Bomb-Throwing Anarchists: Difference between revisions

Content added Content deleted
m (Looney Toons moved page Bomb Throwing Anarchists to Bomb-Throwing Anarchists: Adding proper punctuation to page name)
m (Mass update links)
Line 70: Line 70:


== Music ==
== Music ==
* Music example: Punk rockers often invoked this trope, posing as [[Bomb Throwing Anarchists]]. The [[Ur Example]] may be the band [[Sex Pistols]], whose famous song "Anarchy in the UK" goes as follows:
* Music example: Punk rockers often invoked this trope, posing as [[Bomb-Throwing Anarchists]]. The [[Ur Example]] may be the band [[Sex Pistols]], whose famous song "Anarchy in the UK" goes as follows:
{{quote| I am an Antichrist<br />
{{quote| I am an Antichrist<br />
I am an [[Painful Rhyme|anarchist]]<br />
I am an [[Painful Rhyme|anarchist]]<br />
Line 121: Line 121:
* [[The Tick|"Yeah, baby, yeah!]] [[Department of Redundancy Department|I'm the Evil Midnight Bomber what bombs at midnight!"]]
* [[The Tick|"Yeah, baby, yeah!]] [[Department of Redundancy Department|I'm the Evil Midnight Bomber what bombs at midnight!"]]
* Verminous Skum from ''[[Captain Planet]]'' was one of these a lot. Trying to spread panic through inaccurate AIDS information and getting everyone in Washington DC hooked on a drug called Bliss to create his own zombie army are a few examples.
* Verminous Skum from ''[[Captain Planet]]'' was one of these a lot. Trying to spread panic through inaccurate AIDS information and getting everyone in Washington DC hooked on a drug called Bliss to create his own zombie army are a few examples.
* The Blow Out, a [[Looney Tunes]] cartoon, had [[Cross Dressing Voices|Lucille]] [[Large Ham|La Verne]] - [[Hey It's That Voice|aka]] [[Snow White (Disney)|The Queen]] - as [[No Name Given|The Bomber]]. He adorably is foiled by [[Characterization Marches On|a child version]] of Porky Pig.
* The Blow Out, a [[Looney Tunes]] cartoon, had [[Cross-Dressing Voices|Lucille]] [[Large Ham|La Verne]] - [[Hey, It's That Voice!|aka]] [[Snow White (Disney)|The Queen]] - as [[No Name Given|The Bomber]]. He adorably is foiled by [[Characterization Marches On|a child version]] of Porky Pig.


== Real Life ==
== Real Life ==
* The [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Red_Army_Faction Baader-Meinhof Gang] (claimed to be anarchists in the [[Cold War|West German]] media [[Shaped Like Itself|because they were bombers]]). [[Enforced Trope|Enforced]] insofar as they [[Terrorists Without a Cause|played to expectations as gun-crazed psychos]], squandering any popular sympathy for their cause. For more information, see ''[[The Baader Meinhof Complex (Film)|The Baader Meinhof Complex]]'', the events behind the film are [http://www.nytimes.com/2009/08/16/movies/16kapl.html?_r=2 analyzed here].
* The [[wikipedia:Red Army Faction|Baader-Meinhof Gang]] (claimed to be anarchists in the [[Cold War|West German]] media [[Shaped Like Itself|because they were bombers]]). [[Enforced Trope|Enforced]] insofar as they [[Terrorists Without a Cause|played to expectations as gun-crazed psychos]], squandering any popular sympathy for their cause. For more information, see ''[[The Baader Meinhof Complex (Film)|The Baader Meinhof Complex]]'', the events behind the film are [http://www.nytimes.com/2009/08/16/movies/16kapl.html?_r=2 analyzed here].
** The RAF ([http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Red_Army_Faction Red Army Faction], not [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Royal_Air_Force these guys]) actually had some measure of popular support: a poll showed about 25% of Germans under 40 felt sympathy for them and as many as one in ten youths was ready to hide one of its members.
** The RAF ([[wikipedia:Red Army Faction|Red Army Faction]], not [[wikipedia:Royal Air Force|these guys]]) actually had some measure of popular support: a poll showed about 25% of Germans under 40 felt sympathy for them and as many as one in ten youths was ready to hide one of its members.
** That must have been when they were still only blowing up department stores instead of people (which they resorted to in their later years).
** That must have been when they were still only blowing up department stores instead of people (which they resorted to in their later years).
* The Weather Underground fell into the same trope; despite consciously attempting to avoid being portrayed as crazed bombers, they assumed that "bringing the Vietnam War home" would radicalize America. Instead, several of them ended up blowing themselves up in Greenwich Village (although most of the Weathermen merely dropped out, and the former leadership were mostly pardoned) and had a similar film, ''[[The Weather Underground]]'' made about them.
* The Weather Underground fell into the same trope; despite consciously attempting to avoid being portrayed as crazed bombers, they assumed that "bringing the Vietnam War home" would radicalize America. Instead, several of them ended up blowing themselves up in Greenwich Village (although most of the Weathermen merely dropped out, and the former leadership were mostly pardoned) and had a similar film, ''[[The Weather Underground]]'' made about them.
Line 137: Line 137:
*** It's important to note that Anarchism and Communism started out as extremely similar ideologies. The anarchist movement has been leftist and 'red' (For example, the anarchist Emma Goldman was referred to as Red Emma) for most of their history, with the least communistic strain being individualist anarchism and mutualism, which is still essentially a libertarian socialist thread, albeit one that also supports an unfettered free market. It does this by replacing 'property' with 'possession' of capital. Not until recently have there been 'anarcho-capitalists', and a large part of the anarchist movement does not consider them to be anarchists at all.
*** It's important to note that Anarchism and Communism started out as extremely similar ideologies. The anarchist movement has been leftist and 'red' (For example, the anarchist Emma Goldman was referred to as Red Emma) for most of their history, with the least communistic strain being individualist anarchism and mutualism, which is still essentially a libertarian socialist thread, albeit one that also supports an unfettered free market. It does this by replacing 'property' with 'possession' of capital. Not until recently have there been 'anarcho-capitalists', and a large part of the anarchist movement does not consider them to be anarchists at all.
* The [[Trope Namer]] came from an incident on May 4, 1886 called the Haymarket <s>Riot</s> <s>Massacre</s> Affair where during a rally in support of striking workers recently gunned down by police and [[Pinkerton Detective|Pinkertons]], someone threw a bomb at police, killing one of them. Eight anarchists were put on trial for this and the internationally publicized trials led to the caricature of the Bomb Throwing Anarchist.
* The [[Trope Namer]] came from an incident on May 4, 1886 called the Haymarket <s>Riot</s> <s>Massacre</s> Affair where during a rally in support of striking workers recently gunned down by police and [[Pinkerton Detective|Pinkertons]], someone threw a bomb at police, killing one of them. Eight anarchists were put on trial for this and the internationally publicized trials led to the caricature of the Bomb Throwing Anarchist.
** Four of the anarchist leaders were sentenced to death, and one killed himself in prison. Interestingly, no one actually knows who did it, and it seems like they never will - however, one of the main theories is that it was [[False Flag Operation|an agent provocateur]]. For that matter, the initial blast only killed one police officer; the other causalities were due to the police opening fire on the crowd, and, apparently, themselves (it was dark.) One report put the number of civilian deaths at around 50. The Other Wiki, of course, has more information and details. There were no charges over these deaths, and indeed the anarchists on trial were charged with inciting the violence through their writings or speeches, rather than committing it directly.
** Four of the anarchist leaders were sentenced to death, and one killed himself in prison. Interestingly, no one actually knows who did it, and it seems like they never will - however, one of the main theories is that it was [[False-Flag Operation|an agent provocateur]]. For that matter, the initial blast only killed one police officer; the other causalities were due to the police opening fire on the crowd, and, apparently, themselves (it was dark.) One report put the number of civilian deaths at around 50. The Other Wiki, of course, has more information and details. There were no charges over these deaths, and indeed the anarchists on trial were charged with inciting the violence through their writings or speeches, rather than committing it directly.
** A statue of the officer killed by the bomb, erected in the square, has been defaced and repeatedly blown up as recently as the 1970s. Its current incarnation is installed in the Chicago police station.
** A statue of the officer killed by the bomb, erected in the square, has been defaced and repeatedly blown up as recently as the 1970s. Its current incarnation is installed in the Chicago police station.
** At the time, "mad bombers" were all assumed to be anarchists, and vice versa, based on the notoriety of the assassination attempts, hence the origin of the stereotype. Ironically, in reality, most anarchists at the time were basically [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/council_communism council communists] -- the people who wanted Russia to be run democratically from the ground up by workers councils. They all got killed by Lenin. So basically, anarchism at the time was another name for communism ''without'' the dictatorship part, not nihilism. (In the US, they briefly took over East Saint Louis during a General Strike and turned local governance, mail, etc. over to the Unions until the Federal soldiers seized control of the city). The same thing happened with the Seattle General Strike in 1919.
** At the time, "mad bombers" were all assumed to be anarchists, and vice versa, based on the notoriety of the assassination attempts, hence the origin of the stereotype. Ironically, in reality, most anarchists at the time were basically [[wikipedia:council communism|council communists]] -- the people who wanted Russia to be run democratically from the ground up by workers councils. They all got killed by Lenin. So basically, anarchism at the time was another name for communism ''without'' the dictatorship part, not nihilism. (In the US, they briefly took over East Saint Louis during a General Strike and turned local governance, mail, etc. over to the Unions until the Federal soldiers seized control of the city). The same thing happened with the Seattle General Strike in 1919.
** The 1910 Los Angeles Times Bombing was linked to attempts to unionize the iron workers, but were commonly called Bomb throwing anarchists.
** The 1910 Los Angeles Times Bombing was linked to attempts to unionize the iron workers, but were commonly called Bomb throwing anarchists.
* Italian anarchists and revolutionaries of the Turn-of-the-Century seemed to be particularly [[Ax Crazy]] when compared to others, and it wasn't rare for them to attack rulers from [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Michele_Angiolillo other] [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gennaro_Rubino countries] that had no relation whatsoever with Italy or even [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Felice_Orsini sympathised with it].
* Italian anarchists and revolutionaries of the Turn-of-the-Century seemed to be particularly [[Ax Crazy]] when compared to others, and it wasn't rare for them to attack rulers from [[wikipedia:Michele Angiolillo|other]] [[wikipedia:Gennaro Rubino|countries]] that had no relation whatsoever with Italy or even [[wikipedia:Felice Orsini|sympathised with it]].
* Late 19th-early 20th century terrorists in the Russian Empire were and still are popularly known as "bombists" due to their love for home-made explosives. Of course, far from all of them were anarchists (the Socialist Revolutionaries - eSeRs - outnumbered them as time went on), but then again, many of them were pretty nihilistic in character if not in their party ideology and otherwise fit this stereotype quite well.
* Late 19th-early 20th century terrorists in the Russian Empire were and still are popularly known as "bombists" due to their love for home-made explosives. Of course, far from all of them were anarchists (the Socialist Revolutionaries - eSeRs - outnumbered them as time went on), but then again, many of them were pretty nihilistic in character if not in their party ideology and otherwise fit this stereotype quite well.
* Not to mention that one of the revolutionary movements active in Russia at that time actually was the [[Nietzsche Wannabe|Nihilists]], who considered all authority and hierarchy to stand in the way of free choice.
* Not to mention that one of the revolutionary movements active in Russia at that time actually was the [[Nietzsche Wannabe|Nihilists]], who considered all authority and hierarchy to stand in the way of free choice.
Line 150: Line 150:
* In Ancient Rome, it was those dastardly Christians who were held to be fervently wishing for the demise of the state, and blamed for the [[While Rome Burns|fire that destroyed Rome]], along with promoting class mixing and attacking the state-sponsored religion; resulting in centuries of persecution. They were also called ''atheists'', as they rejected the civic gods of the state religion, including the "divine" Emperors.
* In Ancient Rome, it was those dastardly Christians who were held to be fervently wishing for the demise of the state, and blamed for the [[While Rome Burns|fire that destroyed Rome]], along with promoting class mixing and attacking the state-sponsored religion; resulting in centuries of persecution. They were also called ''atheists'', as they rejected the civic gods of the state religion, including the "divine" Emperors.
** In fact, many Biblical scholars interpret the Book of Revelations as an anarchistic screed foretelling the fall of the Roman Empire.
** In fact, many Biblical scholars interpret the Book of Revelations as an anarchistic screed foretelling the fall of the Roman Empire.
** Somewhat more plausibly in the 14-16th century, when some of the [[Torches and Pitchforks|peasant revolts]] during the Reformation ''were'' anarchist. The leader of the Anabaptists was drawn and quartered for proclaiming that he would rather the Turks invade Germany ([[Values Dissonance|a realistic proposition at the time]]) instead of having self-proclaimed Christians [[Technical Pacifist|rule by force]]. In England in the 1300s, [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Occams_Razor William of Ockham]'s seminary students were Socialists of sorts who tried to eliminate all rulers in England and set up... they weren't sure yet. Their Peasant's Revolt [[What Could Have Been|nearly deposed the monarchy]] [[Alternate History|in the 1300s]], but was turned back at the gates of London. The leaders then met with the king to discuss reforms. He promptly killed them all, promised reforms to their followers (that never happened) and pardoned them, staving off any further revolt. The Diggers in the English Civil War were also essentially Christian anarchists and [[Actual Pacifist|Actual Pacifists]], meaning they didn't last long when the government cracked down. This was also when the word "anarchist" was used the first time in the modern sense, referring to such radical groups.
** Somewhat more plausibly in the 14-16th century, when some of the [[Torches and Pitchforks|peasant revolts]] during the Reformation ''were'' anarchist. The leader of the Anabaptists was drawn and quartered for proclaiming that he would rather the Turks invade Germany ([[Values Dissonance|a realistic proposition at the time]]) instead of having self-proclaimed Christians [[Technical Pacifist|rule by force]]. In England in the 1300s, [[wikipedia:Occams Razor|William of Ockham]]'s seminary students were Socialists of sorts who tried to eliminate all rulers in England and set up... they weren't sure yet. Their Peasant's Revolt [[What Could Have Been|nearly deposed the monarchy]] [[Alternate History|in the 1300s]], but was turned back at the gates of London. The leaders then met with the king to discuss reforms. He promptly killed them all, promised reforms to their followers (that never happened) and pardoned them, staving off any further revolt. The Diggers in the English Civil War were also essentially Christian anarchists and [[Actual Pacifist|Actual Pacifists]], meaning they didn't last long when the government cracked down. This was also when the word "anarchist" was used the first time in the modern sense, referring to such radical groups.
* Anarchists were blamed by most of the media for turning the relatively peaceful 1999 WTO protests into a riot.
* Anarchists were blamed by most of the media for turning the relatively peaceful 1999 WTO protests into a riot.
** Have also been blamed for frenzying the police during the more recent Occupy Movements on the West Coast area.
** Have also been blamed for frenzying the police during the more recent Occupy Movements on the West Coast area.
Line 160: Line 160:
[[Category:The War On Straw]]
[[Category:The War On Straw]]
[[Category:Bomb Throwing Anarchists]]
[[Category:Bomb Throwing Anarchists]]
[[Category:Trope]]
[[Category:Hottip markup]]