Topic on Talk:Member Berries

This trope is a little outside my scope of expertise, but I honestly can't really think of a way to address either bullet point since, let's be honest, its very existence revolves around complaints about what's perceived to be nostalgia pandering. That's not to say that it doesn't deserve to exist though, because it's a kind of complaint that I've really seen become popularized enough to be tropeable.

What I propose is to make it a YMMV trope since one man's memberberry can easily become another man's loving tribute to the past, and make it clear for tropers not to let their personal feelings bleed into it, and instead focus on audience reception to the example they're posting.