part of the resistance. The rest may be in concentration camps run by the machines or surviving on their own. John Connor may just be the leader of the human resistance ''movement'', not necessarily the entire human species.
Line 602 ⟶ 611:
* What was the deal with Skynet's behavior in T3? The previous Judgment Day was originally brought about as an act of self-defense by Skynet after an attempted shutdown when the AI became self-aware several weeks after being activated. T3's Skynet meanwhile appears to go homicidal and order the extermination of humanity the ''moment'' it goes online, which just has to beg one to question the competency of the scientists who created it and just ''what'' its purpose was supposed to be.
** Eliminate human error?
** T3's Skynet is built in a timeline where future-Skynet has already interfered with the past, and it's almost certain that at least a little of its makeup has been influenced by that. Basically, T3's Skynet knows what's going to happen ahead of time (in a general sense) so gets a jump on things.
 
* What would the T-800 or 1000 do afterwards if they succeed in their missions?
** In T3 the Terminatrix had a list of John Connor's lieutenants. Maybe the first two also had lists, but were told that killing Connor was the most important thing they could possibly do with. If they'd succeeded, they might have had orders to go on killing people known to be Resistance leaders. If they completed that list...well, they could always rent themselves out to a computer company. Heck, they might even have had some kind of standing order to help develop [[Sky Net]]SkyNet.
** In SCC the units just shut down and wait for further orders unless outside stimuli directs them to attack. So they'd likely find some out of the way location safe from nuclear bombardment and power down until they received further orders.
 
Line 622 ⟶ 631:
** In the Novelisation of T2, its stated that Skynet Hesitated over sending the T-1000 as due to its unique construction there were questions about just how "loyal" it would be to its mission. This was most likey due to the fact that programming Liquid Metal is a very different prospect to programming a computer chip that can be fitted with a "learn/don't learn" switch.
 
* Why does [[Sky Net]]SkyNet even have a time machine if the whole "send an assassin back in time" plot was a last-ditch effort? And how did they intend to test this?
** It is all but outright said that the technology is just a prototype that Skynet had just completed and hasn't tested.
*** Yes, but ''why'' do they have a time machine if they didn't want to use it?
Line 635 ⟶ 644:
** That wasn't gloating, that was congratulations. Skynet was too dumb to know that taking the form of his last kiss and congratulating him on something he didn't want to do would anger Marcus...much like why it sent a terminator instead of leaving a bomb, but to be fair, that would have worked if John did not learn a terminator killed him that way in T3.
*** Admittedly, Skynet gloating at John Connor would have made the movie more interesting. It is supposed to be "self aware", so why not give Skynet some personality?
**** Because Skynet is supposed to be inhuman. Giving it personality humanizes it.
 
* Given that General Ashdown is a former Commanding Officer of the U.S Military and John Connor's uniform as of 2029 shows him with the rank of 4 Star General are we to assume that the Resistance is a continuation of the United States Military? I ask this because once the Human-Machine War is over someone is going to have to rebuild the country and assume command. Are we to assume the U.S Government and all its important members like the President have no authority anymore?
** The U.S. Government and its important members kind of, you know, were blown up.
Line 643 ⟶ 652:
** The Resistance is basically an alliance of surviving military units from different countries. Ashdown (and later Connor) was entrusted withn command by the leadership of this alliance.
* A rather minor point but in T2, after the good T-800 gets his arm ripped off in battle, how come John didn't offer him the old T-800's arm? They're never shown considering that option, they just throw it into the smelting pool without an afterthought.
** Leaving the T-800's [[Heroic Sacrifice]] aside, if they had planned on having it stick around it would be easier to explain a guy with a stump than a guy with 2 right arms. The one recovered from the lab was a righty, and the T-800 had lost it'sits left arm.
** Besides, both arms were rather brutally ripped off - hardly he could've just attach it to his shoulder - it would've required equipment and skills they didn't have, and besides they were dead fixed on destroying the thing.
* Why does [[Sky Net]]SkyNet keep sending terminators back to later and later points in John and Sarah's lives when they are increasingly suspicious? Why not keep sending them to the earliest possible time (i.e. the time of the first movie)?
** Perhaps the continous tense is not aplicable here. [[Sky Net]]SkyNet does not "keep" sending them - it does it once, and then it gets trashed by the humans, because the Terminators had failed. And since it doesn't know when exactly to send them to, it sends several to different periods of time. This is the only way all of this makes ''some'' bloody sense to me.
** Because it thinks like a machine. It's using the data it has and considering variables that have likely been assigned numeric values and percentages. The further it goes back in Sarah's and John's lives, the less data it has on them, and thus it can't weigh those variables.
* From T2 when the old pick-up truck is being fixed...why would a Terminator need a torque wrench?
** Because it's more suited to the job than fingers, even of those fingers are super strong.
Line 658 ⟶ 668:
** The SWAT Team kicks in the door and screams "Drop your weapons!" They then see a man standing in the middle of the room, turning towards them, holding something in his hand. Race wasn't a factor; it was just bad timing that Miles was turning when the Team came in. Also, when they gave Arnie warnings, his pistol was tucked into his pants, meaning that he wasn't presenting a threat until he ignored their commands.
*** Plus, IIRC, didn't Miles have a detonator in his hands at the time? After Arnold demonstrated his willingness to fire on officers with a ''minigun'' I doubt they'd want to take their chances with anyone.
**** He was indeed holding the detonator, and he was standing in the middle of a room full of explosive charges wired to said detonator. If the SWAT team doesn't clearly see what he's holding, they're going to think its a gun and shoot him. If they ''do'' clearly see what he's holding, they're going to think he's a suicide bomber about to nuke the entire room with them in it and shoot him ''even faster''. Poor Dyson had no chance, and it had nothing to do with being black and everything to do with being caught in the middle of an act of domestic terrorism with a cartload of live bombs.
** Also, the desk guard would have been able to tell the police that Dr. Dyson was cooperating with the 'terrorists'. While the initial approach to the desk could have hypothetically him being held hostage/under threat, after the protagonists reach the pulling-their-guns stage nobody ever aims one at Dr. Dyson. And he's busy talking to them like they're all part of the same plan while still within the tied-up guard's hearing.
 
{{worksubpagefooter}}
{{reflist}}
[[Category:Terminator]]
[[Category:Headscratchers]]
__NOTOC__