Topic on User talk:DocColress

This is a permanent link to the first version of this post. You can view later versions on the post history page.

Thanks. I added why on the Discussion for Disney CM. Might also need to do the same for Chernabog, who's a similar case: virtually The Devil, yet doesn't do anything notably heinous in his screentime - or in his case, much of anything.

Sadly, yes. It went like: "Edgar, according to some fans. Yes, he's one of the least threatening villains in Disney history, but his intended victims are a family of adorable cats." To which it was correctly rebuked with "But you can see he never tries to kill them. Even when they come back, he just tries to send them away. Justified because he thinks that Cats Have Nine Lives. Plain and simple, Edgar is probably one of the least Complete Monster-y Big Bads in Disney." And really, when even his worst action (nearly skewering O'Malley with a pitchfork) was accidental, you know he far from qualifies for a trope about the absolute worst of the worst.

I think the Disney CM page is pretty much finished in terms of pre-existing Disney material now.