"Join the Army," They Said: Difference between revisions

Content added Content deleted
m (update links)
m (revise quote template spacing)
Line 3: Line 3:




{{quote|''We joined the Navy''<br />
{{quote|''We joined the Navy''
''To see the world''<br />
''To see the world''
''And what did we see?''<br />
''And what did we see?''
''We saw the sea''|"We Saw the Sea", [[Irving Berlin]]}}
''We saw the sea''|"We Saw the Sea", [[Irving Berlin]]}}


Line 83: Line 83:
* The recently professionalised [[Poles With Poleaxes|Polish military]] cooked up [http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aEtezMDu5l0 this ad]. It speaks of improving yourself, honour, comradeship and that a soldier won't have unemployment problems.
* The recently professionalised [[Poles With Poleaxes|Polish military]] cooked up [http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aEtezMDu5l0 this ad]. It speaks of improving yourself, honour, comradeship and that a soldier won't have unemployment problems.
* Modern French Land Army ads subvert it, instead asking:
* Modern French Land Army ads subvert it, instead asking:
{{quote| Would you risk your life for someone you don't even know? ''([[Beat]])'' We do.}}
{{quote|Would you risk your life for someone you don't even know? ''([[Beat]])'' We do.}}
** Granted, those are a little old now. The new slogan is "Become yourself".
** Granted, those are a little old now. The new slogan is "Become yourself".
* Several years back there was a slew of "combined armed forces" recruitment ads for the US military, with the slogan "Army, Navy, Airforce, Marines, what a great place to start!". The message of which was apparently, "We don't care which service you join, just join one." In these commercials, the soldiers were seen driving tanks and shooting rifles and running through the woods, the airmen were seen flying (or repairing) jets, the sailors were working with electronics onboard ships, and the marines... were standing in formation, looking pretty in their full dress blues, including sabres, and basically doing a whole lot of nothing. Many active duty service members in the Army, Airforce, and Navy found this ''hilarious''.
* Several years back there was a slew of "combined armed forces" recruitment ads for the US military, with the slogan "Army, Navy, Airforce, Marines, what a great place to start!". The message of which was apparently, "We don't care which service you join, just join one." In these commercials, the soldiers were seen driving tanks and shooting rifles and running through the woods, the airmen were seen flying (or repairing) jets, the sailors were working with electronics onboard ships, and the marines... were standing in formation, looking pretty in their full dress blues, including sabres, and basically doing a whole lot of nothing. Many active duty service members in the Army, Airforce, and Navy found this ''hilarious''.
Line 91: Line 91:
* ''[[Private Benjamin]]'' has Judy Benjamin joining the Army thinking it is all travel and fun, like the adverts (an image reinforced by an unscrupulous recruiter).
* ''[[Private Benjamin]]'' has Judy Benjamin joining the Army thinking it is all travel and fun, like the adverts (an image reinforced by an unscrupulous recruiter).
* The film version of ''[[Starship Troopers (film)|Starship Troopers]]'' is actually intended to represent a recruitment video at many points.
* The film version of ''[[Starship Troopers (film)|Starship Troopers]]'' is actually intended to represent a recruitment video at many points.
{{quote| "Would you like to know more?"}}
{{quote|"Would you like to know more?"}}
** It should be noted that the fake interface includes 'Join' as one of the options.
** It should be noted that the fake interface includes 'Join' as one of the options.
* In ''[[Stripes]]'', the recruits ironically sing the Reagan-era "Pick a service, pick a challenge" recruiting jingle as they wearily trudge back to the barracks after a long march.
* In ''[[Stripes]]'', the recruits ironically sing the Reagan-era "Pick a service, pick a challenge" recruiting jingle as they wearily trudge back to the barracks after a long march.
Line 99: Line 99:
** He then promptly sings "Be all that you can be" before [[The Captain]] yells at him that it's the ''Army'' recruitment song.
** He then promptly sings "Be all that you can be" before [[The Captain]] yells at him that it's the ''Army'' recruitment song.
* While it isn't a military-themed movie, the first ''[[Mortal Kombat]]'' film contains an example that definitely fits the spirit of the first version of this trope. When Johnny Cage starts learning just how strange and unusual Shang Tsung's tournament is, he says the following:
* While it isn't a military-themed movie, the first ''[[Mortal Kombat]]'' film contains an example that definitely fits the spirit of the first version of this trope. When Johnny Cage starts learning just how strange and unusual Shang Tsung's tournament is, he says the following:
{{quote| '''Johnny Cage''': "Come to a little tournament", he said. "(It'll) Be good for the career", he said. Yeah, right.}}
{{quote|'''Johnny Cage''': "Come to a little tournament", he said. "(It'll) Be good for the career", he said. Yeah, right.}}
* ''[[Muppet Treasure Island]]'' has [[Statler and Waldorf]] as the figurehead of the Hispaniola, with the following conversation:
* ''[[Muppet Treasure Island]]'' has [[Statler and Waldorf]] as the figurehead of the Hispaniola, with the following conversation:
{{quote| '''Statler''': "Take a cruise," you said. "See the world," you said. Now here we are stuck on the front of this stupid ship.<br />
{{quote|'''Statler''': "Take a cruise," you said. "See the world," you said. Now here we are stuck on the front of this stupid ship.
'''Waldorf''': Well it could be worse. We could be stuck in the audience!<br />
'''Waldorf''': Well it could be worse. We could be stuck in the audience!
'''Both''': Do-ho-ho-ho-hoh! }}
'''Both''': Do-ho-ho-ho-hoh! }}


Line 115: Line 115:
* In [[Sandy Mitchell]]'s [[Warhammer 40000]] novel ''Scourge The Heretic'', two new Imperial Guardsmen are introduced on guard and grumbling, "Join the Guard and see the galaxy."
* In [[Sandy Mitchell]]'s [[Warhammer 40000]] novel ''Scourge The Heretic'', two new Imperial Guardsmen are introduced on guard and grumbling, "Join the Guard and see the galaxy."
* [[Hand of Thrawn|Shada Du'kal]], high-quality bodyguard and commando (the two go hand-in-hand in Star Wars), while climbing a filthy wall to get in position to cover her employer for a transaction with someone.
* [[Hand of Thrawn|Shada Du'kal]], high-quality bodyguard and commando (the two go hand-in-hand in Star Wars), while climbing a filthy wall to get in position to cover her employer for a transaction with someone.
{{quote| ''Join a smuggling group,'' she thought darkly for about the fifth time since beginning her climb. ''Visit a side of the galaxy the tourists never see.''}}
{{quote|''Join a smuggling group,'' she thought darkly for about the fifth time since beginning her climb. ''Visit a side of the galaxy the tourists never see.''}}
* In ''[[Old Mans War]]'', Colonial Defense Force recruits aren't even told what they're going to be fighting, all they know is that the CDF can probably restore their youth (recruitment age is 75).
* In ''[[Old Mans War]]'', Colonial Defense Force recruits aren't even told what they're going to be fighting, all they know is that the CDF can probably restore their youth (recruitment age is 75).
* Played straight for both comedy and drama in a later book from the ''[[Phule's Company]]''. Much of the book follows a recruit [[New Meat|fresh out of boot camp]], whose only previous knowledge of the Space Legion (which has a reputation for being a [[Legion of Lost Souls]] and [[Army of Thieves and Whores]], at least in the earlier books) comes from a poster that follows this trope.
* Played straight for both comedy and drama in a later book from the ''[[Phule's Company]]''. Much of the book follows a recruit [[New Meat|fresh out of boot camp]], whose only previous knowledge of the Space Legion (which has a reputation for being a [[Legion of Lost Souls]] and [[Army of Thieves and Whores]], at least in the earlier books) comes from a poster that follows this trope.
* In Edgar Lee Masters "Spoon River Anthology" is the story of Knowlt Hoheimer who wishes he had "staid at home" and gone to jail for stealing hogs rather than running away to join the army only to be killed in battle:
* In Edgar Lee Masters "Spoon River Anthology" is the story of Knowlt Hoheimer who wishes he had "staid at home" and gone to jail for stealing hogs rather than running away to join the army only to be killed in battle:
{{quote| Rather a thousand times the country jail<br />
{{quote|Rather a thousand times the country jail
Than to lie under this marble figure with wings,<br />
Than to lie under this marble figure with wings,
And this granite pedestal }}
And this granite pedestal }}


Line 126: Line 126:
* ''[[Monty Python's Flying Circus]]'' has a sketch featuring a soldier who has seen too many of the glamourised ads. "I joined the army for the water skiing and the travel, Colonel. Not for the killing."
* ''[[Monty Python's Flying Circus]]'' has a sketch featuring a soldier who has seen too many of the glamourised ads. "I joined the army for the water skiing and the travel, Colonel. Not for the killing."
** "This is obviously making fun of our slogan, 'it's a dog's life -- man's life in the Army!"
** "This is obviously making fun of our slogan, 'it's a dog's life -- man's life in the Army!"
{{quote| Its a man's life in the British Dental Association!}}
{{quote|Its a man's life in the British Dental Association!}}
* As noted above, "Be all you can be" was an Army slogan. ''[[Buffy the Vampire Slayer]]'' crossed its wires when Riley Finn (apparently a Special Forces soldier) said, referring to demon-hunting, "It's not just a job--" Buffy interrupted: "Right, it's an adventure." He doesn't deny he thinks that way. (They never say what branch of the military he was from. The Initiative is more along the lines of the FBI, CIA or NSA. It's an agency, not a part of the armed forces. Basically, it's the [[The Men in Black|Supernatural FBI/CIA/NSA]], {{spoiler|complete with torture, inhumane experiments and indefinite imprisonment}}.)
* As noted above, "Be all you can be" was an Army slogan. ''[[Buffy the Vampire Slayer]]'' crossed its wires when Riley Finn (apparently a Special Forces soldier) said, referring to demon-hunting, "It's not just a job--" Buffy interrupted: "Right, it's an adventure." He doesn't deny he thinks that way. (They never say what branch of the military he was from. The Initiative is more along the lines of the FBI, CIA or NSA. It's an agency, not a part of the armed forces. Basically, it's the [[The Men in Black|Supernatural FBI/CIA/NSA]], {{spoiler|complete with torture, inhumane experiments and indefinite imprisonment}}.)
* Complained about by minor ''[[MASH|M* A* S* H]]'' characters such as Rizzo, Zale, and Igor. Mocked by Hawkeye and Klinger. The joke's on them. They were drafted after all.
* Complained about by minor ''[[MASH|M* A* S* H]]'' characters such as Rizzo, Zale, and Igor. Mocked by Hawkeye and Klinger. The joke's on them. They were drafted after all.
Line 143: Line 143:
* Sgt. Smiles, marine recruiter. teach you to program computers. teach you all the skills you need. you can die with dignity
* Sgt. Smiles, marine recruiter. teach you to program computers. teach you all the skills you need. you can die with dignity
* [[Rise Against]]'s "Hero of War" features a pretty extremist version of the army. Just look up the lyrics.
* [[Rise Against]]'s "Hero of War" features a pretty extremist version of the army. Just look up the lyrics.
{{quote| ''He said, "Son,<br />
{{quote|''He said, "Son,
Have you seen the world?<br />
Have you seen the world?
Well, what would you say<br />
Well, what would you say
If I said that you could?<br />
If I said that you could?
Just carry this gun,<br />
Just carry this gun,
You'll even get paid."<br />
You'll even get paid."
I said, "[[Tempting Fate|That sounds pretty good]]."'' }}
I said, "[[Tempting Fate|That sounds pretty good]]."'' }}
* ''[[Disturbed]]'''s "Indestructible" seems to be about some sort of black ops soldier, who thanks to skill and equipment is seen as an unholy terror by his enemies. The song is intended as a sort of [[Theme Music Power-Up]] for the troops, since the band's style is popular among soldiers. As a band, they're "For the troops, against the war" (respect the sacrifice, hate on the cause of the sacrifice).
* ''[[Disturbed]]'''s "Indestructible" seems to be about some sort of black ops soldier, who thanks to skill and equipment is seen as an unholy terror by his enemies. The song is intended as a sort of [[Theme Music Power-Up]] for the troops, since the band's style is popular among soldiers. As a band, they're "For the troops, against the war" (respect the sacrifice, hate on the cause of the sacrifice).
Line 160: Line 160:
== [[Tabletop Games]] ==
== [[Tabletop Games]] ==
* The Imperial Guard of ''[[Warhammer 40000]]'' can - depending on the world the troops are from - be made up of all-volunteer forces with much propaganda and patriotism, fitting this trope to the letter. Never mind the daemons, soulless ghost-robots, giant bugs, and the other denizens of the setting they'll be sent to fight against...Although ''generally'', worlds that raise regiments from volunteers are more likely to provide competent soldiers than ones that press-gang conscripts.
* The Imperial Guard of ''[[Warhammer 40000]]'' can - depending on the world the troops are from - be made up of all-volunteer forces with much propaganda and patriotism, fitting this trope to the letter. Never mind the daemons, soulless ghost-robots, giant bugs, and the other denizens of the setting they'll be sent to fight against...Although ''generally'', worlds that raise regiments from volunteers are more likely to provide competent soldiers than ones that press-gang conscripts.
{{quote| "Join the Imperial Guard! Travel to fantastic new planets! Meet exotic new life forms! And then shoot them! Serve the Emperor today - tomorrow you may be dead!"}}
{{quote|"Join the Imperial Guard! Travel to fantastic new planets! Meet exotic new life forms! And then shoot them! Serve the Emperor today - tomorrow you may be dead!"}}
* The ''[[Magic: The Gathering]]'' card [http://gatherer.wizards.com/Pages/Card/Details.aspx?multiverseid=20396 Border Guard] parodies the "...and kill them" thing. "'Join the army, ''see foreign countries''!' they'd said."
* The ''[[Magic: The Gathering]]'' card [http://gatherer.wizards.com/Pages/Card/Details.aspx?multiverseid=20396 Border Guard] parodies the "...and kill them" thing. "'Join the army, ''see foreign countries''!' they'd said."
* The NEG in ''[[Cthulhu Tech]]''.
* The NEG in ''[[Cthulhu Tech]]''.
Line 180: Line 180:
* The [[Feelies]] from ''[[Crusader: No Remorse|Crusader]]: No Remorse'' included a newsletter that had an advertisement for joining "MilOps" (Military Operations Cartel), the assault arm of the [[Mega Corp|WEC's]] forces.
* The [[Feelies]] from ''[[Crusader: No Remorse|Crusader]]: No Remorse'' included a newsletter that had an advertisement for joining "MilOps" (Military Operations Cartel), the assault arm of the [[Mega Corp|WEC's]] forces.
* ''[[Ratchet and Clank Future Tools of Destruction]]'':
* ''[[Ratchet and Clank Future Tools of Destruction]]'':
{{quote| "Greeting, inferior beings of Polaris. Does you life lack a sense of purpose? Do you constantly worry about finding steady income? Do you enjoy killing stuff? Then join the imperial army and aid me on my humble quest for [[Galatic Conqueror|Galactic domination!]] Here, you'll travel to interesting places, meet interesting people, and execute them in the name of me."}}
{{quote|"Greeting, inferior beings of Polaris. Does you life lack a sense of purpose? Do you constantly worry about finding steady income? Do you enjoy killing stuff? Then join the imperial army and aid me on my humble quest for [[Galatic Conqueror|Galactic domination!]] Here, you'll travel to interesting places, meet interesting people, and execute them in the name of me."}}
** From the first one:
** From the first one:
{{quote| "I joined the army to get money to go to college, I didn't know I would end up in a war!"}}
{{quote|"I joined the army to get money to go to college, I didn't know I would end up in a war!"}}
* ''[[Killzone]] 2'''s [http://www.gametrailers.com/player/45960.html Making Of: Enemy Territory] trailer has the narrator use this in full [[Sarcasm Mode]];
* ''[[Killzone]] 2'''s [http://www.gametrailers.com/player/45960.html Making Of: Enemy Territory] trailer has the narrator use this in full [[Sarcasm Mode]];
{{quote| In and out, they said. A show of force, they said. The Helghast war machine was destroyed on Vekta, and you guys just need to sweep it up, ''they said''.}}
{{quote|In and out, they said. A show of force, they said. The Helghast war machine was destroyed on Vekta, and you guys just need to sweep it up, ''they said''.}}
* Arcade game ''Bad Dudes Vs. Dragon Ninja'' wants to know: are you a bad enough dude to <s>[http://hikkyz.net/void/img/badenoughdude.jpg hit your own dick with a hammer]</s> [http://farm4.static.flickr.com/3190/2855445750_7f7eacbb4c.jpg?v=0 rescue the president?]
* Arcade game ''Bad Dudes Vs. Dragon Ninja'' wants to know: are you a bad enough dude to <s>[http://hikkyz.net/void/img/badenoughdude.jpg hit your own dick with a hammer]</s> [http://farm4.static.flickr.com/3190/2855445750_7f7eacbb4c.jpg?v=0 rescue the president?]
* ''[[Mechwarrior]] 3: Pirate's Moon'' produced this sarcastic quip from lancemate Dominic Paine after a particularly tough mission: "Join the army, see the galaxy, what the hell was I thinking?!"
* ''[[Mechwarrior]] 3: Pirate's Moon'' produced this sarcastic quip from lancemate Dominic Paine after a particularly tough mission: "Join the army, see the galaxy, what the hell was I thinking?!"
Line 190: Line 190:
* Satirised in ''[[Metal Gear Solid]] 4'', which has fake military recruitment ads during the opening scene that are based on the style of real ones, exaggerated with tons of [[Deranged Animation|psychedelia]] and [[Values Dissonance]] until it ends up right in the [[Uncanny Valley]]. Notably, the ads, like real ads, repeatedly use video-game like imagery like [[First Person Perspective]] and unthinking, unbleeding, identical enemies - ''[[Metal Gear Solid]] 4'' is in some ways a comment on video games being used to recruit young people into fighting real wars.
* Satirised in ''[[Metal Gear Solid]] 4'', which has fake military recruitment ads during the opening scene that are based on the style of real ones, exaggerated with tons of [[Deranged Animation|psychedelia]] and [[Values Dissonance]] until it ends up right in the [[Uncanny Valley]]. Notably, the ads, like real ads, repeatedly use video-game like imagery like [[First Person Perspective]] and unthinking, unbleeding, identical enemies - ''[[Metal Gear Solid]] 4'' is in some ways a comment on video games being used to recruit young people into fighting real wars.
* In ''Bloodmoon'', the second expansion to ''[[The Elder Scrolls III: Morrowind]]'', the the legionnaires at Fort Frostmoth will occasionally mutter to themselves:
* In ''Bloodmoon'', the second expansion to ''[[The Elder Scrolls III: Morrowind]]'', the the legionnaires at Fort Frostmoth will occasionally mutter to themselves:
{{quote| ''""Join the Legion! See the world!" Freeze your arse..."''}}
{{quote|''""Join the Legion! See the world!" Freeze your arse..."''}}
* ''[[Grand Theft Auto San Andreas]]'' had '''Join The Military''' radio ads which by its very nature, a spoof of recruitment ads. see them [http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FSFQHtKGaE4 here].
* ''[[Grand Theft Auto San Andreas]]'' had '''Join The Military''' radio ads which by its very nature, a spoof of recruitment ads. see them [http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FSFQHtKGaE4 here].


Line 204: Line 204:
** Yet again as a background gag in an early "Treehouse of Horrors" episode. A recruiting poster on the wall advertises "Join the Army, and see the opposing army".
** Yet again as a background gag in an early "Treehouse of Horrors" episode. A recruiting poster on the wall advertises "Join the Army, and see the opposing army".
** And how was Homer convinced to join the Naval Reserve?
** And how was Homer convinced to join the Naval Reserve?
{{quote| "Daybreak, Jakarta. The proud men and women of the Navy are protecting America's interests overseas, but you're in Lubbock, Texas hosing down a statue, because you're in the Naval Reserve. Once you complete basic training, you only work one weekend a month, and most of that time you're drunk off your ass. The Naval Reserve: America's 17th line of defense, between the Mississippi National Guard, and the American League of Women Voters."}}
{{quote|"Daybreak, Jakarta. The proud men and women of the Navy are protecting America's interests overseas, but you're in Lubbock, Texas hosing down a statue, because you're in the Naval Reserve. Once you complete basic training, you only work one weekend a month, and most of that time you're drunk off your ass. The Naval Reserve: America's 17th line of defense, between the Mississippi National Guard, and the American League of Women Voters."}}
* The [[Walt Disney]] [[Wartime Cartoon]] ''Donald Gets Drafted'' begins with [[Donald Duck]] passing a series of ads about how glamorous life in the modern army has become, accompanied by a catchy jingle titled "The Army's Not the Army Anymore". Turns out the Army is ''still'' the Army.
* The [[Walt Disney]] [[Wartime Cartoon]] ''Donald Gets Drafted'' begins with [[Donald Duck]] passing a series of ads about how glamorous life in the modern army has become, accompanied by a catchy jingle titled "The Army's Not the Army Anymore". Turns out the Army is ''still'' the Army.
** However, why Donald, a water fowl, who normally wears a sailor suit, was not in the Navy or at least the Marines, makes no sense.
** However, why Donald, a water fowl, who normally wears a sailor suit, was not in the Navy or at least the Marines, makes no sense.
Line 211: Line 211:
* ''[[Family Guy]]'' has "Aaaww Yeah" and "Actual experience may differ".
* ''[[Family Guy]]'' has "Aaaww Yeah" and "Actual experience may differ".
* In ''[[Evil Con Carne]]'', Skarr rants against his mother and the military while crawling up a hill.
* In ''[[Evil Con Carne]]'', Skarr rants against his mother and the military while crawling up a hill.
{{quote| '''Skarr''': Join the military, my mother said! The military! Curse you mother! Curse you! Curse my luck!}}
{{quote|'''Skarr''': Join the military, my mother said! The military! Curse you mother! Curse you! Curse my luck!}}
* In an episode of ''[[Ned's Newt]]'', an army recruitment message looks more like a travel bureau ad, so much that the enthusiastic Newton ends up enlisting Ned into it without his knowledge.
* In an episode of ''[[Ned's Newt]]'', an army recruitment message looks more like a travel bureau ad, so much that the enthusiastic Newton ends up enlisting Ned into it without his knowledge.