Warts and All: Difference between revisions

no edit summary
m (revise quote template spacing)
No edit summary
 
(6 intermediate revisions by 3 users not shown)
Line 2:
{{quote|'''Delenn''': ''If you go, you will learn things about me that may change your opinion of me.''
'''Lennier''': ''Delenn, I have pledged myself to your side...come fire or storm or darkness or death. Can understanding be a greater danger?''
'''Delenn''': ''In this case...yes.'' |'''[[Babylon 5]]''': ''Atonement''}}
|'''[[Babylon 5]]''': ''Atonement''}}
 
The heroes need the help of a legendary figure who, over the years, [[Shrouded in Myth|has been idolized]] as the paragon of virtue, the source of all that is good and just, a true example for schoolchildren everywhere. The legend has beaten back all enemies, saved the day hundreds of times, and is truly a [[Knight in Shining Armor]] worth looking up to.
Line 14 ⟶ 15:
The trope name comes from [[Oliver Cromwell]] (1599-1658), who, in an attempt to avoid this trope, once told an artist to paint a portrait of him "warts and all". Official portraits were commonly done with the flaws in a person's appearance "corrected" by the artist. Cromwell wanted his picture to include his imperfections. Similarly, this trope is about the legendary character being finally seen for who and what he is, flaws and all.
 
Usually, this trope involves the lead characters convincing the legend that he must rise above his weaknesses and become the true [[Knight in Shining Armor|shining example]] that they thought he was. A more [[Bittersweet Ending]] is possible if one of the leads gets caught up in the hero-worship and refuses to see through the foibles to the human being inside. Or worse, if they only realize the legend is human after a [[Heroic Sacrifice]]; if only the reader realizes it and the characters all refuse to, this trope can reach [[Tragic Hero]] heights.
 
[[An Aesop]] about expecting the [[Knight in Shining Armor]] is possible. Contrast [[Feet of Clay]] or [[No Hero to His Valet]], where the "legendary hero" is anything but. Similar to [[Broken Pedestal]], but there the characters have a rational grounds for thinking the legend is better than he is because they knew him when he ''was'' better. Inverse of [[Hero with Bad Publicity]]. A [[Historical Downgrade]] is doing this to a historical figure.
Line 29 ⟶ 30:
 
 
== ComicbooksComic Books ==
* In ''[[Astro City]]'', Altar Boy learns that his mentor, the Confessor {{spoiler|is a vampire -- and Confessor refused to declare he had not killed people as a vampire. However, his Heroic Sacrifice not only won over Altar Boy, it inspired him to take up the mantle}}.
** Also in ''[[Astro City]]'', an alien is put off by Crackerjack's arrogance, boasting, and foolishness, but follows him for a night and is almost persuaded not to send his race information they need to invade; he does it not because Crackerjack is less than a hero but because [[Gossipy Hens|other humans]] displease him.
Line 49 ⟶ 50:
* [[Peter Jackson]]'s 2005 version of ''[[King Kong]]'' has a good one. After Ann Darrow (Naomi Watts) is taken away by Kong, the crew goes off to rescue her, but about half way (after a run in with some Raptors) Bruce Baxter, the intended star of Carl Denham's (Jack Black) film, decides to turn tail much to the disappointment of Adrian Brody's character. "I always knew you weren't the tough guy you played in the movies, Baxter, I just never figured you for a coward". Later on though, as Jack, Carl, and the rest are about to be killed, Baxter returns with the crew for a [[Big Damn Heroes]] moment and gets to be the action hero he always pretended to be.
* The all powerful ''[[Wizard of Oz]]'' turns out to be {{spoiler|nothing more than a [[Snake Oil Salesman]]. His confidence trickster skills do, however, eventually save the day.}}
* In ''[[Legend of the Guardians: theThe Owls of ga Ga'Hoole]]'', Soren finds out that the ragged, one-eyed, rather cynical old owl Ezylryb is actually {{spoiler|his hero, the legendary Lyze of Kiel}}.
{{quote|'''{{spoiler|Lyze}}:''' Fancy it must be hard, meeting your hero and seeing that he's real and not a myth.
'''Soren:''' You're just not--
Line 60 ⟶ 61:
** Thanks to the unreliable narration from Cain's viewpoint, there's no way to be sure how much of Cain's heroism is really fake. Certainly, his handwaving to explain the selfish, cowardly reasons why he performed seemingly heroic acts looks rather thin at points.
** Assuming Cain is telling the truth about what he does, he's often actively trying to avoid danger and yet somehow ends up in it, so you can agree with his self-depreciation. On the other hand, more of the time he actively puts himself in harm's way even when there are numerous moments he could have quietly slipped away with no one the wiser and no harm to his reputation.
* In Mitchel Scanlon's ''[[Warhammer 4000040,000]]'' [[Horus Heresy]] novel ''Descent of Angels'', Zahariel's first glimpse of Brother Amadis disappoints him: merely a man, not a figure like Lion. But the longer he looks at him, the more he understands his character and heroism.
* In [[Rick Riordan]]'s ''[[Percy Jackson and The Olympians|The Battle for the Labyrinth]]'', they meet up with Briares, the Hundred-Handed One, and find him demoralized and unwilling to fight, much to Tyson's distress. In the end, however, he does join in the final battle.
* In [[Poul Anderson]]'s ''Virgin Planet'', the somewhat callow hero lands on a [[Lady Land|planet inhabited solely by women]] -- and—and women [[Shrouded in Myth|whose myths recount the days where there were men, wonderful and marvellous beings]]. Meeting with a real, merely human man leads them to rapidly conclude that he's really an alien, not being wonderful and marvellous enough. Dealing with him, however, brings various women to realize that he really is a man. (Not at all hurt by his [[Character Development]], all the way up to offering to make a [[Heroic Sacrifice]] at the climax.)
* In [[Piers Anthony]]'s ''[[Xanth]]'', when the Gorgon asked Good Magician Humphrey to marry her, he set the same condition as anyone else who wanted an answer from him: she had to work for him for a year. When Dor discovers this, Humphrey explains that he feared this trope, because the Gorgon had thought herself in love after he cast the spell to keep her from turning people to stone. Working as his housekeeper for a year would ensure that she knew of all his little quirks and annoying traits before she married him -- ifhim—if she married him. A little later, the Gorgon explains to Dor that she had worked this out, and [[Single Woman Seeks Good Man|it is exactly what convinced her that he was the right man]].
* In [[Terry Pratchett]]'s ''[[Discworld/Unseen Academicals|Unseen Academicals]]'', Trev was bitter about his dead father. Nutt pointed out that his father had been only human, not a god; a good father; and, if perhaps a [[Fearless Fool]] who had gotten himself killed, yet people who had risked their lives had been important to the human race -- anrace—an insight which profoundly moves Trev.
** Discworld also references the [[Trope Namer]] in ''[[Discworld/Feet of Clay (novel)|Feet of Clay]]'' when "Old Stoneface" Vimes, a [[Captain Ersatz]] of Cromwell, is persistently described as having 'warts and all' by historical romantics who essentially use this as their justification for considering him the bad guy (King Lorenzo, on the other side, was a [[Complete Monster]] who was "extremely fond of children" ''but he looked the part'').
* The Wizard in ''[[Wizard of Oz]]'', aka the Great and Powerful Oz. {{spoiler|Less so in the book, where he is portrayed as a kindly old man who has simply gone astray in his balloon, as in the 1939 film, where he is shown as a ''[[Snake Oil Salesman]]''.}}
 
 
== Live-Action TV ==
Line 74:
* In ''[[Star Trek: Deep Space Nine]]'', Dahar Master Kor is a legendary warrior that everyone gushes over. But he is really old and becoming more and more senile as time goes on. His legendary status gets stripped away when he starts reliving a battle from his glory days which gets a lot of his people unnecessarily killed. Shown for the senile old man that he was, the crew rejects him. But he redeems himself when he undertakes a suicide mission and shows that he still has the skills that made him the legendary figure in the first place.
* In the ''[[Doctor Who]]'' episode "Father's Day", Rose meets up with her dead father, whom she knows only from her mother's stories. He proves to be up to his neck in get-rich-quick schemes and he and her mother quarrel almost continuously. However, in the end, her father makes a [[Heroic Sacrifice]] to save the universe. Rose's voice-over at the beginning and end of the episode are both about her father, but the concluding one is full of new insight.
* Textbook demonstrated in an episode of ''[[M*A*S*H (television)|Mash]]''. Hawkeye's nightly habits catch up to him, and a hangover prevents him from finishing surgery on a patient. Radar, laid up due to an earlier injury, chastises Hawkeye for his failure, which results in his hero angrily yelling at him. After much discussion (and literally everyone in camp chewing out Hawkeye for his lost temper, Hawkeye included) Radar reaches the conclusion that he was human all along, and that seeing him off the pedestal, he might be able to like him more as a person than an idol.
* Occurs in the ''[[Babylon 5]]'' episode "Atonement". Delenn warns Lennier to stay on Babylon 5 when she goes to face the clan council, lest he find out about her biggest wart. He refuses because of his [[Undying Loyalty]]. When he finds out what it is - that she had cast the deciding vote for the Earth-Minbari war - Lennier tells her that he ''still'' has [[Undying Loyalty]] for her.
** This, by the way, was despite the fact that Lennier had had family aboard the Black Star. He never held a grudge, either against Sheridan (who destroyed it) or Delenn (when he found out she had ordered it into danger in the first place). Lennier doesn't seem to have gone in for grudges.
 
== Video Games ==
 
== Videogames ==
* Guybrush ends up one of these in the eyes of [[Fan Girl]] Morgan Le Flay in the third episode of ''[[Tales of Monkey Island]]'', though this is a big case of [[Wrong Genre Savvy]] on her part. She built up such an expectation of him as an unparalleled swashbuckler and unstoppable [[Pirate]] that she never realized he was the protagonist of a comedic puzzle-adventure game.
* Two examples from ''[[Metal Gear Solid]]:''
Line 86 ⟶ 85:
** The second, Big Boss. Though he ended up being a traitor, that little fact was apparently concealed by the government, as by the time of the fourth game he's a household name as the ultimate soldier and his awesome-ness is apparently common knowledge. Numerous [[Hollywood Style|and highly inaccurate]] [[Take That|video games]] and [[Dan Browned|poorly researched books]] have been made out of his career. What nobody realizes is that he was a mentally damaged man who had to [[Shoot the Dog|shoot his own mentor on the orders of his government]] who was convinced that [[Utopia Justifies the Means|utopia for soldiers is worth nuking people with giant bipedal tanks.]]
 
== Web Comics ==
 
== Webcomics ==
* Rose of all people in ''[[Homestuck]]'', from {{spoiler|Kanaya's}} point of view.
 
 
== Western Animation ==
* Played with in the first episode of ''[[Batman: The Brave And The Bold|Batman the Brave And The Bold]]'': [[Batman]] and the [[Blue Beetle]] (Jaime Reyes) end up on a distant alien planet that reveres the Beetle (actually, a previous owner of the scarab) as their savior. Like the ''[[Firefly]]'' example, Jaime tries to convince the aliens that he's no savior and that [[Holding Out for a Hero|they should stand on their own two feet]], but it fails... until the climax of the episode, of course.
* In ''[[Hey Arnold!]]'', Eugene is disillusioned when he learns that his idol is a foul tempered hypocrite. However, he's also a good person as demonstrated when he selflessly saves Eugene and Arnold from untimely deaths.
* On ''[[Daria]],'' an old sports hero comes to Lawndale High for a dedication, and everybody has to put up with what a [[Jerk Jock]] he is. The discrepancy between his honored status and caustic personality becomes even more difficult when {{spoiler|he dies in an accident, evoking sympathy and [[Never Speak Ill of the Dead]]}}.
* ''[[Beast Wars]]'': [[Invoked Trope]] by Dinobot via his {{spoiler|[[Last Words]]}}:
{{quote|"Tell my tale to those who ask. Tell it truly, the ill deeds along with the good, and let me be judged accordingly. The rest... is silence."}}
 
{{reflist}}
[[Category:Warts and All{{PAGENAME}}]]
[[Category:Drama Tropes]]
[[Category:Morality Tropes]]
Line 104 ⟶ 102:
[[Category:Hero Tropes]]
[[Category:Infauxmation Desk]]
[[Category:Warts and All]]