Once On This Island: Difference between revisions
Content added Content deleted
m (revise quote template spacing) |
No edit summary |
||
Line 15: | Line 15: | ||
---- |
---- |
||
=== Tropes in this show: === |
=== Tropes in this show: === |
||
* [[Adaptation Distillation]]: Regarded by most to be this to ''My Love, My Love''. |
* [[Adaptation Distillation]]: Regarded by most to be this to ''My Love, My Love''. |
||
* [[Bittersweet Ending]]: |
* [[Bittersweet Ending]]: {{spoiler|Ti Moune is dead, and everyone is devastated, but hey, at least she came back as a cool tree}}! This was changed from the complete [[Downer Ending]] of the book. |
||
* [[Bowdlerise]]: In order to make the junior version more accessable to middle and high school students, the racial divide between the [[But Not Too Black]] rich and the very dark-skinned poor is completely removed. The song relating to the history of Daniel's family is removed from the junior version because of this tension (he is the result of [[Son of a Whore|an affair between his father and a peasant woman]]). However, the "Some Girls" |
* [[Bowdlerise]]: In order to make the junior version more accessable to middle and high school students, the racial divide between the [[But Not Too Black]] rich and the very dark-skinned poor is completely removed. The song relating to the history of Daniel's family is removed from the junior version because of this tension (he is the result of [[Son of a Whore|an affair between his father and a peasant woman]]). However, the song "Some Girls" is also cut, resulting to Daniel having ''virtually no singing'' at all. |
||
* [[Broken Aesop]]: The storytellers tell you that the story is about how love can conquer death...when the real message is "Go after a boy who doesn't really care about you - |
* [[Broken Aesop]]: The storytellers tell you that the story is about how love can conquer death... when the real message is "Go after a boy who doesn't really care about you - {{spoiler|you'll die}}, but it's still the power of love!" |
||
** [[Completely Missing the Point|Yeah...]] Either that or, "Even if you are betrayed in the most horrible way possible, you should still continue to be a good person." |
** [[Completely Missing the Point|Yeah...]] Either that or, "Even if you are betrayed in the most horrible way possible, you should still continue to be a good person." |
||
{{quote|"So I hope that you will tell this tale tomorrow. It will help your heart remember and relive. It will help you feel the anger and the sorrow... ''[[Tear Jerker|and forgive.]]''}} |
{{quote|"So I hope that you will tell this tale tomorrow. It will help your heart remember and relive. It will help you feel the anger and the sorrow... ''[[Tear Jerker|and forgive.]]''}} |
||
* [[But Not Too Black]]: Daniel and the rest of the Grand Homme. |
* [[But Not Too Black]]: Daniel and the rest of the Grand Homme. |
||
* [[Crowd Song]]: "We Dance", "Pray" and its reprise |
* [[Crowd Song]]: "We Dance", "Pray" and its reprise "Why We Tell the Story". |
||
* [[Dark Reprise]]: "Pray" is in itself something of a dark reprise (it's based in the melody of "We Dance" played in a minor key), and "Forever Yours" and "The Human Heart" both get dark reprises at the end. |
* [[Dark Reprise]]: "Pray" is in itself something of a dark reprise (it's based in the melody of "We Dance" played in a minor key), and "Forever Yours" and "The Human Heart" both get dark reprises at the end. |
||
** Arguably, the "Pray" reprise is slightly darker too. |
** Arguably, the "Pray" reprise is slightly darker too. |
||
Line 29: | Line 28: | ||
* [[Disposable Fiance]]: Inverted with Andrea. |
* [[Disposable Fiance]]: Inverted with Andrea. |
||
* [[Everyone Hates Hades]]: Papa Ge is portrayed here as a pretty unpleasant guy, to say the least. |
* [[Everyone Hates Hades]]: Papa Ge is portrayed here as a pretty unpleasant guy, to say the least. |
||
* [[The Grim Reaper]]: Papa Ge |
* [[The Grim Reaper]]: Papa Ge. |
||
* [[The Ingenue]]: Ti Moune. |
* [[The Ingenue]]: Ti Moune. |
||
* [["I Want" Song]]: "Waiting |
* [["I Want" Song]]: "Waiting for Life", and technically "Some Girls" as well. |
||
* [[Jerkass Gods]]: Erzulie messes around with innocent mortals' emotions in order to show up Papa Ge, who is just as eager to prove his superiority by forcing a girl to kill her lover. Agwe has a tendency to cause storms that kill people and ruin livelihoods just because he's in a bad mood. Asaka doesn't ''do'' much in the way of jerkassery, but seems perfectly content to take part in the others' petty disputes. |
* [[Jerkass Gods]]: Erzulie messes around with innocent mortals' emotions in order to show up Papa Ge, who is just as eager to prove his superiority by forcing a girl to kill her lover. Agwe has a tendency to cause storms that kill people and ruin livelihoods just because he's in a bad mood. Asaka doesn't ''do'' much in the way of jerkassery, but seems perfectly content to take part in the others' petty disputes. |
||
* [[Love Goddess]]: Erzulie is an interesting take on this trope, as she seems genuinely hoping for Ti Moune to succeed in winning Daniel's heart, but it's more to prove a point to Papa Ge-quinessentially, she and Papa Ge are in something of a pissing contest to prove if love or death is the stronger force, and she'll resort to messing with emotions to do so. |
* [[Love Goddess]]: Erzulie is an interesting take on this trope, as she seems genuinely hoping for Ti Moune to succeed in winning Daniel's heart, but it's more to prove a point to Papa Ge-quinessentially, she and Papa Ge are in something of a pissing contest to prove if love or death is the stronger force, and she'll resort to messing with emotions to do so. |
||
Line 37: | Line 36: | ||
* [[Prince Charming]]: Daniel is this in Ti Moune's eyes. |
* [[Prince Charming]]: Daniel is this in Ti Moune's eyes. |
||
* [[Shallow Love Interest]]: Daniel. |
* [[Shallow Love Interest]]: Daniel. |
||
⚫ | |||
* [[Star-Crossed Lovers]]: Daniel and Ti Moune. |
* [[Star-Crossed Lovers]]: Daniel and Ti Moune. |
||
⚫ | |||
{{reflist}} |
{{reflist}} |