All The Tropes

Uncanny Valley: Difference between revisions

Page Discussion

Uncanny Valley (view source)

Revision as of 07:32, 18 November 2021

1,683 bytes removed ,  2 years ago
adding quote, moving quote.
VisualWikitext
m (Remove useless categories)
(adding quote, moving quote.)
 
(13 intermediate revisions by 7 users not shown)
Line 1:
{{trope}}
<div style="float:right; margin-left:5px; margin-bottom:3px; padding:0px; border:1px solid #ffffff; font-size:100%; line-height:120%; padding:0.4em; background-color:#eeeeee; border-bottom:1px solid #ffffff"><youtube width="480">CNdAIPoh8a4</youtube></div>
[[File:UncannyValleyChart.jpg|frame]]
{{quote|the girl is just human enough to make every nonhuman part that much more disturbing.| Jelisaveta POV|[[Vigor Mortis]]}}
 
{{quote|''"If you see something that... looks human and isn't, you keep your eyes on it and you feel for your hatchet."''|'''[[Talking Animal|Mr. Beaver]]''', ''[[The Chronicles of Narnia|The Lion, the Witch, and the Wardrobe]]''}}
 
Japanese roboticist Masahiro Mori stated in 1970 that the more human a robot acted or looked, the more endearing it would be to a human being. For example, most lovable [[Robot Buddy|Robot Buddies]] look humanoid, but keep quirky and artistically mechanical affectations. However, at some point, the likeness would seem ''too'' strong, and it would just come across as a very strange human being. At this point, the acceptance drops suddenly, changing to a powerful negative reaction.
 
When shown as a graph (like in the onevideo to the right), the acceptance on the Y axis and increasing X approaching human normal, there is a slow rise, then a sudden drop, then a sudden peak as "human normal" is reached. Masahiro Mori referred to this as the "uncanny valley". [http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OzxBpz7Xjl0 This video explains it extremely well.]
 
Thus, things that look somewhat human, but are clearly not -- suchnot—such as C-3PO (in ''[[Star Wars]]'') or a [[Golem]] -- produce—produce an accepting reaction, while things that are very nearly human, but just a little strange -- suchstrange—such as a [[Creepy Doll|child's doll]], a [[Demonic Dummy|ventriloquist's dummy]], or [[Monster Clown|a clown]] -- produce—produce a negative response. For some reason the resonance is stronger with a ''moving'' object, which is why a corpse is creepy but a moving corpse is creepier still. In fact, some say the very lowest point of the valley is [[Our Zombies Are Different|the zombie]]; though others say that zombies are merely another monster, and that [[Marionette Motion|slightly]]-not-[[Not Himself|right]] [[Invasion of the Body Snatchers|Pod People]], for instance, are closer to the nadir.
 
This might explain why we like [[Ridiculously -Human Robots]], even if they don't make a lot of intuitive sense. They are just far enough out of the Uncanny Valley not to bother us.
 
This idea has recently been applied to CG effects. While it's become very easy for programs to simulate textures and skin tones, convincing movement and facial expressions aren't always as simple. This can produce an effect where the character comes off as a zombie, if a production company is going for a purely realistic human look.
Line 16 ⟶ 15:
Similarly, many cartoons nowadays prefer a simultaneously stylized yet simplified character design, versus the realistic look amongst some older cartoons. In the latter, it's more obvious the budget just didn't allow characters to move much. Heavily rotoscoped characters also often seem less real than more stylized animated characters, especially when they're in the same production. See the Fleischer Studios version of ''Gulliver's Travels'' for an example.
 
[[Your Mileage May Vary]] though - some people actually don't think things in this page are that uncanny. Sometimes they just say it's more of an art problem. Sometimes though, some people can actually find stuff like unrealistic facial expressions or disturbing movements with a ragdoll model to be ''funny''. Some actually find [[Furry Fandom|specific cases]] of it erotic. And some simply find the effect cool and part of the entertainment of the film or TV show and don't let any "moving corpse" issues affect their enjoyment.▼
This also happens in video games, especially western ones, because the audience in the western world tends to demand photorealistic graphics for their games, while scorning many of the stylized games of the east, which still do use sprite-based games, although there are some eastern 3D games that enter the valley with too detailed graphics as well. (You'll be ''very'' hard-pressed to find a western studio that's ''not'' Indie or developing for handheld systems that still uses sprites. They're even rarer than studios that use stylized graphics, although some do get a free pass, like Valve and ''[[Team Fortress 2 (Video Game)|Team Fortress 2]]''.) But this is also extremely indicative of a huge generation gap, where 2D was the ONLY type of video game for two decades, and video games only went from niche to mainstream after 3D was implemented and became a standard, for a multitude of reasons. So sometimes you will get people who have been playing video games for decades missing 2D graphics, the [[Nostalgia Filter]] in effect, or thinking [[They Changed It Now It Sucks|a series that started in 2D graphics feels very wrong to them when switching to 3D graphics]], creating a total Uncanny Valley.
 
Compare [[Reality Is Unrealistic]], where the poor impression comes less from being 'creepy' as from breaking [[The Coconut Effect|existing conventions which audiences had come to expect]]. See also [[Off -Model]], [[Bishonen Line]], [[No Flow in CGI]], and [[Ugly Cute]]. And while you're at it, see [[What Measure Is a Non -Cute?]] as the scientific study of that trope gave birth to this one. Opposites are [[Eldritch Abomination]], where the unsettling effect is caused by being way too unfamiliar rather than being way too human, yet still produces the same abominable effect (although the two can overlap as a [[Humanoid Abomination]]), and [[Humans Are Cthulhu]], where ''we'' are the Uncanny Valley.▼
▲[[Your Mileage May Vary]] though - some people actually don't think things in this page are that uncanny. Sometimes they just say it's more of an art problem. Sometimes though, some people can actually find stuff like unrealistic facial expressions or disturbing movements with a ragdoll model to be ''funny''. Some actually find [[Furry Fandom|specific cases]] of it erotic. And some simply find the effect cool and part of the entertainment of the film or TV show and don't let any "moving corpse" issues affect their enjoyment.
 
You'll notice that most the examples below have to do with inadvertently entering the Valley. This trope can also be used to ''[[They Plotted a Perfectly Good Waste|purposely]]'' make something creepy, where creepiness is called for. ThreeCommon cases of such example are: the masks worn by [[Malevolent Masked Men]], [[Creepy Long Fingers]], [[Eyeless Face]] and [[Uncanny Valley Makeup]]. [[The Doll Episode]] uses this purposely as well with too (un-)lifelike dolls. Compare [[Uncanny Atmosphere]].▼
▲Compare [[Reality Is Unrealistic]], where the poor impression comes less from being 'creepy' as from breaking [[The Coconut Effect|existing conventions which audiences had come to expect]]. See also [[Off Model]], [[Bishonen Line]], [[No Flow in CGI]], and [[Ugly Cute]]. And while you're at it, see [[What Measure Is a Non Cute]] as the scientific study of that trope gave birth to this one. Opposites are [[Eldritch Abomination]], where the unsettling effect is caused by being way too unfamiliar rather than being way too human, yet still produces the same abominable effect (although the two can overlap as a [[Humanoid Abomination]]), and [[Humans Are Cthulhu]], where ''we'' are the Uncanny Valley.
 
{{Examples on subpages}}
▲You'll notice that most the examples below have to do with inadvertently entering the Valley. This trope can also be used to ''[[They Plotted a Perfectly Good Waste|purposely]]'' make something creepy, where creepiness is called for. Three such example are the masks worn by [[Malevolent Masked Men]], [[Creepy Long Fingers]] and [[Uncanny Valley Makeup]]. [[The Doll Episode]] uses this purposely as well with too (un-)lifelike dolls.
{{examples|Examples}}
* [[Uncanny Valley/Advertising|Advertising]]
* [[Uncanny Valley/Anime and Manga|Anime and Manga]]
* [[Uncanny Valley/Comics|Comics]]
* [[Uncanny Valley/Fan Works|Fan Works]]
* [[Uncanny Valley/Film|Film]]
* [[Uncanny Valley/Literature|Literature]]
* [[Uncanny Valley/Live Action TV|Live Action TV]]
* [[Uncanny Valley/Music|Music]]
* [[Uncanny Valley/Radio|Radio]]
* [[Uncanny Valley/Tabletop Games|Tabletop Games]]
* [[Uncanny Valley/Toys|Toys]]
* [[Uncanny Valley/Video Games|Video Games]]
* [[Uncanny Valley/Webcomics|Webcomics]]
* [[Uncanny Valley/Web Original|Web Original]]
* [[Uncanny Valley/Western Animation|Western Animation]]
* [[Uncanny Valley/Other|Other]]
 
{{reflist}}
{{Sliding Scale of Anthropomorphism}}
[[Category:Trope{{PAGENAME}}]]▼
[[Category:Otherness Tropes]]
[[Category:Audience Reactions]]
Line 47 ⟶ 31:
[[Category:The Index Is Watching You]]
[[Category:Horror Tropes]]
[[Category:Uncanny Valley]]
▲[[Category:Trope]]
Retrieved from "https://allthetropes.org/wiki/Special:MobileDiff/476175...1941104"