Topic on User talk:Cwf1997

This is a permanent link to the first version of this post. You can view later versions on the post history page.

I'm coming out of hibernation to weigh in on this matter. I'm sorry, I disagree with this judgement. He made a brand new YMMV page for a work that did not previously have one, correctly used 8 out of 9 tropes, and paved the way for others to provide additional information. One of the two tropes deleted in a later edit, Surprisingly Improved Sequel, was exchanged for Contested Sequel; this is not because he misused the trope, but because of a difference in opinion. The only trope he truly misused was Obvious Judas. All in all, 90% of his contribution was useful.

He has shown a willingness to improve. You are being overly critical and ignoring the human.

Retrieved from "https://allthetropes.org/wiki/Topic:Wbk9xhzd1vg8v2iu"