The Savage Indian: Difference between revisions

m
→‎Real Life: Copyedit (minor)
m (remove unneccessary quote box template)
m (→‎Real Life: Copyedit (minor))
 
(13 intermediate revisions by 6 users not shown)
Line 1:
{{trope}}
[[caption-width-right:288File:Savage 3 450.png|frame|''The Death of Jane McCrea'',<br />John Vanderlyn (1804)]]
<!-- %%Image selected per Image Pickin' thread: http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/posts.php?discussion=1301678098007544600 -->
<!-- %%Please do not change or remove without starting a new thread. -->
[[File:Savage_3_450.png|frame]]
[[caption-width-right:288:''The Death of Jane McCrea'',<br />John Vanderlyn (1804)]]
 
The Native Americans are frequently portrayed in modern fiction as a [[Noble Savage|tragic group of people]] subject to prejudice of the White Man and now are suffering in an age of darkness. Seems like it is standard fare for Native Americans to be like that?
Line 9 ⟶ 6:
Not quite.
 
[[Discredited Trope|Though not common today]], in older works the default was the Savage Indian, a native of their land who is a [[Always ChaoticExclusively Evil|bloodthirsty man or woman]] who only wishes to kill and hunt trophies for the sake of satiating their [[For the Evulz|unquenchable thirst or desire for heads]]. They are brutal, uncompromising and is seen as aare "[[Dirty Coward|Betterall youtoo thanwilling me]]"to typelet ofallies persontake ifthe one must work with themfall]]. They are most of the time exiled by their tribes for being too violent, but if a foreigner comes in, expect the Savage Indian to reject the outsider first with a weapon up their vital organs. Sometimes they will be the [[Evil Counterpart|rival tribe]]/griyo that the Noble Indians want to see defeated or at least no longer hurting them and the people they are making peace with but couldn't due to unfortunate damage done by them.
 
This trope has ancient forerunners as practically every culture has identified a more primitive neighbor as '"savages'", particularly when there existed a conflict of interests. It became especially common in the age of imperialism during which blatantly racist ideas were used to advance a policy of [[Mighty Whitey|European nations]] "[[Ethnic Menial Labor|civilizing]]" the rest of the world. In the United States, expanding settlers repeatedly came into conflict with the native tribes. Infrequent abhorrent acts of violence perpetrated by the natives against the intruders led to the perception that all natives were brutal savages, [[Blatant Lies|especially considering that the settlers were all saints]]. Battles against savage Indians were commonplace in Western fiction up until the modern era, putting this on the edge of becoming a [[Dead Horse Trope]]. In the era of the "Revisionist Western," (the era in which we find ourselves) fiction often attempts to provide a more diverse and historically accurate view of violence by and against Native Americans.
 
Compare and Contrast [[Magical Native American]] and [[Noble Savage]].
{{examples|Examples}}
 
{{examples|Examples}}
== Anime and Manga ==
* In ''[[Shaman King]]'', Hao's life 500 years ago is essentially that of a [[Complete Monster]], going so far as to [[A Nazi Byby Any Other Name|destroy entire cultures]] because they don't want to join him in his quest to rid the world of [[Muggles]]. One of the last survivors of that thinks that Silva and the rest are just like Hao. Which is...really weird in [[The Nineties]].
 
== Film ==
Line 24 ⟶ 21:
* In ''[[Calamity Jane]]'' (1953), Jane fights this kind, and brags of the number she has killed.
* In ''[[Damn Yankees]]'' (1958), the Devil recalls "Indians draggin' an empty covered wagon when scalping the settlers was the latest craze."
* Averted in ''Der Kaiser von Kalifornien'' (1936), meaning that American media were [[GodwinsGodwin's Law|worse than the Nazis]].
 
== Literature ==
* Magua from ''[[The Last of the Mohicans (Literature)|The Last of the Mohicans]]''.
* Injun Joe, the [[Ax Crazy]] villain of ''[[The Adventures of Tom Sawyer]]''.
* ''[[Tall Tale America]]'' has these turn up whenever guys like Mike Fink or Davy Crockett get tired of shooting animals.
 
== Professional Wrestling ==
* Apache Bull Ramos, the bookers wanted him to be a [[Face]] because he could wrestle well but had very little charisma. He refused though and became one of the greatest [[Heel|heelsheel]]s ever, when it came to drawing crowd heat. He mainly suffered the [[Worf Effect]] to establish the new champion's credibility.
 
== Religion and Mythology ==
* [[The Book of Mormon (Literatureliterature)|The Book of Mormon]] portrays the Lamanites this way.
 
== Real Life ==
* The Aztecs are almost always portrayed as bloodthirsty and war-loving, even in modern works. Of course, there are [[Human Sacrifice|reasons for]] [[Up to Eleven|this bad reputation]].
** In North America, the Pawnee are the only ones who practiced [[Human Sacrifice]], of virgins from neighboring groups, but [[Les Collaborateurs|since they were allies of the U.S.]], they were typically portrayed more sympathetically. They underwent a meta-[[Face Heel Turn]] in the movies around the time the Sioux underwent a meta-[[Heel Face Turn]].
* This useused to be a major draw at [[Disney Theme Parks|Disneyland]], back when Westerns were popular. Aside from the Indian Village, [[Tom Sawyer]]'s Island included an eternally burning shack with arrows in the side of it. As attitudes changed, it was given [[Multiple Choice Past|several different backstories]] before it became just a shack.
* The anthropologist, Napoleon Chagnon, who ventured into the Venezuelan jungle in the 1960s to study the Yąnomamö tribe, released accounts of a perpetually violent society beset by wars and constant strife. Chagnon believed he found a society in which homicide and warfare were common and most violent men wound up with the most wives and children. Whether or not his views were really founded on actual fact or visualizing the Yąnomamö through his rough childhood, this created a lot of controversy in the anthropological world, as it was taken to justify Christian missionaries' subversion of the native culture and escalated clashes between them and nearby miners.
* As late as February 2011 Bryan Fischer, Director of Issues Analysis for the [[Moral Guardians|American Family Association]], [http://newspaperrock.bluecorncomics.com/2011/02/text-of-fischers-racist-screed.html argued that] Indians were "morally disqualified from sovereign control of American soil" by their "superstition, savagery and sexual immorality". How wrong is this statement? Let us count the ways:
Line 50 ⟶ 47:
[[Category:Discredited Trope]]
[[Category:The Savage Indian]]
[[Category:TropeNative American Tropes]]
{{DEFAULTSORT:Savage Indian, The}}