All The Tropes

Forum:Policy on fake works?: Difference between revisions

Forum Discussion

Forum:Policy on fake works? (view source)

Revision as of 21:53, 7 February 2014

476 bytes added ,  10 years ago
reorganize page, what about Show Within a Show?
VisualWikitext
No edit summary
(reorganize page, what about Show Within a Show?)
Line 11:
:: I favor Vorticity's solution on this topic myself. We have cut TVT pages that we can't repurpose for use on ATT in any form or would not apply here in any circumstance, but if it can be saved in a form that useful, we can go with that if possible. [[User:GethN7|GethN7]] ([[User talk:GethN7|talk]]) 13:13, 7 February 2014 (UTC)
:: How about if we cut the "metafiction" pages and make one trope page covering all tvtropes "metafiction"? [[User:Topazan|Topazan]] ([[User talk:Topazan|talk]]) 14:42, 7 February 2014 (UTC)
::: That seems a little extreme IMO. Besides, if it's a work, self contained in it's own right, then it most likely deserves a page and subpages of it's own. For stuff that has a shared canon/directly references other works/share continuity, that would make sense. [[User:GethN7|GethN7]] ([[User talk:GethN7|talk]]) 14:51, 7 February 2014 (UTC)
::: WellYeah, Vorticity made the argument that tvtropessounds the webcomic counts as a story because of the recap page, but what about a pagemore like ''[[Inspectoran Spacetime]]'',index whereto theme. recap is just a list of episode titles? In a lot of theseEr, there's really not a lot of "continuity" to speak ofcategory. [[User:TopazanVorticity|TopazanVorticity]] ([[User talk:TopazanVorticity|talk]]) 1621:1453, 7 February 2014 (UTC)
:::: NoWell, matterVorticity whatmade wethe decideargument that tvtropes the webcomic counts as a story because of the recap page, webut what about a page like 'll'[[Inspector probablySpacetime]]'', where the recap is needjust a list of allepisode thesetitles? pages. In Ia lot of these, there'lls startreally not a lot of "continuity" to speak of. [[User:Topazan|Topazan]] ([[User talk:Topazan|talk]]) 16:2414, 7 February 2014 (UTC)
::::: I'm pretty sure it's a variant of the [[Doctor Who]] page with the serial numbers filed off. [[User:Vorticity|Vorticity]] ([[User talk:Vorticity|talk]]) 21:53, 7 February 2014 (UTC)
:::: [[Avatar and The Airbending Fellowship of Vampire Slayers]]▼
 
:::: [[Daring Do]]▼
: No matter what we decide, we'll probably need a list of all these pages. I'll start. [[User:Topazan|Topazan]] ([[User talk:Topazan|talk]]) 16:24, 7 February 2014 (UTC)
:::: [[Inspector Spacetime]]
▲:::: [[Avatar and The Airbending Fellowship of Vampire Slayers]]
:::: [[My Little Rainbow Princess Pretty Moon Shortcake]]▼
▲:::: [[Daring Do]]
:::: [[The Punishers Song of Evangelion and I Must Scream]]▼
:::: [[TVInspector Tropes the WebcomicSpacetime]]
::* Isn't this a [[Show Within a Show]], like [[Gekiganger 3]]? If so, shouldn't it actually be covered with [[In-Universe]] examples? -- ∇×V
▲:::: [[My Little Rainbow Princess Pretty Moon Shortcake]]
▲:::: [[The Punishers Song of Evangelion and I Must Scream]]
:: [[TV Tropes the Webcomic]]
Retrieved from "https://allthetropes.org/wiki/Special:MobileDiff/669991"