Binder of Shame/YMMV
- Ho Yay: Biff Bam's Call of Cthulhu (tabletop game) house rules included "the less sanity points you have, the more gay you are." He then forced everyone to strip to the waist, and enforced his rulings by physically wrestling recalcitrant players into submission.
- Squick: Pretty much everything the appropriately-named El Disgusto and Deviant Boy do, probably culminating in the time El Disgusto caused the entire party to end up in Cthulhu's toilet.
- What Do You Mean It Wasn't Made on Drugs?: Most of the campaigns, particularly anything created by Blobert Smith. Weasley ended up actually getting drunk while running a campaign and turned it into a Star Trek crossover. The final entry, "Once More With Filking", claims that Collateral Darren spiked Ab3's drink with LSD while he was running their final game together, just to see what would happen.