Automoderated users, Autopatrolled users, Bureaucrats, Comment administrators, Confirmed users, Moderators, Rollbackers, Administrators
213,684
edits
Umineko: When They Cry/WMG/Colored Text: Difference between revisions
Umineko: When They Cry/WMG/Colored Text (view source)
Revision as of 23:22, 16 January 2021
, 3 years agobot-edit: replaced potholed link to redirect with potholed link to destination page
No edit summary |
(bot-edit: replaced potholed link to redirect with potholed link to destination page) |
||
Line 194:
*** (Respondent here.) I would say the scene in EP5 where Natsuhi, Krauss, Nanjo, and (possibly, not certain) Kumasawa are in Kinzo's study and the old fart has just passed away. The one where Natsuhi convinces the others to pretend that [[Of Corpse He's Alive|Kinzo is still alive]].
**** ...Um, so? Not only is that a flashback provided by supernatural means, but there's no empirical evidence left behind that Battler can use, such as a diary or anything.
***** (Respondent here.) {{color|red|A diary belonging to Natsuhi was mentioned in EP5.}} Battler can ask for the date of Kinzo's alleged death and compare Natsuhi's entry against that of a more "sane" person (say, Nanjo's records) and ''voila'', confirmation. {{color|purple|This is}} {{color|grey|(1)one of many possible ways|(2)the only possible way}} {{color|purple| for Battler to confirm Kinzo's death.}} It has been stated that Gold needs a check for absolute validity. Furthermore, anything said in Gold can be said in Red, but not always vice versa. Finally, {{color|red|Kinzo has been stated in Red to have already died before the events of October 4 and 5, 1986}}, therefore, {{color|purple|Battler}} {{color|grey|(1)can|(2)must}} {{color|purple|use that as well to confirm that the corpse is Kinzo's.}} Counter that, if you can! You can't, can you? ''[[
****** {{color|red|Knox's 8th. It is forbidden for the case to be resolved with clues that are not presented.}} Where was it stated that Gold needs a check for absolute validity and/or that all Gold statements can be said in red, but not (always) vice versa?
******* (Respondent here.) Mmm. Well played. It's stated on this wiki's Main Page for ''Umineko'', which, upon consideration, stirs a question of my own. Where the hell did '''they''' get it from? Anyone up for some snooping? In the meantime, I demoted the statements in question until they have some support from the series itself. {{color|red|Valid support can come from either of the three versions of the story so far. The '''games''' or either the '''manga''' or the '''anime''' should either one ever get to where the Golden Truth is explained.}}
| |||