A Form You Are Comfortable With: Difference between revisions

no edit summary
No edit summary
 
(12 intermediate revisions by 6 users not shown)
Line 3:
 
{{quote|'''Joan:''' ''Are you -- Are you being ''snippy'' with me? God is snippy.''
'''God:''' ''Let me explain something to you, Joan. It goes like this: I don't look like this. I don't look like anything you'd recognize. You can't see me. I don't sound like this, I don't sound like anything you'd recognize. You see, I'm beyond your experience. I take this form [[Trope Namer|because you're comfortable with it]], it makes sense to you. And if I'm "snippy", it's because you understand snippy.''|''[[Joan of Arcadia]]''}}
|''[[Joan of Arcadia]]''}}
 
Sometimes, when [[God]] or some other [[Reality Warper|vastly powerful]] or [[Eldritch Abomination|very strange]] [[Energy Being|Cosmic Entity]] needs to have a chat with a [[Puny Humans|mere human being]], they are aware that the meeting [[Go Mad from the Revelation|might be a little too overwhelming for the human to handle]]. Sometimes the nonhuman being isn't ''so'' powerful, but still has a [[The Masquerade|Masquerade]] to maintain. Or they fear having to deal with ''hours'' of questions and [[What Measure Is a Non-Human?|a great deal of prejudices]]. Humans tend to flip out when they see a dragon or learn that Fairies are real.
Line 53 ⟶ 54:
*** Likewise, the Chaos Lord called Shivering Jemmy of the Nightmare Brigade manifests as a three year old girl, complete with a balloon and a love of ice cream.
{{quote|'''Jemmy:''' Nobody ''clever'' bes boxes!}}
***:* The above two are amusing because they did this to come to a convocation of gods and other powerful supernatural entities in the Dream realm, and there was no one to set at ease; they apparently just find these forms appropriate.
**:* Gilbert, a rotund and helpful middle-aged man, was a manifestation of Fiddler's Green, an [[Genius Loci|intelligent place]] that inhabited the dream realm.
***:* Also, he looks very much like G. K. Chesterton. And talks like him.
**:* Cain And Abel also qualify. It's heavily implied in ''A Parliament of Rooks'' that they weren't the first ''Human'' murderer and victim, but in fact the first murderer and victim in the entire history of the universe and their true forms are actually [[Starfish Aliens]]. Also, they aren't really related to Eve, who may or may not have ever been a real person to begin with, let alone whether or not she was really Human.
**:* Invoked when Delirium actually mistakes a goth-dressed (lesbian) human for her sister Death in the beginning of ''Brief Lives''. (Of course, it's unlikely any of the other Endless would mistake a human for one of their own, but Delirium and reality are not always on speaking terms.)
**:* Lampshaded when Orpheus pays an unexpected visit to Death in ''Fables And Reflections'' catching her [[Perky Goth|dressed down.]] She changes her twentieth century apartment, complete with a teddy bear, a fish-bowl and discarded stockings followed by a t-shirt and jeans clad Death, and replaced it with stone columns, eternal gloom and Death in a black [[Gorgeous Period Dress]] and a veil.
*:* In the ''Lucifer'' comics God appeared to Elaine in the form of her loved ones at first, and when Elaine told him to be someone she didn't know chose to appear as an elderly British gentleman in a bowler hat. He appears content to stay in this form for the rest of the comic after that, something Lucifer comments upon.
*:* The "out of continuity but very much inspired" ''Murder Mysteries'' had God disguised as a strange wingless angel, which the protagonist comments had eyes that seemed to contain more than the others as one of the first hints to his real identity. Oddly enough, once revealed as being God himself he is never shown in panel, despite no evidence of any transformation taking place.
* The Martian Manhunter, [[Shape Shifter]] extraordinaire, avoids using his "true" martian appearance to avoid frightening people.
* [[Galactus]] and other [[Marvel Comics]] "higher plane of existence" beings look humanoid to us, but that's just our filter.
Line 66 ⟶ 67:
** Galactus, however, doesn't have such a temporary body. Instead, his own form looks different to different viewers; for instance, a Skrull sees him as Skrull-like. (Galactus's original form as a mortal being in the universe preceding our own, however, was indeed humanoid.)
*** One issue featured a scene where humans and dozens of aliens gazed upon him at once, the frame was filled with smaller images representing what each of them saw him as.
* Speaking of Skrulls, this is inverted by the cosmic [[Reality Warper]] the Shaper of Worlds, as the form he usually takes, a Skrull with silvery skin and a robotic lower body, is a form ''he'' is comfortable with, as he is an evolved form of a Cosmic Cube built by a Skrull and most of his owners before he evolved were also Skrulls.
* Inverted intentionally by [[Doctor Strange]] foe Shuma-Gorath, who invades dimensions in whatever form will terrify the inhabitants most. On Earth he appears as a single glaring eyeball surrounded by tentacles.
** Played straight with the Vishanti, who take vaguely human or animal visages to avoid [[You Cannot Grasp the True Form|terrifying their worshipers]].
Line 80 ⟶ 82:
* ''[[PS238]]'' has [http://ps238.nodwick.com/comic/01022012/ lords] of [[Order Versus Chaos|Order and Chaos]], and to somewhat lesser extent their minions.
 
== Fan FictionWorks ==
* In ''[[Aeon Natum Engel]]'', thanks to the ''[[Cthulhu Tech]]'' legacy, there are variable auto-censors that automatically render images (in real time) in ways that are deemed to be less harmful to the human psyche. The most common appears to make video look like [[Mythology Gag|something from an anime]].
* Some ''[[Naruto]]'' fanfiction show the various bijuu choosing to assume human forms in order to communicate with their containers. Whether the bijuu are more sociable or not varies from author to author, but the Kyuubi almost invariably ends up being [[Evil Redhead|a redheaded woman]] with a model's body.
Line 92 ⟶ 94:
“Yeah.” }}
* In ''[[The 10 Doctors]]'', {{spoiler|the Guardians}} say that their appearances change with the needs of their desired champions. In the story proper, they manifest as attractive humanoid women in order to toy with the Tenth Doctor's need for meaningful companionship, and in a flashback, {{spoiler|the White Guardian}} manifests to Davros as a military officer.
 
 
== Film ==
Line 135 ⟶ 136:
 
== Literature ==
* [[H.P. Lovecraft|HP Lovecraft]]'s Old Ones avert this trope, as they can't be concerned with whether their appearance causes puny human minds to [[Go Mad from the Revelation|shatter like glass]].
** Nyarlathotep, however, does hide in the ever-so-subtle form of... [[Refuge in Audacity|an Egyptian Pharaoh]]. He also likes to [[Mind Screw|fuck with people's heads]] by sticking to the bare minimum. The reason one of his masks is known as "the Black Man" isn't because it appears to have African features, but because its skin is ''pitch black.''
** Actually, he does not always appear dressed as a Pharaoh, in ''Nyarlathotep''; he is described only as a swarthy man "of the race of the Pharaohs" - from Lovecraft's letter: ''Nyarlathotep was a kind of itinerant showman or lecturer who held forth in public halls and aroused widespread fear and discussion with his exhibitions. These exhibitions consisted of two parts — first, a horrible — possibly prophetic — cinema reel; and later some extraordinary experiments with scientific and electrical apparatus. ''
Line 141 ⟶ 142:
*** So, [[The Sandman|Dream?]]
** The Mi-Go in "The Whisperer In Darkness" take a stab at this trope with the...materials they have at hand.
* Near the end of [[C. S. Lewis|CS Lewis]]' ''[[Perelandra]]'', two [[Our Angels Are Different|eldila]] attempt to find a suitable form to take when they meet the king and queen of Perelandra. Good thing, too, as their first two attempts wouldn't have worked at all.
** In particular, one of those forms is described as being a particular perception of the eldila in much the same way as suffering a concussion and seeing stars is a particular perception of a rock (i.e. one that has been thrown at your head).
* C.S. Lewis also explores the idea in an interesting way in ''[[The Chronicles of Narnia]]''. Aslan the talking lion isn't just a [[Crystal Dragon Jesus]], he actually ''is'' Jesus. Or rather, on Earth, among humans, he went by that name and form, while in the [[Talking Animal]] world of Narnia, he manifests as a fellow talking animal.
Line 154 ⟶ 155:
* Wheeler, an alien of some kind or other beyond human understanding in the books ''[[Signal To Noise]]'' and ''[[A Signal Shattered]]'', by Eric S. Nylund takes on a sort of human form. He takes on the form of the protagonist, Jack, except for perhaps some odd little differences such as the spinning gears in his eyes.
* Michael Scott Rohan's ''[[The Spiral Series]]'' does this twice to the protagonist. In ''[[Chase The Morning]]'' it's part of the [[Battle in the Center of the Mind]] with the [[Big Bad]], and in ''[[Cloud Castles]]'' it's his interaction with the [[Big Good]]. Both times it's presented as a business deal in his office, since that's how his brain could best handle what was happening.
* In ''[[Harry Potter/Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows (novel)|Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows]]'', after being "killed" by Voldemort, Harry finds himself in an [[Afterlife Antechamber]] that looks like King's Cross Station. Dumbledore, who meets him there, is a bit surprised by the description, but says it's what he can cope with. When Harry asks if he has to go back, Dumbledore extends the metaphor: he could, if he wished, metaphorically catch a train. "Where would it take me?" "On."
* Played with in a [[Judge Dredd]] spin-off novel, ''Wetworks'' by Dave Stone: An alien adopts the form of a certain famous cartoon character in an attempt to make the humans it deals with more comfortable; it doesn't really work, partly because seeing a cartoon character in the flesh is actually pretty discomforting, and partly because although the alien's shape has changed it neglected to do anything about the fact that it constantly emits a toxic gas.
* Subverted in ''[[Solaris]]'' by [[Stanisław Lem]], where a planet-sized alien intelligence spawns human replicants convincingly interacting with the protagonists, while the purpose of this phenomenon and the message, if any, behind it are a maddening enigma.
Line 188 ⟶ 189:
* [[Flatland]]: A Romance of Three Dimensions, features an interesting variation of this trope. As the Square passes through Lineland, the king of Lineland can only perceive the Square as another Line. When a Solid passes through the plane of Flatland, the Square can only perceive the Solid as another Shape.
 
== Live -Action TV ==
 
== Live Action TV ==
* This happened a lot in the various ''[[Star Trek]]'' series:
** The original ''[[Star Trek: The Original Series|Star Trek]]'' series featured Trelane ("The Squire of Gothos"), the Organians ("Errand of Mercy"), and the Metrons ("Arena"), all of whom took human form in order to interact with the mere mortals.
Line 232:
** This is immediately [[Lampshaded]] by Ray, who says "You're Santa Claus, not a [[Star Trek|Klingon]]."
* Done in the ''[[Animorphs (TV series)|Animorphs]]'' live action adaptation, where the Andalite Visser 3 takes the form of a human in order to make his enemies (humans who he thinks are Andalites) more comfortable. If you think that sounds like a poor excuse to cut corners on the show's special effects, congratulations, you're smarter than the [[Viewers are Morons|target demographic]].
* Seen in the 2000s reboot of ''[[Battlestar Galactica Reimagined(2004 TV series)|Battlestar Galactica]]'',; angels appear to characters throughout the series in the form of other characters. Notably Six to Baltar and vice versa, as well as an angel who looks like Leoben to Starbuck.
** Head-Leoben is the only one who confirms this though. Head-Six and Head-Baltar appear in these forms even when no one is around to see them. In fact, {{spoiler|Tyrol}} implies that the Final Five designed Cylon Model Six after the angel they saw, not vice-versa.
** Not to mention that incident where Head-Baltar appeared to Baltar. Baltar was everything ''but'' comfortable.
** The angelic-like ascended aliens (called Being's of Light)from the original series did this when they needed Apollo's help with a mercy mission. He got a sidekick that only he (and later Starbuck) could see called "John".
Line 239:
** He could create hallucinations of almost anyone, but it’s implied that he could only physically mimic a limited number of people. Every solid human shape he takes is of a dead person whose corpse is on the island ("Isabella" never physically interacts with Richard). This would explain why he took the form of Christian in front of characters for whom that form carried no significance; Christian was the most convenient non-threatening form that he had in his repertoire at the time.
* The Operators, Specialists, et. al. of ''[[Sapphire and Steel]]''. [[Shrug of God|Maybe.]]
* The Imagin in ''[[Kamen Rider Den-O]]'' have an intrestinginteresting take on this trope. They ALWAYS take a form their host has knowledge of, as their form is from their memories. While this normally more comfortable than taking with a random floating orb of yellow energy with no face, it's different in that it's not for the host's benefit but because the Imagin wants a physical form.
* Played straight in ''[[Odyssey 5]]'' when the chararacterscharacters meet a member of a race of [[Sufficiently Advanced Aliens]]:
{{quote|'''Sarah''': I guess i should've expected it.
'''Neil''': What?
Line 247:
'''Sarah''': How do you know that?
'''Kurt''': 300 hours of [[Star Trek]]. }}
 
 
== Newspaper Comics ==
Line 263 ⟶ 262:
* The ''Tao te Ching'' is an attempt to do this to the Tao, through a series of analogies.
* For the most part, the followers of [[Egyptian Mythology]] understood that the various forms ascribed to their various gods weren't supposed to be how the gods actually were. Those forms were supposed to be symbolic of concepts and traits found in the gods, with the actual gods themselves being thought to exist as abstract forces.
 
 
== Tabletop Games ==
Line 273 ⟶ 271:
** Other Incarnae also have the power to assume more comforting forms. Luna in particular is defined by being a [[Voluntary Shapeshifting|shapeshifter]], with a multitude of forms and identities, some of which are specifically assumed to be comforting to others.
** There's also the implication that some of the jouten (bodies) of certain [[Eldritch Abomination|Primordials]] serve the purpose of giving them a means of interacting with lesser beings in a context other than complete awe and terror. Note that in most cases, this doesn't constitute actual shapeshifting; they're just capable of existing as multiple bodies simultaneously.
 
 
== Theatre ==
* In Marlowe's ''[[Doctor Faustus]]'', the eponymous scholar is appalled by the first form Mephistophilis presents himself in after being summoned (it's never made explicit in the text what that form resembles), and asks him to come back in the shape of a [[Death by Irony|Franciscan Friar]].
 
 
== Video Games ==
Line 309 ⟶ 305:
* Played with in ''[[Catherine]]''. {{spoiler|''Catherine'' is a succubus, meaning that she changes appearance playing up to the fetishes of the men she seduces prefer. You only see one form during the game, but we possibly see her true form in the True Cheater Ending}}.
* [[Final Fantasy X]] has the Eidolon Bahamut appear to you in the form of a small boy with Bahamut-themed clothing. Though considering how Eidolons are made it's a mixture of this trope and [[Was Once a Man]]
* In ''[[MapleStory]]'' when the player reaches level 200, achieving the Fifth Job promotion requires him speaking to the three goddesses. The Goddess of Maple World is the friendliest (especially for explorers, [[Pals with Jesus| who know her personally]]) appearing as a beautiful angelic form. The Goddess of Tyrannium he's a bit more intimidating, but still appears mostly human and attractive, if a little demonic. The goddess of Grandis, however, has three separate forms, depending on what type of character the player is using. If the player is one of the Nova classes or not native to Grandis, she appears as an Ancient Nova, a dragon like humanoid. For the Flora classes, she appears as a Verdant Flora, one of the nobility of the Flora, except with natural looking wings rather than mechanical. For for [[Petting Zoo People|the Anima characters]], she appears as a rabbit-themed Anima.
 
== Web Comics ==
 
== Webcomics ==
* Something does this by accident in ''[[Beyond Reality]]''. It's trying to ''not'' to appear as something the human is comfortable with, but doesn't know much about humans, and thus has to make an educated guess.
{{quote|'''Interdimensional Being:''' You... don't find it frightening?
Line 321 ⟶ 317:
* The [[Starfish Aliens|insectoid]] Princess Voluptua in ''[[The Inexplicable Adventures of Bob]]'' usually interacts with Earthlings by disguising herself as a beautiful woman. One of her subordinates criticizes her that "'Tis undignified for the heir apparent to dress like a monkey!"
* The Sovereign of Sorrow in [[Captain SNES]]'s appearance depends on "how [someone's] mind understands [her]", though she typically appears as female video game royalty. For example, Magus from ''[[Chrono Trigger]]'' sees her as Queen Zeal and [[Super Mario Bros.|Roy Koopa sees her as Princess Peach]].
* When Sissy in ''[[Umlaut House]] 2'' ends up [https://web.archive.org/web/20130801041407/http://maskedretriever.com/uh2/d/20090811.html in the far future] she meets Volair and first recognizes him as Dr. Lee's husband and then guesses that he's some [[The Singularity|post-Singularity]] spook who took on a form that would be neither too familiar nor too strange for her to talk to. Turns out she's right in both cases.
* Inverted in ''[[The Gods of Arr-Kelaan]]''. The mortals-turned-gods can look like anything they want, but they default to what they looked like as mortals because it makes ''them'' more comfortable.
* In ''[[Narbonic]]'', a demon coming to claim a fleeing demon's soul does this, picking an image from Dave's head. That image just so happens to be [http://www.webcomicsnation.com/shaenongarrity/narbonic_plus/series.php?view=archive=45751&name=narbonic_plus#strip5 Helen, dressed like a nerdy fanboy's wetdream].
* [[Trickster Archetype|Coyote]] ofIn ''[[Gunnerkrigg Court]]'' [[Trickster Archetype|Coyote]] appears as a somewhat stylized coyote -- [[Shapeshifting|usually]]—but his [http://www.gunnerkrigg.com/archive_page.php?comicID=679 true form] can be seen by the spiritually aware. [http://www.gunnerkrigg.com/archive_page.php?comicID=678 Carefully], as it's like picking out details on the sun.
** And then [https://www.gunnerkrigg.com/?p=2341 there] are [[Norse Mythology|Norns]].
* In ''[[Olympic Dames]]'', this trope is Pan's excuse for appearing as a tall blond human to the leads. He really just wants to get laid without [[Double Standard Rape (Divine on Mortal)|hearing women scream.]]
* Played for laughs when ''[[Blade Bunny]]'' expresses disgust for being stared at by a big gooey dragon's eyeball that is bigger than she is. The dragon then voluntarily shrinks down small enough to punch out.
* In ''[[El Goonish Shive]]'', Pandora "Chaos" Raven seems to be trying to invert this trope by appearing as a little girl. What she says and does is more creepy that way. Though it seems that mostly she adopted it as more appropriate for childish things, like [https://www.egscomics.com/comic/2016-08-10 temper tantrums]<sup>spoilers!</sup>.
** Also played straight later as she takes the form of Fox, Nanase's summon, to wake her up and get Nanase to listen to her so Nanase will do what Chaos asks with out freaking out too much. Nanase eventually catches on that she's not Fox but by that time she doesn't care and is willing to do what Chaos asked anyway.
* Lampshaded in ''[[Dubious Company]]''. [[Random Number God|Phred]] visits Sal and Leeroy as a [[Visual Pun|pair of sweatpants]].
* In ''[[Wayrift]]'', the Arweinydd ''Zemi Dreigiau'' appears to people in person form or dragon form—depending on his mood. The Arweinydd ''Zazo'' also takes on a wolf form to communicate with people, and eventually takes the form of a woman to gain attention from the man she's in love with.
* For King, from ''[[Housepets]]'', the [[Cosmic Chess Game|Universes & Unrealities]] game is an overglorified [[Dungeons & Dragons]] game... played by two celestial beings who happen to take the respective forms of a giant eastern-style dragon and a griffon.
 
 
== Web Original ==
Line 343 ⟶ 339:
* All of the [[Anthropomorphic Personifications]] in the ''[[Global Guardians PBEM Universe]]'' are made of this trope because, being the physical incarnations of ideas, everyone has a different interpretation of that idea. What this means is that two people could be talking to The King (the [[Anthropomorphic Personification]] of "The Legend of Elvis Presley") and he'd look precisely like how they think Elvis Presley looks like when they think of Elvis Presley (meaning if one person pictures [[Ed Sullivan]]-era Elvis, he looks like Ed Sullivan-era Elvis; if they picture Vegas-era white-tassle pudgy Elvis, he looks like Vegas-era white-tassle pudgy Elvis).
* On deviantART there is this prose piece called "God Drinks Black Coffee". The main character meets God on the sidewalk in the form of a woman.
 
 
== Western Animation ==
Line 379 ⟶ 374:
* ''[[Daria]]'' met many holidays at the "Depth takes a holiday" episode. Christmas, Halloween and Guy Fawkes day wanted to start a band, but Cupid and Saint Patrick day wanted them to return home. They are supposed to say that home is "in your hearth", but it was actually in another dimension they could access through a dimensional wormhole at the back of the chinesse food restaurant. The holidays seem and act like common teenagers, and in their dimension they are all at a place that seems like Lawndale High, but which is worse (a quote that Daria and Jane will be repeating in their adult life).
* In ''[[Young Justice (animation)|Young Justice]]'', {{spoiler|Miss Martian is a White Martian. Since White Martians are pretty hideous by human standards she uses her shapeshifting powers to look like an attractive young green-skinned humanoid. She based her humanoid form along with her ''entire personality'' on broadcasts of an old television show "Hello Megan!" since she hated her lonely life on Mars. As far as she is concerned, her "disguise" ''is'' her true self, so this is actually more a case of a form ''she'' is comfortable with.}}
* Subverted and Played for Laughs in ''[[She-Ra and the Princesses of Power]]''; when Adora first meets Lighthope, the entity appears as a ''very'' tall, very intimidating woman; when Lighthope realizes Adora is ''not'' comfortable with this form, she changes into a shorter, [[Creepy Child]] with pointed ears. Adora quickly asks for the tall woman again.
 
 
== Real Life ==
* Some zoos have been known to feed animals using hand puppets that look like an adult of that species.
** This is actually necessary for baby primates when humans are feeding them. The human literally wears a monkey suit to simulate the fur of the mom. This way the baby will accept the mother when he's returned to her.
** It's also necessary for avians. Birds that "imprint" on humans when they are infants will think that humans are like them, or that they are like humans. This can lead to difficulties, if the bird in question is a part of a breeding program to keep the species from dying out. Ducks and geese are best known for this problem, and may actually end up not knowing how to fly (since humans don't). This is referenced in the [[Discworld]] novel ''[[Discworld/Guards! Guards!|Guards Guards]]'', in which a human raised by dwarves is likened to a duck raised by chickens.
* One example of this is the quadrupolar echo pulse sequence in nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy. The math works out perfectly, but trying to visualize it invariably winds up with the spin pointing 90 degrees from where the math says it should be and where experiment confirms that it actually is. The lesson here is that once you get into the realms of quantum mechanics, physics really ''is'' just math, and what you ''think'' of as "physics" is just a Form You Are Comfortable With.
* Humans instinctively relate to dogs by summoning up qualities dogs and humans share in common (dogs cannot understand space shuttles, they can understand hierarchy, territorialism, tribalism, predation, and familial affection).
 
{{reflist}}
[[Category:{{PAGENAME}}]]
[[Category:Otherness Tropes]]
[[Category:Religion Tropes]]
[[Category:Speculative Fiction Tropes]]
[[Category:Older Than Feudalism]]
[[Category:A Form You Are Comfortable With]]
{{DEFAULTSORT:Form You Are Comfortable With, A}}