Wanton Cruelty to the Common Comma: Difference between revisions

quote cleanup
(quote cleanup)
Line 134:
** As a corollary, when you paragraph-break a monologue, you ''always'' omit the end-paragraph quotation marks for all but the last paragraph of the monologue; doing so lets the readers know the paragraphs are still being spoken by the person doing the monologue, and not by anyone else, or is a non-speaking paragraph.
** "As a second corollary, remember that dialogue tags are never capitalized." Said Bob. "Do you mean that I should keep them lower case even when I end a sentence with a question mark?" Asked Alice. "Yes." Said Bob. "You should also keep in mind that if the sentence would normally end with a period, the period should be replaced with a comma-- but only if the period comes ''before'' the dialogue tag,"
** "Fourth of all," continued Bob, "the speaker and his/her actions belong in the same paragraph."<br />"Why is that, Bob?" asked Alice.<br />"Because otherwise, the readers could get confused and mistake who is speaking." Alice persisted.<br />"But shouldn't quotes begin a paragraph?" Bob shook his head.<br />"Not necessarily." Alice shrugged.
** As mentioned above, it's possible to break rules if you really know what you're doing. The new-paragraph-for-new-speaker rule is one of the ones you see broken most frequently: one character says something, and the description of other characters' reaction include dialogue. Because a paragraph break would kill the flow, the rule is discarded and one kind of readability trumps another.
* And in a similar vein, there's the Block Paragraph Of Doom, where the writer fails to break up the story into paragraphs at all. Not bad in a drabble, but tedious to the point of tl;dr in a multi-chapter fic.