Beneath the Mask: Difference between revisions

no edit summary
No edit summary
 
(12 intermediate revisions by 8 users not shown)
Line 1:
{{trope}}
[[File:rsz_2101789890096491869jvefxz_ph_4991rsz 2101789890096491869jvefxz ph 4991.jpg|link=Naruto|rightframe|Looks aren't everything...]]
 
{{quote|''"We wear the mask that grins and lies''
''It hides our face and shades our eyes."'' |'''Paul Laurence Dunbar'''}}
|'''[[wikipedia:Paul Laurence Dunbar|Paul Laurence Dunbar]]''', ''[http://www.potw.org/archive/potw8.html We Wear the Mask]''}}
 
Virtually everyone has to wear a public mask in order to be accepted by others. That's a simple fact of human psychology. When circumstances (such as anonymity, strong emotion, or sufficient power) allow a character to take off that mask and act in complete accord with their inclinations, they reveal what's [['''Beneath the Mask]]'''.
 
The secrets this mask hides are varied and are not always dark. A villain, for example, might be [[Pet the Dog|hiding a soft spot]].
 
Sometimes a person may never know they had a hidden self before the mask comes off. The change is even a surprise to them. Other times the person is well aware of their hidden self and are determined to keep it hidden. This hidden self that people don't show to others is what [['''Beneath the Mask]]''' is about.
 
This hidden self is sometimes portrayed as "the real self". Occasionally the person actually wants someone to see their hidden side (the "real me") but for some reason can never get people to see it. More complex works might argue that the hidden self is just a part of the real self, and that the public self is also part of the real self.
Line 16 ⟶ 17:
 
{{examples}}
 
== Anime and Manga ==
* ''[[Magical Project S]]'': Misao Amano's normal self is that of a stereotypical [[Shrinking Violet]] [[Friendless Background|friendless]], [[Shy Blue-Haired Girl|blue-haired]] [[Ill Girl]]. However, this persona falls away when she's transformed into Pixy Misa, the manifestation of her deeply repressed id: an egomaniacal [[Chaotic Evil]] [[Green-Eyed Monster|jealous]] [[Dark Magical Girl]] [[Villainous Harlequin|trickster]].
Line 35:
* In ''[[Kare Kano]]'', Arima is insanely scared of what's beneath his.
* ''[[Kashimashi: Girl Meets Girl]]'' has the protagonist who gradually feels more and more free to act more feminine.
* Seems to be a theme in ''[[Durarara!!]]'', where pretty much everyone involved, up to and including the district of Ikebukero, has a hidden second side beneath the personalities they show to the world.
* Kurei from ''[[Flame of Recca]]'' personifies this trope, he even wears a mask! He may seem like one of the most cruel, heartless and sadistic characters in the series, but most of his actions are driven by his love for people he cares about.
* ''[[Higurashi no Naku Koro ni]]'' sort of plays around with this, where in first and last arc of the anime's first season the characters discuss social masks and not speaking about things they don't want to speak about, such as {{spoiler|in the first arc, both Keiichi's and Rena's hiding their respective [[Dark and Troubled Past|Dark and Troubled Pasts]]s, and in the last arc, Keiichi hiding that he killed Rena and Mion in the first arc}}.
** However, it's played more straight with {{spoiler|Rika}} in the second season, where {{spoiler|although everyone knows about her place in the Furude family, she acts like a child usually would at her age. At least, the age everyone thinks she is.}} However, when {{spoiler|she's}} seen alone with {{spoiler|Hanyuu}}, {{spoiler|she}} acts much more like [[The Stoic|a stoic]], or even a [[Determined Defeatist]].
* Barnaby Brooks Jr. from ''[[Tiger and Bunny]]'' has ''two'' masks superimposed on one another. The first is the guise of a charming, skilled [[The Ace|ace]] that hides a rude, untrusting [[Ice Queen|Ice King]] beneath it. The rude, untrusting Ice King mask in turn hides a {{spoiler|traumatized, lonely man who doesn't know what to do with his life beyond getting revenge on the organization that assassinated his family.}}
Line 47:
* Several characters in ''[[Life (manga)|Life]]'' are like this, typically to mask their [[Jerkass]] side.
* In [[Kimi no Iru Machi]] when Haruto first meets Eba Rin he wonders how such a level headed person could be related to Yuzuki, even if only as step-sisters. Eventually Rin gets tired enough of the mask that she completely discards it with Haruto, in fact she is more honest with herself around Haruto {{spoiler|and eventually Yuzuki}} that she doesn't put it back on around them, leading her to change [[Bitch in Sheep's Clothing|just a little bit.]]
* The way ''[[Black Butler]]'' is going, every single character is going to turn out to wear a mask or several. For example Ciel, being a [[Villain Protagonist]] [[Kuudere]], has a cold, ruthless side masking a warm side, underneath which lies a deeply traumatized child side. Later on Ciel learns to adds the mask of a cheerful, social boy on top of everything, to be used when necessary. You can even say that Behind the Mask counts as a [[Central Theme]].
 
== ComicbooksComic Books ==
* The Sentry, though he pretends to be a [[Lawful Good]] hero, has a dark side that manifests against his will.
* [[X-Men|Jean Grey's]] Phoenix persona was [[Retcon|retconnedretcon]]ned to be her actual innermost personality, not a separate entity. It is ''very'' different from her public persona.
** The notion that it was a separate entity was itself a [[Retcon]], and Phoenix was always supposed to be Jean Grey's more passionate, "dark" side. [[Master of Illusion|Mastermind's]] messing with her head was originally what made the [[Super-Powered Evil Side|"superpowered side" evil.]]
* Black Adam of [[Captain Marvel]] was chosen as a champion of justice, but when he received superpowers he [[Anti-Hero|didn't react as his patrons expected him to]].
 
== Fan FicWorks ==
 
* Inverted by Jack O'Lantern in ''[[Ultimate SpiderWoman|Ultimate Spider-Woman: Change With Thethe Light]]''. Although he wears a public mask to be accepted by his fellow citizens, he also begins wearing a ghoulish pumpkin-headed costume and committing increasingly deadly crimes to reveal his ''true'' personality. He is well aware of the irony in wearing a mask to reveal his true face, but he considers himself superior to the pathetic, mindless sheep and cattle that make up most of the rest of society because he's willing to embrace just what he ''really'' is.
== Fan Fic ==
* Inverted by Jack O'Lantern in ''[[Ultimate SpiderWoman|Ultimate Spider-Woman: Change With The Light]]''. Although he wears a public mask to be accepted by his fellow citizens, he also begins wearing a ghoulish pumpkin-headed costume and committing increasingly deadly crimes to reveal his ''true'' personality. He is well aware of the irony in wearing a mask to reveal his true face, but he considers himself superior to the pathetic, mindless sheep and cattle that make up most of the rest of society because he's willing to embrace just what he ''really'' is.
* In ''[[DC Nation]]'', Fauna lampshades this when it comes to Nightwing. After seeing him as Dick Grayson, she wrote in her [[Character Blog]] that not many people put a mask ''on'' when they want to be themselves.
* Played straight in a Danny Phantom [[Fanfic]] called [http://www.fanfiction.net/s/3831182/1/Masks Masks.] It is unusual in that Danny is actually wearing three masks to hide his true self. A surprisingly good read.
 
== Film ==
 
== Films -- Live-Action ==
* In ''[[Bridesmaids]]'' Helen is the typical [[Alpha Bitch]]. At least that's what it appears on the surface. But when she breaks down crying, she reveals {{spoiler|[[I Just Want to Have Friends|she's in a loveless marriage, and just gets invited to weddings because she's good at organizing events]].}}
* [[Film/Enter The Dragon|Enter The Dragon]]: In reference to Han, the villain, whose martial-arts tournament is a front for a really nasty operation: "You must remember... the enemy has only images and illusions, behind which he hides his true motives. Destroy the image, and you will break the enemy."
Line 71 ⟶ 70:
* In the [[Film of the Book|film version]] of ''[[The Voyage of the Dawn Treader]]'', the darkness tempts the main characters, showing their hidden desires.
* The knights' elaborate, mask-like helmets in the John Boorman film, 'Excalibur,' show the real personae of the wearers.
* A major theme of ''[[Wild Things]]''. Sam appears to be an honest, upstanding educator, but he's really a {{spoiler|sleazy, exploitative pervert.}} Kelly appears to be an all-American teenage girl next door, but she's actually {{spoiler|an angry, sexually confused cokehead who hates her family.}} Ray appears to be an honest if overzealous cop, but he's actually a {{spoiler|[[Dirty Cop]] who enjoys prostitutes and is quite willing to murder anyone who pisses him off.}} Suzie appears to be a white-trash loser, but she's actually a {{spoiler|brilliantly calculating [[The Chessmaster|Chessmaster]] who manipulates everyone else}}.<br /><br />Lampshaded by Ray, although in reference to another character.
** Lampshaded by Ray, although in reference to another character.
{{quote|'''Ray:''' People aren't always what they appear to be, Jimmy. Don't forget that.}}
 
 
== Literature ==
Line 79 ⟶ 78:
* In [[The Dresden Files]], wizards have two major abilities related to this.
** A Soulgaze is a one time per person link. When initiated by the wizard staring into someone's eyes for a few seconds, each sees the other's True Self.
** The Sight shows the essence of how things are -- magicalare—magical workings and their aftereffects are visible, people's mental and emotional trauma and strengths, etc. Anything seen with the Sight is permanently etched into the wizard's brain.
* The entirety of the [[Ciaphas Cain]] novels is about a '''[[Fake Ultimate Hero|HERO]] [[Memetic Mutation|OF THE]] [[All the Tropes Wiki Drinking Game|IMPERIUM]]''' who secretly regards himself as a [[Dirty Coward]] whose every action was motivated by self-interest. Whether or not you believe that depends very much on [[Alternate Character Interpretation|how you interpret his true character]].
* In Elias Canetti's book ''Crowds and Power'', he speaks in detail about masks and hiding of a true-self in relation to power. For Canetti everyone wears a mask and for this reason a ruler is never able to truly trust in anyone, which is a cause of paranoia regarding[[Et Tu, Brute?|betrayal]]. For Canetti the "unmasking" is crucial in the movements of power.
Line 89 ⟶ 88:
* Double Subverted in [[Deep Space Nine]] ''Soldiers of the Empire''. Klingons underneath their swagger are lonely overworked soldiers grumbling about their lot just as much as human soldiers do. But when inspired they [[Becoming the Mask|put on their mask]] again and go into battle as a true [[Proud Warrior Race]].
 
== Films -- Live-Action TV ==
 
== Live Action TV ==
* Major Zod in ''[[Smallville]]'' pretended to be an ally to Clark and a caring leader until he received his superpowers, revealing his hidden lust for power. "[[Paradise Lost|Better to rule in hell than to serve in heaven]]."
** Lana Lang once received Clark's superpowers, using them to try to kill [[Big Bad|Lex]], steal his secrets, and discredit him in the media.
Line 98 ⟶ 96:
** This is a premise of the show too , as all the main cast including the patients are not always what they seem to be, in the case of the patients their lies often complicate the medical procedures of the team , while House himself dedicates his time to discover the secrets of his co-workers.
* [[Lizzie McGuire]] displays the title character's duality with an animated version of Lizzie saying whatever Lizzie is really thinking.
* The Doctor, in ''[[Doctor Who]]''. Yes, he wears celery, offers people jelly babies, and has a fascination with [[Cool Hat|Cool Hats]]s; seems like another harmless eccentric fellow, right? Yeah - that "harmless eccentric fellow" can quite literally tear the heavens asunder and reshape reality if he really feels like it. [[Beware the Nice Ones|Still want to piss him off?]]
* In ''[[iCarly]]'', Nevel is a polite, nice kid when within his mom's vicinity, but is a complete [[Jerkass]] outside of it.
* Pretty much the entire basis of ''[[Hannah Montana]]''.
* ''[[Odyssey 5]]'' has Kurt occasionally show a much kinder side than his usual persona.
* Effectively everyone of any importance on ''[[Babylon 5]]'', as summed up by G'Kar's word of warning to Catharine Sakai: ''"No one here is exactly what he appears. [[Ass in Ambassador|Not]] [[Magnificent Bastard|Mollari]], [[The High Queen|not]] [[Lady of War|Delenn]], [[The Captain|not]] [[Obfuscating Stupidity|Sinclair]]... and [[Well-Intentioned Extremist|not]] [[Cassandra Truth|me.]]"''
* In [[Deep Space Nine]]: ''Soldiers of the Empire'' we go aboard a Klingon ship for a routine patrol and see that beneath their boasting they are grumbling soldiers [[Not So Different]] from humans. When they are finally [[Let's Get Dangerous|rallied]] they [[Becoming the Mask|put their mask back on.]] Which come to think of it is also [[Not So Different]] from humans.
 
 
Line 118 ⟶ 117:
 
 
== TheaterTheatre ==
* Explored deeply in ''[[Jekyll and Hyde]]'', most notably with the song ''Facade'' and its numerous reprises.
{{quote|There's a face that we wear in the cold light of day/ It's society's mask, it's societies way/ And the truth is... That it's all a facade.}}
Line 147 ⟶ 146:
* A bittersweet one for ''[[King's Quest]]'': despite his return to Daventry, his rank of prince, and his joy of being a free man with a loving family, Alexander considers that identity as "a cloak." [[Expanded Universe]] material establishes that he still considers himself to be "Gwydion," the name he had as Mannanan's slave. In the series guide, he makes a concession to both identities by signing his name Alexander-Gwydion.
* ''[[Heavy Rain]]'' has Lt. Blake and his boss, Captain Perry, liking [[By-The-Book Cop]] Norman Jayden. However, their true selves revealed that [[Jerkass|they don't like him]].
* [[Disgaea: Hour of Darkness/Characters|Laharl]] from ''[[Disgaea]]'' tries his very best to be completely perceived as an evil demon, but his more positive qualities, like his forgiving, noble and strangely kind nature, is regularly provoked to the surface throughout the game.
* Zelos from [[Tales of Symphonia]] at first appears to be a Skirt Chasing pervert who uses his rank as the Chosen to bring Ladies to his bedroom and simply just relishes the limelight. Inside, he's really {{spoiler|a calculating individual who suffers from self-loathing due to an EXTREMELY messed up childhood, which involves his mother telling him "I Wish You've Never Been Born" just before she dies.}}
* [[Tales of Legendia]]: Grune starts of as an Amnesiac who is basically the teams personal [[Cloudcuckoolander]]. Later on, even though she tries to hide it when she figures it out, it is revealed that Grune is really {{spoiler|a goddess of time whose only purpose is to battle with her evil counterpart in order to determine the fate of the world.}}
* ''[[Tales of Vesperia]]''. After {{spoiler|his [[Face Heel Turn]] and subequent redemption}} we get to see the person behind Raven's sleazy-selfish-pervert mask. {{spoiler|After revealing, he does return to the mask though, because he much prefers that persona.}}
* Several characters in [[StarcraftStarCraft|Liberty's Crusade]] would discuss what Mengsk could be like under the mask - as Kerrigan points out, he's unreadable. When Raynor calls him out on sacrificing Kerrigan, he engages in his well known tirade prompting Liberty to remark that Mengsk has finally shown his true face: that of a power crazed madman.
 
 
=== Visual Novels ===
* {{spoiler|Lesteena}} in ''[[Eien no Aselia]]'' isn't sure whether her normal personality or the one she pretends to be when she gets a chance to relax is the real one. The answer seems to be both and neither.
* Tohsaka in ''[[Fate/stay night|Fate Stay Night]]'' is a bit of a funny example. She acts like a perfect and kind student, but beneath that she's irritable, [[Tsundere|dishonest about her feelings]], [[Not a Morning Person]], selfish and something of a [[The Gadfly|troll.]] However, beneath ''that'' is something she doesn't seem entirely aware of: She values people's lives a great deal, will die for others, values fair play and honesty and is actually rather kind. Nor is she as ruthless as she thinks she is.
Line 160 ⟶ 159:
 
== Web Original ==
* ''[[Dr. Horrible's Sing-Along Blog|Doctor Horribles Sing Along Blog]]'' has elements of this in both the [[Hero Antagonist]], who looks like [[The Cape (trope)]] but is really an arrogant bully; and the [[Villain Protagonist]], who's trying to woo the girl of his dreams as Billy, but is also trying to [[Take Over the World]]. Both masks come off at the end, with tragic results.
** Both Dr. Horrible and Captain Hammer actually have three layers to them. On the surface, Billy is just Billy, leading a normal life, trying to woo Penny, underneath that he's the power-hungry Dr. Horrible, but even deeper down he's just Billy. As Penny mentioned, she first thought Hammer was just a big jerk, but he became really sweet later on. However, he really is just a [[Jerk with a Heart of Jerk]].
* In [[Neopets]]: {{spoiler|Xandra in the "Faerie's Ruin" plot initially has a facade of a helpful and nerdy innocent appearance with anger issues (even using glasses to appear more innocent}} [http://images.neopets.com/faerieland/tfr_fa61c26562/conv/2_9815d2d41a.png pictured here]. However she is revealed to be a [[Well-Intentioned Extremist]] with a completely "machiavellian" and [[A God Am I|egomaniacal personality]] [http://www.drsloth.com/p/view/162912/ pictured here].
* [[Ask That Guy With The Glasses]] is a nicely layered version of the trope. The "mask" is a distinguished gentleman, underneath that is a bastard who likes playing with people, underneath that is an invoked Complete Monster, and underneath that is a cesspool of self-loathing and damage.
* In ''[[Ears for Elves]]'', [https://web.archive.org/web/20140421193157/http://www.earsforelves.com/archives/352 Luero calls out Tanna on her near-constant smiling]. He goes on to say "Masking your emotions may be necessary for dealing with most people.".
* ''[[El Goonish Shive]]'' acquired a running gag about this, once Susan began to [http://egscomics.com/?date=2010-06-02 summon a fairy doll replica] that acts on her subconscious desires. When it is first summoned, Sarah and Grace have a field day interpreting how its actions show things that [[The Stoic|Susan tries so hard to hide]]. Also, Susan's [[Hates Being Touched|aversion to being touched]] evidently does not work by proxy (even though she ''does'' receive [http://egscomics.com/egsnp/2014-12-17 some tactile feedback]). It took her some time to learn "manual control", but when she isn't paying attention, the doll [http://egscomics.com/egsnp/2015-01-02 still gives her away].
 
 
== Western Animation ==
Line 173 ⟶ 172:
** Prince Zuko as well, especially in season one. He is introduced as a ruthless, conceited bully of a prince who only cares about himself and seemingly looks down on everyone, including his superiors. In reality, he's just a [["Well Done, Son" Guy|good-natured kid]] who wants his father to be proud of him. Over the next two seasons, this facade begins to gradually break and by the final episode it has disappeared completely.
* Helga from ''[[Hey Arnold!]]'' expressed her true feelings for Arnold when alone.
* Trixie Tang from ''[[The Fairly Odd ParentsOddParents]]'' is secretly a tomboy that likes comic books and disguises herself as a boy because she has fear of being judged and rejected due to the fact that she is a popular girl and the [[Alpha Bitch]] of her school.
* In ''[[Phineas and Ferb]]'', there are numerous examples:
** Candace Flynn is secretly a fan of a series called Duckie Momo (a parody of both [[Hello Kitty]] and Pokemon). She used to wear a costume in order to hide her love of the series from her friends, going as far as lying to both her boyfriend and her best friend.
Line 196 ⟶ 195:
* [[Kevin Spencer]], in his confrontation with [[Love Interest]] [[Axe Crazy|Shawna]], states that beneath all her sociopathic, murderous tendencies, she's really a popularity-obsessed bitch.
* Casper The Friendly Ghost, in one of the older cartoons, ''Fright from Wrong'', is force-fed a huge jar of "Mean Pills" by his mean uncles, who want him to be a mean ghost to ''humans''. But Casper spends the rest of the short putting them through the wringer (both literally and figuratively). It would appear that this example wouldn't count since Casper was drugged to act like that, right? Ehhh, not so much... he reveals at the very end that he never took the pills; all the cartoonish brutality he'd unleashed on his uncles was all him just trying to teach them a lesson! The little Friendly Ghost has a vicious side hidden under the "friendly".
* In ''[[Thundercats 2011|ThunderCats (2011)]]'' [[Rascally Rabbit]] the Drifter is an always smiling, [[Brilliant but Lazy]] man who's facade is one of carefree, perpetual mild amusement. In actuality, he's deeply depressed and grieving a personal loss, to the point of fixatedly attempting to save others from duplicating his mistakes by delivering [[Adventure Rebuff|Adventure Rebuffs]]s and an unending stream of unsolicited advice, all the while peppering his speech with his insistant "[[Implausible Deniability|I don't care]]."
 
 
Line 204 ⟶ 203:
 
{{reflist}}
[[Category:Beneath the Mask{{PAGENAME}}]]
[[Category:Disguise Tropes]]
[[Category:More Than Meets the Eye]]
Line 209:
[[Category:Psychology Tropes]]
[[Category:Fame and Reputation Tropes]]
[[Category:Beneath the Mask]]
[[Category:Identity Index]]