Jump to content

Rescued from the Scrappy Heap: Difference between revisions

m
update links
m (update links)
m (update links)
Line 17:
Naturally, the two can be combined, if the main reason a character is disliked is their cowardice and lack of skill.
 
In a way, this is the opposite of [[Canon Dis ContinuityDiscontinuity]], which excludes the character from [[Canon]] entirely. Compare [[Ensemble Darkhorse]] and [[Badass Decay]]. Also contrast [[Author's Saving Throw]], which is an attempt to [[Hand Wave]] away the offending element, rather than fix it outright. See [[Growing the Beard]] in case you feel this way about the show itself. Might overlap with [[Alas, Poor Scrappy]], [[Reimagining the Artifact]], or especially [[A Day in the Limelight]].
 
'''[[No Real Life Examples, Please]]'''
Line 103:
*** He's also become a big-time [[Deadpan Snarker]].
** Drift is a major case of a phenomenon you see a lot in comic books: a [[Mary Sue]] is hated by all but the writer, then the ''next'' writer gets his hands on the character and opinion turns around. Evidently, it takes someone who can ''step back'' and figure out where he fits and who he ''needs'' to be instead of the creator who can't get past his "I adore him, so, you must too, and I'll keep him onscreen 24/7 until you do!" feelings about [[Creator's Pet|his pet]].
* Matter-Eater Lad of the ''[[Legion of Super-Heroes (Comic Bookcomics)|Legion of Super-Heroes]]'' started out as a total weirdo with an incredibly [[What Kind of Lame Power Is Heart, Anyway?|lame power]] who was eventually written out of the storyline, first by going back to his home planet and eventually [[Alas, Poor Scrappy|going into a coma]] after saving the universe by eating a "Miracle Machine" that was warping reality. During the "[[Time Skip|Five Years Later]]" era, though, he was re-imagined with a rock-star persona ([[Cool Shades]] and all), gleefully reveling in his own absurdity.
{{quote| "All this roughhousing is giving me an appetite * CHOMP* and you don't want to give '''me''' *gulp* an appetite."}}
** In the most recent [[Re Boot]] of the series, he ''[[Took a Level In Badass|bit a guy's finger off]]''.
Line 126:
* Kaine in [[Spider-Girl]]: Once he was a [[Wangst|wangsty]] [[Creator's Pet|over-hyped]] [[Nineties Anti-Hero]]. Now he's a [[Deadpan Snarker|snarky]] [[Badass Grandpa]] just trying to [[The Atoner|atone]] and [[Mysterious Protector|watch out]] for [[Papa Wolf|his niece and nephew. Excuse me, nephews.]] Doesn't hurt that they gave him a new look either.
* The creation of the [[Marvel Adventures]] line saw a lot of characters getting a much-needed face lift, but by far, the best-received [[Retool]] was changing [[The Wasp]] into [[Marvel Adventures|Giant Girl]]. Readers that hated the former loved the latter, and readers who liked the former adored the latter even ''more''. Of all the characters who were axed when the MA: ''Avengers'' series was cancelled in favor of a continuity reboot in MA: ''Super-Heroes'', Giant Girl was the one most fans were saddest to see go.
* Superboy-Prime had, by ''[[Legion of Super-Heroes (Comic Bookcomics)|Legion of Three Worlds]]'', become a [[Villain Sue]], a [[Straw Fan]], and a positively colossal [[Jerkass]]. Then, there came ''[[Blackest Night]]'', where he featured in a crazily metatextual story, became the butt of several ''massive'' [[Take That Scrappy]] scenes, started receiving major repercussions, and was shown being almost heroic for once - trying to save the heroes of the DCU from getting killed off in the latest event, something you'd expect from a genuine fan. Some fans have since reevaluated him. The story ends with it unclear if he'll continue down this path or backslide.
* [[Red Hulk]] was introduced by [[Jeph Loeb]] taking down one major league hero or cosmic entity after another, with no particular motivation and a secret identity that no one cared about. He used to provide the page picture for [[Villain Sue]]. Recently (and after Loeb lost control of the character) it's been explained that his [[Villain Sue]] abilities were due to a [[Deadly Upgrade]] by a group that was [[Unwitting Pawn|using him to dispose of their enemies]], then die. It's been removed, and Red Hulk is going through the process of being cathartically (to both readers and characters) beaten up by the people he trounced while in God Mode and facing up to the consequences of his actions. Commentators on his newer storyline have mentioned how it just feels ''weird'' to actually be interested in Red Hulk as a character.
** A similar rescue has taken place with the Red She-Hulk. Originally she was introduced as a generic 'sexy bad girl', complete with giant guns and a ludicrously [[Clothing Damage|ripped costume]], and a prime example of [[Jeph Loeb|Jeph Loeb's]] inability to come up with good names. Since then the firearms and the torn outfit were unceremoniously dropped, instead putting her and [[Incredible Hulk|the Hulk]] into a well-received two-person [[Love Dodecahedron|Love Quadrangle]].
Line 369:
* ''[[Castlevania Judgment]]'' received all kinds of flack ever since it was announced, from reports of terrible controls to [[They Changed It, Now It Sucks|heavy bashing of the new artstyle]]. Now that the game is out, the general consensus is that it's a pretty good Wii fighting game with awesome music... among some of the fans, anyway. [[Reviews Are the Gospel|The game critics]] still don't like it.
* ''[[Dissidia Final Fantasy]]'', which had a similar cold reception, won its way out by repeatedly leaking details to set the [[And the Fandom Rejoiced/Video Games|Fans Rejoicing]].
* ''[[Final Fantasy IV the After Years|Final Fantasy IV: The After Years]]'' not only pulled [[Spoony Bard|Edward]] out of the Scrappy Heap, but polished him up, and [[Took a Level In Badass|gave him a set of steel cajones]] before setting him out in the world. See the [[Final Fantasy/Awesome|CMoA page]] for details on his newfound [[Badass|badassery]].
** His rescue came even earlier: The DS remake of ''[[Final Fantasy IV]]'' gave him genuinely useful abilities, pleasing design, and a good voice actor.
** And before that, the GBA remake increased the chances of status effects with his attacks, to where he became a legitimate powerhouse.
Cookies help us deliver our services. By using our services, you agree to our use of cookies.